10.7340/anuac2239-625X-5046
application/pdf
2239-625X
5046
2
en
urn:nbn:it:unica-28026
Irene Cieraad
Anuac
House and home: Reconsidering the anatomy of houses in Western societies
Text.Serial.Journal
https://ojs.unica.it/index.php/anuac
10
Thematic section: The anatomy of houses: Materialities of being at home
2021-12-22
2021-12-22
2021-12-31
2021-12-31
197-214
1
Irene Cieraad
2021/12/22
10.7340/anuac2239-625X-5046
197
University of Technology, Architecture and the Built Environment, Delft, Netherlands
2239-625X
2
214
urn:nbn:it:unica-28026
House and home: Reconsidering the anatomy of houses in Western societies
https://ojs.unica.it/index.php/anuac/article/download/5046/5028
10
                                       2021 | ANUAC. VOL. 10, N° 2, DICEMBRE 2021: 197-214




House and home
Reconsidering the anatomy of houses in Western societies
Irene CIERAAD
University of Technology, Architecture and the Built Environment, Delft




ABSTRACT: The article develops a critical and transversal reading of the special issue.
Each contribution inspired the author to seek for a mirror image or an analogy in
Western societies and test the mentioned Carsten and Hugh-Jones observation of the
seemingly self-evident relation between house and the self. Rosalie Stolz’ contribution
on the changing communities of sounds in northern Laos changed the author’s
perspective on the background of the popularity of camping in the West. Jonathan
Alderman’s contribution on the bloody libation rituals performed in the patio of rural
houses in Andean Bolivia made her realize that there is a heightened sensitivity in the
West towards blood, and more in particular visible blood spatters, be it animal or
human blood. From this consideration, the article presents some reflections on the
relation between house and blood. The cultural dead-lock between home-ownership
and manhood in southern Tunisia, as described by Pontiggia, points to a general
relation between the material home and the male self.
KEYWORDS: HOUSE; HOME; SELF; COMPARISON; WESTERN SOCIETIES.




This work is licensed under the Creative Commons © Irene Cieraad
House and home: Reconsidering the anatomy of houses in Western societies
2021 | ANUAC. VOL. 10, N° 2, DICEMBRE 2021: 197-214.
ISSN: 2239-625X - DOI: 10.7340/anuac2239-625X-5046
198                                                                  IRENE CIERAAD




   “Western children’s drawings of houses with two windows and a door –
two eyes and a mouth – underline this projection of the self in the house but
there are surprisingly few anthropological explorations of this identity
between house and self in non-Western societies” according to Carsten and
Hugh-Jones in their introduction of About the House: Lévi-Strauss and
Beyond (1995: 3). Perhaps not so much in the title of this special issue The
Anatomy of Houses. Materialities of Being at Home, as in their selection of
articles discussing fieldwork related to houses in regions as diverse as Laos,
Bolivia and Tunisia, the editors may have had the intention to repair the lack
of anthropological explorations of the house and the self in non-Western
societies. Still the self in the physical interpretation of the body, its gender,
functions and fluids is only indirectly addressed in relation to the houses
under discussion in the articles. For that matter the title “the anatomy of
houses” of this special issue may seem farfetched, but the articles each in
their own way inspired me to seek for a mirror image or an analogy in
Western societies and test Carsten and Hugh-Jones initial observation of the
seemingly self-evident relation between house and the self in Western
societies.
   The subtitle of this special issue Materialities of Being at Home is even
more intriguing. Although the title of Stefano Pontiggia might suggest
otherwise, home as a topic in its own right is not addressed in the selected
articles. Combining house and home in one and the same title is a
courageous attempt in joining together what in anthropology has always
been separated. The friction between the concepts of house and home has a
history of its own as I have pointed out elsewhere and will summarize in the
section below (Cieraad 2018). The anthropological concept of the house
lacks the emotional connotation of home which Westerners including
anthropologists find so special about their own dwellings. Home’s emotional
meaning, especially that of the childhood home, is more related to the
psychological or mental aspect of the self (the mind) than the physical or
material aspect of the self (the body) as represented in anatomic analysis of
houses (Carsten 2018). Still home is not only about emotions or memories,
but also about bonding with a place and a material environment, ranging in
scale from a room, a dwelling, a street, a neighbourhood, a village or town, a
region or a country. It will almost certainly also include an emotional
attachment to one or more living beings in that location, ranging from pets,
significant others, family members, and friends to neighbors, fellow citizens,


2021 | ANUAC. VOL. 10, N° 2, DICEMBRE 2021: 197-214
HOUSE AND HOME                                                                   199


and compatriots. Although there is a hierarchy in home attachments of ties
to people over places, both commitments are not necessarily twinned and
both will change in the course of a lifetime. In my view home is not fixed in
time and space, but is reinvented time after time in different locations. It is
in fact a lifetime cycle of reinventions of home in different locations
(Cieraad 2010, 2017).
   My research pertains to the home and its history in Western societies. It
has been part of a lifelong professional project in reversing anthropology’s
scope by bringing so to speak anthropology home and look for the exotic in
the familiar (Cieraad 1999). The concept of home defies easy definitions, not
just because it is layered and multifarious but more so because it is deeply
engrained in Western culture and societal organization. Western culture and
society thrive on the emotional, social, and spatial opposition between the
domains of home and work. From my anthropological perspective home is
one of the core concepts of Western culture. It is the outcome of a historical
development toward the progressive separation of two domains, represented
in the separate urban domains of consumption and production as the spaces
of living and working. The cultural meaning of home is molded in the
nineteenth century by a middle-class history and gender ideology in which
men are breadwinners and women are housewives. In the twentieth century
the cultural meaning of home with all its middle-class implications, became
even stronger when urbanistic solutions for the housing of the working
classes were modeled on the suburban ideal of the middle classes. At
present, in the twenty-first century the domains of home and work may not
be as strictly separated as before but they still play a major role in society as
well as in individual life histories.
   The personal and the cultural meaning of home still thrive on its opposite,
on the non-home so to speak. For adults the non-home will be work but for
children it will be school. Home is in essence a place you want to return to;
as such home gains more meaning the longer one has been separated from it
(Cieraad 2020a). The separation may even develop into homesickness and
the fact that children are more prone to homesickness than adults
demonstrate the age-relatedness of the personal meaning of home. Even
young children prove to be capable of expressing multiple dimensions of
their personal meaning of home. Their answers varied from “home is where
Mum and Dad are,” in which they addressed the all-important convivial
dimension of home, to “home is where my toys are,” in which they addressed
the material dimension of home, which will become more important in later
life. To children the convivial home, the presence of one or more meaningful
others, supersedes the material dimension of home. The answers of school-


                                  2021 | ANUAC. VOL. 10, N° 2, DICEMBRE 2021: 197-214
200                                                                IRENE CIERAAD


children presented an even wider variation. In “home is where my bedroom
is,” they addressed the privacy dimension of home, which is also the
dimension adults appreciate so much; and in the answer “home is where my
friends are,” they addressed the neighborhood dimension of the wider home.
More importantly, it illustrates that the personal meaning of home not only
for children but also for adults has a much wider meaning dimension than
domestic space, or the interior of the house, because it may encompass a
neighborhood or even a home country. As such it parallels the different
scales and meaning dimensions as described in this issue by Jonathan
Alderman for the house in rural Andean Bolivia.
   Practices are vital in keeping the dimensions of the personal meaning of
home active, in the same way as the performance of rituals in the Bolivian
case as described by Alderman in this issue. Both the convivial dimension
and the privacy dimension of the home are effectuated by demarcation
practices, such as the shutting of doors and the closing of curtains. The
modern family home in particular is an arena of demarcation practices.
Memories to the childhood home are tied to all meaning dimensions of the
home but in particular to the convivial dimension and the related family
practices – not only mundane practices of having dinner together or
watching television but also the more ritual practices of celebrations.
Homemaking practices, as mundane as cleaning and cooking, appeal to the
child’s senses and contribute to the important, but often neglected, sensory
dimension of the home and the childhood home in particular (Cieraad 2010:
97-99). Not only the materials, tools and household equipment, food stuff
and liquids used in homemaking practices could be interpretated as the
materialities of being at home, but also the comforts and conveniences of
home, which are supported by a vast network of public utilities. There is,
however, an interesting and even cultivated ignorance in Western homes
regarding their dependence on public urban utilities, like the sewer system,
piping, electricity and more recently the fiber optics network (Cieraad
2020b).
   Not only the homecoming of anthropology but also the study of the
contemporary home in consumer societies have resulted in a revival of
material culture studies. Individual consumers appropriate mass-produced
objects by incorporating them into a domestic universe of personal meaning,
that is also more and more the case in non-Western societies. Already more
than a decade ago Vellinga noted that “the new studies of material culture
suggest a more equal connection, in which objects do not passively represent
or stand for a subject, but actively help to define the latter” (2007: 761). In
addressing an example of Cameroon where chiefs are perceived to have more


2021 | ANUAC. VOL. 10, N° 2, DICEMBRE 2021: 197-214
HOUSE AND HOME                                                                             201


materiality in the form of body substances, such as blood, saliva, and semen
than commoners Vellinga concluded that not only the degree of materiality
ascribed to persons and objects may differ, but also that the boundary
between the subject and the object is much more fluid in nonacademic
thinking (Ivi: 763). In academic thinking there has been an acceptance of the
dualism of subject and object, in which subjects have agency over objects.
French structuralism, however, Lévi-Strauss cum suis, rejected the mind-
body dichotomy, and paved the way for a more lenient academic approach in
anthropology. It led to the present approach in material culture studies in
which materials and objects are reversely perceived as having agency over
subjects. That is the point where houses as material objects, their building
materials and architecture come in. Testing the agency of houses, building
materials, construction methods and architecture over subjects will be a
valuable starting-point for my peer review of the articles in this issue.

Privacy and Permeability
   Rosalie Stolz in her article “Listening through houses: Changing
communities of sounds in northern Laos” discusses the negative effects on
community life of a recent change of building materials of houses in
northern Laos, from permeable walls of woven strips of bamboo to more
solid walls of timber and concrete1. In villages with traditional houses of
bamboo screen walls conversations and sounds easily transgress the
boundary of the individual houses and created, according to Stolz, a
soothing village soundscape of familiar sounds and voices. Not only do
modern houses with concrete walls block the transmission of sounds and
voices, but also force unwanted family privacy on the villagers. In response
villagers tend to spend the evenings in front of their concrete houses to keep
contributing to the cherished community of village sounds. Stolz’s article
confronted me with my dislike of camping and more in particular its lack of
aural privacy, which had to do with my teenage experience of lying awake all
night due to an unknown snoring man in a neighboring tent. Despite my
pride of having a tent of my own and thus being able to secure the primal
visual privacy akin to the closed door of my bedroom, the snoring neighbor
made me realize that the canvas blocked the gaze of others but not the
noises produced by neighbors, and as such completely failed in providing
aural privacy.

1. Also Alderman in this issue alludes to the potentially negative effects of changed
construction materials in Andean Bolivia from the traditional indigenous adobe to the
modern non-indigenous materials of red-brick, cement and ceramic tiles on the inhabitants
relations with the house as the center of rituals that need to ensure individual and collective
wellbeing.

                                        2021 | ANUAC. VOL. 10, N° 2, DICEMBRE 2021: 197-214
202                                                                              IRENE CIERAAD


   The vivid memory of my invaded teenage privacy illustrates that the
visual and aural privacy of one’s bedroom were and still are the most
appreciated dimensions of home. Especially by Western teenagers, who like
to create with their own music preferences a private soundscape within their
bedrooms, which in turn will be a test of their parents’ noise tolerance.
Present family homes are in fact a collection of private soundscapes, which
thanks to the technology of ear phones can peacefully mix together.
Technology, however, is only a poor help in cases of noise disturbances on
camping sites. Nightly conversations can be stopped by active intervention,
but actively intervening and stopping noises produced by neighbors, be it
snoring, farting, vomiting, crying, or loud sexual intercourse is far more
difficult if not impossible, for these body related sounds normally produced
within the secluded privacy of bedrooms and toilets have to be politely
ignored. My teenage frustration made me realize that Western ideas of visual
and aural privacy are shaped by the brick and concrete walls of our houses,
which also prove more practical in a cold and windy climate characteristic of
the Western hemisphere. Without the agency of these solid building
materials privacy never would have been developed into such an important
dimension of the Western home2.
   The western history of privacy is written along the lines of spatial
demarcations, and the ensuing multiplication of separate rooms for persons
and functions (Flanders 2015: 55-93). Solid dividing walls made of timber,
brick or concrete progressively separated private spaces from more public or
shared spaces, and thus separating individuals from each other, and groups
of individuals from the larger community. First of all by concentrating family
groups in their own spaces or houses to facilitate collective sleeping and
working, which resulted in a kind of family privacy centered around the
hearth for cooking and heating. When work spaces were separated from
living spaces of the family, domestic servants as workers within the living
space of the upper classes were not treated as part of the family anymore but
spatially separated and relegated to the kitchen and the back zones of the
house. The front zone of the upper-class house became the liminal reception
space for outsiders to the family. Family privacy was restricted to the

2. Stolz’s article reminds of Helliwell’s study of Dayak longhouses which contain nine to
fourteen apartments separated by flimsy walls. According to Buchli (2013: 79) Helliwell is
“at pains to note that […] the flimsiness of partitions also assures a certain privacy [...]
accepted rules of propriety [...] are strictly observed, assuring a guarded privacy within this
highly communal space”. This leads Buchli to the conclusion that “‘Flimsy walls’ produce a
complex sensorium enabling the negotiation of individualizing and communalizing needs
through their materializing effects” (Ibidem).


2021 | ANUAC. VOL. 10, N° 2, DICEMBRE 2021: 197-214
HOUSE AND HOME                                                                   203


intimate, but collective family space of the living room, which did not mean
that every family member was entitled to individual privacy. Visual privacy
for individual members within the family home developed along the lines of
hierarchy of age and gender, which first and foremost entitled husband and
wife to have their private bedroom(s), followed by teenage sons and
daughters. In the first half of the twentieth century when publicly facilitated
amenities for defecating, bathing and washing were integrated into the
private space of houses, they produced a further compartmentalization of
the internal living space. Private flush toilets, bathrooms, and wash kitchens
required, however, the penetration of public piping and sewers through the
walls of the house. Their installation had to be hidden behind and within
walls, and under floors in order not to disturb the autarkic illusion of the
home as a fortress of family privacy secured by seemingly impenetrable walls
(Cieraad 2020b).

Camping: A ritual of reversal
   The history of privacy makes one wonder why so many people in the West
love to camp and are willing to sacrifice – at least temporarily – the privacy
that has been painstakingly created within the built environment. Camping
is effectively and willingly reversing the history of privacy. Tents have no, or
only scant internal divisions and if so they are made of canvas and closed by
zippers. Ringing the door is impossible in the case of a tent, or knocking the
door to get permission to enter and abide the individual privacy is as
ineffective on canvas as well. Also there are no locks on a tent either, while
in a home situation there are multiple locks on the front door to prevent
burglary, including simple locks on bedroom doors and bathroom door to
protect the privacy of the individual family members. Considering the
absence of locks it is amazing that a camping as a temporary community of
strangers is able to create a communal feeling of safety and social control, a
real communitas, for zippers do not give any protection against burglary, like
the flimsy shell of most tents does not protect against violent assaults by a
knife.
   Interestingly the rise of camping in the early twentieth century paralleled
the rise of housing acts regulating decent housing for the working classes.
For sanitary reasons the legislation forbid the very combination of sleeping
and cooking in one and the same room. While sleeping next to the cooking
fire was and still is one of the joys of primitive camping. Even in modern
caravans and campers sleeping and cooking are joined in the same space.
The housing acts ordained not only a separate kitchen and separate
bedrooms which were separated by walls from the living space, but also a

                                  2021 | ANUAC. VOL. 10, N° 2, DICEMBRE 2021: 197-214
204                                                                 IRENE CIERAAD


separate space with a flush toilet. A bathroom, however, was not ordained in
the Dutch housing act, which presumed the presence of public bathhouses in
urban neighborhoods. Most women, however, preferred a weekly bath within
the privacy of their own kitchen, and stimulated the construction of private
showers. Considering the post-war luxury of a private shower for the urban
working classes, it is all the more amazing that campers wittingly sacrifice
this luxury and gladly use the public conveniences provided on site. This
sacrifice becomes more of a burden for middle-aged campers which explains
why they often change the tent for a caravan or camper with a private toilet.
   The many privacy sacrifices made by present-day campers makes it clear
that there should be major gains involved to make them worthwhile. I may
not be the best judge of the joys of camping, but Solz’s article suggests that
also for convinced campers their favored camping site does create a
temporary community of soothing sounds, which represents the relaxing
atmosphere campers associate with a summer holiday. Even the sound of
rain drops falling on the tent’s canvas, or a nightly thunder storm can
heighten the holiday feeling. A primeval connection with the forces of
Nature is seen as one of the dubious pleasures of camping, but only if it is
temporary. It contrasts with the history of housing, which shows a
continuous effort in making the built environment more weather and sound
proof, not only by the application of insulating double or triple glazing and
sound proof floors, but also by the installation of lightning-conductors and
air conditioning in order to protect and isolate inhabitants from Nature’s
forces and noises produced by their neighbors. The temporary character of
camping in the best season of the year is part of its pleasure, for otherwise it
will turn into the nightmare of a refugee camp. Camping is in essence a
summerly ritual of domestic reversal, which like carnival will not be
appreciated by everybody.

Blood: Protection or pollution, life or death
   Jonathan Alderman’s article “House personhood in rural Andean Bolivia”
impressed me most by his description of the bloody libations performed in
the patios of houses to ensure a good harvest, and thus the prosperity of the
inhabitants, house and cattle. Spattering the blood of freshly offered
animals, more in particular guinea pigs and lamas, against the walls of the
patio and drinking the blood of the animals demonstrates according to
Alderman “the consubstantiation between the house and its inhabitants.” By
quoting Carsten and Hugh-Jones “[t]he house is an extension of the person”
(1995: 2) he wants to put the ritual in a more general perspective. The quote,
however, is cut short and continues as follows “like an extra skin, carapace

2021 | ANUAC. VOL. 10, N° 2, DICEMBRE 2021: 197-214
HOUSE AND HOME                                                                             205


or second layer of clothes, it serves as much to reveal and display as it does
to hide and protect” (Ibidem). Equating the protective cover of the house, its
walls and roof, with the human skin is not so farfetched, but it leaves in my
view no room for the interpretation of the libation ritual. For blood and
bleeding entails a damaged skin. The libation ritual of spattering fresh
animal blood from a ripped-out heart on the walls of the house presents first
of all a physical and symbolic analogy between animals and humans as both
species have a skin which needs to be pierced to start the bleeding and both
have a beating heart as their crucial blood pump. Only in second instance
there is a relation between the owner of the house who paid for the costly
sacrifices of the guinea pigs and lamas to command the prosperity of his
house, harvest and cattle. The burial ground of the sacrificed animals at the
wall of the patio is the most sacred spot of the house comparable to an altar
or shrine.
   Ripping out the beating heart of humans, mostly captives, was the
gruesome libation ritual the Aztecs were known for; they saw human blood
as the necessary fuel of the cosmos. To Western eyes Alderman’s image of a
blood spattered house gives the impression of a crime scene where someone
is stabbed and probably killed. A bloody murder case means an extreme
defilement of the house. Even after a thorough clean-up selling a house with
a bloody history proves to be difficult. In the West there is nowadays a
heightened cultural sensitivity regarding not only human blood but also
animal blood. While bloodshed and sacrifice of either humans or animals
were and still are a crucial part of most religions, not in the least in
Christianity, there is also within religious circles a growing sensitivity
towards its bloody aspects. The ritual throat cutting of animals in Islamic
tradition is deemed barbaric by outsiders. Although the consubstantiation of
the blood of Christ into wine and his body into bread is a crucial and sacred
part of Christian services celebrated by the ritual consumption of bread and
wine, it has become more and more a matter of speech in which the death of
Christ has resulted in eternal life of his believers. Depictions of Christ’s
bloody crucifixion scene which were so prominent in medieval churches,
have gradually disappeared from the interior of modern catholic churches in
the second half of the twentieth century3. Present-day slaughter-houses are
perhaps the best proof of the heighten sensitivity towards blood. They are
closed-off locations where cattle is brought in alive and leaves the premises
as sealed packages of bloodless pieces of meat.


3. In protestant churches which exist since the late sixteenth century only a simple wooden
cross refers to the bloody crucifixion scene and is a token of Christ’s sacrifice to redeem the
sins of believers and bestow eternal life on them.

                                        2021 | ANUAC. VOL. 10, N° 2, DICEMBRE 2021: 197-214
206                                                                      IRENE CIERAAD


   The meaning of blood, its spilling and visible blood stains has clearly
changed in the West. From the sixteenth to nineteenth century it was a
normal medical procedure to incise the veins to get rid of so-called bad
blood, or too much blood. The cure was practiced by barbers but also by the
patients themselves performed within the domestic environment without
fear of defilement. At that time blood was only one of four essential body
liquids which all needed to be in balance with each other. Bloodletting was
such a common practice that it led to the manufacture of specially shaped
and decorated china bowls as receptacles for the blood. The uncontrolled
loss of blood did not seem to scare people, like the china bowls were show
pieces in seventeenth-century Dutch interiors. It is such a contrast with the
present situation, in which even the natural blood loss in menstruation has
to be carefully concealed and any spontaneous blood loss is an alarming
topic only to be discussed in the privacy of a doctor’s consultation room.
Uncontrolled loss of blood may cause death, while controlled blood donation
and transfusion can be lifesaving. Blood has become the one and only vital
body liquid, which is not only the bearer of a person’s unique DNA, but also
the medical mirror of a person’s health and disease.
   Still, although blood lines have become the key medical and biological
kinship structures in Western societies associated with genetically
transferable diseases, they have lost their cultural importance as physical
foundation of kinship structures within modern households, which are
primarily based on affective bonds of love and care between adults and
children living in the same house. Modern family households are more
diverse in composition than ever before, not only households of same sex
parents which may entail sperm donation, surrogate motherhood, or
adoption of foreign children, but also households of divorced single parents
with shared parenthood which means that children constantly shift between
two houses, and large composite households of former divorcees which
easily leads to three types of blood-related children, the ones related to the
divorced mother and those related to the divorced father and the children
born out of the new relation between the former divorcees4.
   Although the bloodlines have lost their importance in modern family
structures of affective kinship, most adopted children feel the need to know
their bloodlines and start searching for their biological parents in their
country of origin, and the same with children who are beget from sperm of
anonymous donors, or carried by anonymous surrogate mothers. Especially

4. The doubling of houses is only the case when divorced parents remarry, and not when
widowed parents remarry.


2021 | ANUAC. VOL. 10, N° 2, DICEMBRE 2021: 197-214
HOUSE AND HOME                                                                              207


from the perspective of children of divorced parents who are living in two
households at the same time Western society could be perceived as a modern
interpretation of Lévi-Strauss’s concept of société à maisons5. Children of
divorced parents speak about “houses” as they narrate about their daily life
in either their mother’s or father’s house. In this modern interpretation
houses are temporary moral and social entities of affective nature in contrast
to the traditional interpretation of the noble and royal houses in which the
continuation of rights and possessions over the generations is most
important.

Nesting: Condor and stork
   Not so much Alderman’s description of a house construction ritual in
which a lama fetus is buried in the cement of the foundation as a sacrifice to
Mother Earth, Panchamama, which in my view could be perceived as an
embryonic conception of the house as a person, but more so his description
of the roofing ceremony when the house has reached its highest point, which
in his view is an illustration of the symbolic personhood of a house when the
house gets ‘hairs.’ However, in the related ceremonies there is an even
stronger link with the animal world in comparing the house to the condor’s
nest which is associated with the birth of humans. According to his
informant “Condor Tapa Mammani is the god of the house, because once the
house is finished it is like a person. It is living energy.” The energy of the
Condor deity, however, is not restricted to the house but paramount.
Offerings in the shape of a nest of wool fibers filled with coca leaves may
serve as a personal penance to Panchamama and the divinities. It illustrates
in my view not so much the consubstantiation between the house and its
inhabitants as the consubstantiation between animals and humans, between
nests and houses, between the deities of heaven and earth.
   There is an interesting comparison between the ritual role of the Bolivian
condor and the European stork. Since the beginning of the twentieth century
the stork plays an important symbolic role in Germany and the Netherlands
as the deliverer of babies to the house. Its wooden image in front of the
house signifies the birth of a child and symbolically turns the house into a
real family home. Like the condor also the stork is a rare and special bird
mainly because of its size. The stork’s solitary nest is huge and built in plain
view on special high poles, which are placed by farmers in the middle of a
meadow. Having a stork’s nest on one’s ground or on the top of the chimney

5. The English translation of Lévi-Strauss’s concept of société à maisons into “house societies”
(Carsten, Hugh-Jones 1995: 1) seems problematic as the French term stipulates society in the
single and houses in the plural, literally “society of houses”.

                                         2021 | ANUAC. VOL. 10, N° 2, DICEMBRE 2021: 197-214
208                                                                              IRENE CIERAAD


is interpreted as a blessing and promise of posterity. Its symbolic role as
deliverer of babies is still very popular and celebrated in all kinds of house
decorations also for urban settings. Again the similarity between nests and
houses, between animals and humans is stronger than between the human
body and the house.
   The warm and affective relations between humans and their pets in
Western societies have often encountered disbelief in Africa and Asia. Pets,
more in particular cats and dogs, have become surrogate children and
favorite family members who may even have their own room, but they are
certainly pampered with special food, have their own toys and are played
with. Especially small dogs are sometimes clothed with a jacket against the
cold and wear shoes. Pets are taken to a therapist when they have behavioral
problems, and when ill the owners go to great length in paying the doctor’s
bills hoping for a recovery. When the cat or dog sadly dies s/he will get a
grave with a grave stone, or its urn will put on display in the living room next
to the cat’s or dog’s portrait. The humanizing of pets may have to do with
the fact that affection has become the core of Western kinship structures,
and for that matter may also explain a growing sensitivity towards animal
suffering and blood.

Home-ownership and Manhood
   Without mentioning the impetus of economic migration Stefano
Pontiggia’s contribution “Great Home-Spectations: ‘Houses-to-be,’
Marginality, and Social Expectations in Southern Tunisia” addresses without
doubt one of the most urgent social problems in contemporary history. The
poor economic prospects of able and ambitious young men in the Global
South, including the Tunisian men as described by Pontiggia, are the long-
term effects of a history of colonization and exploitation by the Global
North6. They have set in motion an exodus of young men seeking for job
opportunities elsewhere. Some are so desperate that they are willing to pay a
huge amount to human traffickers knowing that they will have to risk their
lives at sea in order to reach Europe and make their dreams come true.
Pontiggia’s article clarifies why in particular unmarried men instead of
unmarried women are so desperate to find a poorly paid job as illegal
immigrant in Europe. An adult Tunisian man is under social pressure to
become a home-owner before he has any chance of getting married and start

6. In footnote 2 of his article Pontiggia alludes to the peculiar demographics in his fieldwork
town in southern Tunisia where most of the men between 28 and 35 years old have left town
“looking for employment on the coast or in Europe”.


2021 | ANUAC. VOL. 10, N° 2, DICEMBRE 2021: 197-214
HOUSE AND HOME                                                                   209


a family. With rising unemployment there is not much chance of becoming a
home-owner and thus a suitable marriage partner, and the present situation
in Tunisia is even worse than the period Pontiggia described.
   The cultural complex of home-ownership, manhood and marriage chances
has become visible in the poor region of southern Tunisia in the many
unfinished house building projects. Building a house has become a long-
term project which will depend on savings and investments. The houses
under construction, Pontiggia calls them houses-to-be, are often of poor
quality and testify to the desperate situation of men trying to become
suitable marriage partners. That is why the average marriage age of males
has risen above the age of thirty. If home-ownership is the pivot of young
males’ dreams, but also of their fears of not being successful in reaching this
dream, as Pontiggia concludes, it makes you wonder how young females as
potential brides-to-be experience their fate of being the final objective in the
often risky undertakings of potential marriage candidates. With no job
opportunities in the region it will be a marriage with a labor migrant as an
absentee husband. One might hope that Tunisian parents of marriageable
daughters and sons confronted with this critical situation will become more
creative in dealing with this suffocating cultural complex. For example, the
creative solution of the Turkish parents who lived in exile in Greek refugee
housing and who dug out a cellar apartment for themselves in order to be
able to give the ground floor of their refugee accommodation as dowry to
their marriageable daughters (Hirschon 1981).
   The immediate postwar housing shortage in Western Europe due to war
damage and a lack of building materials also led to creative and temporary
solutions to accommodate the many newly-wed couples. For example, the
forced sharing of houses which were occupied by only one person, or the
transformation of boats into floating houses. The cultural norm in the
Netherlands also demanded independent housing for newly-weds, which due
to the circumstances had to be reduced to a separate room in one of their
parents’ houses or forced co-housing. Most couples in the postwar period
started their families in these cramped accommodations. The newly
constructed housing stock was state-funded rental housing. Its houses and
apartments were fairly distributed among the families on the waiting list. It
was seen as God’s gift when after years of waiting a rental apartment was
finally allotted. At that time home-ownership was not an issue at all because
the Dutch had always been a nation of renters in line with a strong social-
democratic tradition. Thirty years later, however, when the political wave of
neo-liberalism got hold in Europe, home-ownership in the Netherlands


                                  2021 | ANUAC. VOL. 10, N° 2, DICEMBRE 2021: 197-214
210                                                               IRENE CIERAAD


became not so much the norm as the ideal. The once state-funded social
housing is now more and more sold to the highest bidder. Within four
decades the Dutch have become a nation of home-owners.
   Since the 1970s marriage is not a necessary condition anymore to be
selected for a rental apartment as it was in the postwar years. Not only the
ideal but also the right of independent housing for singles has been widely
acknowledged. Dutch university students have set the trend in the late 1960s
in not just renting a bedroom from a landlady but favoring independent
accommodation with kitchen facilities. Nowadays Dutch freshmen will start
searching for a rental room with kitchen facilities some months before
classes begin. In creating the material conditions of an independent
household, the student-to-be shapes his or her new social identity as an
independent citizen (Cieraad 2010: 88). Leaving the parental home and have
a place of your own has become the most important rite of passage for
adolescents, males and females alike, which does not coincide with marriage
or living together anymore. The transitional home experience of students
has set an example for today’s working girls and boys who also want to leave
home and have a place of their own, which has led to a shortage of affordable
housing due to the subsequent rise of commercial rents and real estate
prices. The present situation is annoying but it does not lead to risky
undertakings or a halt on love relations or marriage, as in the Tunisian case.

Conclusion: Towards a reinterpretation of société à maisons
   The three articles under discussion inspired me to seek for a mirror image
or an analogy in Western societies. Rosalie Stolz’s contribution on the
changing communities of sounds in northern Laos changed my perspective
on the background of the popularity of camping in the West. Her article
made me realize that the attraction of camping also has to do with being part
of a temporary community of sounds, but most of all that camping is a
summerly ritual of reversal of the normal housing situation in which privacy,
security and climate control are all-important. While Jonathan Alderman’s
contribution on the bloody libation rituals performed in the patio of rural
houses in Andean Bolivia made me realize that there is a heightened
sensitivity in the West towards blood, and more in particular visible blood
spatters, be it animal or human blood. The affective relations between
humans and animals, more in particular pets, explain why Westerners are as
sensitive to animal blood as they are to human blood, especially when it
concerns their own pet.



2021 | ANUAC. VOL. 10, N° 2, DICEMBRE 2021: 197-214
HOUSE AND HOME                                                                             211


   Although blood lines have become the all-pervasive genetic kinship
structure from a medical point of view, they have lost their primal
importance within present-day nuclear kinship structures which are
primarily based on affection between parents and children, and not
necessarily or only partially based on biological kinship. The legal claims of
divorced parents on the continuation of the affective relationships with their
under-aged children has resulted on the part of their children into a
doubling of material houses and childhood homes in which they participate
and have a room7. It warrants in my view an update and reinterpretation of
Lévi-Strauss’s concept of société à maisons describing the different affective,
and often only semi-biological kinship circles as “the houses,” in which
todays’ children participate. Also, when parents stay together the only one
childhood home will most probably be located in different material houses
on different locations, for moving to a bigger house in a better neighborhood
is an aspiration of many parents. The next stage is when adolescent children
leave the parental home to have a place of their own within the vicinity of
their university, they are also effectively doubling houses. A room in a
student house represents the hope to participate in a new affective circle of
peers as a kind of semi-family. In a successful student career the house of
peers should become more important than the parental home, but it will
always serve as a safe back-up home.
   The cultural dead-lock between home-ownership and manhood in
southern Tunisia, as described by Pontiggia, points to a relation between the
material home and the male self. Like the many half-finished houses, which
often have dilapidated due to the extended intervals in its construction,
quite obviously illustrate the man’s impotency in creating a family. He is in
fact only half a man. Carsten and Hugh-Jones (1995: 3) initial observation of
the seemingly self-evident relation between the house and the self in
Western societies, was far more difficult to establish. The only link between
the house and the body I could find was the ideal of a smooth human skin
which covers and conceals the blood-vessels mirrored in the ideal of smooth
interior walls invisibly covering a maze of electricity cables, piping and gas
conducts. In old houses where cables and piping are still in plain view a
renovation is warranted to get rid of these ‘varicose veins’ on the walls. The
similarity between the surface of the interior walls of the house and the
human skin is an illustration of Carsten and Hugh-Jones’s quote “[t]he house

7. The multiplication of houses is also evident on the level of grandparents, who multiply in
number when each of the divorcees start a new relation. Instead of the potential two couples of
grandparents a child may have to deal with four couples of so-called grandparents. Mutual
affection more than biology will determine the relationship between grandparent and child.

                                        2021 | ANUAC. VOL. 10, N° 2, DICEMBRE 2021: 197-214
212                                                              IRENE CIERAAD


is an extension of the person like an extra skin, carapace or second layer of
clothes, it serves as much to reveal and display as it does to hide and
protect” (1995: 2). The autonomous human body sealed by its skin is a
perfect parallel to the celebrated home ideal of autarky in Western societies
(Cieraad 2020b).




2021 | ANUAC. VOL. 10, N° 2, DICEMBRE 2021: 197-214
HOUSE AND HOME                                                                      213


REFERENCES
Buchli, Victor, 2013, An Anthropology of Architecture, London, Bloomsbury.
Carsten, Janet, 2018, House-lives as Ethnography/Biography, Social Anthropology/
      Anthropologie Sociale, 26, 1: 103-116.
Carsten, Janet, Stephen Hugh-Jones, eds, 1995, About the House: Lévi-Strauss and
      Beyond, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Cieraad, Irene, 2020b, The Home Ideal of Autarky: A Social history of Domestic
      Comfort, Privacy and Sociability. The Example of the Netherlands, Raddar
      Design Annual Review, 2: 70-97.
Cieraad, Irene, 2020a, Irene Cieraad: Delving into the Spatialities and the
      Temporalities of Home (interview), Thinking Home on the Move: A Conversation
      Across Disciplines, Paolo Boccagni et al., eds, Bingley UK, Emerald Publishing:
      106-109.
Cieraad, Irene, 2018, Home, in The International Encyclopedia of Anthropology,
      Hilary Callan, ed, Hoboken, NJ, Wiley-Blackwell.
Cieraad, Irene, 2017, Home-making: Tra ricordi e proiezioni nel futuro, in Forme
      dell’inclusività: pratiche spazi progetti, Antonio Longo, Chiara Rabbiosi, Pier-
      luigi Salvadeo, ed, Milan, Maggioli Editore.
Cieraad, Irene, 2010, Homes from Home: Memories and Projections, Home Cultures,
      7, 1: 85-102.
Cieraad, Irene, 1999, At Home: An Anthropology of Domestic Space, Syracuse, NY,
      Syracuse University Press.
Flanders, Judith, 2015, The Making of Home: The 500-Year Story of How Our Houses
      Became Homes, London, Atlantic Books.
Hirschon, Reneé, 1981, Essential Objects and the Sacred: Interior and Exterior
      Space in an Urban Greek Locality, in Women and Space: Ground Rules and
      Social Maps, Shirley Ardener, ed, London, Croom Helm.
Vellinga, Marcel, 2007, Review Essay: Anthropology and the Materiality of Architecture,
      American Ethnologist, 34, 4: 756-766




                                     2021 | ANUAC. VOL. 10, N° 2, DICEMBRE 2021: 197-214
                                       2021 | ANUAC. VOL. 10, N° 2, DICEMBRE 2021: 197-214




 Irene CIERAAD is a cultural anthropologist and Senior Researcher affiliated to
 Faculty of Architecture and the Built Environment of Delft University of
 Technology, the Netherlands. She is the editor of At Home: An Anthropology of
 Domestic Space, Syracuse University Press (2006, 2nd edition; 2021, e-book) and
 many more articles and book chapters on the topics of home, gender and domestic
 space (accessible on ResearchGate). Forthcoming (2022) is a chapter on liminal
 objects in the edited volume Interiors in the Era of Covid-19 (Bloomsbury Press).
 I.G.Cieraad@tudelft.nl




This work is licensed under the Creative Commons © Irene Cieraad
House and home: Reconsidering the anatomy of houses in Western societies
2021 | ANUAC. VOL. 10, N° 2, DICEMBRE 2021: 197-214.
ISSN: 2239-625X - DOI: 10.7340/anuac2239-625X-5046
