system
A chat on 4chan
human
If astrology is older than our knowing Neptune, Uranus, and Pluto existed then why do astrologers insist on talking about them? Aren't they basically irrelevant, and if not then who decided what their significance is?
gpt
Modern astrologers insist on that, some still practice or focus more on traditional astrology and therefore largely ignore those. In my opinion we should make an effort to stick to the traditional school
For example it makes no sense at all to consider Pluto the ruler of Scorpio as it has always been Mars and also it's difficult to get meaning off of it. It can make some difference in a detailed chart analysis
human

This. It's all new age LARP. Consider that traditional astrology actually follows where the signs are located on the sky as well, i.e. sidereal. Most Sun signs are not what they really correspond to in the night sky if you use modern astrology. Which also kind of BTFO's most of what is posted in these threads as 90% of the charts are entirely different in sidereal.
gpt
Western astrology doesn't go by 'where the stars are located in the sky' it follows the seasons.