 In 2013, the boys U14 team won the Eastern Ontario District Soccer Association L5 league, and was promoted to the ERSL.In 2018, the men's team were finalists in the Ontario Cup, losing 1-0 to Caledon FC.The competitive club's most recent triumph came with winning the Open Canada Cup in 2006, defeating the Toronto Lynx who, at the time, were members of the USL First Division, two tiers above Italia in the Canadian soccer pyramid.