 He made 25 appearances and scored one goal during the 2011–12 season, but despite winning the 2012 Middlesex Senior Cup, the Beavers suffered relegation to the Isthmian League Premier Division.Carder-Andrews committed to the club for the 2012–13 season by signing a new contract in June 2012.Carder-Andrews made only 8 senior appearances during the 2012–13 season before departing in February 2013, due to budget concerns and a lack of game time.