You Are Here > > Blog >     POLL: Mike Mussina and the Hall of
Fame  Posted by Andy on June 27, 2010  It seems logical that we
should have a poll about Mike Mussina's HOF chances, given that
his name got brought up quite a bit during the recent Curt
Schilling HOF debate. For Schilling, nearly exactly 2/3rds of
voters believe he deserves to be in the HOF while 1/3rd do not.
(Interestingly, 73% think Schilling will get in while 27% do
not.)  Anyway, let's see what folks think about Mussina.  Here's
a quick summary of the argument, as I see it. Please add your
own comments and then vote in the poll below.  In favor:    •
270 wins (33rd all-time)   • 74.8 WAR for pitchers (24th all-
time) including top AL pitcher in WAR in 1994 and 2001.   • .638
W-L% (37th all-time)   • 3.58 K/BB ratio (14th all-time)   •
Career ERA+ of 123.   • 57 career complete games including 23
shutouts   • 5-time All-Star, 7-time Gold Glove winner, 9 top
ten Cy Young finishes   • 3.42 career post-season ERA over 23
games (21 starts)   • Led