In what ways is that laudable or tragic?

Thoreau asks, "What should we think of the shepherd's life if his flocks always wandered to higher pastures than his thoughts?" What, indeed, should we think of a computer scientist, engineer, architect, chemist, ect., whose products at work are the most imaginative things he or she creates? In what ways is that laudable? In what ways is that tragic?

Asked by
Last updated by jill d #170087
Answers 1
Add Yours

In the passage we see Thoreau seeking what he may believe to be unattainable. His sights are bound for something that will be "forever new and unprofaned." What he seeks is perfection.

The original wording in the lines before this is;

"There was a shepherd that did live,

And held his thoughts as high

As were the mounts whereon his flocks

Did hourly feed him by."

Thoreau's question is what happens when the flock seeks more than the shepherd........ thus, the shepherd would lose his flock. Today, the scientist, engineer, chemist, ect., are all seeking "higher meaning;" they seek more....... a computer programmer unwilling to take the next step will be left behind. All things created by man aren't possible without using their God given intelligence and a sense of imagination. Without using the talents we've been given there would be no advances in anything (medicine, technology, building).

It is laudable.............. not tragic