Petition Closed
Petitioning Assistant Secretary of Defense for Health Affairs Jonathan Woodson and 4 others

US Military: Stop Shooting, Cutting Open, and Breaking the Limbs of Living Animals


Thousands of live goats and pigs animals are cut apart, shot, and blown up in U.S. military training drills every year even though humane methods like human-patient simulators that provide more effective and realistic training are available and military regulations require that alternatives to animals be used whenever they exist.

As a physician and retired Navy medical officer, I know what it takes to save the lives of soldiers and civilians. And I can say as someone who has participated in animal laboratories that they did not improve my ability to treat humans and that the skills needed to treat traumatic injuries are best acquired without hurting any animals.

So I was shocked and disappointed to see this newly released hidden-camera video footage of live goats who had their limbs chopped off during a recent U.S. military training exercise (warning: graphic footage).

Crudely practicing emergency medical techniques on small, anesthetized animals is nothing like treating moving, screaming soldiers who have been injured in combat. Compared with humans, goats and pigs are much smaller, their skin is thicker, and the anatomy of their organs, blood vessels, skeletons are drastically different.

On the battlefield, military physicians, medics, and corpsmen must make quick life-and-death decisions and do not have the luxury of spending time to make sense of the drastic anatomical differences between humans and goats before treating their wounded comrades.

Unlike animal laboratories, simulators like SimMan and the Cut Suit have the right anatomy and can respond to medications and treatments just like a human would. This is acknowledged by many military facilities in the US, including the Navy Trauma Training Center in California where no animals are used, and by militaries in other countries around the world that use only non-animal methods for training. 95 percent of civilian medical training programs—including at prestigious facilities like Harvard and Yale—have completely replaced the use of animals for
training in how to treat traumatic injuries like those covered in these military courses.

Switching to simulators that more realistically replicate human war injuries will not only spare thousands of animals' lives, but it ultimately will improve the training experience for soldiers and better equip them to save human lives.

Letter to
Assistant Secretary of Defense for Health Affairs Jonathan Woodson
Secretary of Department of Homeland Security Janet Napolitano
U.S. House of Representatives
and 2 others
U.S. Senate
U.S. Secretary of Defense Leon Panetta (U.S. Secretary of Defense)
I just signed the following petition addressed to: US Military.


I just watched a disturbing undercover video showing a military training exercise in which goats were stabbed and have their limbs chopped off with tree trimmers. I am disgusted that the U.S. Coast Guard, which your agency oversees, continues to allow this cruel use of animals for
medical training, especially since there are modern non-animal simulation models that better replicate human battlefield injuries and that are more effective at teaching lifesaving skills.

I strongly urge you to immediately end the use of animals in military trauma training exercises in favor of alternatives that will save animals' lives and provide our brave men and women in uniform with a superior training experience.


James Santos started this petition with a single signature, and now has 135,359 supporters. Start a petition today to change something you care about.