Discuss the idea that people can have a good reputation without actually being good or vice versa. Mention examples from different fields such as politics and law enforcement.
Lots of horrific people had spotless records - before they were caught. And lots of horrific criminals have spotless records because they haven't been caught yet and/or may never get caught because they buy their way out or are given a free pass. Look at the cops that shoot and kill innocent people. Free passes.