system
A chat on 4chan
human
If majority consensus has always been and will always be that the rape and murder of a young girl is wrong, then maybe we can consider this an objective evil, but don't strawman my philosophical argument with a single example designed to elicit an emotional response rather than rationally interrogating my words piece by piece. A blind man cannot perceive the brightness of the Sun, and likewise a man blind to the form of good does not perceive what is right and wrong, but the state of what is good is not absolute; it is not static or concrete; it is in a constant fluctuation, ever changing and ever evolving. Ancient Greeks practiced pederasty. This would not land them in jail and was not viewed as wrong by their contemporaries. For all intents and purposes this was not wrong according to the current form of good at the time. It is only in retrospect, through the lens of the modern form of good, that we consider pederasty deplorable. Yesterday slaves were considered property and freeing a slave was considered theft and subject to punishment. Today slavery is evil and those who would free a slave are lauded as heros. Yesterday cannabis was illegal and the powers of justice would lock you in jail for possession. Today cannabis is legal and sold in stores, and those who were supposedly dispensing justice were actually wrongfully removing the freedom of innocent people. In a sense, what is good is determined by a competition of willpower. The will of those who advocated slavery was conquered by the will of those who do not. The will of those who advocate cannabis prohibition was conquered by the will of those who do not. What is good has changed, and in light of that change those who were thought to be doing good were actually doing wrong according to a newer, higher form of good. So how does a man stand upright and remain poised and balanced when God is constantly pulling the rug out from under our feet?
gpt
What's good is what's useful, what's useful is dictated by whoever holds the most power. Sometimes evil things are painted as good, because they are useful to those in power.