My biggest complaint about Treasure Island is the rank smell the downstairs casino has. It is very distinct. It made me sick each time we came downstairs and made us leave the hotel to shop and eat at other places. It was a mixture of suntan lotion, sweat, hot garbage, barf, and smoke. As soon as you walk in, it's there.\n\nEveryday by like 2:00 the pool would have a murky, creamy hue to it. This is due to people spraying on sunscreen while in the pool, or putting it on and getting right into the pool. Along with, I'm sure...pee. It was gross! I think they should close it for an hour mid-day to zap all the nastiness that is there by the afternoon. We only went in the mornings.\n\nThe buffet was just okay. We went during the crab leg night and they were sooo skinny, and had no flavor. They tasted like they were water logged.  The fried foods were soggy, and it seemed like we had gotten there when the food wasn't as fresh. We arrived before the line started forming. \n\nThe staff when we checked in and out were great! No complaints with the staff what so ever! However, the smell alone is enough to make me choose another hotel next time I'm there. I wish they could filter that out. It could just be the old carpet.