Sign In | Subscribe
Loading video...
For more information, please see full course syllabus of Molecular Biology
  • Discussion

  • Study Guides

  • Practice Questions

  • Download Lecture Slides

  • Table of Contents

  • Transcription

Bookmark and Share

Start Learning Now

Get immediate access to our entire library.

Sign up for

Membership Overview

  • Unlimited access to our entire library of courses.
  • Search and jump to exactly what you want to learn.
  • Practice questions with step-by-step solutions.
  • Download lesson files for programming and software training practice.
  • Track your course viewing progress.
  • Download lecture slides for taking notes.

Genome Editing, Synthetic Biology, & the Ethics of Modern Science

    Medium, 4 examples, 5 practice questions

  • Genome editing is the insertion or deletion of a DNA sequence from a genome using artificially engineered nucleases.
  • Gene therapy is a type of genome editing focused on the treatment of disease.
  • Synthetic biology is the design and manufacture of biological components that do not exist in nature.
  • In 1996, Dolly the sheep was the first animal to be cloned from an adult somatic cell, using the process of nuclear transfer.
  • Research ethics involves the application of ethical principles to a variety of topics involving research.

Genome Editing, Synthetic Biology, & the Ethics of Modern Science

Genetic engineering in which DNA is inserted, replaced, or removed from a genome using artificially engineered nucleases is called:
  • Genome sequencing
  • Genome editing
  • Stem cell biology
  • Synthetic biology
  • True/False: Meganucleases are a type of engineered nucleases used in genome editing.
    • True
    • False
    True/False: CRISPR is a type of adaptive immune system in prokaryotic cells to protect against infection from foreign invaders.
    • True
    • False
    The design and manufacture of biological components that do not exist in nature is called:
  • Genome sequencing
  • Genome editing
  • Stem cell biology
  • Synthetic biology
  • True/False: The Declaration of Helsinki is a set of ethical principles regarding human experimentation developed for the medical community by the World Medical Association.
    • True
    • False



    Genome Editing, Synthetic Biology, & the Ethics of Modern Science


    • Intro 0:00
    • Lesson Overview 0:47
    • Genome Editing 1:37
      • What is Genome Editing
      • How It Works
      • Four Families of Engineered Nucleases in Use
    • Example 1 3:03
    • Gene Therapy 9:37
      • Delivery of Nucleic Acids Into a Patient’s Cells a Treatment for Disease
      • Timeline of Events
    • Example 2 11:03
    • Gene Therapy 12:37
      • Ethical Questions
      • Genetic Engineering
      • Gene Doping
    • Synthetic Biology 13:44
      • Design and Manufacture of Biological Components That Do Not Exist in Nature
      • First Synthetic Cell Example
      • Ethical Questions
    • Stem Cell Biology 18:01
      • Use Stem Cells to Treat or Prevent Diseases
      • Treatment Uses
      • Ethical Questions
    • Selected Topic of Ethical Debate 21:30
    • Research Ethics 28:02
      • Application of Fundamental Ethical Principles
      • Examples
      • Declaration of Helsinki
    • Basic Principles of the Declaration of Helsinki 28:57
      • Utmost Importance: Respect for the Patient
      • Researcher’s Duty is Solely to the Patient or Volunteer
      • Incompetent Research Participant
    • Right Vs Wrong 30:29
    • Ethics 32:40
      • Dolly the Sheep
      • Ethical Questions
      • Rational Reasoning and Justification
    • Example 3 35:17
    • Example 4 38:00
    • Questions to Ponder 39:35
    • How to Answer 40:52
      • Do Your Own Research
      • Difficult for People Outside the Scientific Community
      • Many People Disagree Because They Do Not Understand
      • Media Cannot Be Expected to Understand Published Scientific Data on Their Own

    Transcription: Genome Editing, Synthetic Biology, & the Ethics of Modern Science

    Hello, and welcome back to, thank you for joining me.0000

    This is going to be our last lesson in this molecular biology class.0003

    What I wanted to do is talk about a few subjects that seem to be kind of glazed over,0007

    if it even touched upon it all in normal college classes because they often run at of time.0017

    There is certain information that needs to be covered.0024

    While, this is very interesting stuff, it is not of the utmost importance.0027

    It is really hard to lecture on.0032

    In no way am I going deep into this, I’m just giving a surface level view and try just to get your mind working.0035

    Try to get the topics in your head and just have you thinking about it a little bit.0042

    We are going to talk about genome editing, synthetic biology, and stem cell biology.0048

    We are going to talk about the ethical aspects of each of these, as well as just ethics of science in general.0053

    Many of you who end up going to graduate school will actually have to take seminars in research ethics.0061

    This is something that maybe will just be a starting point for you guys.0069

    For any of you who work in a lab, this is going to be something that you always have to keep in mind.0074

    It is always something that is going to surround your projects.0080

    It is good, we need to think about this.0084

    I’m going to do my job of introducing it to you and hopefully you take this upon yourselves to really think about these aspects. 0088

    Genome editing, let us start with that.0099

    First of all, what is it?0101

    It is genetic engineering in which DNA is either inserted, replaced, 0103

    or removed off from a genome using artificially engineered nucleases.0110

    Remember, nucleases are the enzymes that cut up nucleic acids, DNA and RNA.0116

    How do they work?0123

    Double strand breaks get introduced by the action of the nucleases, at desired locations in the genome.0124

    These double strand breaks then just get repaired by the normal mechanism 0132

    that we have talked about in this molecular biology class of homologous recombination or of non-homologous end joining.0136

    Therefore, families of engineered nucleases that are in use for these processes today.0145

    We have zinc finger nucleases, we have TALENs, we have meganucleases, 0152

    we have the CRISPR-Cas9 system or just the CRISPR system.0157

    Meganucleases, they usually cut on average once per genome.0160

    I'm going to focus on the CRISPR-Cas9 system because this is actually a really interesting system 0167

    and really cool things can be done with this system.0177

    For genome editing, I’m just going to focus on this one.0180

    Here is our example, here is our CRISPR-Cas9 system.0184

    What is CRISPR? It stands for Clustered Regularly Interspaced Short Palindromic Repeats.0189

    Cas9, the Cas proteins, that is CRISPR associated protein.0231

    In this case Cas9, that is CRISPR associated protein 9.0250

    What is this, basically what CRISPR is a very, let us say primitive, adaptive, immune system for bacteria.0255

    If we are looking here, this is some membrane of bacteria.0280

    It is their way of defending against a bacteriophage which is a virus that infects bacteria.0283

    This is a primitive, adaptive, immune system for our prokaryotes, a bacteria.0295

    This CRISPR, it is Clustered Regularly Interspaced Short Palindromic Repeats.0302

    What it does is you have repetitions of base sequences in here, followed by spacer DNA such as this.0312

    These are spacer DNAs.0330

    Those spacers will recognize and cut, act like an endonuclease, cut up invading viral DNA.0334

    It is almost similar to RNA interference but it is a different system for doing it.0346

    How does this work?0353

    First, the virus latches onto the bacteria, injects its DNA.0354

    We have a double stranded viral DNA.0363

    It can be simplified down to a 4 step process.0367

    The invading viral DNA, double stranded DNA, or if it is an RNA virus, same thing can happen.0371

    It is cut into small fragments.0386

    From those fragments, you end up creating a novel spacer.0391

    This is in DNA sequence and this is basically a way that this is linked to this specific piece of DNA.0397

    The invading DNA or RNA is cut into small fragments, that is step 1.0407

    Step 2, a copy of that invading DNA or RNA is integrated into the CRISPR locus as a spacer.0414

    This one, this corresponded to a different piece of viral DNA.0426

    This one to a different one and to a different one, and to a different one.0435

    It is adaptive meaning it has seen that before, it keeps a piece of it so if it ever sees that DNA again, 0441

    it will be able to break that down and silence it.0448

    Step 2, you make a copy of it, you put into that CRISPR locus as a spacer.0452

    3rd step, the CRISPR RNA which is called a crRNA, CRISPR RNA, they get transcribed.0459

    We will call this, this is step 1, this is step 2, this is step 3.0470

    The CRISPR RNAs are transcribed from the CRISPR locus.0485

    And then step 4, we have the crRNAs, the CRISPR RNAs, being incorporated into the CRISPR-Cas complex.0488

    And then 5, it will target viral DNA, invading viral DNA and it will degrade that.0501

    If want to call that, this is 6.0513

    The crRNA will provide specificity.0516

    It will act only, the crRNA, produced from these specific spacers, will specifically act on what is already seen.0520

    Researchers can utilize this as the crRNA, the CRISPR RNA, providing specificity for such things as, 0532

    let us say gene editing for medical purposes.0543

    You can silence something, let us say if you have an overactive gene that is causing the disease, 0546

    you can use the CRISPR-Cas9 complex to utilize that, you could silence that.0552

    There is plenty more in depth detail to go into this that I'm not going to go into.0563

    But I recommend you try to look this up, this is really cool, fairly cutting edge techniques being used here.0567

    Gene therapy, specifically that is our delivery in nucleic acids into a patient's cell for treatment of a disease.0579

    You can either be adding a gene, you can be knocking out a gene.0587

    You could be replacing a gene, any of that.0593

    The polymers of the nucleic acids are either expressed as proteins.0598

    Therefore, interfere with protein expression or directly correct genetic mutations by replacing the actual DNA sequence.0604

    The DNA that encodes a functional therapeutic gene will replace the mutated gene.0614

    Therefore, when it is transcribed and translated, you will get the wild type protein, 0621

    instead of the mutant protein that has been causing the disease.0626

    Gene therapy, the theory on it was first published in 1972.0632

    The first experiment approved by the FDA occurred in 1990, about 18 years later.0638

    13 years after that, the first commercial gene therapy was approved at for use as a cancer treatment.0645

    The gene therapy called genidicine was approved in China in 2003.0653

    An example of a gene therapy, right here, we can see this is gene therapy using an adenovirus vector.0664

    An adenovirus is a specific type of virus, what it can do is you can manipulate the DNA inside the virus.0672

    The virus will infect the cell, bring that DNA into the nucleus of the cell.0680

    That DNA now being a good piece of DNA, not something we need to worry about of like viral DNA.0686

    But something that we plan on putting there, that will be healthy for the cell, 0693

    will then make the certain proteins that we wanted to make and will help, if used properly to treat that disease.0697

    This is a little different from RNAi or from the CRISPR system, in the fact that we have something 0707

    that we always need taking into consideration, when we involve a virus.0714

    Yes, it is there are plenty of research on it and plenty of ways that it has been altered, 0720

    so that it should not be able to replicate and cause disease as any normal virus would.0729

    As always, something as a scientist and as the public, you keep in the back your mind.0735

    But for the most part, it does its job without infecting quote and quote, in a bad way, but infecting in a good way,0740

    getting in the cell, giving its DNA which has the good DNA that we want to make the protein of interest.0748

    Some ethical questions revolving around gene therapy is, there is always going to be problems of genetic engineering.0758

    Maybe the protein that you wanted to be sent in there.0766

    Maybe there is a mutation on the gene.0771

    Maybe you did not engineer the gene properly.0773

    Or just maybe the ethical question of just revolving around genetic engineering itself,0776

    manipulating the genome, playing god, if you want to say it that way.0784

    Another question that always is going to surround gene therapy is the aspect of gene doping,0790

    meaning, basically, if used improperly, you could almost use it as a performance enhancing drug alteRNAtive.0797

    You can do gene therapy to make you bigger, faster, stronger, have more oxygen carrying capacity, something like that.0810

    That is always a question that will be thrown around.0819

    Moving on to a different topic, synthetic biology.0827

    Synthetic biology is described as the design and manufacture of biological components that do not exist in nature.0831

    There are many ways of look at synthetic biology.0840

    I want to look at a specific one.0843

    This is an example of synthetic biology work.0847

    In 2010, scientist at the J. Craig Venter institute, if you remember J. Craig Venter, 0852

    he was the entrepreneur that was involved in pushing the private funded aspect of the human genome project.0856

    Scientists at this institute had been opened, run by him, created the first synthetic cell.0869

    What they did is they started with a bacteria called mycoplasma capricolum.0876

    What they did is they took out all of the DNA, any genetic material in there, 0882

    and replaced it by using the transformation technique with a brand new fully synthesized,0889

    fully synthetic, fully brand new DNA, made from their typing on a keyboard.0898

    They made it in a computer, made a bunch of DNA, you can get DNA made.0907

    They inserted their computer coded DNA into this completely empty cell.0914

    It is like a shell at this point.0922

    They obviously tried it many times until one work.0924

    And they finally found a sequence that was actually able to replicate the cell, as if it were a normal cell.0926

    In this case, they actually created a new species that they called mycoplasma mycoides.0937

    This is huge, they were able to take a manmade coded DNA sequence and put it in a shell of a bacteria, to make a living replicable organism.0944

    This is a huge, absolutely huge event.0964

    That was such a huge event like that, there is always going to be ethical questions.0971

    One of the big questions that surrounded this was, did they create new life or did they just manipulate life?0978

    You can have your own opinion on this, one of the rulings I believe it went to the court system was that, 0992

    this was not actually the creation of a new life.0999

    However, this is something that will always be asked about.1002

    Some other ethical questions regarding synthetic biology is genome always are an ethical debate in and of itself.1009

    But when you start being able to computer code genes and be able put it into an organism, 1016

    that brings up an entire new set of questions about gene.1024

    Finally, the fear of these synthetic bacteria that they made does not exist in nature.1030

    It was not intended to exist in nature.1039

    We have made it exist, we as a human race made it exist.1041

    What is that going to, what type of effect will that have on the current ecosystem, the currently living system?1046

    Can that bacteria infect other species?1055

    They took very good precautions to make it a non infective bacteria, in non-virulent strain.1059

    But there are ways that it can mutate or there are ways that,1066

    maybe somebody else might not take as great of care or might use this for ill purposes.1070

    That is always going to be an ethics debate.1078

    Moving on to stem cell biology, I know this is a big hot topic.1082

    This is been ethically debated, since the thoughts of stem cell biology came out.1086

    What is stem cell biology or using stem cells to treat or prevent disease.1093

    Often you have your stem cells coming from the bone marrow.1097

    When you talk about bone marrow transplant, a lot of times people with cancer,1104

    or multiple myeloma, they are one of the specific ones.1109

    You need to get bone marrow transplant and that is because cancer,1113

    as well as the chemotherapy, ravages your quickly dividing cells such as your B and T cells.1117

    Your B cells, part of your immunity that is found in your bone marrow.1124

    You need bone marrow replacement.1128

    You have what are called hematopoietic stem cells, these are stem cells that can turn into any type of white or red blood cell.1131

    Your B and T cells are a type of white blood cell.1139

    This is very useful and a very common practice nowadays.1143

    Some people do not agree with the fact of umbilical cord blood being utilized as a source of stem cells.1149

    In a huge contest or point of contention, is the fact of actually using embryonic stem cells.1157

    Stem cells from fetuses or unborn fetuses, that is a huge point of contention1166

    with many groups especially your religious focus groups.1173

    As well as even some nonreligious focus, some scientists do not agree with it.1179

    You can also have embryonic stem cells.1184

    You can also have what is called somatic cell nuclear transfer technique.1186

    But you need to start with some sort of a cell to begin with.1190

    The good thing about stem cell biology is that it can be used to treat many types of diseases.1196

    You have leukemia lymphoma, diabetes, injuries to the brain and spinal cord, deafness, anemia.1204

    Anemia is the low concentration of red blood cells which will then affect your oxygen carrying capacity.1214

    As well as stem cell biology can be used to treat organelle transplantation, to hope that goes well.1225

    Some of the ethical questions, are you destroying life?1234

    If we are talking about using embryonic stem cells, are you actually destroying a life that should have been?1239

    That is going to be a point of contention that people are going to have, a side versus the other.1247

    A lot of these decisions on ethics, you try to use as much as possible.1254

    But really, it is going to come down to belief systems and 1260

    how you can manage that between yourself and the people that you have a contention with.1263

    Another one is human cloning.1270

    If we are using stem cells to make other humans, that is a huge point of contention.1272

    As of right now, human cloning is not allowed.1281

    Will it be in the future? Maybe, we do not know.1286

    Other than the ones that I had mentioned before, there are many other topics that are up for ethical debate.1292

    Some that I wanted to list here, genetically modified organisms.1299

    Vaccines, the whole vaccines, people will be thinking that they are correlated to autism.1304

    Based on a study published by a medical doctor who named Andrew Wakefield, in The Lancet,1313

    who was actually paid by competing vaccine company to falsify data 1323

    and talk bad about the vaccines that are out on the market, which has spawned even though he lost his medical license.1330

    Once it was found that he falsified his data, the paper was retracted but a lot of people do not hear that part of it.1339

    They only hear the fact that the story was published years ago.1346

    This is always going to be for debate.1351

    A lot of people do not have the right facts to follow that one specifically.1353

    We have other topics for debate like save your babies.1358

    A save your baby is when a couple has a child with a condition where they are dying because they lack,1361

    let us say for example they have a kidney disease and they need a kidney transplant.1374

    Sometimes a couple will have another baby that was basically meant 1379

    to use that second baby as basically an organ farm for the treatment of the first child.1385

    The second baby was born so that it can give a kidney transplant to the first child who is sick.1395

    There is always going to be ethical debate over that.1406

    There is ethical debate on genetic manipulation.1410

    Gene editing for health, you will have people on both sides.1413

    As well as the build –a-bear type baby, I want to make my baby blue eyes, 6’5, highly athletic and highly intelligent.1419

    Who is to stop somebody from picking all the best qualities to make their child, just like a freak of nature?1433

    I want to make somebody with the basketball skills and body type of Le Bron James, with the mind of Albert Einstein.1443

    It is something crazy like that.1454

    Prenatal genome sequencing, for the same reason, on being able to do that build-a-bear baby.1458

    Genome sequencing and insurance companies.1464

    If I sequence my genome because I want to know what diseases I’m susceptible for.1467

    Insurance companies are allowed to have that data, they might not offer me insurance at all.1474

    Or might have an extremely high premiums, based on my risk factors.1482

    That is a huge debate.1488

    Cloning, always a big one, specially human cloning.1490

    Animal testing, big debate.1493

    You are always going to have groups that PETA and even other scientists telling you that animal testing1495

    does not need to happen or does need happen.1503

    You do need to test on animals, if you want to pass selected drugs through the FDA, to get to the market.1507

    Like your Advil, your Tylenol, even all the way up through your chemotherapies,1518

    they have all had to have been tested on animals, before they allowed to go in the clinical trials and be tested on humans.1525

    Even though there is ethical debate on this, there is a specific way that you have to follow, 1534

    to be able to get your drugs on the market.1542

    And then, one that is a different type of ethical debate is falsifying data.1547

    As a scientist or as a future scientists, this is extremely important.1558

    Falsifying data, whether it is for any reason, sometimes people falsify 1565

    because it will help them get a promotion or maybe they work for a drug company and they are trying to push their product.1571

    Maybe they just want to become famous, whatever the reason.1578

    This has a huge detriment to the scientific community.1581

    Not only does it make people in the scientific community and outside the scientific community distrust the overall scientific community.1586

    But it can actually hurt the current focus of research because if someone comes out and says that1598

    this is an answer to a question that everyone has been looking for, and they falsified all your data,1612

    you do not have a lot of people able to back up their results but maybe just believe it.1621

    Then, you take that for granted that that is the correct answer.1628

    It can set you back 50 years.1633

    It can end up causing you to go down the rabbit hole.1635

    This is a huge deal that everyone needs to have high morals, when creating their research.1639

    They need to give their data, not falsified data.1647

    Do not cherry pick your results, you give all your results not just the ones that make your story look good.1652

    If you do the experiment 10 times and 9 out of 10 times it fails, but one fails does not gives you an answer you do not want.1661

    But the one time, it gives you the answer that you do want, that is the only piece of data that you share with the public, that is a problem.1670

    That is a big ethical problem.1677

    Let us talk about research ethics in general.1684

    Research ethics involves the application of fundamental ethical research principles to variety of topics involving research.1687

    Examples will include the design and implementation of research, involving both animal and human experimentation.1700

    As well as scientific misconduct, like the falsifying data falls under that.1706

    The declaration of Helsinki which is set forth in 1964 is a set of ethical principles, 1713

    regarding human experimentation developed for the medical community by the WMA, the World Medical Association.1724

    This is the first fairly complete document that most countries adopted.1731

    The basic principles of this declaration of Helsinki was that, of utmost importance is the respect for the patient.1739

    Their right to self determination and their right to make an informed decision which we hear very often, 1749

    informed consent, we hear that in hospitals a lot in the US.1756

    It is important that they know what they are getting themselves into in a certain research, trial, let us say.1763

    What is important is at the researchers duty is solely to the patient or volunteer,1772

    meaning they care most importantly about the patient, overall, even over the research.1778

    As hard as that is to think about, as a researcher, the patient is the most important part.1788

    Patient welfare takes precedence over both scientific and societal interests.1796

    Ethical considerations will take precedence over laws and regulations.1804

    Very importantly, same thing that we see in the hospital system as well.1810

    If a research participant is incompetent, physically and mentally incapable of giving a consent or is a minor, 1816

    then you need to get surrogate consent from somebody else.1823

    The last few slides, I just want to talk about what is right vs. wrong.1833

    When we talk about ethics, you talk about right vs. wrong.1841

    The ultimate debate, ethics is the ultimate debate of right vs. wrong.1846

    There is no correct answer, there are maybe one that you favor but there is no truly correct answer, when we are talking about this.1852

    The question is going to be asked forever.1862

    Much of modern biotech has a markedly lifespan and health span focused approach.1864

    Lifespan, making people live from saying not just 80 years old to 100 years old.1871

    Health span is actually being healthy until you are 80 instead of 70, something like that.1878

    A lot of that is a morally, good morally, just goal.1888

    There are still lingering fears that exists that scientists have too much control over human evolution and destiny.1894

    Because the better we get with technology and biotechnology specifically, 1902

    the more control we have over the human body, the animals, plants, and bacteria around us.1906

    It is that fear of we are becoming a godlike figure, we can affect destiny.1917

    In additional laws and regulations, both public and political opinions1928

    can affect the current and future state of research and development.1933

    This is something that we are forever going to have to work with, that is not going away.1936

    Scientists cannot just stay in a hole and do their research, without worrying or taking into consideration 1945

    what politicians and the public have to say about it, for better or worse.1953

    Let us talk about a specific aspect.1963

    We will bring up Dolly the sheep, if any of us remember that.1966

    This happened in 1996 in Scotland.1969

    Dolly was the first animal to be cloned from an adult’s somatic cell, using the process of nuclear transfer.1972

    What that was is, the nucleus from an adult cell is transferred into an unfertilized, enucleated, without a nucleus zygote, which is an egg cell.1980

    You have an egg cell, you take out the nucleus.1995

    You take the nucleus from an adult cell, from a different animal.1998

    Take the nucleus out, put it into the egg.2004

    Zygote enucleated, adult cell with the nucleus.2015

    Take that out, put it into here, and then try to grow an organism.2020

    They actually did this with the sheep.2028

    That sheep lasted about 6 years, before passing away.2031

    This brought up a lot of questions and will continue to bring up a lot of questions.2037

    The fact of, is science unstoppable or can we actually limit how far we go, based on rational ethical thinking?2041

    Just because certain science is possible, does not mean that it will actually come to fruition, 2054

    if we as scientists or researchers think rationally and ethically.2060

    But the public always fears that science and scientist would not.2066

    It will always be, we want to do this just because we can do it not because we think it is going to be beneficial.2072

    That is why this is kind of, just because we can, should we, type of the question.2080

    What is going to happen is that, it may fall upon the scientific community to start the ethical discussion within itself.2088

    As human biotech research progresses, as it is doing right now, 2097

    ethical debates will continue to heat up and will continue to be extremely hot.2101

    Not only actions but also the intentions of the scientific community require rational reasoning and justification.2108

    An example here for ethics is the whole genome sequencing.2120

    Pretty expensive in general but it is becoming cheaper and cheaper.2126

    We have that $1000 genome insight, meaning, I might, in the near future be able to send in a sample of my DNA 2130

    and for only $1000 get my entire genetic profile, which would be amazing.2138

    But whole genome sequencing differs from current prenatal genetic testing.2147

    First of all, current tests identify only serious genetic conditions in fetuses, at about moderate to high risk.2153

    Whereas prenatal whole genome sequencing could allow for the entire genetic profile.2165

    This could lead to the possibility of wanting to make that build-a-bear type kid.2173

    I can see that my kid will have brown eyes.2185

    Maybe we can use some gene therapy and give him or her, blue eyes.2188

    Or maybe, my child is going to be a boy, is it early enough to where I can change it to be a girl?2193

    Or my child will have autism or another type of disease that is not considered seriously fatal, that is not currently being tested.2201

    I think we only test for somewhere, I could be wrong, I think around 13 to 15 different genetic conditions.2221

    But this can lead to a situation where me and my child will have chondroplasia, might be a little person.2229

    Any of these things that are not perfectly in line with what the parents wanted, 2240

    they can either fix that to their liking or decide to not proceed with the pregnancy.2248

    A lot of these ethical issues will come up.2256

    Also, this whole genome sequencing, as I said before, you can get your whole genome profile2259

    but maybe the insurance companies, the health Insurance companies get a hold for that.2265

    They would be able to possibly then decline you, based on your risk of a certain disease, big ethics problem.2269

    On the good side, golden rice, a genetically modified organism.2283

    This is a rice strain that was modified to contain β carotene.2288

    β carotene is a precursor of vitamin A.2293

    A single serving of this golden rice supplies 60% of the recommended dietary allowance of vitamin A.2297

    This is important because according to the World Health Organization,2308

    more than 215,000,000 preschool age children are vitamin A deficient.2313

    Over 2 million deaths in more than 500,000 cases of blindness are due to vitamin A deficiency worldwide.2321

    Just the introduction of this strain of rice can help decrease this.2332

    In fact, there have been estimates that over a million people have been saved from dying, 2340

    in the several years that the golden rice has been on the market.2351

    It will just continue to rise, as year by year goes by.2359

    This is a good aspect, however, still going to be ethical debates.2364

    There is always going to be people who are for or against genetically modified organisms.2367

    I had just last two slides and I want to leave you with some questions to ponder.2377

    When thinking about research, any specific research, you want to know what is the societal impact?2383

    Are any human rights being violated?2391

    That is a big one.2393

    Do the benefits outweigh the risks?2396

    Do any means justify a good end?2400

    The means justify the end, right?2406

    Or sorry, does the end justify the means?2408

    But does any means, how you get to that result, is that okay?2410

    Does biotech ultimately advance or impede the common good of humanity, and the world as a whole?2416

    This is probably the toughest one to think about, is there anything that we have not thought about yet?2426

    That is a tough one to think about because you think about everything, and then there is always something later.2432

    This one you really have to prepare, prepare and think.2439

    How do you answer questions on ethical debates?2454

    The biggest thing that I can tell you is doing your own research, do your own literature research.2461

    You should be the expert on all the experiments that have been done before, both for and against.2471

    You want to know both sides of the argument, why it is an ethical debate, why it is bad.2482

    You need to do your literature research, that is a huge thing.2494

    You need to understand the science and you need to understand the ethical ramifications from this.2497

    This is extremely difficult, even for people in the scientific community, literature and analysis is a tough job.2504

    It is tough to do, you get better every time you do it but is really tough.2517

    It is a tough skill to master.2524

    For those of you outside of the scientific community, it is even harder because2527

    they are not strong in the subjects of biology, of genetics, of biotechnology.2532

    They do not understand it, they might not understand why you would use a certain experiment 2538

    or why you might have to use animal experimentation.2544

    A lot of the disagreements come from the fact that many people are uninformed or many people do not understand the science.2550

    The media, the scientists are not usually the ones who is talking straight to the public,2561

    the media are the ones talking to the public and the politicians.2566

    The media, as much as we want them to know everything,2570

    they cannot be expected to understand published scientific data on their own.2578

    That is going to land on the scientific community.2584

    We need to educate the general public and especially those in the media who cover scientific topics.2589

    It falls on our shoulders, we need to educate the media, we need to educate the public 2597

    so we can bring them up onto the knowledge level to understand much easier.2602

    But once we educate the public, especially once we educate the media,2610

    the media is responsible for taking it upon themselves, taking it upon themselves to gauge their level of understanding,2616

    before writing articles that will reach the masses and possibly promote fear mongering.2631

    The media needs to understand the science, before writing an article that could cause a huge problem in the nonscientific community.2640

    We, as scientists, can only do our best to educate the community, to educate the media.2656

    The media has to take it upon themselves that if they do not really understand what is going on,2662

    they need to reach out and do their own homework and get in touch with the scientists to prepare themselves.2668

    That is the end of the lecture, the end of the course.2676

    I wanted to say from myself, thank you so much for joining the course.2680

    I really hope you enjoyed it, and from, we appreciate you seeing this course.2685

    Please check out some other courses, there are plenty, from high school through the college level.2692

    From me, and, thanks for joining and we hope to see you again.2700