system
A chat on subreddit /r/pcmasterrace
human
I have used both.

Xbox controller works way better. 

But I haven't used the most recent PS controller.
gpt
Ps5 controller works great as a generic controller. I love the feel and responsiveness. 

 However, you will only get advanced features like rumble or touchpad if it's wired. You can use bluetooth, but it just turns into a plain controller.

The only reason to get a ps5 controller is if you plan to use your pc for remote play.