Joe's Stone Crabs, Sustainable, Keys Fisheries, Gary Graves, Bureau of Seafood and Aquaculture, The Lobster Place, Chelsea Market, Florida, Key West, Stone Crabs, Stone Crab Claws, Marathon, Insider Fish Restaurant Recommendations, Where to eat Stone Crabs, Where to buy stone crabs, Who ships stone crabsChefs, Bartenders, Sommeliers, Where to drink in Philadelphia, Best Bars in Philadelphia, Best Restaurants in Philadelphia, F | E | D Guide, F.E.D. Guide, City Guide, Where to shop, Travel Guide, City Guide, Go Where The Pros Go, GoWhereTheProsGo, Eat Where the Pros Eat, Chefs Feed, Where Chefs Eat, Chef’s Guide, Drink Where The Pros Drink, Drink What the Pros Drink, Insider Recommendations, Pro Recommendations

Eat Stone Crabs  - Find. Eat. Drink.


The Seasonal Sustainable Seafood Delicacy



October 15 until May 15.

The Species

They are crustaceans and are two different species: menippe adina and menippe mercenaria.

Life Span

Males crabs live to about 7 years and female crabs live to about 8 years.


They are a renewable commercial fishing resource. Population levels are estimated to be high and no overfishing is occurring. It is nearly impossible to wipe out the stone crab population due to the fact that the crabs are not harmed and are able to regenerate their claws.

How They Are Fished

All of the stone crab claws on the market come from wild fisheries; there is no aquaculture for stone crab claws. Crabs are caught in traps, Only one claw per animal is harvested - so they can continue to eat and defend themselves - then returned to the water alive to generate new claws, regenerating 4 to 5 claws in its natural lifetime.

Cool Fact

Each time the crab molts, a new claw grows larger. A “large” crab claw can weigh up to half a pound and “colossal” claws have reached a pound or more. In order to be fished, claws must be at least 2 3/4” in length and they cannot be taken from egg-bearing females.


A good, low-fat source of protein, vitamin 6, selenium and magnesium. A 4 ounce raw portion is equal to 60 calories with zero grams total fat.


Contrary to popular belief, stone crab claws are graded based on weight, not size. They are graded based on ounce weight.

- Medium claws weigh up to 3 ounces (5 to 8 pieces per pound)

- Large claws weigh between 3 and 5 ounces (3 to 5 pieces per pound)

- Jumbo claws weigh 5 ounces and up (3 claws per pound)

How To Tell Freshness

Once cracked, if the meat comes off the shell easily it’s fresh. If it sticks, they’ve been frozen. Stone crab claws have a 5 to 7 day shelf life.


Once harvested, the raw claws are cooked on the boat or more commonly at dockside. In a restaurant, hot crab claws may mean that they are re-heated. But you can opt for either hot or cold. Eat with a simple squeeze of lemon on the meat, or dip in drawn butter, or in a mustard sauce.

How To Crack The Claws

Place crabs in a towel or put a plastic bag over the claw (this will keep from splattering crab juice all over you and everywhere else).

Using the back of a large spoon, hammer or mallet, strike the back or rounded side of the two knuckles and finally the claw with a quick snapping motion. The shell should be cracked gently, so the meat stays intact and is not pierced by the shell.

Next, peel the shells from the claw and then separate the two knuckles from the main pincher. That’s where the tasty goodness is found. One note of caution, there is a hard center membrane inside the meat, so when biting into the meat be careful.

Ship Them To Your Door

Keys Fisheries has been in business for over forty years and supplies Miami Beach’s famous Joe’s Stone Crab with its seafood. Gary Graves moved to the Florida Keys in 1967 and now owns 28 fishing boats, which specialize in lobster and stone crabs. He exports his seafood all over the world.

The Bureau of Seafood and Aquaculture provides this list of purveyors who ship.

Available In New York

Stone crab claws are often available, in season, at The Lobster Place in Chelsea Market.

Photo Credit: Find. Eat. Drink.




F.E.D. Photos | Instagram

More photos and follow us on Instagram at FindEatDrink.

Follow Us



Get the App




Follow Us