Essay about The Evolutionary Approaches Of Anthropology

Essay about The Evolutionary Approaches Of Anthropology

Length: 1167 words (3.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Since its inception, the academic discipline of anthropology has gone through constant paradigm shifts. In the nineteenth century, anthropology began as a nomothetic study based upon the development of cultures and societies through the process of evolution. Later on, several anthropologists particularly Franz Boas shifted the nomothetic approach of American anthropology into an idiographic approach, which focuses on assessing the development of cultures individually as their own separate entity. (Moore 2012:161) In the twentieth century, however, anthropology ushered in another paradigm shift. Several American anthropologists during this time, valued empirical data rather than applying the idiographic or the “Boasian” approach into their research. (Erickson 1998:116) This new paradigm shift revived the nomothetic approach back to American anthropology and thus initiated the creation of a new evolutionary theory known as neo-evolutionism. The following essay examines the evolutionary approaches of anthropologists and neo-evolutionists Leslie White and Julian Steward. Although, Leslie White and Julian Steward debated against each other over their respected evolutionary approaches, both approaches do share several similarities amongst each other, even though both anthropologists disregarded any relationship between the two.
In order to examine the evolutionary approaches of Leslie White and Julian Steward, we must therefore discuss about what the theory of neo-evolutionism is. Neo-evolutionism is a nomothetic theory which is based on using the general principles of evolution to explain how cultures change through time. This theory is a “reformation” of the late nineteenth century evolutionary theory of cultural evolution. (...

... middle of paper ...

...0’s, Marshall Sahlins and Elman Service who were both students and colleagues of Leslie White and Julian Steward, wanted to find a resolution over this debate between unilineal evolution and multilinear evolution. Sahlins and Service concluded that cultural evolution can be seen as two different dimensions known as specific evolution and general evolution. (Erickson 1998:119) Specific evolution refers to the particular sequence of change and adaptation of a particular society in a given environment. (Ember 2011:23) This evolutionary model is best represented by the ideas and concepts of Julian Steward. General evolution refers to the general progress of human society, in which “complex” cultures evolve from “simple” cultures due to their technological advancements. (Ember 2011:23) This evolutionary model is best represented by the ideas and concepts of Leslie White.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

What´s Evolutionary Psychology? Essay

- Evolutionary Psychology has been controversial since its rise in the 1990s, with critics and proponents debating its merits as a science. While critics (e.g. David Buller, Elizabeth Lloyd) have extensively criticized the fundamentals of Evolutionary Psychology, few philosophers or scientists have challenged them. Given the growing influence of the evolutionary behavioral sciences within mainstream science like Psychology and Anthropology, it is important analyze the critiques and see if the arguments against Evolutionary Psychology have merit....   [tags: human mind, adaptation]

Better Essays
2527 words (7.2 pages)

Fieldwork in Various Anthropological Schools of Thought Essay

- Cultural anthropology is a social science that studies the origins and development of human societies (History World International, 2001). Many theories to explain cultural variations among humans have emerged. As a result, numerous anthropological schools of thought have been established based on these theories since the nineteenth century. These schools of thought encompass the dominant beliefs about culture during a time period and are constantly changing as new knowledge is acquired. As schools of thought develop, ethnographic methods have changed and developed as well....   [tags: Anthropology ]

Better Essays
1169 words (3.3 pages)

Religion 's Impact On Society Essay

- Religion’s Impact on Society Religion is the belief in and worship of a superhuman controlling power, especially a personal God or gods. While not every religious person practices their faith in a church, there are still various different ways to approach the idea of religion. No matter where you live on this earth, it is guaranteed whether it is in a small town, city, rural area, and villages, in North America, Europe, Asia or the other 5 continents, there will be at least one church near you....   [tags: Religion, Sociology, Faith, Anthropology]

Better Essays
1350 words (3.9 pages)

Anthropology and Gender Essay


Better Essays
1582 words (4.5 pages)

Applied Anthropology: Domains of Application Essay


Better Essays
1505 words (4.3 pages)

What Is Anthropology? What It Is It? Essay

- What is anthropology. When I was signing up for classes that is what I wondered myself. It is not an easy subject to fully understand for me at the least. It is all confusing to me. I feel like it can be hard to study a human when obviously you are a human yourself, I am sure it is easy to miss important and helpful information that would clarify research of humans. It is the research of humanity from its evolutionary origins to today’s cultural diversity. It is not only studying the past but the present of human kind....   [tags: Anthropology, Culture, Sociology]

Better Essays
1674 words (4.8 pages)

Anthropology is Quantitative Essay


Better Essays
959 words (2.7 pages)

Cultural Anthropology Article Comparison Essay

- Introduction: Cultural Anthropology is a term that is in everyday lives and topics. When one thinks of anthropology they think of the study of old remnants commonly referred to as archaeology. This, however, is not the only form of anthropology. There are four types of anthropology and they are archaeology, biological anthropology, cultural anthropology, and linguistic anthropology. However, Cultural anthropologists are every where and study people of all walks of life. One can find a topic and find some type of study that an anthropologist has conducted on the matter....   [tags: Anthropology Culture Essays]

Free Essays
3071 words (8.8 pages)

Anthropology Today Essay


Better Essays
1735 words (5 pages)

Anthropology Essay

- Anthropology Anthropology what a vulnerable observer you are. You may well have to jump into the arms of the scientists if you are going to try to keep your grass hut at the academy. -- Ruth Behar Debates on the role the reflexive plague the field of cultural anthropology as postmodern critics join the bandwagon attempting to claim authority in this dubiously recognized discipline. In the borderline realm between the sciences and humanities, cultural anthropology has tried to find a niche in which it can comfortably rest....   [tags: Anthropologist Culture Essays]

Better Essays
1331 words (3.8 pages)