A detonation is a particular type of destabilization event. In a true detonation, a shock wave passing through a detonating substance or mass destabilizes the substance at the wavefront, causing it to explosively decompose, thus fueling the shockwave further. It should be noted that the 'wavefront' travels inside the substance, whether from the inside out or the outside in, but wherever it reaches the surface it expands outward as explosive gases and/or electromagnetic energy. High explosives are those which detonate; at least, they detonate at standard temperature and pressure. This is not to be confused with deflagration, which while similar is not the same phenomenon. Low explosives tend to deflagrate rather than detonate.

Therefore, if the reaction front arrives before or simultaneous with the shock wave from the explosion, it was a detonation rather than a deflagration. Both reactions can be exhibited in the same explosion; this can be caused either by multiple reactants and/or reactions taking place (some detonating, some deflagrating) or by a deflagration 'morphing' into a detonation via a Deflagration to Detonation Transition.

In automobiles, this phenomenon is also known as "engine knock" or "abnormal combustion." In a perfectly functioning engine, the spark plug ultimately determines when to ignite a cylinder, creating a controlled explosion. In a detonating engine, the fuel/air mixture ignites (due to high pressure and heat) before the spark plug would otherwise do so, creating multiple flame fronts within the cylinder. These flame fronts often collide with eachother or the piston, and the resulting uncontrolled reaction leads to losses in power and fuel efficiency. Detonation is one of the leading causes of engine damage.

It is often called "knock" because many forms of detonation are accompanied by a knocking or pinging noise (which, as drinkypoo pointed out in a /MSG, is the sound of the piston itself wobbling against the cylinder wall). This noise is the result of a relatively "late" detonation. If detonation occurs early enough in the combustion cycle, no sound will be heard, and the engine may be damaged without providing any indication to the owner. Silent detonation can sometimes be worse than knock, as if it occurs early enough, the piston is forced to move upwards against a wave of compressed, exploding gas. This "unnatural" action ("preignition") can actually bend the connecting rods within the engine. There are several causes of detonation, most of which involve increased compression, increased temperature, or a leaner fuel/air mixture:

  • Bad gas. In general, higher-octane fuel burns more controllably, and is less likely to explode before the spark ignites it. It is for this reason that "racing fuel" means 100 octane or better. In most areas, the best available gas is 91 or 93 octane, although octane booster can be added.
  • Advanced ignition timing. Ignition timing is preset by the manufacturer, and is chosen in part based on the manufacturer's fuel quality recommendations. This is why it's a bad idea to put 85 octane fuel in a 2001 Z06 Corvette. The engine has been designed with a high compression ratio and rather advanced timing, so dumping a poor-burning fuel in it is a bad idea. It's pretty difficult to advance ignition timing on a car with a distributorless ignition, as it is computer controlled. One popular "mod" with performance-enthusiasts is to advance the ignition timing just enough to where the car won't knock (at any point from idle to redline), but has increased performance. The trade-off? You must use fuel with an octane rating equal to or greater than the fuel you used when you set the timing, for the rest of the car's life, or until you retard the timing again (which isn't a good idea).
  • Carbon deposits. Carbon deposits can accumulate on the piston or in the combustion chamber. This black coal-like substance will retain enormous amounts of heat, reaching temperatures high enough to initiate combustion before the spark would otherwise do so. There are various ways to deal with this, including chemical treatments that don't require dismantling the engine.
  • "Hot spots" within the engine block or on the piston itself. Because engines are mass-produced, they are always going to have imperfections within as a result of their die-cut nature. Roughly cut edges on a piston or in a combustion chamber can reach temperatures high enough to spontaneously ignite.

Detonation is more of a problem with people who tune their cars, as most new cars are designed with rigid specifications and sensors intentionally designed to prevent it. As soon as one decides to mess around with their car's performance, they must consider the effects of detonation. The most effective way to increase a car's power output is to use forced induction. The three most popular (are there any other forms?) forms of forced induction are the turbocharger, the supercharger, and nitrous oxide. All three methods increase the amount of air (and pressure) in the combustion chamber, so something must be done to increase the amount of fuel as well. In other words, it's a bad idea to slap on a turbo without doing anything to your fuel system.

A car's compression ratio is an important factor when dealing with detonation. The higher the ratio, the more likely detonation is to occur (given other undesirable variables), and the more likely it is to do some serious damage to your engine when it does occur. A higher compression ratio requires higher octane fuel, and generally results in better fuel economy. It's usually a bad idea to add forced induction to a car that already has a very good compression ratio, unless something is done to lower it first. A popular modification is to simply install two gaskets between the cylinder head and engine block. This small increase in volume can lower a compression ratio by as much as half a point in many cases.

It is for these reasons that most serious enthusiasts will never add a turbo/supercharger without lowering their compression ratio and adding an intercooler, which cools the charged air dramatically before it's forced into the combustion chamber. Also, ignition timing is generally retarded when using such equipment. Many tuners have aftermarket ignition systems installed, allowing them to control their timing during a drag race, which is especially important when using nitrous oxide (as it often provides too much initial power to get good traction). A common practice is to advance the timing for at least the first thirty feet of the race. Once the driver has sufficient traction, he/she will simultaneously retard the timing and kick in the nitrous oxide, which rapidly increases the power output of the engine while also minimizing the potential for detonation. Some aftermarket manufacturers have come out with systems that change the ignition timing on the fly, depending on the amount of boost going into the engine, providing true best-of-both-worlds results.

Unlike what Webster seems to believe, a detonation is not just any explosion - it is a very specific explosion.

There are two different types of explosion; namely deflagration, and detonation.

Black powder, for example will never detonate: when it burns, the oxidant (KNO3 / Potassium Nitrate) releases oxygen, which causes the fuel (C / carbon, normally) to burn faster, which releases more oxygen etc. This chain reaction propagates throughout the mixture in a very quick manner, during which hot gasses expand very fast. When the container this mixture is kept in (A gun barrel with a bullet, or a fire cracker, for example) cannot hold the pressure anymore, causing an explosion in the form of the rapid expansion of pressurised gas. In the case of a gun, the bullet flies out of the barrel, and in the case of the fire cracker, it is blown to smithereens with a satisfying bang - deflagregation.

When we talk about detonation, however, we are no longer talking about low explosives like gasses or gunpowders, but about high explosives such as nitroglycerine.

If you were to set fire to nitroglycerine, it will start burning quite merrily - deflagration*. However, if you want nitroglycerine to detonate, you need to start a chemical reaction which breaks the molecular structure of the high explosion. This is where blasting caps come in: to start a detonation.

During a detonation in, say, a stick of dynamite, explosive molecules are hit by the blast cap, which sets the chain-reaction going: Once the actual detonation starts, the entire stick is instantly turned into a gel-like plasma, which contains absurd amounts of pressure - up to 100,000 bar.

Comparing a detonation of a stick of dynamite to a black powder-filled firecracker or a deflagration is like comparing a shotgun to a bb-gun or a cork gun - the powers involved are barely comparable.

*) Something that is deflagrating can under some circumstances unpredictably detonate. Do not set fire to high-explosives unless you know what you are doing

Det`o*na"tion (?), n. [Cf. F. d'etonation.]



© Webster 1913.

Log in or registerto write something here or to contact authors.