it is not in fact clear where urin dwelt : it is said here that after the battle 'mavwin got her in tears into the land of hithlum or dor lomin where all men must now dwell ' , which can only mean that she went there , on account of melko 's command , from wherever she had dwelt with urin before ; on the other hand , a little later in the tale ( p. 73 ) , and in apparent contradiction to this , mavwin would not accept the invitation of tinwelint to come to artanor partly because ( it is suggested ) 'she clung to that dwelling that urin had set her in ere he ment to the great war ' .