Ten Moneyball Metrics for Competitive Cities

Source: Meeting of the Minds on January 24, 2017 | Stephen Jordan and Steve Rochlin

In a world where people can increasingly choose to live anywhere, cities have to compete in ways that they never anticipated. International finance, global supply chains, connectivity, automation, rapid transit and transportation have all combined to heighten mobility in unprecedented ways. Specifically when it comes to economic development, there are many traditional metrics that city executives know that business leaders evaluate:

  • Tax and regulatory environment
  • Workforce development and readiness
  • Transportation and transit solutions
  • Connectivity

But there are also some not-so-obvious “Moneyball” metrics that will help to promote city attractiveness, sustainability, and resilience that also contribute to success. These include:

1. Access for All

When cities advance policies, solutions, and investment like those listed above, do they create mechanisms to enable individuals from all income backgrounds to benefit from them?

2. Flow

This is an important component of accessibility. How well and how easily can employees and their families get from point A to point B – not just in terms of employment, but in terms of access to culture, cuisine, sports, and outdoor recreation? This has great implications, not just for transit, but also for being open to an array of transportation options.

3. Diffusion

Accessibility is vital for all residents to be able to take advantage of existing urban amenities, but the converse of this is also important – how well does a city diffuse amenities throughout, as opposed to maintaining clusters and status quo patterns?

4. Resilience

Vulnerabilities, whether to extreme weather, climate, geology, or even human factors are unavoidable, but how well does a community anticipate, prepare for and mitigate them?

5. Red Space v Green Space

Many older cities in particular, have white elephants, whether they are strip malls, housing blocks, or other monstrosities that made sense at one time, but which take up space that could be otherwise used now. At the same time, cities are increasingly discovering that repurposing old infrastructure with an eye for green space can be an important magnet and competitive advantage. Look at what happened with the New York High Line.

6. Education

For the last few years in site selection surveys, education and quality of life have ranked consistently in the top 3-5 preferences. Employees with school age children often cite the caliber of school as affecting their housing decisions.

7. Health and Well-Being

This concept has expanded a lot in recent years. It isn’t just about the number of hospitals or clinics that a city has, but also its sports, hiking, lakes, clean air, bicycles, sidewalks, food culture, and other factors.

8. Civic Environment

Robust civil society organizations form important intermediary and social networking functions that help tie communities together. One of the first things that many senior executives do when they transition their corporate headquarters is to join one or more municipal civic boards like the arts or community chest organizations.

Read more here