Question the credibility of the Civil Comments concept due to a comment made by "agirlwhoknowsherownmind" attacking Senator John McCain's illness and suggest that allowing such comments goes against the principles of Civil Comments.
Logan, it's hard to take your concept  of Civil Comments seriously when we read there, for example, the disgusting attacks by "agirlwhoknowsherown mind" upon Sen. John McCain and his illness in response to your thoughtful editorial.
It can't get any lower than these--
"There isn't an honorable bone in John McCain's body. He worked against the best interests of the people of this country every chance he got."
If you're OK printing this, you might as well eliminate your peer evaluations and just print any garbage the haters submit.