









Military staff work

Military organizations from the battalion level up operate under a commanding officer (CO) who runs things through a staff. The staff positions at the battalion level (the lowest level with a formal staff) are enumerated as follows:

 1. S-1, typically a Captain in charge of personnel, orders, schools, awards, promotions. This guy is the paper pusher.

 2. S-2, typically a Captain in charge of intelligence and reconnaissance. This guy is the spook.

 3. S-3, typically a Captain, sometimes a Major, in charge of plans and operations.

This is the guy who hammers out the attack orders and coordinates with supporting artillery, fast movers, choppers, and other air assets.

He is typically a very experienced former company commander. He is the plans guy.

 4. S-4, typically a Captain in charge of logistics and supply — beans & bullets. This guy makes sure the troops get chow, water, and ammunition as well as weapons and gear.

 5. S-5, typically a Captain in charge of civil affairs. This is a new area since the Big Red Car was in the service back in the day.

This organization is overseen by the Commanding Officer and the Executive Officer. The XO, the CO’s understudy and his replacement if the CO is killed, runs the staff.

At a higher level, such as an Army or Marine infantry division, there is also a Chief of Staff in addition to Assistant Division Commanders for maneuver and support. At the division level, a “G” is used rather than a “S.” So, the S-1 at Division is the G-1.

In every instance, the staff reports to the CO through the XO or the Chief of Staff. Nobody is freelancing, though the CO is perfectly free to wander over to the “3” shop and make a progress check on the planning or the “2” shop and get an update on intel.

The point is that the military is uber organized and the roles played by each staff officer are well-documented and orchestrated. The Chief of Staff is the guy who makes sure the staff is converting the “commander’s intent” into real world plans.

In the White House, the staff positions are of varying function and order. Whoever has the President’s ear exerts the most influence on the rest of the President’s body including his brain.

General Kelly knows how a staff is supposed to operate to achieve the commander’s goals.

White House, WTF?

President Trump is an experienced big company executive, but he has never operated at the level of complexity and breadth required of the POTUS. No harm, no foul. It is a unique job.

Nobody in this office ever has come in ready to go except for General Dwight David Eisenhower who’d had a stint as a 5-star General and the first NATO commander. He knew how a staff was supposed to operate and his wartime staff was Americans and Brits.

He had served under both Gen George Catlett Marshal and Gen Douglas MacArthur as a staff officer. He learned from the best ever.

He once said of MacArthur: “Oh, yes, I studied dramatics under him for twelve years.”

To which MacArthur retorted: “Eisenhower was the best clerk I ever had.”

general eisenhower, general dwight d. eisenhower, air chief marshall sir arthur tedder, general sir bernard montgomery, lieutenant general omar bradley, admiral sir bertram ramsey, air chief marshal sir trafford leigh mallory, lieutenant general w. bedell smith, world war II, allied military leaders

Lt General W Bedell “Beetle” Smith, Eisenhower’s WWII Chief of Staff, back row, right. At this time, Lt Gen Omar Bradley (left, back row) was the foremost and most experienced amphibious planner in Europe. He later became an Army and Army Group Commander when the DDay invasion was launched. He knew the plan because he’d overseen its crafting. Lower right, man Eisenhower is facing, is General Sir Bernard Montgomery, the most cautious General in the post DDay fight.

You can expect General Kelly to organize, streamline, and operate a complementary staff with military precision.

General Kelly, who is this guy, Big Red Car?

They are not giving out four stars in USMC Crackerjack boxes. To become a Marine 4-star is as likely as winning the Irish Sweepstakes. You have to be the best of the best. And, you have to perform like a Lipizzaner.

Kelly has been in the following assignments of note:

 1. At the company level: platoon commander, executive officer, company commander of both rifle and weapons companies;
2. Battalion S-3 officer in a Marine infantry battalion;
3. Head of Offensive Tactics Section, and Director of the USMC Infantry Officer Course;
4. Commanding Officer 1st Light Armored Recon Battalion, 1st Marine Division (involved in the 1992 Los Angeles riots);
 5. Commandant of the USMC’s Liaison Officer to the US House of Representatives — note this! He knows how the Congress operates;
 6. Special Assistant to the Supreme Allied Commander, Europe;
 7. Assistant Chief of Staff, G-3, 2nd Marine Division;
 8. Assistant Division Commander (under Mad Dog Mattis, CO) 1st Marine Division in Iraq (a position held by the legendary Chesty Puller);
9. Commander of Task Force Tripoli which took Samarra and Takrit after the 1st Marine Division participated in the conquering of Baghdad;
 10. Legislative Assistant to the USMC Commandant;
11. Commanding Officer 1st Marine Expeditionary Force (Afghanistan);
12. Commanding Officer Multi-National Force-West (Iraq);
13. Senior Military Assistant to the Secretary of Defense (Leon Panetta); and,
14. Commanding Officer of the US Southern Command (Caribbean, Mexico, South America)

This is a man exquisitely prepared for command and service at the highest levels for almost half a century. He knows the subject material.

In addition, he attended the following schools:

 1. Undergrad University of Massachusetts (BA),
2. Masters Georgetown University School of Foreign Service in National Security Studies (MA),
3. Masters National Defense University (MS),
4. Officer Candidate School USMC,
5.  The USMC Basic School;
6. The US Army Infantry Officer (Fort Benning School for Boys),
7. The USMC Command and General Staff College,
8. School for Advanced Warfare, and,
9. National War College.

This is an extraordinary amount of schooling for a man who served his first two years in the USMC as an enlisted man.

General Kelly has had exquisite preparation for his new position. He has been well educated, has been challenged in his assignments, has had a record of superlative and increasing responsibility, and has been at the touch point of legislation and the military numerous times. He knows everybody who needs to be known in Washington, DC.

It is unlikely you could create a fictional character with better preparation.

The Trump White House

The Trump White House provides some unique challenges. First, there is the President himself. He is not a professional politician. He and Kelly will get along fine.

[Let’s face it. Donald J Trump was a bone-spurred draft dodger during the Vietnam Era. There, it’s been said. The Big Red Car said it. Deal with it. President Trump will defer to General Kelly — who did not serve in Vietnam — like a jock sniffer. Figure that one out, but it’s all about compensation. Check with your shrink and ask her to ‘splain that to y’all.]

Then, there is the Trump royal family and insiders. To get control of the White House, it is essential that Kushner, Ivanka, Bannon, Kellyanne, and The Mooch get with the program. They cannot report directly to the President and have the White House run efficiently.

This is the biggest operational challenge for President Trump — not for General Kelly, for President Trump. If he wants to get the most out of General Kelly’s ability to run a staff, then he has to ensure the staff reports to Kelly.

No give on this issue. This is the keystone of the entire operation.

BTW, the President, Secretary Ross, Secretary Mnuchin, and General Kelly had dinner at the Trump hotel in DC last night. Hitting the ground running. Huge advantage, General Kelly knows the Cabinet.

Prediction, Big Red Car?

Yeah, I’ll give you a prediction. You are going to find out that the guy with the four stars is smart, articulate, clever, gentlemanly, and efficient. In the end, he will run that White House like it was an adjunct of the United States Marine Corps and when the Marines are in charge of things, things get done.

You’re also going to find out that Kelly and Mad Dog mesh like a hand in a glove. General Kelly was Mad Dog’s ADC (assistant division commander) when Mad Dog had the 1st Mar Div. That ain’t chopped liver, y’all. They are battle buddies.

Hey, America, I got this. Calm down and let me operate. See you on the high ground. Now, President Trump, what do you want done, sir?

But, hey, what the Hell do I really know anyway? I’m just a Big Red Car, but this guy is a Marine.  And, that, dear readers, is how the cow is going to eat the cabbage.



3 thoughts on “Chief of Staff — John F Kelly, Gen, USMC Retired — Hold On, Get Ready!

  1. Right away, early, first day on the job, Kelly dumps Mooch! That was fast!

    Supposedly the WH communications team (group, department, flock, gaggle) has 40 people. Gads. No wonder Trump wanted a strong CoS!

  2. Q 1. How is it possible to go from an enlisted Marine for two years to an officer Marine?

    Q 2. That’s a LOT of people: The POTUS already has a Cabinet.

    E.g., the Marines have the 2 sections, S-2, G-2, while the POTUS has the NSA, CIA, DIA, NRO, and no doubt more. He not only has the DoD but also has his National Security Advisor H.R. McMaster, the NSC right in the White House, and the whole Department of State.

    Trump also has Pence for various assignments.

    My impression is that Trump wants Bannon, Ivanka, Jared, KellyAnn, and Mooch as close-in people he can trust, to look at the issues and the mountains of input and tell Trump what they think, e.g., what the public might think, so that Trump doesn’t have to do all the thinking, can have some people he trusts to do some of it for him, and so that he can get some trusted feedback on some of his thinking. I’m also guessing that Trump is grooming Ivanka as the first female POTUS. Bannon may also be the main source of most of Trump’s speeches and well crafted phrases.

    Then I’m left wondering just who will report to Kelly?

    Who in the White House, McMaster and the NSC? E.g., if Trump is to be shooting at North Korea, I’m guessing that he will want to discuss that in detail in person with Tillerson, Mattis, McMaster and the NSC, maybe the Joint Chiefs, WITHOUT Kelly as a layer
    between Trump and those people.

    Sure reporting to Kelly would be the White House Travel Office, the appointments and scheduling people, the Secret Service, the White House kitchen, etc. I have to doubt that Kelly was brought in to do better with those groups.

    Who outside the White House will report to Kelly — some of the cabinet secretaries? The NSA, CIA, DIA, etc.?

    To guess Kelly’s job, a way to guess is to improve in some respects on Priebus. E.g., maybe Trump wanted the White House to push on Congress hard enough to get them to repeal and replace ObamaCare; since the White House didn’t do that, maybe Trump wants Kelly to take whatever White House people are needed to get that repeal and replace DONE — or have Kelly go to the White House Congressional Liaison office, kick some butts, and get them actually getting things done? Same for the tax bill, the funding for the border wall, jobs for inner cities, judges and other appointments approved, etc. So, in this way, Kelly is just to charge harder than Priebus did?

    Good to learn some about how the military battalions and divisions are organized and managed, but it looks to me like the White House and the cabinets are quite different.

Comments are closed.