 After World War One had finished, Katamatite returned to the GVFA in 1920 and 1921, only to be "outed" in 1922 when the GVFA club delegates decided to have a railway line association, which meant that Katamatite and Benbartha club's were left in limbo just prior to the start of the football season.In 1924, Katamatite were admitted into the Dookie Football Association and were defeated by the Dookie Football Club in the Preliminary Final.On Saturday, 20 July 1925 Katamatite - 78.19 - 487 defeated Wattville - 1.3 - 9, in what was a record score in country football at the time.