For 10 points, namethis thesis from the philosophy of mind, which states that a single mental kind can have more than one physical instantiation.
A Lawrence Shapiro article titled after this concept considers the example of a pair of corkscrews and compares the causalcontribution of their material versus their color. David Lewis argued that this idea is not inconsistent with its opposite if it ismade domain specifiÂc, using the example of a lottery having different winning numbers in different weeks. Arguments againstthis idea include the "denying projectability" reply, which uses the example of jade, and one which notes that this idea allowslocal structure-specifÂc bridge laws; those replies were formulated by Jaegwon Kim. This idea was generalized to occur withina single token system by Jerry Fodor, who used it to show that the special sciences cannot be reduced to physics. This idea wasintroduced in a series of papers attacking the identity thesis by Hilary Putnam, who considered the fact that many differentkinds of animals feel pain, and is generally conceived of as a challenge to psychophysical reductionism. For 10 points, namethis thesis from the philosophy of mind, which states that a single mental kind can have more than one physical instantiation.
A Lawrence Shapiro article titled after this concept considers the example of a pair of corkscrews and compares the causalcontribution of their material versus their color.
multiple realizability