Online shopping options offer credit card safety

Avoid credit card fraud dangers

By  and Emily Starbuck Gerson

About half of all Americans do at least some shopping online. While buying via the Internet beats fighting the mall crowd, it also carries the risk of identity theft and fraud, so new solutions are being created to further safeguard credit card information. Here are some of the most widely used, and safe, online shopping alternatives. 

Virtual cards

Shopping and credit cards
Shopping and credit cards


Virtual credit cards are not very popular, but they are excellent for consumers very fearful about losing control of their personal information. These cards allow consumers to shop using a temporary number connected to their existing account that functions for the length of the transaction or at just one store.  Credit card issuers including Citibank and Discover offer virtual cards.  Because the virtual card is linked to your existing account, charges appear on your regular statement.  While they can be used to minimize the exposure of your credit card information online, virtual cards cannot be used in the physical world.

Scott Mitic, CEO of TrustedID, an identity theft protection company, knows of several new options for further protecting consumer information. "Some issuers are now creating one-time-use cards that can be used in physical stores in addition to online," he says. "And a company called Revolution Money has recently created an anonymous credit card that contains no personal information on it or stored inside it. That way if it gets in the wrong hands, nobody can connect it with you." The Revolution Card requires a PIN number to make purchases, which safeguards it if it is stolen.

PayPal, a company owned by eBay, is probably the best-known credit card alternative.  Consumers looking to make payments with PayPal provide the service with a source of funds in the form of either a credit card or a bank account.  Instead of giving account data directly to a seller, you tell PayPal to transfer your payment to the seller's account, with PayPal identifying you to the seller only through your e-mail address.

Although an increasing number of smaller merchants accept PayPal, most large commercial websites do not.  And while PayPal promises complete refunds for unauthorized transactions, its safeguards against unethical merchants are much less complete. Payments of up to $1,000 are covered for qualified eBay purchases if you do not receive the item or it is "significantly not as described."

Using a credit card to fund your PayPal account could enable you to recover money via a charge-back through the credit card company.  But because PayPal is responsible for the entire amount, it expects you to exhaust its dispute resolution process before turning to your credit card issuer.

That delay could mean you miss the credit card issuer's deadline for reimbursement. Even so, Susan Grant, director of the National Consumers League's fraud center, says consumers should always use their credit cards on PayPal as a safeguard. "There have been some suits by state general attorneys concerning some problems with PayPal in regards to them not making clear to people what their protections are," Grant says. "When you make payments with your credit card, you have protection from federal rights. But if you make a purchase using your bank account, you lack the same protection."

Electronic payment systems
More recently, some websites have begun to rely on electronic payment systems that many consumers already use to pay their monthly bills.  With ModaSolutions' Secure-eBill, for example, the electronic payment system is generally offered as an option for payment in addition to credit cards or PayPal.

Customers who select this option receive an invoice e-mail from the merchant.  First-time customers need to establish that merchant as a payee with their bank or electronic bill-paying service.  After making the necessary payment, the customer is e-mailed a confirmation that the merchant has received the funds. Instead of merchants having access to any bank information, ModaSolutions just informs them that a payment has been posted to their account in the customer's name.

Difficulties with electronic payment include possibly having to wait several days for the payment to be processed, as well as having to set up numerous payees you may not give repeat business to.  Additionally, since the payment is a direct debit from your bank account, you will have no charge-back remedy if you are unhappy with the purchase.

Merchant programs
Regardless of where you shop, major credit cards have zero-liability policies for credit card transactions without the cardholder's authorization.  It can be a major headache to clean up if your credit card number is stolen, so for extra safety, shop online at merchants who take part in the Verified by Visa or Verified by MasterCard programs. The number of merchants using these two programs is relatively small, though many more are asking for the card identification number to ensure the card is in the shopper's physical possession.


Mitic asks consumers to be cautious but not paranoid about their information getting into the wrong hands. "There isn't a need for consumer hysteria. There are simple steps we should all be doing, but there is no point in living in a state of fear."

Updated: October 14, 2009

Join the discussion



Follow Us

Updated: 07-31-2015

Weekly newsletter