"Team Boo" garnered positive reviews from music critics.Tim Sendra of AllMusic praised the album's upbeat production and the vocal work of Gardner and Hammel giving life and exuberance to even slower tracks like "Parachutes (Funeral Song)" and "An Experiment", saying that ""Team Boo" is a record that will make even the staunchest nonbelievers believe in the power of simply played, honest, and energetic pop music again."