I try to be objective in any review I give...as well as open minded with any review I read. I have to say some reviews just make no sense at all unless of course they were for a totally different place than where I was at the time of this review. We had a great time at the Harvey American Public House this past Saturday....The Patio was full even after the rains have come through. The only thing I could say was that the crowd was not as a whole appreciating the band called the Mods...Not that they were bad mind you, they were actually really good. It seemed that the music is just a background for socializing conversations. Now about the food...I had the prime rib which was fantastic....this is the second time I visited this place and the hamburger I had then was tasty as well. Our bartender was knowledgeable on most things we asked but made sure he found out from someone else if he didn't know. This place is open until 2am 7 days a week. Where else can you go in Gilbert for a pint and a burger at 1am? This restaurant is owned by the people who own Fibber Magees Irish Pub in Chandler....good food, good staff....and good atmosphere. Im not sure what others consider to be a good experience....Everyone has their own agenda when writing a review. I consider the people factor as well, not everyone is going to be at their best 100% of the time. I am looking forward to many visits there as well as around the valley...Im out to support our local economy, one beer, one meal,....one day at a time! Cheers!