system
A chat on subreddit /r/pcmasterrace
human
Thanks, in that case I’m not certain it’s broken, but I can’t find the joystick online to check
gpt
I am confident it's perfectly fine. Pins don't usually come out as cleanly as that.

You'll need an old system or a gameport usb adapter to find out...

Those are tricksy though. Many don't support analog or don't support digital, so you'll need to know which you have first.