Physicists are not Metaphysicists

So this came in over the transom:

Dartmouth Researchers Shed New Light on Dark Energy, Cosmic Speed-Up

Study uses Big Bang afterglow to show Earth has no special place in expanding universe


While the findings don’t explain the cosmic speed-up, they eliminate one provocative possibility that our planet, solar system and galaxy are at the center of the universe and that there is no dark energy. The findings appear in the journal Physical Review D. A PDF of the study is available on request.


But Dartmouth researchers found that this model can’t hold up to other observational tests. The sky glows with light left over from the Big Bang, also known as the Cosmic Microwave Background, so they calculated how that glow would be affected. Their findings show that the center-of-the-universe model’s prediction is completely contrary to the glow that has been measured.

“Essentially, we held a mirror up to the universe and asked if the reflection was special,” says Robert Caldwell, a professor of physics and astronomy who co-wrote the article with undergraduate physics major Nina Maksimova `15. “The reflection shows that we do not appear to live in a special location, and decisively excludes this explanation for the universe’s accelerating expansion. It would be a great relief to be able to understand a basic problem of cosmology within the known laws of physics, but our research is an important step in explaining the physics responsible for the cosmic acceleration.”

I think this is a sample of a corollary of what Tom Kreitzberg calls Spong’s Law of Theophysical Asininity: “Whenever a person appeals to quantum physics as the basis for a theological or religious principle, he is making an ass of himself.”

It is significant that they choose the word metaphysically loaded word “special” and not the more accurate word “central”.

This is the sort of press release you get when scientists are trying to sex up their findings so that chin strokers in the pop science press will cover it in that breathless “Science again demonstrates truth of secular godlessness” way they have.

The physical location of the earth in a relativistic universe means nothing about whether or not the earth is “special”.  Everywhere and nowhere is the center.  So what?

Like Patheos Catholic on Facebook!


Nice Interview with Sarah Reinhard on Slowing Down the Hail Mary
Still More on the Allegorical Sense of Scripture
Prayer Request--Praise Report Update!
Walk Like MADD looks like a worthy cause