In 1987, Philip W. Anderson gave the first theoretical description of these materials, based on the resonating valence bond (RVB) theory, but a full understanding of these materials is still developing today. These superconductors are now known to possess a d -wave pair symmetry. The first proposal that high-temperature cuprate superconductivity involves d -wave pairing was made in 1987 by N. E. Bickers, Douglas James Scalapino and R. T. Scalettar, followed by three subsequent theories in 1988 by Masahiko Inui, Sebastian Doniach, Peter J. Hirschfeld and Andrei E. Ruckenstein, using spin-fluctuation theory, and by Claudius Gros, Didier Poilblanc, Maurice T. Rice and FC. Zhang, and by Gabriel Kotliar and Jialin Liu identifying d -wave pairing as a natural consequence of the RVB theory. The confirmation of the d -wave nature of the cuprate superconductors was made by a variety of experiments, including the direct observation of the d -wave nodes in the excitation spectrum through angle resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES), the observation of a half-integer flux in tunneling experiments, and indirectly from the temperature dependence of the penetration depth, specific heat and thermal conductivity.