iOS app Android app More

Warren J. Blumenfeld

GET UPDATES FROM Warren J. Blumenfeld

Before the Stonewall in Ukraine

Posted: 07/05/2012 10:07 am

"It is a violation of human rights when people are beaten or killed because of their sexual orientation, or because they do not conform to cultural norms about how men and women should look or behave. It is a violation of human rights when governments declare it illegal to be gay, or allow those who harm gay people to go unpunished," U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton, addressed the United Nations on International Human Rights Day (Dec. 6, 2011) in Geneva, Switzerland.

Throughout the world, in large cities and small towns alike, we set aside the month of June to commemorate the historic rebellion at the Stonewall Inn in New York City's Greenwich Village on June 28, 1969, what many historians and activists consider as the event sparking the modern movement for lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) civil rights. During this past June, turn to almost any progressive publication, print and electronic (including The Huffington Post), and you will find news coverage, including luminous reader-contributed photos of joyous revelers marching down the boulevards in brightly-colored outfits of all stripes and shades announcing their entry, their solidarity, their feisty outrage, and yes, their pride.

Eastern Europe

"We are still at the pre-Stonewall level!" exclaimed a Ukrainian LGBT rights activist in Kiev on June 22.

As amazing and inspiring as Pride events have become over the years, they do not yet extend universally, especially to certain regions and entire countries in Eastern Europe. A case in point included actions on Sunday, May 20, of this year, when organizers of the first scheduled Pride march planned for Ukraine in their capital city Kiev were compelled to cancel the event over safety concerns as an estimated 500 neo-Nazi nationalists threatened to disrupt the proceedings. A group of masked thugs savagely attacked activist and organizer Svyatoslav Sheremet of the group Gay Forum of Ukraine, following a media briefing regarding the march's cancellation called just before it was due to start. Also, the previous day, vandals destroyed a photo exhibit that showcased the lives of LGBT families in Ukraine under the former Soviet Republic. This came shortly following the seventh consecutive prohibition by Russian authorities of Moscow Pride activities.


In St. Petersburg, Russia's elected officials approved a law criminalizing "the propaganda of homosexuality and pedophilia among minors," while mandating fines up to $16,000 on individuals and up to $160,000 on organizations. These bans against "gay propaganda" also remain in effect in the Arkhangelsk, Kostroma, and Ryanzan regions of Russia. This year, the Siberian regional government also added a ban on "gay propaganda." According to the NDTV news website and, Alexander Ilushchenko, leader of the Siberian regional committee on culture, education, sports, and youth policy talked about the purpose of the new law: "It's mainly about various gay parades... about their promotion among minors. It's about preventing people who are not related to homosexuality from explaining to their kids what is going on."


In Moldova, the Bălți city legislature ratified a law against "gay propaganda." This year, the Hungarian far-right political party Jobbik also submitted an anti-gay propaganda bill to the country's parliament. The bill would ban "promotion of sexual deviation" targeting LGBT people as well as banning pedophilic behavior. Also this year, a police commission in Budapest turned down a request to allow an annual LGBT Pride march. A Metropolitan Court overturned a similar ban last year.

The Case of Ukraine

On June 20 2011, six members of the Ukrainian Parliament from all the major political parties introduced a draft law (a bill), No. 8711 titled, "On Introduction of Changes to Certain Legislative Acts of Ukraine (regarding protection of children's rights on the safe information sphere)." The draft law restricts basic human and civil rights of LGBT including freedom of speech and freedom of assembly. This bill, if passed, will amend the Ukrainian Criminal Code in sections "On Protection of Public Morals," "On Print Mass Media," "On Television and Radio," and "On Publishing," thereby making it a criminal offense to promote "propaganda of homosexualism" by distributing information and the use of public broadcasting. Violation of Ukraine's criminal code carries penalties ranging from a fine to 5 years imprisonment.


designed to strengthen anti-homosexual propaganda in Ukraine and ensure the legal framework for prosecution of violations of public order and morality of the Ukrainian society. The spread of homosexualism is a threat to national security, as it leads to the epidemic of HIV/AIDS and destroys the institution of family and can cause a demographic crisis....It is moral depravity and so-called sexual freedom promoted in Ukraine, that pose a threat to the above values - health, family institution, the constitutional rights of fathers, mothers, children, freedom of speech and religion, and a stable demographic situation.

The draft law defines "propaganda of homosexuality" as follows:


This can take the form of public as well as nonpublic "propaganda" including:

holding of rallies, parades, pickets, demonstrations, and other mass public events... lecturing, giving of thematic talks or elective classes, organization of interactive games, conducting of educational work, or holding of other educational events concerning homosexuality... dissemination through media outlets of messages or articles about homosexuality, or of any appeals to adopt a homosexual lifestyle...

Ukraine gained its independence from the former Soviet Union in 1991, though its transition to a modern democratic republic has been precarious at best. For example, hundreds of thousands of protesters took to the streets in and around Kiev's Independence Square ultimately inspiring millions throughout Ukraine for 17 days in freezing temperatures to engage in acts of civil disobedience during November 2004 in what has come to called "The Orange Revolution." Demonstrators protested the deceitful and corrupt national presidential elections in which Viktor Yanukovych was officially declared the winner against Viktor Yushchenko, his run-off opponent. During the election process, Mr. Yushchenko's face was pockmarked and scarred after he ingested a toxic substance, which he claimed was slipped into his food by government agents who attempted to force him out of the presidential campaign. Protestors succeeded in their calls for new elections in which Yushchenko was ultimately declared president of Ukraine.

Shortly after taking power, however, party infighting and charges of corruption seriously diminished Yushchenko's popularity and tore apart the unseasoned democratic movement. As irony would have it, Viktor Yanukovych, the object of scorn and protest of the Orange Revolutionaries, sits today as Ukraine's president.

My Travels to Ukraine

I had the opportunity to travel to Ukraine to meet with LGBT activists to compare and contrast organizing strategies between our two countries and to present a workshop focusing on internalized oppression at their fifth annual conference, June 22-24 2012, organized by a standing committee of LGBT movement activists and professionals from HIV/AIDS service groups. Funding agencies ranged from USAID (the United States Agency for International Development) dedicated to administering aid to foreign countries to promote social and economic development, Sidaction (a French foundation devoted to raising awareness and funding for HIV/AIDS services and research), an alliance of international HIV/AIDS agencies, and the German federal organization Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ) GmbH focusing on international cooperation for sustainable development.

The day prior to the conference, we all heard news accounts of the vicious beating in the Darnytsia district of Kiev of Taras Karasiychuk, the head of the organizing committee of the ill-fated LGBT march in Kiev and a registered participant of our conference. While listening to expert panels and participating in workshops ranging from strategies in counteracting the clearly discriminatory draft legislation banning so-called "gay propaganda" currently being debated in the Parliament, to HIV/AIDS education efforts, to leaning about and working with transgender people, to financial management practices for non-governmental organizations (NGOs), conference participants always had on their minds the physical and emotional condition of their beloved comrade. Conference organizers provided frequent updates on Taras's condition. On the second day of the conference, Taras underwent surgery on his broken jaw in two places and on the soft tissue on his head. He also suffered a concussion.

Throughout the weekend, conference participants stuffed Ukrainian currency of various denominations of bright colors comprising a veritable rainbow of heartfelt and hopeful donations for the speedy recovery of their friend and colleague, which signaled his spiritual presence inspiring and grounding the conference goers' urgent efforts to work for a more just and welcoming society. We also learned that police officers had not yet arrested any suspects in the case.

Not A Conclusion

Among other organizations, Amnesty International and the European Union have denounced the violent events transpiring in Ukraine and other countries throughout Eastern Europe. In reference to Ukraine, Catherine Ashton, European Union Policy Chief, expressed in a formal statement her "solidarity with the victims of these acts," and urged the Ukrainian authorities to investigate the violent incidents "thoroughly and to bring the perpetrators to justice." Ashton also asked Ukrainian authorities "to protect and to enforce the rights of all Ukrainians, including lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender persons, to peaceful assembly and to freedom of expression."

The current events, policies, and assertions against so-called "gay propaganda" most certainly are not unique to Eastern Europe since echoes resound in other countries across the planet, including the United States. As the truism advises, "Think globally, and act locally," therefore, I have a hope that we can join together to create a world where everyone can celebrate their Pride throughout the year safely and with integrity in ways that express their truest joys while showing their full humanity, freedom, and liberty.

During her speech at the United Nation, Secretary Hillary Rodham Clinton committed herself to and spoke for people of good will everywhere when she said: "To LGBT men and women worldwide: Wherever you live and whatever your circumstances... please know that you are not alone."