The Icicle survived his fall into the river, and returned to plague the Emerald Gladiator time and time again, eventually becoming a member of Wizard 's second Injustice Society of the World which succeeded in briefly hypnotizing the Justice Society of America. During their Patriotic Crimes, the Icicle stole the Washington Monument. Later, he was a founding member of the Crime Champions of Two Earths, along with Wizard and Fiddler, which teamed up with a trio of crooks from Earth-1 after Fiddler accidentally discovered a way to travel between worlds. Icicle committed a million-dollar robbery on Earth-2 and escaped Hourman and Doctor Fate. He was defeated by Doctor Fate while robbing a museum on Earth-1. The Justice League and the Justice Society were captured and imprisoned in cages in space by the Crime Champions though, but escaped with the help of the Green Lanterns. All the villains were then captured.