Neal Stephenson Sheathes Crowdfunded Swordfighting Game for Good
So long, Clang. You were a very, very expensive curiosity, in part because your lead proponent is something of a literary treasure. The crowdfunded project to develop an ultra-realistic motion control driven sword fighting simulation, which originally generated over half a million in funding but ran out of money in September 2013, has been officially shelved  it sounds like for good. In a "final update" to Clangs Kickstarter site, Stephenson writes that he's decided to "cut the cord, and announce the termination of CLANG." He says he delayed announcing the end sooner because of "new ideas and opportunities" that were happening, and that he says "may ultimately wind up in some of the same places we wanted to take CLANG.", But he says as far as Clang-the-Kickstarter-project is concerned, it's over. He expresses regret that it couldn't continue further, but makes it clear he believes it delivered on its promise, though assuming much of the blame for its inability to continue. Stephenson, author of speculative fiction novels like Snow Crash, Cryptonomicon and Anathem, launched Clang in 2012 as a project he hoped would "revolutionize sword fighting video games." Stephenson is a self-described "swordsmanship geek," though I'm not entirely sure what that means. I can't find anything about him actually hefting blades or suiting up to fence with sabers, foils or pes, but he often talks about sword history at least in the many interviews I've read over the years, for instance admiring the way a show like Game of Thrones is careful to represent aspects of swordsmanship realistically. Here's Stephenson's original pitch for the game, Clang sounds like a classic example, by Stephenson's own admission, of someone relatively un-versed in the insanely byzantine complexities of game design and bringing a concept to fruition, but very well-versed in the history of sword fighting, over-obsessing about the latter and not enough over the former. As he says of the reasons that ultimately led to Clangs termination, The debate from here out, I suspect, is going to be over whether Stephenson and his cohorts delivered the goods. The promise made on Clangs Kickstarter page, somewhat buried in the print, does seem fairly unambiguous "The next step is to build a functional proof of concept in the form of an exciting prototype we can share with you and use to achieve our next level of funding." Anything subsequent to that prototype would have required additional funding, writes Stephenson  funding beyond the project's original Kickstarted 526,125, that is. I'm not sure anyone's verified whether Stephenson and Subutai delivered their prototype or donor rewards to backers as claimed it doesn't seem that anyone's yet written about their experience with the prototype. Stephenson says he's issued 700 in refunds to "around two dozen CLANG backers" who've asked for their money back. He adds that the financial burdens on members of the design team, as well as himself, have been substantial, above and beyond the money spent from the Kickstarter pool, There are no further formal plans to return backers' money or at least no obvious ones. Stephenson ends his final update by offering a link to sign up for a list to receive updates about future projects, but cautions those projects may or may not come to anything. The reactions to the announcement, restricted to backers, have been mixed, from folks chiming in to express their support for Stephenson and satisfaction with the project, to others asking for their money back.