 Cotten had another success on Broadway when he appeared in "Once More, With Feeling" (1958–60) which ran for 263 performances.For the third time Cotten was in a Broadway hit but did not reprise his role in the film version – Yul Brynner did.In 1960, Cotten married British actress Patricia Medina after his first wife, Lenore Kipp, died of leukemia earlier in the year.