10.59987/ads/2011.1-2.1-2
application/pdf
1971-1441
186
1-2
en
D. De Simone
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
Annali di stomatologia
Editorial
Text.Serial.Journal
https://www.annalidistomatologia.eu/ads
2
Editorial
2011-06-01
2022-08-18
2011-06-01
2024-04-18
1-2
Ann Stomatol (Roma)
D. De Simone
2011/06/01
10.59987/ads/2011.1-2.1-2
1
1971-1441
1-2
en
2
Editorial
https://www.annalidistomatologia.eu/ads/article/download/186/166
2
    Editorial




                                                                                                li
                                                                                             na
    Biomedicine is undergoing momentous evolution in these early years of the third millennium. Naturally,
    the dental sciences are not excluded, with subtle but decisive developments concerning quality in cli-
    nical practice, multilevel training for professionals (dentists, paramedics, residents, lecturers and stu-




                                                                                          io
    dents in continuing education in medicine, etc.), applied and basic scientific research, technology re-
    search and materials science. Patient awareness is also of growing importance. A basic knowledge




                                                                       az
    of the signs and symptoms of both common and rare diseases is essential for the general public, ena-
    bling prompt action to be taken when necessary. This is an important tangential aspect of scientific re-
    search, which is stimulated by the social needs of populations in northern countries. Patients (fami-
    lies and schools, in the case of children) thus need to be involved in issues such as public health and




                                                                     rn
    the spread of monitoring and rapid response practices.
    The present issue represents part of the best international - predominantly European - scientific pu-
    blishing precisely because it highlights the scientific and technological originality of research in this sen-




                                                            te
    sitive and continuously developing sector. Its perusal, consultation, and, it is hoped, its rapid inclusion
    in international databases (hopefully the ISI, being so far the most prestigious) will boost its use and
                                                   In
    subsequent discussion among the international leaders in this scientific sector.
    For several years, the “Sapienza” University of Rome’s Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Scien-
    ces and the Istituto Superiore di Sanità (ISS - the Italian National Institute of Health) have collabora-
    ted, through a scientific publishing training program, to promote the importance of the international dif-
                                                 ni
    fusion of original data in the areas of science, epidemiology, medical ethics and the translation from
    preclinical to clinical research. For example, we have constantly stressed the importance to Italy of data
    sharing: making our best clinical and methodological data available to the broadest international com-
                                       io


    munity (including more and more emerging economy-BRIC countries). This seems both necessary and,
    indeed, urgent, to strengthen the standing of Italian universities and research groups which in some
                             iz



    regions still need to develop a more international outlook, including through the good practice of scien-
    tific publishing. Publishing is in fact of growing importance. Scientific books, articles and papers are
    made immortal by the creation of scientific libraries as cradles of knowledge and guardians of ever-
             Ed




    improving methodology. However, the advent of computers, followed by the Internet, has given rise to
    strong bibliometric currents in scientific publishing: evaluation of both the number and, it is hoped, the
    quality of citations of individual authors and research groups provides a “cold” evaluation of the importance,
    relative persistence and citations durability of a given paper. A “publish or perish“ attitude is in fact cur-
 IC




    rently flourishing among Italian ministerial decision-makers, albeit in a debatable and perhaps misleading
    form.
    With respect to biomedicine in general, this issue forms part of an ambitious attempt to strengthen ex-
    cellent clinical practice, particularly in less industrially and economically privileged European countries,
C




    with publications meeting the highest international standards. Associationism in international science
    reflects and is reflected by scientific publishing, as is evident from the history of at least the last two
    centuries of contemporary scientific thought. As an aside, this seems a good opportunity to lament the
©




    excessively fast globalization of scientific publishing by both professional bodies and specialist publi-
    shers, bypassing Europe and thus hindering the construction of preeminent European networks to at-
    tract funding for research and education.
    In Italy, joint initiatives between the ISS and the world of academic clinical research in orthodontics,
    whose heart is the Department of Dental and Maxillofacial Sciences in Rome, have been ongoing for
    the last 15 years. These have revealed an important common objective: people (both young and not-

    Annali di Stomatologia 2011; II (1-2): 1-2                                                                  1
    so-young) who choose a profession in healthcare for its social prestige and necessity, and because
    it provides great satisfaction and social respectability. This often complements students’ spontaneous
    altruism, as demonstrated by the growing number of aspirants to some medical professions and the
    direct experience of many researchers of the cultural and ethical prestige conferred on the medical




                                                                                                         li
    profession (not excluding the veterinary sciences, in some respects) by the most capable secondary
    school students. However, it is essential that the university system - seemingly even more than the ba-




                                                                                                      na
    sic research system - trains new “armies” of health workers whose Hippocratic mission is flanked by
    awareness of the need to enter a highly competitive international context. This can be done through
    the quality (and unfortunately also the quantity) of outstanding published papers: whose authoritati-
    veness, paradoxically but increasingly, reflects on the prestige of the medical institution, with respect




                                                                                                   io
    to both funding of its clinical research facilities and its national and international visibility, as is often
    demonstrated by patient demand. In short, a clinical institution which publishes regularly in leading in-




                                                                            az
    ternational journals will enter into a virtuous circle enabling its self-empowerment. Obviously, not all
    facilities will be able to boost their international standing quickly and easily, while others that have al-
    ready reached this level may find it difficult to maintain adequate bibliometric standards due to logi-
    stic difficulties or the inevitable generational turnover. However, such an undertaking must not be avoi-




                                                                          rn
    ded and can be achieved with the help of European and international networking, good publishing prac-
    tice and progress in perfecting bibliometric evaluation methods.




                                                               te
    Just as an ability to reach a prompt diagnosis is essential for clinicians, so do leading researchers and
    forward-thinking lecturers need education in a complementary field. The practice of studying not only
    medicine but also for a degree in dentistry or a doctorate in medical research (sometimes with over-
                                                     In
    lapping residency courses, at least in the United States with their MD PhD programmes) is ever more
    frequent in many foreign institutions. If we look at the etymology of the word “diagnosis“, deriving from
    ancient Greek, we are reminded that it means knowledge through a series of elements. Fast diagno-
    stics, experience and a certain intuition, probably related to natural talent combined with clinical prac-
                                        ni

    tice alongside experienced professionals, translate very well into “dia-gnosis“. Similarly, PhD, the stan-
    dard term in English for a research doctorate, stands for Doctor of Philosophy: that suffix -sophy me-
                                io

    ans wisdom, common to all humans, and thus by definition common to all scientific disciplines. If phi-
    losophy is scentia scientiarum (the science of sciences), the doctorate has elements of wisdom, scien-
    tific logic, and now also publishing awareness, that crosses all scientific fields and sub-disciplines. It
                        iz



    is therefore hoped that the present issue galvanizes its readers to pay attention both to diagnosis and
    the need to participate in the progress of biomedical knowledge that is ever more reflected in such a
           Ed




    translational activity, from the laboratory bench to the sickbed; or, vice versa, when clinicians turn to
    researchers, to stimulate the scientific curiosity and passion of the latter with intriguing therapeutic is-
    sues.
    It is an adventure in which many of us are now involved, each in line with the core mission of our re-
    spective institutions: and it is hoped that this joint effort will act to productively boost the scientific and
 IC




    clinical potential of our diverse specialties.
C
©




                                                                            Enrico Alleva* and Diego De Simone**
                                              * Director, Section of Behavioural Neurosciences, Istituto Superiore di Sanità;
                                                                                                   Editor-in-Chief, Annali ISS;
                                                               President of Italian Society for the Study of Animal Behaviour.
                                                           **Institute of Science and Technologies of Cognition-CNR, Rome




    2                                                                                  Annali di Stomatologia 2011; II (1-2): 1-2
