Over the past few years, it's become somewhat of a trend to send up high-altitude balloons and post videos on internet. Well-known examples include Toy Train in Space and Picard & Kirk in Space.

I think this is very cool, and a great way to show that space can be accessible to ordinary citizens. As such, I'd love to see more of this.

However, I can't help but feel that there have to be a fair number of risks involved (the most obvious being that if a part falls off a few hundred meters up, it'll fall fast enough to kill but not fast enough to disintegrate), which might become considerable if the number of experiments increase. As such, I'm not so sure I would want to see more of it.

So, my question is really two-fold:

  • What are the risks involved with such experiments?
  • What steps can be taken to insure safety in the event that such experiments do keep increasing in frequency?

I assume most of these balloon flights follow the proper regulations, and thus are legal, and in theory safe. There are a number of regulations, which this site includes, including weight limits, not dropping objects, and limiting the weight/surface area ratio, to keep the terminal velocity low. There are also quite a few regarding communication, but I'll skip on those for now. The key points to legally do this in the US are are:

  • Payloads cannot exceed a package weight/size ratio of three ounces per square inch. (Determined by taking the total weight of the package divided by the smallest area)
  • No payload package can exceed 6 lb in weight.
  • Entire weight of all payloads cannot exceed 12 lb in total weight (This doesn't include the weight of balloon).
  • No rope or cable should be used which requires more than 50lb of force to separate payload packages from balloon.
  • No one may launch a high-altitude weather balloon which creates a hazard to other people and property.
  • No one may use a high-altitude weather balloon to drop objects (i.e. projectiles).

If all of these regulations are followed, then the process should be relatively safe. The package should also be structurally sound so it doesn't fall apart. There are also a few other issues, the primary one being how do you track the balloon after it hits the ground, and when it's in the air, for that matter. But it can be a lot of fun.

| improve this answer | |

How do you stop people acting irresponsibly?

I have no idea. I don't think anyone has. They have been main antagonists of our nightmares ever since we started dreaming.

Why am I saying this? Because you're absolutely right and the Toy Train in Space was let from a densely populated area, possibly without notifying and gaining permission from airspace authority of the jurisdiction, and has also landed in populated area. Yes, some will say, "but it landed in a cornfield". So it did, lucky neighborhood. And the next one might land on someone's head and Huffington Post won't have so cute photos and videos to report on. Let's all laugh about it, right?

Not right. And it's not even the toy train that is really a problem. Or action figures. The problem is, that common people don't realize that access to airspace is tightly controlled mainly to prevent accidents / disasters. The problem is, that there were largely loose metallic rods holding the camera and the toy, and the camera wasn't as light as the toy either. This is what you see in the videos. The toy. What you don't see is the darn thing that will kill you. A metallic rod travelling pointy side first at near mach one (340.29 m/s) towards the skulls of civilians. And that's only one skull. How about this cute thingy together with the balloon and the frame being sucked into a jet engine? While the airplane is at low altitude, low airspeed and ready to land maybe? Still cute?

There is a way to do it properly tho:

  • Declare your intentions and gain access to airspace with your authorities,
  • ask for aviation weather report before launch,
  • launch into jet streams that will push your balloon over unpopulated areas and from a no-fly zone,
  • equip your balloon's frame with a self-activating parachute release system,
  • have tracking devices in place and
  • coordinate with authorities in case of unpredictable turn of events, so they will
  • keep contact with your event's organizer and can
  • notify local population to remain indoors, while
  • you or the nearest airspace tracking radar can tell them which area to notify to do so.

Too difficult? No problem. Join your local model rocketry, balloon or airship club, or even your school's related extracurricular activities, and organizers of the events will do that for you. They will even help you build it, give advice, and maybe even provide snacks for the event. Then, it can be properly cute. Meet Camilla:


      Camilla is a rubber chicken mascot of NASA's Solar Dynamics Observatory, launched by Bishop Union High School's Earth to Sky
      student group, in mountains near Bishop, California on a helium balloon to the stratosphere, roughly 120,000 ft (36.6 km) high.

Camilla was launched from unpopulated mountain range near Bishop, California by a group of Bishop Union High School students for an astrobiology project:


One week later, on March 10th, the storm was underway, and the students repeated the experiment. Sam Johnson (age 16) of Bishop Union High School's Earth to Sky student group mentions the second landing site:


As you will likely know, both these landing site areas are scarcely populated, if at all, and their balloon both times had a parachute properly deployed. More can be read in this article on NASA Science.

So there is a way to have fun, learn from it, and keep everyone safe at the same time while launching a balloon with a toy on its travel towards the edge of space.

By the way, I don't enjoy being as serious as this answer might sound. I'd much, much rather see it completely unnecessary and self-understood, and we can all continue having fun launching odd things into space.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

