4 stars only because they took the dirty chips off the menu...WTF?  However, they did make them for us, but couldn't add the chicken livers...damn.  Anyway, I've been here 3 times, mainly because the beer challenge has become a tradition. Everything I've had has been outstanding.  Brown Butter Lobster Rolls are bomb! Carvery stuff is always tasty. Great oysters!  Bartenders are on point and a good draft  beer selection...overpriced, but what do you expect at the Crystals shopping area (Aria, Cosmo)?  And I'm 3 for 3 on the beer challenge.  I'll be back!