Related BBC sites

Page last updated at 19:06 GMT, Thursday, 6 January 2011
Male and female butterflies 'take turns courting'
By Ella Davies
Earth News reporter


Scientist Antonia Monteiro describes the butterfly's courting habits

Male and female butterflies switch courting roles depending on the season they were born in, say scientists.

Squinting bush brown butterflies use reflective "eye spots" on their wings to attract potential mates.

Males born in the wet season beat their wings to flash their spots but in the dry season females grow brighter spots instead and take the lead.

This behaviour could benefit females, allowing them to control mating when fewer food resources are available.

Bicyclus anynana wet season female (c) William Piel and Antonia Monteiro
Eye spots on the underside of butterfly wings are used to deter predators
Eye spots on the surface of the wing are used to attract mates and warn off rivals

Published in the journal Science, the study is the first to show that butterflies develop sexual ornamentation in response to their environment.

Like many butterfly species, squinting bush brown butterflies (Bicyclus anynana) perform wing-beating courtship displays to attract potential mates.

Unusually, the male and female butterflies take it in turns to lead this courting behaviour depending on the season.

Males beat their wings to attract mates in the warmer wet season and in the cooler dry season, the roles are reversed.

In many butterfly species, members of the courting sex have more ornamented wing surfaces with distinctive eye spots that they flash at potential mates in wing-beating displays.

However, to the human eye both sexes of B. anynana sport very similar surface wing patterns.

So in order to understand the role-switching, researchers at Yale University, Connecticut, US analysed courtship displays from a butterfly's perspective.

Led by Dr Antonia Monteiro, the team found that the white "pupil" at the centre of each butterfly's eye spot reflects different amounts of ultraviolet (UV) light, depending on what temperature the butterfly was reared at when a larvae.

Comparison of surface wing patterns in Bicyclus anynana (c) Kathleen Prudic and Antonia Monteiro A.
Wet and dry season surface wing patterns look similar to the human eye. A: Wet season female B: Wet season male C: Dry season female D: Dry season male

"Cool temperatures increase the UV reflectance of female sexual ornaments, warmer temperatures increase the UV reflectance of male sexual ornaments. These changes are not visible to humans because we do not see UV," explains postdoctoral fellow Dr Kathleen Prudic.

However butterflies can see UV, so by developing more attention-grabbing eye spots, females born in the dry season are able to attract males.

Researchers suggest that female butterflies may take over the performance role in order to survive the adverse conditions of the dry season.

By actively attracting mates and mating more often researchers have found that the dry season females in their studies live longer.

Butterflies have evolved complex and dynamic mating behaviours that can respond to predictable changes in their environment
Kathleen Prudic

This evidence supports previous studies that suggest female butterflies benefit from receiving sperm and associated nutrients during mating.

"The implications of these findings build upon a growing understanding that butterflies and other insects have evolved complex and dynamic mating behaviours that can respond to predictable changes in their environment," says Ms Prudic.

Squinting bush brown butterflies are native to sandy forest habitats from central to south eastern Africa.

Three to five generations are born per year and developing caterpillars experience considerably different temperatures between wet and dry seasons.

Print Sponsor

The beauty of British butterflies
16 Dec 10 |  Earth News
'Old maid' butterflies fly more
26 Nov 10 |  Earth News
British butterflies on the brink
12 Nov 10 |  Earth News
In Pictures: Butterfly 'bling'
10 Jun 10 |  Earth News
Artificial butterfly takes to air
20 May 10 |  Earth News
'Supersized' butterflies fly far
27 Jan 10 |  Earth News
Butterfly 'GPS' found in antennae
25 Sep 09 |  Science & Environment



From Science/Environment in the past week


Sign in

BBC navigation



Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific