But I want to look again at this story here and focus on something different to look down at verse number 13 where the Bible says, And the Jews pass over, was at hand, and Jesus went up to Jerusalem and found in the temple those that sold oxen and sheep and doves and the changers of money sitting. And when he made a scourge of small cords, he drove them all out of the temple and the sheep and the oxen and poured out the changers money and overthrew the tables. And said unto them that sold doves, take these things hence, make not my father's house and house of merchandise. As disciples remembered that it was written, the zeal of thine house hath eaten me up. So tonight I want to focus on this idea of, you know, we looked at verse number 16 really where Jesus was saying, don't make my father's house a house of merchandise. Why are you selling in church, you know, trying to make businesses out of the house of God? I want to kind of look at verse number 15 tonight where the Bible says he had made a scourge of small cords. So he first goes in verse number 14 and he sees what's happening in the temple of God and then Jesus takes time and sits down and makes a scourge of small cords. What that is, is he makes a whip. He makes a whip and then he goes in with this whip and he drives the people, the oxen and all the animals out with this whip. I mean, imagine the scene here with Jesus going and doing this and not only that, but there's no indication here that the disciples were in here with him.  They actually watched this happen, watched Jesus do this, whip these people and these animals out of the temple and then flip over all these tables and give this lecture to these people. I mean, Jesus, this kind of goes against the narrative of who Jesus really is today. Jesus was angry here. Jesus was very angry. Turn to Matthew chapter 12. Jesus is angry other places in the Bible. This isn't the only time when Jesus drives people out of the temple for selling.   We're going to talk a little bit more about that on Sunday morning. But Jesus, look at Matthew chapter 12. Again, just this idea that we're sold today that Jesus is just this soft, spoken, you know, love everybody all the time, type of person, type of God. You know, God is being changed today is what you're seeing. The spirit of God, who God actually is, is what the Bible tells us that he actually is. Look at Matthew chapter 12. Look at verse number 34. Matthew 12 verse 34. We see this one verse, but the context here is the Pharisees just accused Jesus of casting out devils using Satan. You know, this is where Jesus accuses them of blasphemy of the Holy Ghost.  You know, what you say doesn't even make any sense. But then he gets serious here in verse 34 and he says, oh, generation of vipers. How can you be an evil, speak good things? He basically says, you're just all bad.   He's like, but you're the snakes. He's like, you're all bad and nothing good can come from you is what Jesus is saying here. Look, he's angry at them. Unless you think he was like, oh, generation of vipers, snakes, please listen to me. No, he's mad. He's angry. You know, I mean, I'm glad in, in John chapter two, I'm glad we have the whip because people, that's, that's the importance of the whip and the fact that he was flipping over tables because you can't change that story. You can't make that story nice. You know, he literally sits down, makes a whip and just goes in there and just takes care, like physically takes care of business. That's who Jesus is, folks. That's who God is.  They're just all bad all the time. I'm going to show you tonight how literally that makes no sense to even the person that can just logically think to the first level in their linear thought process that makes no sense, but is anger always bad as, as we, you know, we're taught today? First of all, go to Hebrews chapter four. It can't be. We know the answer to that already from the story in John chapter two because Jesus got angry. Look at Hebrews chapter four and verse 15. Hebrews chapter four and verse number 15. The Bible says in Hebrews four, 15, this is a great verse out-sowning.  If Jesus was a sinner, Jesus couldn't die for our sins. Otherwise, we could all just die for each other since. Like, I could die for Brother Benjamin's sins. He could die for mine, but Jesus had to be without sin. That's the only way that that sacrifice would be acceptable to God is if it was a sacrifice. This is why, you know, the Passover lamb was without blemish, to picture Jesus that had no sin. This is why it was unleavened bread, that leaven picture's sin. This is why the wine would not have leaven in it in John chapter two.  See how the Bible just all just connects together perfectly? Look at Hebrews chapter four, verse fifteen. For we have not a high priest which cannot be touched with the feeling of our infirmities. So the Bible here, this is a great verse because the Bible is saying, it's literally telling us that Jesus was 100% man. He was 100% God and 100% man. You're like, I don't understand that. Isn't it like a pie? Shouldn't it be 50-50? You don't have to understand. You just have to believe it. The Bible says that he was touched with our infirmities, meaning he felt everything that we feel. He was tempted, look, look at the next part, but was in all points tempted like as we are. So he felt all the desires, the pain, the suffering, the depression, the anxiety, all these different things. Jesus felt everything that you do as a man, yet what's the difference? Without sin. Jesus did all that without giving into that flesh, into those feelings, into that temptation without sin. He did it without sin. He did it perfectly. He did it, he did this human life perfectly. This is the purpose of the millennial reign by the way, not to give away Sunday. Jesus is going to show us how to do it perfectly. He's like, I told you how to do it perfectly. I told you how to run a nation perfectly. I told you how to run a world perfectly. I guess I got to come there and I got to show you how to do it. Just like he showed us how to live this life as a man perfectly, with all the infirmities.  You know, my grandpa had this problem and my dad had this problem and I got this problem. He felt all the infirmities that men feel, except he conquered it. He did it without sinning. He did it without giving into it. All right, so we know in John chapter two from this verse and other verses we know that Jesus did not sin. So the narrative, what the narrative of today's Jesus of the story in John chapter two, the narrative of the modern Jesus would have been Jesus went into the temple and he saw that they were doing things that they shouldn't have been doing and he went in there and he's like, well, folks, guys, I think that maybe we should do things a little different way. You know, and he goes and he just talks them down. But no, the Jesus of the Bible went in there, sat down, made a whip, threw the tables over and whipped them out of the temple of God while chastising them as they're heading out the door. He got angry with them. Turn to Psalm chapter 37. So look, anger definitely can be wrong and I'm going to show you that in Psalm 37. I'm going to spend a lot of time on that but anger can be wrong. It can be wrong but there is a righteous anger. It's an, I don't want to look at the difference between anger that's wrong and righteous anger. Look at Psalm chapter 37 and verse number 8. I mean, we see here, Psalm chapter 37 and verse number 8 clearly shows us that there is an anger that's wrong. And look, a lot of times the anger that we have as people is wrong. Don't get me wrong. But that is the case and I'm going to show you the difference tonight. Look at Psalm 37, 8. The Bible says, cease from anger and forsake wrath. Frit not thyself and likewise to do evil. So here the Bible is comparing this type of anger here in Psalm 37, 8 with this idea it's used. This anger is used as a source to do evil, meaning what? A source to hurt people. A source to do harm. Okay? So that kind of anger is definitely wrong. Now turn to Ephesians chapter 4 though. So you say, what what kind of anger could be righteous?  That's really what we need to see tonight because obviously we're probably not going to get in the exact situation as Jesus walking into the temple of God and seeing a bunch of people, you know, selling oxen there. So what does righteous anger look like? Well, the Bible tells us this. Look at Ephesians chapter 4. Look at verse number 26. The Bible in Ephesians 426 says, be angry and sin not. Showing us right there, it says be ye angry. It doesn't say don't be angry. It says be angry and sin not, meaning there is an anger that is not sin, clearly from this verse. And it says, and let not the sun go down upon your wrath. So here we see that righteous anger, this is the first verse I'm going to show you tonight, that righteous anger has a time factor to it. Turn to Ecclesiastes chapter 3. It has a time factor to it. Here we see that righteous anger should not be long lasting for us. Meaning you shouldn't just be perpetually angry at somebody.  But it's clear here that there is a time to be angry. In Ecclesiastes chapter 3, in verse number 1, we get this great set of verses here that basically tells us there's a time for everything. So all of these people that teach this falsehood today, that you should never do this. You should never be angry. You should never be hateful. You should never be these things that are just painted with this broad negative brush today. It's just wrong. Look at Ecclesiastes chapter 3, in verse number 1, to everything there is a season and a time to every purpose under heaven. Under the heaven. A time to be born.  I mean look, these are things that you think are good and things that you think are bad. You know, dying is bad, right? But there's a time to die.  A time to plant. A time to pluck up that which is planted. A time to kill. A time to heal. Can you imagine? A time to kill. A time to heal. A time to break down. A time to build up. A time to weep. A time to laugh. A time to mourn. You say, what do you mean a time to mourn? Well, when you go to a funeral, that's a time to mourn. That's a time when somebody that you love has died. When somebody that you love has lost someone has, you know, maybe you didn't even know the person that died. But you go there because why? Because it's a time to mourn. It's a sad negative thing but there's a time for it, the Bible says. A time to dance. A time to cast away stones. And a time to gather stones together. A time to embrace. And a time to refrain from embracing. A time to get. And a time to lose. A time to keep. And a time to cast away. A time to rend. Meaning a time to tear things. Time to wreck things. And a time to sew. A time to fix things. A time to keep silence. And a time to speak. Now look at this in verse number eight. A time to love. And a time to hate. A time of war. And a time of peace. So there are times for all of these things. You say oh we should just love everything all the time. No, there's a time to love and a time to hate. Look beware of anyone who tells you to never love or never hate.   Hate means to strongly dislike. You know these people today saying oh that's hate this is hate and that's hate. You know what they're saying? You should never dislike anything.  That's what I would say to those people. Are you saying that I'm to love everyone? What are we seeing today?  Literally that's what's happening today. Look don't don't judge. Don't ever hate. Look these are evil people that are teaching this. You're supposed to like everything and everyone all the time. What kind of weird wicked satanic doctrine is that? It's satanic doctrine.   He's evil.  There's a righteous time for getting angry. There's a right time. There's a right time so we see that not only should it not last a long time our anger and our relationships with each other but there's literally a right time for it. And obviously Jesus was showing us you know what the right time is. So here's some more on timing. You say well what do those times look like? Turn to Proverbs chapter 14. Let's look at this idea of let's get some what's let's narrow down the target now. We know it's got a time factor to it. We're looking at righteous anger. I want to make sure that every time I get angry in my life it's righteous. So we need to figure out what this time that we you know are righteous to be angry is. Look at Proverbs chapter 14 and verse number 29. Every time we're talking about righteous anger in the Bible it's very specific to time. To timing how long it lasts and how long it takes for you to get angry. Look at Proverbs 14 and verse number 29. The Bible says this. So we see another time factor here. Proverbs 14 29. He that is what? Slow to wrath is of great understanding. It doesn't say he that never has wrath. He that never gets to wrath. It says he that is slow to wrath is of great understanding. But you know we got the Proverbs coin here, right? We got the we got the same verse. We got the good way and then it shows us the exact opposite. The bad way in the same verse. Beautiful. It says he that is slow to wrath is of great understanding. But he that is hasty of spirit exalted folly. You know what that means? He's saying one side you have somebody that's slow to wrath meaning they're slow to get angry. They don't just get angry just like that. They're slow to get angry. It takes a while for them to get to that point of wrath. What's the opposite of that though? He that is hasty of spirit. Look at Proverbs chapter 16. Proverbs chapter 16. I want you to focus on that word spirit there. I'm going to show you what it means. Look at Proverbs chapter 16. Look at verse number 32. Proverbs 16 verse 32. Again the Bible says it says he that is slow to anger is better than the mighty. And he that ruleeth his what? Ruleeth his spirit than he that taketh a city. You know what spirit here is talking about? It's talking about your emotions. The word spirit here is talking about your emotions. It's talking about somebody that is in control of their emotions. In Proverbs 14 it says somebody that's hasty of spirit. Meaning somebody that can't control their emotions. Like they just get mad and they just act it out. Right. This is why by the way this is why an adult should have this under control. But this is why children should not be allowed to throw temper tantrums. Because what are they doing? They're just mad. They're mad immediately about something. Sorry kids.  But they're mad about something and they just act out on it right away. You know what that is? That's a hasty spirit. And that needs to be they need to be taught as young children to control that. Otherwise they will be adults that are quick to wrath. You ever met an adult that's like that? An adult that just goes from zero to angry in like 0.5 milliseconds. We've all met plenty of people like that. But you know nobody taught them to to control their spirit when they were three, when they were four. And so they're just hasty of spirit. Look at Proverbs chapter 15. Proverbs chapter 15. Verse number 18.  No but it's a really big deal. That could really literally affect them into their life. That could make them this person that is of a hasty spirit that has no control over their spirit. That is just this person that's just quick to wrath in their life. As a 30 year old. And look if you can't get you know it's better to control something, get something under control as a parent when they're three, when they're four, when they're five than to have a 30 year old now trying to change you know who he literally is. That's a much more difficult task. Look at Proverbs 15 verse 18. The Bible says wrathful man stireth up strife, but he that is again slow to anger appeaseth strife. So again it's this idea of being we want to be people that are slow to anger. People that are uh that that you just don't snap. You just don't snap on people. It takes you a while to get angry. Look at James chapter one. Look at James chapter one in verse number 19. James chapter one in verse number you go to James chapter one. I'll read for you Ecclesiastes seven nine where the Bible says be not hasty in spirit to be angry for anger resteth in the bosom of fools. Again hasty in your emotions.  That's being hasty in spirit. All right. Look at James chapter one verse 19. Again the Bible says here it says wherefore my beloved brethren let every man be swift to hear so you should be quick to hear things. You should be quick to listen. Slow to speak and slow to wrath. So the things that you should be slow about you should be you should just always be willing and quick to listen to things but slow to speak and slow to wrath. I mean it makes sense. Jesus got angry here. Jesus got angry in the temple but it makes total sense because the Bible says in all over the Bible that God is angry with the wicked every day.  Look one day God will judge this world in his wrath. He will literally pour out his wrath which is his anger on the world itself. Turn to Romans chapter one. I mean the Bible all over this is a main theme this idea that you should just never be angry. I mean people are missing a main theme in the Bible. Why did God have the prophets? God had the prophets not just to prophesy Christ.  God's upset with you and he's going to destroy this place if you don't get right. God's mad is what the prophets were saying and instead of listening the people they didn't listen and God poured out his wrath. He acted out on that anger. So look at verse Romans chapter one. The Bible says in Romans 118 the wrath of God. The anger of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men who hold the truth in unrighteousness. I mean the Bible says in John 3 36 that the wrath of God abides on the unsaved. It says but you know he that believeth on the son he that believeth on the son half everlasting life but he that believeth not the son the wrath of God abideth on him. The wrath of God is on the unsaved. It's sitting on them. It's bearing down on their shoulders and it will be realized if they die unsaved. It will be realized unless they get saved. That's why we need a mediator. That's why we need a mediator. So the Bible tells us in 1 Timothy 2 like there's one mediator. There's one mediator between God men the man cries Jesus. Why? Because we need a mediator because that wrath of God is down upon us. We need someone to step in and take it off of us and that's what Jesus did. I mean look when you got saved especially you got saved as an adult. If you got saved as adult later in life you probably had this feeling. I mean I'm hoping you had this feeling.   I mean I remember feeling that that way specifically when I got saved in my 30s. You're just like wow I feel like wow I really slid into home on that one. Missed you know missed the tag. I mean it was it was kind of like it was kind of like a butterfly in your stomach type feeling.  You were in danger of hell and that's how God's wrath is going to ultimately be shown acted upon you know for the unsaved. So there's a time. Let's go back to anger. There's a time for anger. We know that. It should be slow. It should be slow. It should not last a long time and there's a specific time for us. But what specifically should make us angry? Let's go back to Jesus. Back to John chapter two and look at verse number 15. Back to John chapter two. So it should be slow. You should not just be hasty in spirit and just quick to get angry. It should not last a long time. But what specifically should make us angry? Look at verse number 15. The Bible says it's interesting because you know Jesus took his time here. He made, he literally made a whip. You know he just didn't go in there and just go crazy. Like just immediately you know go crazy. He literally sat down. He made a whip. He methodically did this and then he went in and he took care of business. Look at verse number 15. It said he when he made a scourge of small cords he drove them out of the temple and the sheep and the oxen and poured out the changers money and over through the tables and said unto them that sold doves take these things hence take these things out of here. Make not my father's house and house of merchants or merchants. So the first thing that I really want to show you tonight that you know what should make us angry disrespect to God should make us angry. People disrespecting the one true God should anger us. You know we should be willing to defend the Lord. I mean this isn't somebody right here who just didn't know the rules these people in the temple. They were people that knew the rules and they were just blatantly defying the rules just so they could make money themselves. And this is look this happens in church. This happens in church as a matter of fact this is one of the changes I have personally made from the first two years of the satellite ministry to you know being a pastor now where I've consciously looked back at the first two two and a half years of this ministry and I've kind of looked at where I feel like I could have done things better and there was let me just tell you something there was people in this church that were blatantly disrespecting this church. And I just kind of told myself like well you know I'm just gonna have mercy and mercy and mercy and just kind of talk to people and just have mercy but there becomes a point where the man of God needs to get angry. Where people are blatantly doing things. Where they've been told again and again and look it can become a danger to people in the church. And I've realized that that I need to be you know more assertive in certain cases. I'm not talking about with anybody here but I'm just saying like where there's cases where people are just blatantly just throwing something in the pastor's face. Flowing something you know just against the Bible in the church. Look the pastor needs to just drop the hammer on situations like that. And you know there's a time when mercy needs to end. Turn to Acts chapter 13 and that's really my main point on the second point where we really need to have righteous anger in our lives. Righteous anger in our lives should come when we see danger to others. When we see dangers to people that we love. Look at Acts chapter 13 for a good example of this. Acts chapter 13 look at verse number six. So there's two sorcerers in the book of Acts. There is the sorcerer here in Acts chapter 13 and then there's the other sorcerer that actually ends up getting saved in the book of Acts. But look at Acts chapter 13 in verse number six where the Bible says and they had gone through the isle unto pathos. They found a certain sorcerer but look at this a false prophet.  So here you have this deputy, this governor, this ruler of this of this this island and he wants to hear the gospel. But Elimus the sorcerer the what? The false prophet. Verse number six kind of tells us the difference between these two sorcerers. This guy's a false prophet. But Elimus the sorcerer for so his name by interpretation was stood them seeking to turn away the deputy from the faith. That's the difference right there. The other sorcerer, he was just in it to make some money. He was just in it to make some box.  He's just he was just a dummy. He was just a a con artist trying to make a few bucks. This guy's a literal false prophet. He's a literal what what is called what is Saul say to him?  He's basically calling him Satan right there. He says full of all sins and mischief thou child of the devil. You know what he just called him? He just called him a son of Belial. He just called him a reprobate. Thou enemy of all righteousness will pervert the right ways of the Lord. Now this is a very specific false prophet example but Paul got angry here. He got angry. Why? Because somebody was fighting against this man getting saved. This man was actively trying to hurt somebody. He was actively I mean he was actively trying to hurt this man's eternity.  So in situation where there's danger to those that we love that should make you angry. I mean this is a false prophet example here but and look we really need to understand the difference between the false prophet and somebody that's confused. And you really really need to kind of like look for this out soul winning because you're going to see both. You're going to see both. You have to understand that somebody that's just confused is going to be willing to listen to what you have to say. Somebody that's a false prophet is going to sit there and they're going to be talking to you. They're going to be not letting you talk to the other person that's there and they're going to be coming in and trying to stop what you're saying as you know the truth of the Bible the truth of the gospel they're going to try to stop that. You need to take that situation seriously and realize what you're dealing with in that case. I mean that is someone that is actively trying to do harm. Turn to Matthew chapter 23.  Look at Matthew chapter 23 in verse 15. So we see that we should be angry. We should be angry with somebody's disrespecting the house of God. That's Jesus is a very specific example but literally the encompassing thing here is that something is actively trying to hurt someone else that should make us angry. Look at Matthew 23 verse 15. He says Rowan do you scribes and Pharisees hypocrites for you compass sea and land to make one proselyte?


Welcome into the original gangsters podcast I'm your host Scott Bernstein another quick hitter edition coming right at you breaking news out of the New York, New Jersey area Keith Conan the barbarian Richter the president of the pagans motorcycle club the most consequential biker boss of this era and definitely public enemy number one for the federal government. It looked like he was coming out of prison after two years on a gun case. He was supposed to be released last last week but I'm being told that the day that he was supposed to come out which was August 10th that he was brought into custody by state authorities in New York. He was serving his time down in out in New Jersey at Fort Dix and that Suffolk County wants him for another two years related to another gun case. Both of these gun seizures happen in the winter early spring of 2021. One of the one that he just served time for came from a traffic stop in New Jersey and Mercer County where they were tipped off that there was a gun in a secret compartment in the car that he was traveling in. Conan had just attended an annual pagans party where they celebrate the life of a fallen brother a guy they called mailman who was killed in a brawl in the early 2000s I believe maybe late 90s and they celebrate him and in Lancaster Pennsylvania which was where he was from. Conan was with a lot of pagan shot callers at this event in February of 21 and someone at that event tipped the police off that he was on his way back to New York Conan is based out of Long Island Suffolk County and he was pulled over and they found a gun in a secret compartment underneath the center console. That was very very high profile that arrest that bust a lot of headlines that's what he went to prison for two years for in the feds. What seemed to slip under the radar that we're just learning about now was if there was another state case stemming from that same time period in a raid of his home on Long Island where state officials found a gun on the nightstand next to Conan's bed Conan being a convicted felon he's not allowed to have firearms or be anywhere near firearms and under normal any you know under every other possible circumstance these two cases would have run concurrent he would have done the two years for both the fed at the same time but because he is such a valued target by in terms of you know in the government's viewpoint they seem to want to jam him here not let him back on this on the street people that are watching this that that follow this pagans Conan the barbarian saga over the last five years know that Conan the barbarian is the architect of the blue wave which is this massive pagans expansion effort that is the brainchild of Conan the barbarian Keith Richter when he took power in the pagans in late 2017 and a bloodless coup forced his way into the presidency and wanted to spread the brand of the pagans plant flags in parts of the country that the pagans had never been in before he launched this in 2018 in the last five years you know two dozen or so new chapters around the country another dozen two dozen if not more chapter absorptions or patch overs pagans have always been a southeast east coast club and and now they have a presence pushing west there's been pagan activity in washington state montana or again oklahoma texas a lot of areas where you never saw pagans before new jersey is an is an area that they had a presence in but they've really ramped it up with conan's vice president hugo uh zoro new yet nevis uh who has also led this uh very calculated recruiting of latino members they made a deal or have re established a deal with the mongols uh to help them with that push west and it's just it's causing a lot of waves and right now conan the barbarian keith rickter is at the same level as taco bowman was in the 90s sonny barger uh george christy guys like that these biker boss icons and you know the government comes brings the full core press and uh what looked like conan coming back to the street uh in the late summer of 2023 now appears that conan's going to have to go do two more years um we'll know more next week and check the gangsta report for uh you know real time breaking news but right now i'm told he is in custody at suffolk county and probably will be in front of a judge at some point next week and they'll figure out if he actually has to do these two years um i'm being told that he probably will and uh question of what happens when conan comes home will now be we'll be kicking the can down the road and we won't be asking that now until at least i'm guessing late 24 maybe uh you know mid 25 so uh this is you know it doesn't get any bigger than this conan the conan the barbarian keith rickter uh he is on the bulletin board of every dea atf fbi agent uh every one of those units and they are coming after him with a full arsenal check back at the gangsta report og pod for all your breaking news related to lakosa nostra and the bikers as well as you know all time types of organized crime that we're gonna be feeding you we love giving you the the the hottest content and we're gonna keep doing that for og pod i'm scott burnstein out


hi guys what is up welcome to my channel so for today's video she is here in today's video i'm going to be trying out the taughty beauty volume one eyeshadow palette so if you want to see how i got this looking kind of my first impressions first time messing around with this beauty then just keep watching okay so i don't have any makeup on because this is going to be like a pure first impressions i don't do these types of videos very often on my channel because i love to give kind of my full in-depth experience using the palettes and all my collected thoughts but i feel like this moment was so special that i actually wanted to capture it on camera like my very first first impressions so that's why we're doing it this style today obviously i mean i'm sure you guys have already heard and are aware of the palette i'm sure the majority of you have already probably ordered it but i love taughty i don't necessarily agree with everything that she does but as a beauty channel i think she's phenomenal at what she does i think she's a really smart business woman so i really do genuinely feel like she put all of her hard work and thought into this palette and that she wasn't going to release anything horrible so i think that i forgot to mention about the whole ordering process was that it did go very smooth i wasn't in a waiting line for too long my heart was pumping but it was really easy and painless and so taughty ordered enough stock she is awesome like she did not screw that one up like a lot of other brands have in the past i think even her reveal video was incredible i love how open she was about who made it which by the way it is seed beauty which also makes kkw beauty color pop and kylie cosmetics which i think is really cool because one it's made in the usa and two they make good quality eyeshadows so i knew that this was going to be good and sometimes i feel like people don't understand that just because it's made in the same factory doesn't mean it's the same formula i don't know too much about makeup manufacturing but i do know that there are only so many factories like part of the business is that each factory does cater to multiple businesses so the fact that she went to a factory that already has brands is completely normal it does not mean it's the same formula so that whole thing never crossed my mind it i feel like sometimes people don't realize that it's a very normal thing in the makeup industry so anyways let me stop professing my love and admiration for taughty let's get into this beauty so this is 48 it is currently sold out but you can pre order it it says online on her website which you can only get it at taughtybeauty.com pre order now to reserve your palette from the december restock and receive guaranteed shipping by december 15th which is perfect if you want to get it for somebody as a gift i did purchase this myself i did order expedited shipping because i wanted to review it for you guys and so this is what it came in it just came in a regular black box and then you open it and then you have taughty who of course is so gorgeous i think this is really cute packaging i love that the box like decorated and made with love and then it came packaged pretty well and then you have the palette now i'm not gonna lie when i first saw the initial photos i was like morphe and i say that because it was like all sleek black packaging and then circular inside and i was like that really looks like it could be a morphe palette but i mean it is made in the usa most morphe palettes are made in china now that i have it in my hands it is totally different than a morphe palette the product itself feels like it's good quality which i was going to be very disappointed if it was like a morphe palette but just even from picking this up i can tell it's not a morphe palette it is 48 dollars and i do think that is a very fair price you are getting a lot of different shadows and honestly if taughty had put the price up more i wouldn't be surprised but i think 48 is a really good price just giving her demographic of followers she has people all over the board and she dabbles into all different types of makeup whether it be luxe or complete drugstore so i think this is a very fair price point for her and her audience so here's the unicart in it just comes right out it has taughty beauty on it and then you have the actual palette it's a little bit rubberized if you have a vizier palette it's similar feeling to a vizier palette and it feels very very sturdy and it says volume one so that leads me to believe there will be more volumes of this type of palette but yeah it feels like a good quality palette and then you open it up and you have a sturdy heavy mirror you know how sometimes mirrors can feel a little bit flimsy or like they're coming off like this is a nice heavy-duty thick mirror and let's see oh and she's a good mirror too at that and then of course you are going to reveal the shades it's an all neutral palette which i think is perfect for taughty she always loves a good neutral and she has these glitters on top which is all taughty all the way so some people were disappointed from this color scheme honestly i think it's gorgeous and these are colors that people are going to love and use i know for me this is like speaking to me and the layout of the palette i think is very neat i love palettes like this it's designed to completely monochromatically so there are four layers of different textures and then also six columns of different tones all in the neutral family and nightish shade has a name the way she does it is she labels it by the finish that the eyeshadow is and then by the name of the whole tone so if i was to use this shade for example it'd be sequin poet so a lot of people said they hadn't seen a layout or like a concept like this before i love concepts like this i have a palette let me see if i could find it now these are completely different but it's like a similar idea these nyx ultimate multi finish shadow palette where again it's organized by tone and then you have three different finishes of that tone so i have seen products similar to that obviously it hasn't been executed like this one but just a similar idea so i have seen that before and i was always attracted to these because i loved this concept so when i saw taughty was doing that i was like yes this is amazing so let's get into some live swatches so that we can really explore in this palette so we are going to swatch by finish by the way ignore my nails i don't have enough time to get them done so just let it be i know they're growing out i just need to get them shaped we're gonna start off with mats so so we're gonna start off with poets okay so instantly as you can see there was a little bit of fallout there so she was a little chunky that was like a terrible swatch but ooh so we do have some pigment but just keep in mind we did have a little bit of fallout there this is aura again a little bit of kickback but nothing crazy so a lot of times with the shadows that that clump up like that that means they're really really soft but it still is very smooth and buttery this is sooth this is a great transition shade beautiful i should line them up to the palette more huh now we're gonna go with story which is more warm again a lot of kickback coming up from that we have ritual don't tell me i'm a bad swatcher i know i am okay these browns are so necessary i'm so happy she has a whole row of them and then we have memory which who that's a very nice pigmented black so that is what the matte row is looking like and they seem very smooth just be careful because it looks like when you put a brush in there's gonna be some kickback so this next formula is the sequin formula and this type of formula i'm normally not very partial to it's like more of a matte with some shimmers and glitters embedded into it and a lot of times for shades like these you will find that the glitters just kind of rub away and then you're just left with a matte shade so i'm not quite sure how to feel about this formula a lot of times they have similar formulas in two-phase palettes and they're kind of useless so this one this purpley one from poet has some like blue reflects in it these seem to have a little bit more glitters than normal shades like these do which i think will make it better then we have aura this one has more gold reflex oh that one's really pretty by swatch these are really pretty i don't know how pretty they will be on the eye so this is sue that has some golden shimmers in it so this looks like it's literally the exact same matte shade just with some glitters in there let's do story this one is like a pumpkin color with some gold reflex and then ritual some gold reflex and then memory which has some silver ooh that's pretty that could make a really neat smoky eyes hopefully you can really truly see these shimmers embedded in the shade super stunning okay so now we're going to move on to the metallic side i feel like these are going to be amazing i have high expectations because tati loves her metallic shades so let's start off with poet which is more of a pinky cranberry shade very pretty not giving up maybe as much glimmer as i had hoped for aura this is such a necessary shade for like an inner corner highlight against not super impressed with how these are swatching they're really nice but just knowing tati i think a little bit will bam bam would be nice but if you use these wet i'm sure you can really get that bam in there story this color looks incredible ooh that's really pretty this peachy golden shade and we have ritual a bronzy brown this is going to be stunning for a bronze smoky eye and then memory so this one in particular feels a little bit more creamy and thick ooh this is stunning so let me give you guys a close-up on the these so these shimmers are really really pretty i wouldn't say they're knocking my socks off by any means but we'll have to see how they perform on the eye okay so the last row of course is the one that i'm most excited for the glitter row this is totally tati i'm so excited about this it's about to get everywhere though so this glitter of course poet is the most stunning and it is very soft to touch oof really pretty now these i'm interested to see if you need a glitter glue with them this aura one is incredible it has like blue and gold and so many different color reflex i will be doing close-ups so you can see when i'm done swatching then we have a gold one i'm very impressed with how these are swatching for pressed glitters story which is your more orange you want it has like pink and yellow reflex in there then we have a ritual really pretty bronzy color then let's dig into memory this is going to be killer and i don't like smokey eyes so take a closer look i mean that's everything is a knot wow so i forgot to film like a transition for this segment so the video is about to abruptly just go to my eye tutorials so we went with swatches now we're going to see how it applies to the eyeballs so it is time to move on to actually trying these beauties out so i have applied mac painterly paint pot all over my eyelid and now let's dig in so i want to do a look that i'm pretty comfortable with and also able to try all the formulas with so we're going to start off with some of the matte soothe shade and we are going to apply that as our basic transition shade so i did get a little bit of pickup in the pans with the brush as i stated what happened earlier but this is the perfect transition color for my skin tone it has a touch of warmth to it this is a wingos number 16 brush by the way in case you are curious but i mean that got the job done so now i'm going to take a little bit of the matte aura shade and we're going to just apply that right underneath our brow bone so that has a good amount of pigment to it i love that she added a cream shade cream shades do not get enough love i'm just going to brighten underneath my eyebrow with that so let's play with the sequin formula so let's try some of the ritual sequin the sequin also has some kick up i'm going to pat that right in the outer corner so what i'm interested in seeing with this formula is if the glitters stay or if they blend away to become a matte and in that case it's just like why have a matte and a sequin formula i don't know if you can tell though but that just blended like a dream holy cow so the blending on that was incredible sorry i didn't move you in closer but i will say there is a bit of that shimmer still embedded into the color but for the most part it looks pretty matte i also have like no fallout of glitters by the way which is awesome so i think if you want that sequin formula if you apply it with your finger all over the lid it is going to leave that glimmer there but if you do use a blending brush like i just did that is what is going to kind of blend those glitters away there's still somewhat there but i think the best way to apply it to get the most out of the glitters is just to put it all over the eyelid but blended super dreamy so we are going to warm this look up i'm going to take just a little bit of the matte story color on a blending brush all i'm doing is i'm just patting this right where that brown stops and just a touch to add some general warmth to the look see how that added Thanksgiving vibes right there so trying out the metallic formula let's dig into ritual which is the bronzy color i'm gonna apply that all over the lid now this look keep in mind is more so just to try out all of the different formulas i will probably do an update video on this palette altogether with different looks so you can get some inspiration but just initially trying the formulas this metallic is super pretty it applied really smooth with a brush i didn't even need to use a finger and like applied full pigment so these are not super metallic they're a softer shimmer but that is super stunning so i'm gonna wet my brush just to see if that brightens everything up so i'm gonna dig into the soothe color which is more golden and we're gonna spray my brush okay yeah so instantly that took everything up a notch so if you do want that super metallic color just wet the brush oh my gosh this look by the way is everything so now we're gonna create just a little bit of an inner corner highlight so i'm gonna use the metallic aura shade right here perfect i'm so happy she added this color in as well gosh i love this whole cream roll it was so necessary i'm running some of the matte shades that i use underneath this look itself is absolutely stunning and up my alley but you know we gotta add some glitter i want to use it without a glitter glue to really see what it can do so i want it to be a little bit more golden so we're gonna use the shimmer from the soothe all you have to do is pat very lightly and you get a lot i'm gonna start that off just everywhere never mind okay so without a glitter glue it seems to be sticking very well and it's scattered pretty well too so if you want more of a scattered effect just very very lightly press on the top and you will get all that you need i really like this pressed formula i'm going to say that the best way to apply this is with a finger but you can get away with a brush let me put just a touch of that also like down here just because glitter okay here's a close-up of the shadow super stunning so i'm going to finish the rest of my makeup and we will be back for the final thoughts all right so i'm back here is the final look i feel like this is a very taughty kind of look she loves glittery neutral kind of looks and honestly i'm loving it so one thing that i did additionally off-camera was i took the matte black shade and i lined my upper lash line with it before lashes and i've got to say it is a really amazing black it was super black on my eye very pigmented and it didn't go grayish which was really good so so far from what i can tell that black matte shadow is a good one something also worth noting is that the glitter shades on the back of the unicorn it says not intended for use in the immediate eye area i mean that's not surprising most press glitters say the same thing so maybe do so at your own risk i think it's worth the risk i think it's really pretty i will update you guys down in the comments letting you know if they fell out throughout the day and if i think adding a glitter glue would help with that but overall i mean this is a really fabulous palette i think for 48 it is a great value given all the shimmers and shades that you have to work with i think this is a phenomenal color story i know a lot of people think it's boring but honestly this is in my opinion one of the best ways to start off a brand you're getting a range of different textures to play with but you also have these basic colors no matter what other colors tati comes out with she has these to rely on this is the basic palette that everybody needs before you get into the fun stuff from what i can tell everything blended beautifully everything had a great pigmentation to it and just application overall was extremely easy all the shades blended great they showed up on the eyelid how they looked in the pan the press glitter formula was quite impressive and very easy to work with because sometimes press glitters can be a little bit more difficult to work with them so far i am loving this palette these are my colors these are my textures i am definitely going to get a lot of use out of this palette and i don't know for 48 this is such a good value i look forward to playing with this palette more and updating you guys so if you aren't subscribed to my channel already make sure you do so so that you can hear about my updates because i might just do a separate tutorial video creating looks with this palette and yeah so thank you guys so much for watching this video i really hope you enjoyed it let me know what your thoughts down below about this palette and i will see you guys in my next video bye guys have a good one


You would think that this would be our first time, but it feels so much like the first time that we are able to meet and cut ribbon together. It touches my heart to see so many people taking the time out. This is a work day lunch time. You could be eating lunch somewhere and you're with us and we truly, truly appreciate it as you join us as we go through our ribbon cutting ceremony. I welcome each one of you and before you leave, we have cards because we're going to draw for some gifts. We want to pass out some gifts because we want to show our love back to you for your love to us for showing up for this event. So if you would, we have cards if you can fill them out and put it in the box towards the back and we do have snacks for you as well that we don't want to eat ourselves, all by ourselves. So please share with us, okay? And we're going to move forward. Before we speak with the mayor, Jimmy is going to come up and he's going to pour libation. Let me first say this is libation. This is not a love potion as the mayor would call it, but it is a libation and African customs libation was always poured to include the ancestors involved in all that we do. So this is truly a celebration that we want our ancestors to be here with us so that they may be included in everything that we do from start to finish. We want our ancestors, you know, our mothers and fathers, great grandparents, who all those who played a part in our lives that to bring us to the moments that we're in right now, this is what this libation is for. So as I go through the libation, when I pour water into the plant, the plant is always a symbolism of growth. As the plant grows, we also want to grow in our spirituality as well as our knowledge and our wisdom because life and nature clearly gives us clarity and understanding. So as I speak, and as I say, when the water is poured in the plant, I'm going to say, I say, and we ask all of you to say, I say, I say means for our ancestors to be with us. That's what it means. So every time we pour, we say, I say, okay, we call upon our ancestors far and near fathers and mothers of our fathers, mothers and fathers of our mothers to bear witness to all that we have done. And it is by their example that they continue to inspire us towards reclaiming our African minds, regenerating our African spirit, liberating our families and our communities and restoring our greatness as a people. We pour libation to bring into our midst their venerable African spirit, radiating their great wisdom, their courage and dedication and their unyielding commitment to victory by any means necessary. It is in the honor of our creator, our ancestors, our mothers and fathers, our sisters and brothers, our children and their children, our grandparents, great grandparents, aunts, uncles, cousins, friends and elders of our communities, those who have all transitioned that we call upon your engaging spirit, your energy and your soul, that it may manifest itself through all thoughts, words and actions that we commit ourselves to. We pour this libation in your honor, in the honor of our creator and in the various manifestations of the creative spirit. We pour libation. I share for our steam ancestors who laid the foundation for human civilization and who provides the wisdom to which we live and the models by which our lives are guided. We pour libation and for our steam ancestors who suffered the atrocities and the horrors of our ma'afah but yet demonstrated the victorious power of the African spirit by maintaining their dignity no matter the cost. We pour libation. And for our steam ancestors who survived and made it possible for us to be here today to continue on the value fight for African liberation and vindication. We pour libation. And for our children and our children's children and future generations of Africans to come that they too in their time will vindicate our race from all adversaries and to continue to imprint upon the world the great genes of African humanity. We pour libation. May the venerable spirit engulf this occasion to reaffirm our Africanity. It is done. Our creator is satisfied. Ashe. Ashe. Ashe. Ashe. Ashe. Thank you. At. Thank you. Thank you. At this time we will now bring uh at the mirror to come up and speak for us as well as we can do the ribbon cutting ceremony and after that after that time we will have several people to come up and speak about their experiences in the house of Hathor. Thank you. It's a great great honor to be here today not only because they're growing the house is growing that is a testimony in itself folks if you if you had been to the old location it was filled with love reflections on family history culture all in one place and now they have room to grow and what's even great and you know this is meant to be because if you look at the sign over there guess who's the top billing I don't think I have to say much more than that you know I mean there's a reason for everything that happens and I really appreciate uh Jimmy and Angela and the community constantly giving back making the community better showing up to public hearings thank you Jimmy for being there last night because it's important that people understand that that when a store invests and grows in a community they're part of that community we have to support them and they're supporting us they're going to continue to grow and they're going to bring a center of cultural awareness art history and and teaching our youth not to forget about our past but don't spend your whole time looking in the rear view mirror look at the windshield how we move forward together congratulations on the the reopening I like to call it a grand opening because it's about four times the size of your old store and this is a blessing thank you very much to both of you for what you're doing in our community and your re-investment here in North Columbia thank you peace and divine blessings everyone it is such an honor to be here my name is Anne Vrenasia Williams and I am a young goddess who is continuing to carry the torch forward from all of the knowledge that I am learning from this beautiful beautiful establishment and the beautiful community that I am a part of it is such a joy to number one not be a Colombian native at all but to come down and find such an awesome couple as Brother Jimmy and Sister Andrea and just find a home it's more than the house of Hathor it is the home for me because it's so much love like the mayor said is full of love community art culture I've learned so much and I'm continuing to thrive and grow this is an awesome place to bring your youth to continue to learn even more and grow I thank you so much for all that you poured into me and we shall continue to thrive and move forward and the store shall continue to get bigger because that is the goal so thank you so much and it's so well deserved and it's an honor thank you greetings everyone how's everyone doing you all look so beautiful out here for this beautiful occasion I don't want to I don't have too much to say because when it comes to what the house of Hathor has meant to me and has done for me in my life I can take a million years and not come up with the correct words verbiage or phrases to describe what they've done for me I found myself in this place I don't call it the house of Hathor I call it the home of Hathor and Jimmy and Angela you know they they aren't people you know oh they are royalty and what they've done for not not only me but people around me and you know you go out into the world and you carry that reflection with you and that energy you feel when you walk inside that door and when you come out of that door no matter who you are the energy you feel will reverberate to others around you you got to believe if you don't believe in the power of energy the power of collective community work and consciousness I dare you to walk through that door and walk back out and not be a better person. Jimmy and Angela I can only laugh with y'all. Thank you for the opportunity and just thank you thank you thank you. Good afternoon everyone. Peace and blessings to each and every one of you. I want to take the time to say more than thank you. On this corner here there's no other culture center on this corner but right here one of the things that we have to be very clear about that we need to be culturally balanced and when I say we humanity humanity began in mother Africa we need to be culture about this is a culture center this is a culture center when I met my brother Jimmy as the mayor said earlier it was in the community my life has been community that's been my life community and this is where I met brother Jimmy I think it was on 14 several years ago we was addressing some issues and from there the rest is history my life has been centered around community culture politics economic etc out of the house of Hattor I bear witness the young folks who has been resurrected the adults who has been resurrected in regards to wisdom and knowledge in regards to counseling there's all we're talking counseling we're talking from education the economics the politics we're talking community collectiveness ongoing I think it was recently we was over in one community when some young folks got killed this is what's the house they have to been doing so it's more than just a culture center it is a community it's where the community can come and resolve the issues at the last uh at the last place over here where they have I think we had several meetings and I think the mayor was there several meetings with all kind of politicians we must continue to raise the house of Hattor we must raise it and as we raise it let's focus on the children let's focus on the children let's continue as the children came in there let's make sure they come in here and as they come in here let's pool our resources together collectively collectively as one village one community they said take a what was it saying take a village to raise a child oh who's going to raise the village who's going to raise the village we we have to move away from the eye and we because that's what the eye that's what the eye is about the eye must be turned into we and we into them and them and today and day into us and we all in this thing together regards to the fact because surely under the sky we all must transition we all must transition but the question remains what legacy will we leave behind for the children and I'm emphasizing the children because we got some major issues today that's centered around the children so we have to come together as a collective no more lip service no more lip service let's put aside our petty differences let's begin to engage our self-conservative engagement as brother jimmy went down to the city council last night it should have been thousands of people down there let's begin to teach the children about local government local politics economics because again it's necessary critically necessary and we must remember and the final analysis the question remains what have you done to make it better for those that came before you welcome to the house of hapten


listening library presents who was mark twain by april jones prince read for you by kevin paraso who was mark twain when i was younger i could remember anything whether it had happened or not mark twain if you can't quite place the name mark twain think of the adventures of tom Sawyer and the adventures of huckleberry fin their mark twain's most famous books mark twain was america's greatest storyteller he was so good at making up stories that he even made up his name he was born samuel langhorn clemens his best stories came from his own boyhood adventures in the mississippi river town of hannibal mark twain had an exciting life he was a steamboat pilot a gold miner a newspaper reporter he traveled all around the world giving lectures which were really more like one-man shows about his writing and experiences mark twain became the most famous and successful author of his day many of his stories are funny but often the humor touches serious issues including racism greed and injustice america changed a great deal during mark twain's life he challenged americans to look at who they were and where they were going chapter one in with the comet there comes a time in every rightly constructed boys life when he has a raging desire to go somewhere and dig for treasure mark twain samuel langhorn clemens the man who became famous as mark twain was born in a two-room house


Good morning Hank, it's Tuesday. Happy 2018! I really want to bring it in 2018, like that's my main goal for the year, but in order to do that I have to decide, like, you know, what to bring. So I want to talk about three things I want to help bring into the world this year because, you know, if you promise to do something and then people have heard that promise, it's more likely that you'll actually do it. First, in 2018 I want to collaborate with my wife to make at least four episodes of a new YouTube series called Cooking History to be uploaded at least initially here on the Vlogbrothers channel. My wife Sarah produces an amazing channel with PBS Digital called The Art Assignment and one of her series over there is called Art Cooking where she will make, for instance, a huge crawfish tower that Salvador Dalí once made while also talking about his life and work. It's such a brilliant series because you learn about food and cooking while also learning about art, link below by the way. Right, so this year we're going to try to do the same thing with history, attempting recipes from different periods of history while learning about that period and also how food shaped history. So we'll consider, for instance, what French bread tasted like in the run-up to the 1789 bread riots that presaged the French Revolution. We'll also attempt to make porridge from 3700 years ago. If you have any other ideas, please leave them in comments. Okay, thing number two, I want to make at least 10 episodes in 2018 of a new podcast called The Anthropocene Reviewed where I review different aspects of the human-centered planet. This started out as a joke between Hank and me but I have decided to actually do it. The first episode reviews Canada Geese, the animal, and Diet Dr. Pepper, the soda. Here's a little excerpt. The man who popularized America's greatest soft drink was named Woodrow Wilson Clements but he preferred to be called Foots, a nickname that he picked up in high school due to his oddly shaped toes. Foots took Dr. Pepper from a regional brand to a global juggernaut because he understood exactly what made Dr. Pepper significant. I've always maintained, he said, you cannot tell anyone what Dr. Pepper tastes like because it's so different. It's not an apple, it's not an orange, it's not a strawberry, it's not a root beer, it's not even a cola. Cola, after all, is derived from cocoa leaves and vanilla to real-world flavors. Sprite has that lemon-lime taste. Purple soda is ostensibly grape-flavored. But Dr. Pepper has no real-world analog. In fact, U.S. trademark courts have tackled this issue, categorizing Dr. Pepper and its knockoffs as pepper sodas. Although they contain no pepper and the pepper in Dr. Pepper refers not to the spice but either to someone's actual name or else to pep, the feeling that Dr. Pepper supposedly fills you with. It's the only category of soda named not for what it tastes like but instead for how it makes you feel. Get ready to know a lot about Diet Dr. Pepper. The first episode of the Anthropocene Review will hopefully be up by the end of January. Okay, lastly, an idea that is not yet well formulated and may not launch until later in 2018, if at all. I would like to do another podcast because, you know, the world doesn't have enough of them about an old book that nobody reads anymore. The book I'm thinking of at the moment, although this may change, is Tom Grogan by Francis Hopkinson Smith, which is a book about an Irish-American woman who adopts the name Tom Grogan from her maybe-dead husband and then becomes a successful dock worker. It's a weird book, and what's weirder is that it was the best-selling novel in the entire United States in 1896 and its author was wildly famous. But today it's been out of print for many decades and is almost entirely forgotten. P.S., the author of that book, Francis Hopkinson Smith, also designed and built the base of the Statue of Liberty. So maybe that book may be another one, but some book that nobody reads anymore from a deeply polarized time in American history that might have some relevance for us. So that's it. I really want to spend this year trying new things while also not neglecting the things I currently do. It's nerve-wracking to talk about goals you haven't accomplished yet, but I also think it can help increase accountability. So if you have a moment and you have any feedback on any of my ideas, please let me know because there's still time to change all of them. But also if you want, maybe leave a goal of your own in comments so that if nothing else, you can return to that comment in 12 months and be like, Hey, I did that thing I said I was gonna do. Hank, I'm gonna go back to writing about the astonishing history of Diet Dr. Pepper now. Happy New Year. I will see you on Friday.


From theCUBE Studios in Palo Alto in Boston, bringing you data-driven insights from theCUBE and ETR. This is Breaking Analysis with Dave Vellante. The rise of Kubernetes came about through a combination of forces that were in hindsight, quite a long shot. Amazon's dominance created momentum for cloud native application development and the need for newer and simpler experiences beyond just easily spinning up compute as a service. This wave crashed into innovations from a startup named Docker and a reluctant competitor in Google that needed a way to change the game on Amazon and the cloud. Now add in the effort of Red Hat, which needed a new path beyond enterprise Linux. And oh by the way, it was just about to commit to a path of a Kubernetes alternative for OpenShift and figure out a governance structure to herd all the cats in the ecosystem and you get the remarkable ascendancy of Kubernetes. Hello and welcome to this week's Wikibon Cube Insights powered by ETR. In this Breaking Analysis, we tapped the backstories of a new documentary that explains the improbable events that led to the creation of Kubernetes. We'll share some new survey data from ETR and commentary from the many early innovators who came on theCUBE during the exciting period since the founding of Docker in 2013, which marked a new era in computing. Because we're talking about Kubernetes and developers today, the hoodie is on. There's a new two-part documentary that I just referenced, it's out and it was produced by Honeypot on Kubernetes, part one and part two, tells the story of how Kubernetes came to prominence and many of the players that made it happen. Now a lot of these players, including Tim Hawken, Kelsey Hightower, Craig McClucky, Joe Beta, Brian Grant, Solomon Hikes, Jerry Chan and others came on theCUBE during the formative years of containers going mainstream and the rise of Kubernetes. John Furrier and Stu Miniman were at the many shows we covered back then and they unpacked what was happening at the time. We'll share the commentary from the guests that they interviewed and try to add some context. Now let's start with the concept of developer-defined infrastructure, DDI. Jerry Chan was at VMware and he could see the trends that were evolving. He left VMware to become a venture capitalist at Greylock. Docker was his first investment and he saw the future this way. What happens is when you define infrastructure and software, you can program it, you make it portable and that's the beauty of this cloud wave, what I call a DDI is now to your point is every piece of infrastructure from storage, networking, to compute has an API, right? And AWS was an early trend where S3, EBS, EC2 had API. And I see- As building blocks too. As building blocks. Is it exactly? The Lego blocks- Not monolithic. The monolithic building blocks, every little blue and bone block has its own API and just like Docker really is the API for this, you know, the cloud enables developers to define how they want to build their applications, how to network them, you know, as Will's talked about and how you want to secure them, how you want to store them. And so the beauty of this generation is now developers are determining how apps are built, not just at the end user, you know, iPhone app layer, the data layer, the storage layer, the networking layer. So every single level is being disrupted by this concept of DDI and where, how you build, use and actually purchase IT has changed and you're seeing the incumbent ventures like Oracle, VMware, Microsoft try to react but you're seeing a whole new generation start. Now what Jerry was explaining is this new abstraction layer that was being built. Here's some ETR data that quantifies that and shows where we are today. The chart shows net score or spending momentum on the vertical axis and market share which represents the pervasiveness in the survey set. So as Jerry and the innovators who created Docker saw the cloud was becoming prominent. And you can see it still has spending velocity that's elevated above that 40% red line which is kind of a magic mark of momentum. And of course, it's very prominent on the X axis as well. And you see the low level infrastructure, the virtualization and that even floats above servers and storage and networking, right? Back in 2013, the conversation with VMware, and by the way, I remember having this conversation deeply at the time with Chad Sackage, was we're going to make this low level infrastructure invisible and we intend to make virtualization invisible, i.e. simplified. And so you see above the two arrows there related to containers, container orchestration and container platforms, which are abstraction layers and services above the underlying VMs and hardware. And you can see the momentum that they have right there with the cloud and AI and RPA. So you had these forces that Jerry described that were taking shape and this picture kind of summarizes how they came together to form Kubernetes. And the upper left, of course, you see AWS and we inserted a picture from a post we did right after the first reinvent in 2012. It was obvious to us at the time that the cloud gorilla was AWS and had all this momentum. Now, Solomon Hikes, the founder of Docker, you see there in the upper right, he saw the need to simplify the packaging of applications for cloud developers. Here's how he described it back in 2014 in the cube with John Furrier. Tainer is a unit of deployment, right? It's the format in which you package your application, all the files, all the executables, libraries, all the dependencies and one thing that you can move to any server and deploy in a repeatable way. So it's similar to how you would run an iOS app on an iPhone, for example. So Docker at the time was a 30 person company and it just changed its name from dot cloud. And back to the diagram, you have Google with a red question mark. So why would you need more than what Docker had created? Craig McClucky, who was a product manager at Google back then, explains the need for yet another abstraction. You create the strong separation between infrastructure operations and application operations. And so Docker has created a portable framework to take a basically a binary and run it anywhere, which is an amazing capability. But that's not enough. You also need to be able to manage that with a framework that can run anywhere. And so the union of Docker and Kubernetes provides this framework where you're completely abstracted from the underlying infrastructure. You could use VMware, you could use a red hat open stack deployment. You could run on another major cloud provider like. Now Google had this huge cloud infrastructure, but no commercial cloud business compete with AWS, at least not one that was taken seriously at the time. So it needed a way to change the game. And it had this thing called Google Borg, which is a container management system and scheduler. And Google looked at what was happening with virtualization and said, you know, we obviously could do better. Joe Beta, who was with Google at the time, explains their mindset going back to the beginning. I started up Google compute engine, VM as a service. And the odd thing to recognize is that nobody who had been at Google for a long time thought that there was anything to this VM stuff. Right, because Google had been on containers for so long that was their mindset. Borg was the way that stuff was actually deployed. So, you know, my boss at the time who's now a cloud era booted up a VM for the first time and anybody in the outside world be like, hey, that's really cool. And his response was like, well, now what? Right, you're sitting at a prompt, like that's not super interesting. How do I run my app? Right, which is that's what everybody's been struggling with with cloud is not, how do I get a VM off? How do I actually run my code? Okay, so Google never really did virtualization. They were looking at the market and said, okay, what can we do to make Google relevant in cloud? Here's Eric Brewer from Google, talking on theCUBE about Google's thought process at the time. One of the things about Google is it essentially makes no use of virtual machines internally. And that's because Google started in 1998, which is the same year that VMware started. It was kind of brought the modern virtual machine to bear. And so Google infrastructure tends to be built really on kind of classic UNIX processes and communication. And so scaling that up, you get a system that works a lot with just processes and containers. So kind of when I saw containers come along with Docker, we said, well, that's a good model for us. And we can take what we know internally, which was called Borg, a big scheduler. And we can turn that into Kubernetes and we'll open source it. And suddenly we have kind of a cloud version of Google that works the way we would like it to work. Now, Eric Brewer gave us the bumper sticker version of the story there. What he reveals in the documentary that I referenced earlier is that initially, Google was like, why would we open source our secret sauce to help competitors? So folks like Tim Hawken and Brian Grant who were on the original Kubernetes team went to management and pressed hard to convince them to bless open sourcing Kubernetes. Here's Hawken's explanation. When Docker landed, we saw the community building and building and building. I mean, that was a snowball of its own, right? And as it caught on, we realized we know what this is going to. We know once you embrace the Docker mindset that you very quickly need something to manage all of your Docker nodes once you get beyond two or three of them. And we know how to build that, right? We got a ton of experience here. Like we went to our leadership and said, please, this is going to happen with us or without us. And I think the world would be better if we helped. So the open source strategy became more compelling as they studied the problem because it gave Google a way to neutralize AWS's advantage. Because with containers, you could develop on AWS, for example, and then run the application anywhere like Google's cloud. So it not only gave developers a path off of AWS, if Google could develop a strong service on GCP, they could monetize that play. Now, let me focus your attention back to the diagram which shows this smiling Alex Pulvy from CoreOS which was acquired by Red Hat in 2018. And he saw the need to bring Linux into the cloud. I mean, after all, Linux was powering the internet. It was the OS for enterprise apps. And he saw the need to extend its path into the cloud. Now, here's how he described it at an OpenStack event in 2015. Similar to what happened with Linux, like, yes, there is still need for Linux and Windows and other OSes out there, but by and large on production, web infrastructure, it's all Linux now. And you were able to get onto one stack. And how were you able to do that? It was by having a truly open, consistent API and a commitment to not breaking APIs and so on that allowed Linux to really become ubiquitous in the data center. Yes, there are other OSes, right? But Linux by and large for production infrastructure, what is being used. And I think you'll see a similar phenomenon happen for this next level upwards, where you're treating the whole data center as a computer instead of treating one individual instance as just a computer. And that's the stuff that Kubernetes and Mesa and someone is doing. And I think there will be one that shakes out over time. And we believe that'll be Kubernetes. So, Alex saw the need for a dominant container orchestration platform and you heard them. They made the right bet. It would be Kubernetes. Now, Red Hat, Red Hat's been around since 1993. So it has a lot of on-prem. So it needed a future path to the cloud. So they rang up Google and said, Hey, what do you guys have going on in this space? And Google was kind of non-committal, but it did expose that they were thinking about doing something that was, you know, pre-Kubernetes, it was before it was called Kubernetes, but hey, we have this thing and we're thinking about open sourcing it. But Google's internal debates and some of the arm twisting from the engineers was taking too long. So Red Hat said, well, screw it. We got to move forward with OpenShift. So we'll do what Apple and Airbnb and Heroku are doing and we'll build on an alternative. And so they were ready to go with MeSos, which was very much more sophisticated than Kubernetes at the time and much more mature. But then Google, the last minute said, Hey, let's do this. So Clayton Coleman with Red Hat, he was an architect and he leaned in right away. He was one of the first outside committers outside of Google. But you still had these competing forces in the market and internally there were debates. Do we go with simplicity or do we go with system scale? And then Goldberg from Google explains why they focused first on simplicity and getting that right. We had to defend of why we are only supporting 100 nodes in the first release of Kubernetes. And they explained that they know how to build for scale. They've done that. They know how to do it. But realistically, most of users don't need large clusters. So why create this complexity? So Goldberg explains that rather than competing right away with, say, misos or Docker swarm, which were far more baked, they made the bet to keep it simple and go for adoption and ubiquity, which obviously turned out to be the right choice. But the last piece of the puzzle was governance. Now Google promised open source Kubernetes, but when it started to open up to contributors outside of Google, the code was still controlled by Google and developers had to sign Google paper that said Google could still do whatever it wanted. It could sub license, et cetera. So Google had to pass the baton to an independent entity and that's how CNCF was started. Kubernetes was its first project. And let's listen to Chris Anizek of the CNCF explain. CNCF is all about providing a neutral home for cloud native technology. And it's been about almost two years since our first board meeting. And the idea was there's a certain set technology out there that are essentially microservice based that live in containers that are essentially orchestrated by some process. That's essentially what we mean when we say cloud native. And CNCF was seeded with Kubernetes as its first project. And as we've seen over the last couple of years, Kubernetes has grown quite well. They have a large community, a diverse contribution, contributor base and have done kind of extremely well. They're one of actually the fastest, highest velocity open source projects out there. Okay, so this is how we got to where we are today. This ETR data shows container orchestration offerings. It's the same XY graph that we showed earlier and you can see where Kubernetes lands. Not we're standing, that Kubernetes is not a company but respondents, they know they're doing Kubernetes. They maybe don't know who's platform. And it's hard with the ETR taxonomy. It's a fuzzy and survey data because Kubernetes is increasingly becoming embedded into cloud platforms and IT pros. They may not even know which one specifically. And so the reason we've linked these two platforms, Kubernetes and Red Hat OpenShift is because OpenShift right now is a dominant revenue player in the space and is an increasingly popular pass layer. Yeah, you could download Kubernetes and do what you want with it but if you're really building enterprise apps you're going to need support and that's where OpenShift comes in. And there's not much data on this but we did find this chart from Omnia which shows the container software market, whatever that really is, and Red Hat has got 50% of it. This is revenue. And we know the muscle of IBM is behind OpenShift so it's really not hard to believe. Now we've got some other data points that show how Kubernetes is becoming less visible and more embedded under the hood if you will as this chart shows. This is data from CNCF's annual survey. They had 1,800 respondents here and the data showed that 79% of respondents use certified Kubernetes hosted platforms. Amazon Elastic Container Service for Kubernetes was the most prominent of 39% followed by Azure Kubernetes Service at 23% and Azure AKS Engine at 17% with Google's GKE Google Kubernetes Engine behind those three. Now, you have to ask, okay Google, Google's management initially they had concerns, well, why are we open sourcing such a key technology? And the premise was it would level the playing field and for sure it has, but you have to ask that, has it driven the monetization Google was after? And I would have to say no, it probably didn't but think about where Google would have been if it hadn't open sourced Kubernetes. How relevant would it be in the cloud discussion? Despite its distant third position behind AWS and Microsoft or even fourth, if you include Alibaba, without Kubernetes Google probably would be much less prominent or possibly even irrelevant in cloud, enterprise cloud. Okay, let's wrap up with some comments on the state of Kubernetes and maybe a thought or two about where we're headed. So look, no shocker Kubernetes for all its improbable beginnings has gone mainstream. In the past year or so, we're seeing much more maturity and support for stateful workloads and big ecosystem support with respect to better security and continued simplification, but it's still pretty complex. It's getting better, but it's not VMware level of maturity, for example, of course. Now adoption has always been strong for Kubernetes for cloud native companies who start with containers on day one, but we're seeing many more IT organizations adopting Kubernetes as it matures. It's interesting, Docker set out to be the operating system of the cloud and Kubernetes has really kind of become that. Docker desktop is where Docker's action really is. That's where Docker is thriving. It's sold off Docker Swarm to Mirantis. It's made some tweaks. Docker has made some tweaks to its licensing model to be able to continue to evolve its business. You hear more about that at DockerCon. And as we said years ago, we expected Kubernetes to become less visible. Stu Miniman and I talked about this in one of our predictions post and really become more embedded into other platforms. And that's exactly what's happening here, but it's still complicated. Remember, go back to the early and mid cycle of VMware, understanding things like application performance. You needed folks in lab coats to really remediate problems and dig in and peel the onion and scale the system. You know, in some ways you're seeing that dynamic repeated with Kubernetes, security performance scale, recovery, when something goes wrong, all are made more difficult by the rapid pace in which the ecosystem is evolving Kubernetes. But it's definitely headed in the right direction. So what's next for Kubernetes? We would expect further simplification and you're going to see more abstractions. We live in this world of almost perpetual abstractions. Now as Kubernetes improves support for multi-cluster, it will begin to treat those clusters as a unified group. So kind of abstracting multiple clusters and treating them as one to be managed together. And this is going to create a lot of ecosystem focus on scaling globally, okay? Once you do that, you're going to have to worry about latency and then you're going to have to keep pace with security as you expand the threat area. And then of course recovery. What happens when something goes wrong? More complexity, the harder it is to recover. And that's going to require new services to share resources across clusters. So look for that. You also should expect more automation. It's going to be driven by the host cloud providers. As Kubernetes supports more stateful applications and begins to extend its cluster management, cloud providers will inject as much automation as possible into the system. Now, and finally, as these capabilities mature, we would expect to see better support for data intensive workloads like AI and machine learning and inference. Scheduling with these workloads becomes harder because they're so resource intensive and performance management becomes more complex. So that's going to have to evolve. I mean, frankly, many of the things that Kubernetes team way back when, you know, they backburned early on they, for example, that you saw in Docker swarm or mesos, they're going to start to enter the scene now with Kubernetes as they start to sort of prioritize some of those more complex functions. Now, the last thing I'll ask you to think about is what's next beyond Kubernetes? You know, this isn't it, right? With serverless and IoT and the edge and new data heavy workloads, there's something that's going to disrupt Kubernetes. So in that, by the way, in that CNCF survey, nearly 40% of respondents were using serverless and that's going to keep growing. So how is that going to change the development model? You know, Andy Jassy once famously said that if they had to start over with Amazon retail, they'd start with serverless. So let's keep an eye on the horizon to see what's coming next. All right, that's it for now. I want to thank my colleague, Stephanie Chan, who helped research this week's topics and Alex Meyerson on the production team who also manages the Breaking Analysis podcast, Kristen Martin and Cheryl Knight helped get the word out on social. So thanks to all of you. Remember, these episodes are all available as podcasts wherever you listen, just search Breaking Analysis podcast. Don't forget to check out ETR's website at ETR.ai. We'll also publish a full report every week on wikibon.com and siliconangle.com. You can get in touch with me. Email me directly, david.volante at siliconangle.com or DM me at dvolante. You can comment on our LinkedIn posts. This is Dave Volante for theCUBE Insights, powered by ETR. Have a great week, everybody. Thanks for watching. Stay safe, be well, and we'll see you next time.


When we talk about what our ancestors ate, the first thing in general that comes to mind is the paleo diet. Eating foods presumed to have been available to humans during the Paleolithic era when we were cavemen, still hunter-gatherers. Unfortunately, the paleo diet has fallen short. One reason being that modern foods are different than the past. You can argue that our ancestors ate meat, fruits and vegetables, but they weren't eating conventional feedlot beef, apples half the size of our heads, and monocropped broccoli devoid of nutrition. The other reason the paleo diet has fallen short is that it hasn't identified what makes a diet healthy, not that any other diet really has. The sheer variance of climates and regions that humans have thrived in leads us to important observations. For example, you have First Nation Alaskans surviving solely on seal and caribou. There are various coastal tribes subsisting off of fish and foraged vegetables, tubers, fruits. The only consistent factor between every single diet of these groups of people is the presence of nutrition from animal foods in large amounts, typically an average of 55% of their calories. And this leads to the main point I establish in the majority of my videos, that we need to obtain certain vitamins, minerals and elements, fatty acids that are only present in quality animal sources. But once that is achieved, what more is there? We know there is a presence of raw, cooked and fermented foods in all groups of people. What determines what plant foods we should consume? What we have access to? What our specific ancestors ate? I had some gene testing done a couple years back as part of a volunteer program. I mean God knows what they do with the DNA. There are probably a bunch of frank to final clones running around in a different dimension, but the results pretty much confirmed what I had thought previously. To my knowledge, both my parents are Italian, both of their sets of parents are Italian as well originating from Naples. For percentages, I am 65% European, 32% West Asian, North African and 3% Central Southeast Asian. This makes sense as there were various North African conquests throughout recent Italian history, possibly the reason I have a giant bush of curly hair. Does this information help me though? Does this mean I should be able to subsist off of a Southern Italian diet as well as a North African diet? Is this why I am not able to digest dairy that well or tolerate lactose? What would these people have been eating? One can speculate in Naples there would have been a fairly high grain consumption, probably wheat and the rest of the diet may have been supplemented with pork, fish, certain goat and sheep dairy in the form of cheese. The same could be said of North Africa. There are dishes strongly based around grains like wheat, rice, barley with similar meat choices. What is interesting is that human beings developed depending on their diet and geographical location. Here we can see that native Indian tribes have similar but different facial features, the only variants being the part of America they settled in, therefore what foods they were eating in that specific geographical location. Skin color of course correlates to the amount of sun exposure throughout the year, which was fairly similar across Native American Indian tribes, some of them in the South obviously having darker skin due to more sun exposure. So will eating like an Italian make you as beautiful as an Italian? Will living in a Scandinavian country give you blonde hair, blue eyes and make you twice as tall as me? Of course not, but if you place humans in an environment for thousands and thousands of years, certain physical adaptations will be made, those features included. Why do you think everyone looks a certain way? Why do you think these groups of people, whether it's Polynesians, Japanese, Chinese, why do you think they all look similar? It's because of their location which is correlated directly to their diet. What we can do is observe the differences between these groups of people who was the tallest, the strongest, most beautiful. But that gives us the answer we spoke about earlier, the basis of animal nutrition in the diet. As the percentage of animal foods goes up or down, the height, the physical stature, the width of all of the bones in the body changes drastically. Why do you think Italians are so short in some parts? It's because of the high grain consumption. Interestingly, intelligence doesn't correlate directly to nutrition. Yes, brain size does, yes certain functions do, people tend to have straight teeth, not need glasses, but that social aspect, the environment the person is in for those thousands and thousands of years, those social interactions are what correlate to intelligence. Now are there other factors determined by these plant foods present in the diet? We do see reproduction go way up when grains are incorporated as opposed to hunter gathering. This could be because of the high energy and consistent availability of the caloric energy from grains that you're growing year round and you always have a food supply. But should I consume oats and cod liver because my Scottish ancestors were healthy, though I opt for rye bread and cheese as certain Swiss settlers did, eat ancient strains of wheat like the Romans, or perhaps indulge in sheep cheeses famous to Sardinia? Are these foods even remotely similar to what my ancestors ate or is the type of seed, the soil, the way we're growing them now, not even comparable? There's obviously far too much to consider and talk about, but in the end, the answer is obvious. Just like past humans survived with foods they had access to, we should be doing the same thing. See what your options are from an animal food perspective, from a plant food perspective, and then you can make subjective choices based on that. You might have access to raw dairy, but not pasture raised eggs. Perhaps you don't have access to grass and beef, but there is plenty of wild caught fish. Maybe it's a choice between conventional white rice or organic sourdough bread. As much as we can look at the paper value of foods and expect what happens when you consume them, anecdotal experience weighs heavily. If you feel like taking a nap after eating rice, but sourdough bread makes you feel great, it can definitely bring up questions that lead to further education. Is it because of your ancestry? Is it because of the gut microbiome you developed through your early years? Was there a pollutant concern in the rice fields? Did they use a specific sourdough culture? There's so many factors at play here, it's really, really, really subjective. Once we have a basis of animal nutrition in the diet from the highest quality animal foods you have access to, the plant foods that you might want to incorporate, whatever you tolerate, you know, if you do want to have a variance in your diet, very, very, very subjective and a good general guideline is stick to organic, stick to heirloom varieties of fruits and vegetables and grains and of course gauge your reaction, see how you tolerate the food. Thank you guys for joining me. If you could please like the video, subscribe, hit that bell icon, share the video if you can. If you guys would like to support me further, definitely check out Frankie's Free Range Meat, high quality, nutrient-dense animal foods at an affordable price. Hopefully in the future, however long it is from now, I'm able to provide you guys with all types of quality, you know, natural, ancestral foods even outside of meat, whether it's grains, fruits, vegetables, who knows? So that's definitely something not too far off the horizon. You guys can also check out Frankie's Naturals for minimal ingredients, minimally processed hygiene and cosmetic products. If you guys do want to reach out to me for one-on-one consultations, you can send me an email frankatufano at gmail.com. Thanks again for joining me guys and enjoy the rest of your day. We are doing a Halloween live stream later. That's why I'm not wearing my costume yet. So definitely tune in around seven to eight o'clock Eastern time.