Fog Creek Software
Discussion Board

"one mile south" answer

I don't think the answer to "one mile south" at is completely correct.  It is not possible to walk one mile south from the north pole.  To do so would be walking "into" the earth, which is not possible.

This question has an infinite number of possibilities.  You could start at any point one mile north of the lattitude line whose circumference around the earth is one mile....or half a mile....or 1/4 of a mile...or 1/n where n has a factor of 2...I think

Jon Chin
Saturday, August 10, 2002

This depends very much on what your definition of south is. If you're standing at the equator, the shortest line to the south pole also goes through the earth. This is true for any point on the surface of a sphere, apart from the south pole itself. If you define south as something like 'walking along a geodesic line joining this point and the south pole' there's no problem. This definition also works at the north pole - it just isn't unique.

There is also no requirement for n to have a factor of 2. 1/3 of a mile will work fine as well.


Paul Viney
Monday, August 12, 2002

you start about 117 meters from the pole: go 100m south so your 17m away, at that point, when you go east, the circumfrence of the globe around the pole is 100m, so you end up back on the same spot, then you go the 100m north, back to where you started
Thats from my friend, a physics genius

Alissa Frame
Wednesday, September 18, 2002

*  Recent Topics

*  Fog Creek Home