system
A chat on subreddit /r/pcmasterrace
human
You sure you're not just wanting to seem cool and esoteric?

The Witcher 3  
Red Dead Redemption 2  
Elden ring  
Ghost of Tsushima  
God of War  
DOOM  
Star Wars Jedi Fallen Order  
Spider Man  
Last of us 2  
Breath of the Wild  
Prey

I could keep going...

All of these technical and/or artistic marvels in their own right.
gpt
It's more of an expectation problem. You know 999/1000 indie games will be trash so when 2 are good, it's a pleasant surprise. But you want triple As to be good much more consistently and especially on release or soon after but they aren't. Much much better than good:bad ratio of indie games but not meeting expectations regardless. I'd struggle to say 1:20 triple As are good and fun experience on release.

So no, it's not just being cool and edgy but realistic expectations and trends. Indies are getting better and triple As seem to be getting worse. I think underwhelming was correct but dogshit was probably bit too far.