In The Conscious Mind, David Chalmers replies directly to this argument by proposing a two-by-two matrix whose diagonal and top row encode primary and secondary intensions.
Brian Loar's critique of this argument opens by citing the Frenchman Pierre in Saul Kripke's "A Puzzle About Belief." In The Conscious Mind, David Chalmers replies directly to this argument by proposing a two-by-two matrix whose diagonal and top row encode primary and secondary intensions. This argument was modi3ed by Tyler Burge, whose paper "Other Bodies" discusses a woman named Jane with arthritis in her thigh. The classic statement of this argument appears alongside a discussion of the di5ference between elms and beeches and states two Fregean (FRAY-gee-an) principles it 3nds fallacious. That statement of this argument takes place in the year 1750, before modern chemistry, and concludes that meaning "just ain't in the head" because "water" means both H2O and XYZ. For 10 points, name this thought experiment 3rst proposed by Hilary Putnam which involves a planet super3cially identical to our own.
Brian Loar's critique of this argument opens by citing the Frenchman Pierre in Saul Kripke's "A Puzzle About Belief."
Twin Earth thought experiment [or semantic externalism argument]