Hmm, so we're coming to the end of the day if You are leaving early. Please note that there's this feedback section. Please vote in these polls I guess these are all multiple answers, so Vote for any statement that you agree with and this is very important to us, so We know without a doubt we have material here and we haven't gone through it top to bottom like a lectures or slides or something like that and Well, that's sort of Well a strategic trade-off we've made because you can read the documentation as well as we can I Think it would be nice if we had more demos or exercises But like Seimo was saying there's sort of a lot to do before we can really get there There's a lot of boring things to say before we get to the interesting stuff so Tomorrow there'll be a lot of stuff to do a hands-on, so Don't worry mmm It doesn't really good feedback on that On the hack and be like it's really good that you added there because like in the polls I was talking to Richard that like this kind of a lecture It might be a bit disorganized because we are jumping between the her come the and the material and stuff like that But for us it's also really valuable because then we know how it's from your side of the Situation because for us we see it from the situation where we've accustomed ourselves to the system And it's it's sometimes really hard to see the other side of how does one see the system when you don't know any of that stuff. So put please put like Instructions there or whatever you you would require because that will help us improve the course A lot basically already in this course. There's lots of like really good feedback that we will be updating for the later later courses mm-hmm and and also I want my answer like this good Comments about like how the sites are like that stuff is different in different universities and this is kind of a like a byproduct of like this course used to be only for alto and then we wanted to make it more inclusive and have all the fcci sites with us friends in the fcci because like we want everybody to have these kinds of stuff and and also Like to share basically like what we were talking at the start of the day and it is important note that like we haven't See also seen necessarily like how this material looks from the outside perspective So it's good that you put there and stuff there so that we can work together in the fcci and we can We can like try to create documentation that is Common for all of sites but but also remember that like there's philosophical things underneath here such as like the q-system You like the interactive jobs non-interactive jobs So if you know that okay these kinds of features exist you can then look out there find detail Later on but it's important to know that okay these kinds of stuff exists because then you know how to look for it so so Even though if you had problems with the exercises Do do know that uh like later on once you start using the system in your own work You can figure out the fine detail quite quickly usually yeah it would be one of my dreams that Clusters could be more similar I mean really it's such a bad Bad for learners that every time you go somewhere else you have to learn new commands like slurm itself is pretty similar but then There's all these custom commands and procedures and so on Which I mean if you think that it's different in finland imagine when you go to other countries. It's even worse so Yeah, it's often the Xkcd situation where you have 10 standards competing standards and somebody says that okay We should have one standard for everything and then you have 11 competing standards So so it's it's very hard to usually like figure out something that works for everybody. Yeah, and that's Like but the underlying layers they are usually the same so so basically the Similar things happen in similar like different places. So you should be like the knowledge transfer is is quite easy Once you learn it one in one place yeah and um Yeah, like I think that in this kind of thing I mean we don't expect you to know everything after this course Like I think that any given course of this length you're not going to be able to directly Go and apply it without referring to other things But I'd hope that we're able to somehow Show you what it looks like in what considerations. So you're able to Go and read the other instructions much more quickly and efficiently to answer things But yeah, yeah, yeah, but yeah, should we close off there and uh Uh, yeah Tomorrow we'll have like like today like we had We went through that there's the stuff already installed there applications might vary on different sites storage solutions might vary inside But but there's there's some storage space is on every side Every site has slur You can run interactive stuff there command arguments might vary between sites But but still like the overall thing are the same and tomorrow we'll talk about serial jobs how to monitor the jobs how to run parallel jobs how to run gpu jobs and uh those are an array jobs also So we have lots of stuff to cover still, uh, but hopefully we get it through Yeah Okay, um Well, if that's all I guess we will see you Tomorrow Yeah, I hope it's tomorrow. It is right. Yeah. Okay. Yeah Okay. Yeah, great. Thanks a lot And bye for now Please continue answering feedback stuff


But is the president being wise when it comes to his job and managing the economy? New details and what you can expect as early as next month from financial expert Melissa Armo coming up. And shock and outrage after this video captures Canadian police officers arresting a nearly 80 year old great grandpa, the small gesture that he did to support the freedom convoy that many of us do every day. And later, what is this man doing you may ask, well let's just say it's one for the record books or should we say it's among 52 of them to be exact. We'll explain all of that and more coming up right here on News On. Let's look at the reviews of the inflation. The reviews of the inflation are just the supply chains and the cut off means. We're going to get to more of what the president had to say in just a moment. Consumer price is surging more than expected over the past 12 months indicating a worsening outlook for inflation and cementing the likelihood of substantial interest rate hikes this year. The consumer price index for January, which measures the cost of dozens of everyday consumer goods that you pay for, well that rose 7.5% compared to just a year ago. This means your food prices, gas prices, even the roof over your head costs more. Way more. Joining us live now is CEO and founder of Stock Swoosh, Melissa Armo. Melissa, before I get your opinion of what you believe is causing inflation to soar, I want to show you the reasons the president is giving right now. Take a look. Let's look at the reason for the inflation. The reason for the inflation is the supply chains were cut off, meaning that the products, for example automobiles, the lack of computer chips to be able to build those automobiles so they could function, they need those computer chips that were not available. So what happens? The number of cars were reduced, the new cars reduced, it made up at one point one-third the cost of inflation because the price of automobiles were up. Melissa, what is your reaction to what the president just told NBC's Lester Holt? Nothing that he says is going to change the fact that everything has virtually gone up. And let's, before we talk about food and gas, let's look at what's happened in the housing industry just in the last two years. At some point, there's going to be a bubble. People have overpaid for many homes that they purchased and rents have gone up across the country too. And remember, that is people's number one monthly charge. That's the most expensive thing, people pay their housing. After that, you have utilities, you have food, you have gas, and the price of gas has gone up. When they say seven and a half percent inflation, I know that that isn't even the real number. How do I know? I'm a consumer. I go and I shop and I buy things. For example, it's Valentine's Day on Monday. If you want to buy strawberries, organic strawberries, in New York City, they are $9.50 for a thing of strawberries. I used to pay $3.99 a year ago. That's crazy. I mean, you've really got to love strawberries to pay almost $10 for those things. Yeah, a lot. So on top of inflation, Citibank is now forecasting that the Federal Reserve will raise interest rates by 50 basis points by next month. So in layman's terms, what does that mean for the real Americans, you know, the ones that are watching this show, not the elite? What does that mean to them? Well, if you have any type of credit, a credit card or a line of credit or anything that is tied to a variable rate, you're going to see an increase in your monthly payment. Or if you're someone that's looking to get a new loan, like an auto loan or a home, if you want to buy a home, you're going to see higher rates. What does that translate to, for example, on every 100,000, if we go up 1 percent, they're actually talking about 1 percent by July. So a half a bump in March and then another half a bump in July. So 1 percent within a four month period. That is a massive jump when we've had such low interest rates that would translate to about $60 per 100,000. For example, if you were to be buying a home and say you want to buy a $400,000 home, it would be about $240 more a month from July than compared to now. But it's really going to affect people's credit cards if they have revolving balances. All right. So we're talking about homes. We've talked about strawberries. Another major hit to our wallets right now. Energy prices, which have been a major driver of inflation for most of the year. The Labor Department reported that gas prices have skyrocketed 40 percent over the past year. Again, I don't need to tell our viewers that they know they go to the pump. Natural gas prices surged almost nearly 25 percent in electricity. Well, that is at more than 10 percent. Speaking of energy, and I want to draw your attention to the state of New York, because that is where you live right now. Energy bills for New Yorkers surged last month and in some cases almost doubled. I have to know, are you one of those New Yorkers? Well, I've got to be honest with you. I live in a one bedroom apartment. It's a large one bedroom. But my average electricity bill here is about $300 a month. That's what my parents pay to heat their entire home in Pennsylvania. So in New York City, electricity bills are always outrageous, in my opinion. But as far as what's going up, it hasn't hit me yet. But there's a backlog because I live in a building with a lot of people. So by the time the landlord bills me, it's too much behind. So I'm probably going to see those charges increase to make on March or April. But it is a racket in New York because you really don't have any other choices. You are stuck with one one provider, and that's it.  And unfortunately, we pay outrageous electricity bills here, particularly in the summer, when we're using mostly for the air conditioning. So I think it's going to hit people come to summer months a lot in New York City. Real quickly, speaking of New York, New York, as you know, just lifted its indoor mask mandate this week, citing science. But that doesn't change children who are in schools and their parents either. We're going to be. Oh, time to look at this. Look at this. What are you doing? What are you doing? What are you doing? So what you just saw there was a father from upstate New York being forcibly tossed from a school board meeting this week after he refused to wear a mask. I want to get your reaction to that. And also another story involving schoolchildren at a play kind of reminiscent of an 80s song. Can we play that song real quickly? Because your friends don't dance and if they don't dance for the no friends of mine. OK, it's got a good beat, but this one may hit a sour note with some of our viewers. We're going to get you to weigh in on that when we return. So please stick around, Melissa Armo, joining us for our panel next. Also still ahead on this edition of News On. They say a picture is worth a thousand words. What new satellite images may say about Russia's intentions to invade Ukraine?


So recently I saw a Christmas tree that Wexter just designed for filamentum. So I tossed some colors into Neo and we got the print going. I just wanna jump in and say Merry Christmas everybody from my family to yours. I hope you have a great holiday season and a great new year. Thank you all so much for watching the channel, tuning in, hitting that like button, the subscribe, everything. We have a lot of fun stuff coming up in 2023 and I can't wait to show you what's ahead for the channel. Merry Christmas and have a great day. Oh, I'm done. I'm done. Wexter really did an amazing job on this Christmas tree. Let me know what you guys wanna see printed next and don't forget to follow and subscribe for more.


Hello and welcome to another video. The last time I came out to celebrate spring with some wild garlic a few days later I was pissing on me on tent pegs to get them out at ground so we're taking this with a pinch of salt but the sunshine in spring is definitely in the air take two so I've come out to collect some wild garlic and my plan is to make wild garlic scotch eggs. Come on here we are wow the smell is lovely right I only really want some of the little the smaller leaves and I don't want too many depending on the size of your eggs you want to boil them for about six and a half to seven minutes for a soft centre and around eight minutes to be fully cooked through once your timer's up get them in some cold water and that'll stop the cooking process fold your wild garlic up into a little bowl and then get it shredded add the wild garlic to your sausage meat you can use any sausages take the skin off and use that or you can buy sausage meat straight from the shop and it's already seasoned so just choose which seasonings you'd like or you can add stuff to it chilies cheese whatever you want get creative cut yourself a piece of cling film put a little bit of oil on there so the sausage meat doesn't stick flatten your sausage meat into a round add the egg and then use the cling film to roll it back up once the eggs fully covered in the sausage meat we're going to dip it in our beaten egg and our breadcrumb mixture use one hand for the wet and one hand for the dry to save you making a mess and repeat the process again if you want it extra crispy you can use any cooking oil to deep fry it I chose to use duck fat for that extra flavour get your oil up to about 180 degrees or until a cube of bread turns brown within about a minute cooking for six minutes until they turn a golden brown so I was aiming for the egg to be fully cooked but the centre of the yolk to be nice and gooey and that is exactly what I got y rigade I ate that warm scotch egg with salad and new potatoes and it was delicious for the other two I thought I'd go somewhere a little bit wilder and there we are looking what better place to enjoy a home made wild garlic scotch egg than by the sea I've got the wig one I'm out on a wild camp and I've got this delightful you can smell the wild garlic in there oh wow perfectly garlicky the egg is ever so slightly soft in the middle it's perfect I did put this put this recipe on instagram and a few people saying that seven minutes was too long it's like six and a half seven minutes depending on the size of your egg but it's not too long I'm not making soft boiled eggs I'm making a scotch egg so I want all the outside and the white and everything to be tough and then the yolk just to be sort of unctuous is the right word stunning man I made three of these thankfully I'd want to own when they were crispy and brought the other two out with me to enjoy I'm going to get myself a sunset and I'm out on a wild camp look so worth a try get yourself out slack hand full of wild garlic knock yourself up a scotch egg if you want to tag me on instagram or just send me a picture of it that'd be cool I'd like to have a look what you up to stick a bit of black pudding in it a bit of cheese in it do whatever you want but just use wild garlic as the herb beautiful way to use it right thanks for watching take care of yourselves and I'll see you soon bye for now


Welcome everyone to this meeting of the Australian Sensitive Data Interest Group. So this is an interest group that meets approximately monthly to talk about all things sensitive data. This group is co-facilitated by ARDC, the Australian Data Archive, PHRN and the Melbourne Data Analytics Platform. I'd like to begin by acknowledging and celebrating the first Australians on whose traditional lands we're meeting today. For me that's the Wajatmanga people here in Perth and pay my respect to Elders past, present and emerging. So just a note, as you would have heard, this meeting will be recorded and we do like to share these meetings on an ARDC YouTube channel. If this just means that if your camera's on or your mic's on, you may become part of that recording. If you want to avoid that then just switch those things off and if you have questions you'd like to ask at the end but you don't want to be recorded then you can just put them into the chat and I can present them to our speaker and in fact as we go through the presentation if you could enter questions in the chat or save them for the end that would be great. Okay so a few things to do today. We have a few new co-chairs for this interest group coming into 2023. So Felicity Flack from PHRN and Alex Mihailovic from MDAAP who I didn't put there but brilliant. So thank you very much to both of you for joining and opening up our network of interesting presenters who we can bring along to these sessions. I'd like to remind you that we have a mailing list for this interest group. You can sign up, I'll in a second I'll pop a link into the chat with the how to sign up to that but so we use that mailing list to let you know about meetings to coming up but you can also use that mailing list. So if you have something, some news you'd like to share that sensitive data related or a question for the community you're actually able to post back to that mailing list so any of you who haven't used that feature before you're very welcome to. The other thing is that we have a collaborative notes document. We can take notes into that document today as we listen to the presentation. It's especially useful if often people will share useful resources in the chat we'll pop them into there but I've also added at the top a section for suggestions for future meeting topics. So if anything occurs to you either that you'd like to hear about or you hear about something really interesting and you're like yes they should be presenting at Osdig then you can put that there so I will pop a link to that into the chat as well in just a moment. So that's all of my nonsense out of the way. I'm really happy to introduce today's presenters. I think that so governance within one jurisdiction can be tricky enough. This project has been doing the very important and challenging work of trying to sort out governance across many different jurisdictions and I think that for that reason alone it's a really it's going to be a really interesting talk but I also love to hear about sensitive data from ecology. I always find it really interesting. So without any further ado I'd love to introduce Cam and Tanya to talk about the restricted access species data project. So I'd like to start by acknowledging the traditional owners of the land which we're speaking from which is the Nunguul people and acknowledge their elders past present and emerging. As a bit of context for this project and I'll be talking about what comprises sensitive species data and the background of the project before Tanya then talks about some of the some of the solutions were in the process of developing but I suppose it's a way of kicking off. Sensitive data has been a long-term issue in biodiversity data. In fact it probably appeared just about the same time as everybody actually was starting to compile species data sets. Now can I just pause and can everybody now see the slides? Yep we can see it now thank you. Yeah it's good thank you. So yeah as I was saying sensitive species data and biodiversity data have kind of been issues since the first emergence of biodiversity data sets. So it's not only a national problem it's an international problem and it's probably on an ongoing basis one of the single biggest impediments to being able to undertake landscape level analysis of biodiversity data. So this project was proposed as an ARDC funded project with in-kind contributions from 16 partners including all the government jurisdictions in Australia as well as the Western Australian Biodiversity Science Institute, the Atlas of Living Australia and Eco Commons. The project has kind of evolved a bit over the life of the project. Originally it was aimed at developing a national framework, a data repository and then a demonstrator of a secure data haven but over time that's evolved into while we've continued to persevere with the framework the data repository has merged more with the concept of a sensitive species data servers which we'll be talking about a bit later and while the demonstrator and the demonstrator of a secure haven for data analysis has also really continued to evolve over time. Our conversational pretty much be focused on the framework and the data service. In our space there's a key dependency in so far as the Department of Climate Change Energy Environment and Water is currently developing a thing called the Biodiversity Data Repository which will be a shared view of the biodiversity data held by all jurisdictions in Australia that's used for decision-making with regards to environmental assessments. That project is independent with our project because really sorting out issues around sensitive species data services is an important element of being able to build a sensible biodiversity data repository and it's also key to our workplace being the Atlas of Living Australia which is the largest public display of biodiversity data in Australia. So just kind of reprise what restricted access species data is and just to kind of kick off by sort of talking about terminology, conventionally in the biodiversity data space people talk about sensitive species data that becomes very problematic and it was discussed at length at an early stage in the project because the use of sensitive tends to get very rapidly conflated with official government security classification statuses. So one of the elements of the framework has been to try to disentangle what constitutes true I suppose classified data from data that is sensitive or restricted for a range of departmental or operational reasons but the project was also originally focused on species-related data categories which I'll talk a bit more about in a moment and it was very clear at an early stage in the project that while the core was sensitive species data per se there were a range of behaviors around types of data that meant what was actually impeding data access was a larger group of issues they include personal identifiable information, indigenous data, usage restricted categories so things like third-party data licenses, data embargoes and the like and then lastly what would more traditionally be called sensitive species data so basically data that either from a conservation or similar basis you wish to impede access to information about the species either the identification of the species or where the species occur or some attributes associated with those records. So what is the difference between most people tend to conflate the concept of threatened species and sensitive species and what's the difference? So a threatened species of those species listed by legislation or recognized by programs such as the IUCN red list most species even if not seen are widely distributed enough, populist enough or simply so hard to find that regardless of whether or not they are actually listed threatened species they're more at risk from major threatening processes, climate change, land clearing, other human perturbations, pest species and this includes rare species who might have a wide distribution range but a very inconsistent occurrence within that distribution range or whose presence in the landscape are basically that difficult to predict or that difficult to find there's no actual risk knowing where those species occur. Sensitive species however are rare or even common species whose appearance, value, habits or rarity make their location information high risk if shared in the public sector. So the classic example would be parrots that are valuable to a wildlife trade that can also include things like frogs, species that whose occurrences can be affected by threatening processes such as the spread of fungus in the case of one of the frog pictures there or simply just species that have a particular stage in their life cycle that makes them highly sensitive if their locations are known. Most jurisdictions and some third party data holders like Birdlife Australia maintain sensitive list species lists and so the purpose of the framework was to really deal with the sensitive species or as we're now intending to call them restricted access species but also come up with the framework managing these things by also managing the other data issues that I talked about in the previous slides. Next slide please. So just to clarify that some threatened species are listed certain species are sensitive species some are not and some sensitive species aren't listed as threatened but there's overlap that they're not necessarily the same. Good point. That's all right. So a key part of the project has been the development of the restricted access species data framework which is intended to be a non-legally binding document. It will outline consistent best practice guidance for sharing restricted access species data between trusted parties and try to provide a nationally consistent method for modifying restricted access data for public release. And just to kind of flesh out that a bit what one of the the recurrent issues that we have with regards to this type of data is that a very common means of withholding the data is to fuscate the data by randomizing it or generalizing it the latitude and longitude. Because of the increasing prevalence of aggregated data sets in the biodiversity space one of the commonest issues is you can get potentially get the same record from four different sources into an aggregated data set and legitimately end up with four different points because it's been fuscated in four different ways and the metadata has not been adequate for one reason or another to actually track that change. So trying to develop a nationally consistent approach is partly about where the data is made public making sure that the data being made public is consistent enough that people can recognize commonly fuscated points. The framework is comprised of principles and guidance on managing and sharing different types of RASD. So basically principles about how the data should be shared or fuscated or modified provide consistency on how the data should be transformed. It proposes a common approach to how requests for restricted access data are handled and also suggest clauses for legal agreements and another big focus of the framework is suggesting that negotiated legal agreements are generally preferable to standard clause data license agreements in terms of adding more legal protection for both the data provider and the the data requester. So where's the framework up to? We're up to draft 15. In fact we're hoping to actually have a final version ready by the end of this week. The next project working group meeting is tomorrow. The framework's undergone a fair audit and it's also been broadened to include the care principles about Indigenous data sovereignty. The drafts have been reviewed by all jurisdictions and have also been put out to third party comment twice now. The DECWA, the Commonwealth Department, has been briefed monthly as have the state territory jurisdictions. As I've already mentioned we have undertaken broader public consultation and while we started with a signatory type document we moved towards a statement of principles which most parties were happier with. So basically we would anticipate publicly releasing the framework towards the end of this month all other things being equal and I'm now going to hand over to Tanya to talk a bit about the data service. So the data service is currently in development where it will be a simple request management system that basically funnels data requests to data custodian. Not everybody who adopts the principles in the framework necessarily have to use the data service at its voluntary and its opt-in. What it does is track requests for restricted active species data so that both the requester and the data custodians know where they request it up to at any point in time. It includes an approval process and a release just tracking the release of data. It doesn't transfer or aggregate or hold data. So it's a simple request management system. We are going to enable on DOIs to be minted for each data set that's released to a data requester so that the data custodians can track those DOIs and use them for reporting purposes to track usage and different elements of the data sharing. And then it also will include functionality for if a request staff puts in the inappropriate request or breaches data. The legal agreement conditions and other custodians can be alerted to that and take that into consideration once they when they get extra requests from those the same data request. And I'd probably also add that the reason for taking this approach early in the process as I mentioned we were looking at an aggregated data set or using the BDR as the aggregated data source to deal with some of these issues. It became very clear as we evolve the framework and the concept of a aggregated data set that that that was problematic for a lot of data custodians. And we did an international review of how these things work elsewhere, the answer to which is pretty much as ineffectively as we do it in Australia. However, the Finnish biodiversity information facility actually developed, as far as we can tell, the only functioning data service in the world, which it was a very simple approach, a la what Tanya has just outlined, where the participants in the data service all retain data sovereignty and retain the ability to transform and release data themselves. But what is effectively being developed is a front end that makes it easier for data requesters to be able to go out to most data custodians within a national context. And that was certainly the feedback that we've had from third parties was that the data service was a much needed mechanism to make it easier for organisations and individuals to identify where data sets exist nationally. And for some of these species we're talking about 14 or 15 primary data sets. So it can be very difficult to disentangle and identify where those data sets sit in Australia. So part of the service will also include a metadata catalogue. So a catalogue in one place that is listable, the data sets that include restricted access species data that's searchable, so that a data request that can identify which data sets potentially might include information or data that they're interested in for one purpose or another. And then they can register and put in a request. And then that request is then, if it covers multiple data sets from multiple custodians, it'll field those requests, that request to each of the individual data custodians. And it will also track the negotiation and development of the data licence through the legal agreements between the data requester and the data custodian. So as Pam said, we did a review of international precedent. The only similar model for restricted access species data or sensitive species data was the finished biodiversity information facilities one. We reviewed similar projects in the health and biology space and also had some detailed conversations with Data Place that's being developed by the Office of the National Data Commissioner. There is overlap, but we didn't quite meet our needs and nor time frames of our project. So as we went through a procurement process through what used to be called Digital Marketplace, what's called MyRT or something now, we received six applications to develop the service and we've now on boarded our preferred vendor and development is underway. They've been on board for three weeks. It's a pretty ambitious timeline. We are scheduled to deliver the data service by the end of April with you. So another aspect of the project that's evolved over time, we've spoken a bit in the presentation about sensitive species lists or restricted access species lists. Because each jurisdiction in Australia maintains a list, it's going to be relatively important nationally for users to be able to discover what species are actually on which lists and what the level of fascination is that's being applied to those species. So over the life of the project, we've also been trying to develop a single national list of restricted access species that third-party data custodians can apply to their data again for this idea of national consistency in the way things are dealt with. That's arisen a number of issues. There are fair issues because not all lists are publicly available. There are vocabulary issues. In particular, the taxonomy of species names varies between jurisdictions quite markedly. And there are methodological issues because the processes for identifying species and a fascination isn't really consistent. I can't remember if there's another split. So really, that's involved a lot of meetings. So what we've been trying to do is reduce the level of conflict in existing lists, so particularly where species are listed in more than one jurisdiction, trying to land some commonality of how species should be dealt with, which is frankly still ongoing. But probably the biggest take-home message that we've had is to really try to engineer both the framework and the amalgamated species list or the national restricted access species list in a way that avoids interfering with existing regulations and procedures. Effectively, the approach we've taken with the RASL has been to enable jurisdictions to continue to use their existing processes and species lists, try to define taxonomy nationally for third-party users, make the combined list publicly available and get agreement that jurisdictions will have an agreed process for new species. So basically trying to avoid any sort of conflict with effectively what are eight quite different processes. And so that's it. We'd like to thank our colleagues in the project and technical working group that are involved with the project because this has involved a lot of input from many people around Australia, and at least a few of them are on the call today. And also ARDC and ALA as well as the Department of Education for funding the project. Thanks for listening everyone. Thanks Bo. So we do have a couple of questions in the chat already and I'd encourage the audience to add some more there. But there were quite a few people who were interested in your processes around DOIs. So the first question sorry is the DOI on the data before the request or on a specific request for the data? So I think that they're asking so is there's all the data received at DOI and that DOI is then shared, you know, or used when a request is made? Do I get applied once a request is made? So DOIs will come, will be assigned to divisional data sets and often they already have identify the sign to them already. So we'll just reuse those. What will happen when someone puts in a request? A DOI will be admitted for that request and then it will include information around the parameters included in the request. So it might be for a particular species in a particular location. It may cover several data sets. It will give you it will report on which data sets were the request was used that were that the request was derived from and and who and when it'll it'll include some kind of information as well. Okay thank you so I think that answers the next question which is how would the data services integrate with existing data repositories like those at academic institutions that already meet DOIs or have options to create a process. But then final question because you did that. Do you still have anything to follow up on that point? Yeah thanks. Hi Tanya, hi Cam. Yeah so I mean that's a interesting approach. I'm just trying to understand it a little bit about why you do it that way. So you said that if a data set already has a DOI then that would just be associated with the request and use. But you said in some cases it might be a new DOI meant that it is the released data set. Now I assume that that's not a duplication thing but that maybe is the data set being released. It's a subset of a larger data set or it's an amalgamation of multiple data sets. Yeah okay all right that's that's helpful. So then a related question is how are you, it's not my area but I've got a colleague who's very much into data provenance and tracking you know if a data set in DOI is assigned you know around the collection point and then is kind of amalgamated with other data sets or subsets used exactly as you described how do you track the you know your DOI here that's being used for this particular project relates back to you know the the original DOI? The DOI will that's attached to the data set the requested data set will include the source data set in the in the DOI metadata and it will include that DOI. So all the data data sets DOIs will be included in that. To enable someone who comes later that they can actually recreate that request if need be because we can't attach the data necessarily to the DOI because it's always restricted access. Okay thank you. So do those DOIs they resolve to a record within your service? Yeah we'll be using data set. Awesome. So another question. RIS is obviously SLEE-C based so how does that handle end-range of communities? Good question. So noting the I suppose the the temporal and funding limitations of the project we had to basically identify what was in and out of scope of the project so the two areas that were identified for things that would have to be a next step but not dealt within the project were it became very and kind of drift off sideways and then come back to actually answer the question it became very clear during the project that there was quite a substantial proportion of restricted access species data that was effectively restricted for cultural reasons. So what we've done is kind of put I suppose holding statements in the framework for dealing with those issues and then recognise what actually needs to happen is a separate process that actually looks at the cultural issues around this type of restricted data. The other the other big issue that was quite quickly identified was non-observational data aka ecosystems, communities and the we basically identified it as out of scope simply because it was too complicated to deal within the confines of the project. We needed to basically sort out what was happening on a species record by species record basis before any consideration could be given to ecological communities noting that some of the issues with ecological communities actually overlap complex survey data where you've effectively got the same basic issue where which is if a sensitive species or restricted access species forms part of the community the vegetation community identification or indeed is one of the the species observed at a information ridge plot site in both cases you're going to have problems withholding the record because it affects the functionality of the data but that that will be the next problem to solve once we finish this project unfortunately. So and the other difference is that the framework predominantly deals with point data whereas indigenous ecological communities and usually polygon data and as far as I know at least from the commonwealth commonwealth perspective I managed a section that is that data may release it publicly anyway because there's less risk some of the factors including targeting specific species are less the risk risks associated with that are much lower than not releasing that data publicly for example land clearing can wipe out a whole community no one knows there for example so for a risk-based approach releasing data publicly at least from I can only speak from the commonwealth's perspective if you want want to talk from the state perspective but as far as I'm aware most jurisdictions release that community data publicly anyway. Yeah I think you're asking me in New South Wales we don't have an issue with releasing that sort of data but I think I raised this before that there is the possibility you can treat polygons using the same sort of algorithms that we do for points so that you end up with sort of a grid representation of a polygon which would be all flascated in a similar way but it's not it's not impossible. Will the list of all restricted access spaces be available at the stern or the ALA in machine radar form? Each of the jurisdictions have different maturity levels with respect to how they they store and share species data so we're not interfering with any of those processes. Restricted access species data won't essentially the services host it's going to be hosted at least initially by the ALA but it's not it's separate to the ALA in terms of what we don't necessarily own and it's a it was a collaboration between all the jurisdictions and really the like I said we're not transferring data we're relying on the existing processes that or storing data we're relying on the existing processes that each of the jurisdictions have in place to do that this is merely a request tracking service. And yeah I suppose with particular respect to the amalgamated list potentially but I don't think we're mature enough in our conversations but with all the project working group partners to really confidently say that it would be available externally but that's the intention to move in that direction. Will the license agreements and legal clauses be in the release information that's due to come out in the next few months so that others can see these documents without a data request or is it specific to a data request? So there's in the framework will include does include suggested legal clauses the specific license agreements for each request will be treated as sensitive information and not released publicly. So yeah there is suggested clauses and again each jurisdictions have their own legal departments and they might be slightly tweaked. We've only put suggestions in there and we've had feedback from some NGO data providers such as Birdlife Australia that because they don't they're only a small operation and they don't have a big legal department or none at all they're really happy to have something like that to use to create their own license agreements. Thanks Tanya yeah a related question and you did mention it in your talk about the data service I just missed the detail so you said the data service is a simple request management system but you did say something about whether it be kind of storing the completed agreements or not can you can you remind me what that was I just didn't hear it. Yeah at the moment it will be tracking the negotiation stages of that agreement and then it will also say it's finalised and it will store a document ID only at the moment we're not going to be storing the actual physically physical agreements because we're using an external a different service to do the signature process for the agreements and that'll be stored in that and there'll be links to that in the data custodian and requests that can download that those documents the final final documents. So if I can ask a supplementary question to that does that mean then that your group is kind of one of the parties involved in the execution of the agreement or named in the agreement or has a kind of assigned responsibility for management like overseeing those documents or are you just kind of you're getting a tracking number that kind of allows people using your service to keep everything recorded. Okay thank you. I'm only going to do slightly manual processes and they'll send me the agreement and I'll send it to the signing service and offer code. I'm not yeah I'm not helping drafting or anything like that or even tracking. And you're not not responsible for the management of the document you just kind of offer a technology service there. Thank you. Let's see when I ask about the data set themselves what will the data sets be would you just a current stash or a monitoring data etc and what is the first process for identifying and apologies if I messed this up a chance. It'll probably it's a mix of it'll be a mix of survey systematic survey and internal observation data and museum collection data eventually. It's basically it's really the data sets that the that each of the data custodians sign up to the service have available so it would be the same as approaching New South Wales or WA environment departments and asking them access to via net or or or any of the other state data sets are approaching the museums in her area via the AVH or OSCAM. They're just the similar sorts of amalgamated data sets that exist in the ALA. It's just that because you're going directly to the the data custodians some of the limitations that do exist in ALA data such as as complex data being simplified to meet Darwin core principles may not necessarily be an issue. And one last question at the moment if I am managing a specimen collection how easy will it be for me to confirm if there are restricted access conditions in relation to a particular species that I'm working with or considering loading out? So there's a two part answer to that question. You can actually do that currently albeit with with a slight error margin attached. You can actually load a species list into the ALA. The ALA has all of the the current sensitive species lists in Australia loaded into it. I do have some reservations about saying that because there is a slight error margin associated with it. If the if the process that we're currently embarked on is completed then the idea would be that there would be a publicly amalgamated version of the list with the obfuscations required in each state and territory. And we've also been in conversations with a few of the third party data set providers such as Birdlife Australia who do have their own sensitivity list about how they might be able to contribute to the process as well. Thanks. So I'm not seeing any more questions in the chat at the moment but to be honest I'm really curious about just what the process was for managing coming to cross jurisdictional agreement at this scale across Australia and whether there are any particular challenges that you had in trying to create that level of alignment? Look I think it was a very collegiate process. I think it was made slightly easier in our space because it's universally recognised that there's an issue. I think the key to agreement though when we started the project most project working group partners were keen to have something akin to a signed document either a non-binding legal agreement or a legal agreement. It became abundantly clear as the process went on that that was just not in any way shape or form ever going to be achieved. There's just too many variances in approaches and process to make that achievable within a short timeline. I think the single biggest learning that we would have would be recognising from the start that the best approach was the sort of principle-based approach where organisations can voluntarily indicate compliance with rather than trying to get signatories to a document would have I think probably cut the time required by about two-thirds. And frankly I don't think a binding legal agreement had we continued down that track would have been achievable ever. Nor do we have the government's body to have oversight of that. Yeah actually that's a really good point Tanya because the other thing is particularly under the terms of our funding we need to develop sustainable management of the framework and process that would not have been achievable with the legal agreement because we would have had to establish a recognised entity that could actually manage this to the satisfaction of all jurisdictions in Australia which was similarly almost impossible now that if you went back 20 years ago the environmental resources information network within the Commonwealth often coordinated those kinds of activities but these days that kind of national coordination is very difficult to establish or get approval for. So again going down the principles-based approach has proved to be the key to success I think. Thank you I think that's some really valuable observation. So one last call out to the audience or to my co-chairs if anyone has any last burning questions that that might be everything then. Well yeah I'd just like to thank you both so much for sharing your experiences. I'm really looking forward to seeing the framework. So yeah you said fairly shortly that'll be coming out. How can people in the audience who are interested how can they keep track of what's going on and be informed when that comes out? We can probably just pick a copy that can be circulated once we've finally got everybody to pull out their teeth and reticently confirm that they're all relatively happy or at least not unhappy with it. Well then maybe I can when that's available if you let me know I can share it on our interest group mailing list I think that might be a good way and I'm sure we'll also be promoting it through our ARDC channels as well. I hope to have a website or a web page up in the coming weeks which will include some FAQs and sort of a bit more about the project as well. Maybe when that goes live we can link from today's meeting notes there so that anyone who's interested from today can find out as well and I'll be making this recording available as soon as I can and also I know that there were a few people who said they couldn't be here today but were really excited to hear about it. Brilliant, well then thank you both for coming and thank you everyone for attending today and all your questions and a great meeting.


Felly, amser i chi i gael i gyd yn ymwneud efo'r iawn i'w gweithio'r ffwrdd yng ngyfyrdd. A ydych chi'n 16 mewn gweithio'r gweithio, Ronald Cooman'r 10 o'r ffwrdd yn ddod. Ond David Onsworth yn ystod yn ymddangos cyrtymu'r cyfrifol. I'm absolutely delighted that the gaffer has joined us, fresh from a very, very encouraging display against Chelsea and the Carabao Cup that ultimately ended in a narrow defeat, Dave, but the performance must have pleased you as much as it pleased the punters. Absolutely, the performance was fantastic. I'm not happy that we lost the game at all. I'd never be happy losing any game at any level, alone in our first team, so yeah, disappointed to lose the game but so many encouraging signs, positivity, so much to work with. And all credit to that is it goes to the players taking on board the things we worked on on the training ground and what we spoke about in a couple of the meetings. So they took to it straight away. I was delighted with that. I was delighted with the way they stuck to our game plan and it was a really encouraging start. Plenty of reasons to be cheerful, Graham. Yeah, it was. Listen, it's a difficult time, you know, but as Dave just said there on the training ground, you know, you'd be looking for a spark. You know, sometimes it happens, you know, when a new manager comes in, new ideas, the players look forward to it. I think certainly second half when you listen, we all knew going down to Chelsea was a tough, tough ask. I'm a tear of what team they put out, but I think going down, I think we saw more in the game than we've seen in a long time, you know, and that's no disrespect to the previous manager, but I just thought there was more of a more energy, more passion, more drive, you know, to score goals. More than a couple of chances. So I think there was a lot of positives, second half especially. You know, it's never nice losing goals, but I think the reaction from the players, second half especially when they had chance after chance, you know, I think that stands as well for the future. When did you get the call, Dave, from the chairman? Chairman just walked into my office just after lunch on, was it Monday? Was it Monday? It's been a long week. I don't even know what day it is. And I was sort of taking her back a little bit. I said, hello chairman, you okay? So we had the afternoon together, spoke about everything, Everton, as you would expect. And, you know, we sat with Robert as well and discussed what we were going to do and how I was going to do it. And we went from there. Obviously, it's never, it's never an easy time. Doesn't matter at what level, at what club. It's always difficult when somebody loses a job. You never want to see that because, you know, that the team has struggled for everybody who loves this club. You know, we all want to see us succeed and win games and win trophies and that's what we're all about. So a disappointing end to another manager's tenure. But, you know, I'm very proud to have been asked by the chairman and Farhad and the board to take the reins. So it's a very proud moment for me. How did the players respond to your first training session, for example? I thought they were brilliant. Steve Walsh and I spoke to them in the morning. Steve spoke to them first and then I wanted to speak to them on my own. So, you know, I wouldn't repeat what I said to them because that's between myself and the players. But we went on the pitch and they were superb. They were lively. They were bright. They took on board information quickly. We worked on a few things and they certainly responded to that. And, you know, thankfully, they took it into the game. And we were unfortunate because, second half, I thought we dominated the game and should have come away with a victory. One player who certainly responded was Benny Benengami. We'll speak to both of you about Benny Benengami shortly, but let's hear from the young man himself who thoroughly enjoyed his senior debut at Chelsea. I mean, I've got to thank Unzi. He's had the confidence in me since day one.  So I'd like to thank him and John Ebone and all the staff.  Yeah, definitely. I was nervous for Unzi before. He was like, you know what, you're ready. You've been at my 23s level long enough and you're ready. So that gives you confidence. I mean, I was nervous for the game. But when you get on that pitch, all the nerves just went away. Was there any major difference from playing under 23-foot water being out there one specific thing maybe that you thought, wow? To be experienced, I mean, sometimes I've probably taken too long on the ball. Sometimes I got caught on it and I thought, like, I should probably play the first time, which, you know, you always learn, don't you?  I was just thinking, you know what, I'm playing here. That's how it's like, that's the confidence that I have and that's the confidence that Unzi gave me. Being a big week for the family as well, hasn't your brother made his debut for Wigan as well last night, didn't he? He made his debut last night, only 17. It's a great moment for our family and it's just mad where we've been. It's like to thank my dad for taking me training on my mum, you know, all the sports. My brother Charlie and my sister Karen, you know, honestly, it's great. I'm so proud. Sharpie, that young man can be extremely proud of himself. He can, Dan.  But listen, in those circumstances, you can sink or swim, you know, and the boy certainly swam. You know, I thought he was outstanding.   We all talk about the tackle, all the evertonians who went, we probably wake up this morning and say they made the top of the game, like, oh, we're unlucky, but I like a boy, Benny Beningo, I was exactly made and everything else. So right away, he's had a positive impact on not only the team, but the supporters as well. So he can be very proud of himself. You never had any doubts about the boy? No, no, none at all. Ability-wise is there, physicality is there, temperament's there. Which is key, isn't it, the temperament? Absolutely, age is but a number, doesn't matter what age you are. If you're ready, you're ready, and he's certainly ready, you just need an opportunity. Like, you know, like I did, like Graham did, and like we all do, we all need an opportunity.  And these young players have never let us down, and from my experience, never will, because they're great lads with great temperaments who love the club and who will give you absolutely everything they've got. Okay, they might, you know, they might not influence the game as much as a senior player will do, but he did. And he was smashing them delight for him as well, he's a great kid. And to balance that, you need a bit of experience as well, and Dave brought back, your Kevin Morales, your Anna Lennon, your James McCarthy's, and they did well too. Yeah, you do it. You listen, for young players come into a team, you know, and it's a difficult time as well where they run the team they're on. You know, it's a difficult time to put youngsters in. You know, but I thought he did really well, but as you said, the older players as well. You know, they've got a point to prove. You know, some may have fallen out with the previous regime, you don't know, but they now got an opportunity. I'm sure David would have said, listen, clean slate here now. You start from now. You know, we've got a reaction there as well. Listen, we all know that they're quality players as well. Now it's up to them to force themselves into Dave's reckoning and try and get a start in place. But certainly you could see second half, you know, the reaction there, you know, you could see there was a reaction, as David said, his first training session.  You can see, OK, I'm sure we've got it going in the right way now. We've got the right reaction that they wanted, and they got that the second half. The second half, especially, I thought, as David said, you could have won the game. They had the opportunities. Young Lukman came on at the crossbar, had another opportunity. That's something we haven't seen for a long, long time. I think the disappointing thing for Evertonians were coming away from matches thinking, we're never going to score here, we're never going to win a game. But I thought the seeds were there last night. They said, OK, and that was in both a mix of youngsters and experienced players. Talk about Benny Benningamy not having any pre-match nerves. What about the gaffer? No, I was thoroughly looking forward to the game. I loved it. I absolutely loved it. Did you get the opportunity to speak to Antonio Conte? I did. I had to say he was a touch of class. When I never go out for the warm-up, I always let the staff and the coaches take the warm-up. I think when the manager speaks, you listen and I think you can speak too much sometimes as a manager. I never go out for the warm-up. I was sat in the changing rooms and I was reading the programme I was talking to one of the lads. There was a knock on the door and he was one of the Chelsea stewards. The Chelsea manager would like to speak to you. So I went to speak to him and I have to say he was absolutely class. Telling me a few things about Chelsea and about himself. He wished me all the best and good luck. I thought, you know what? That's a touch of class. He seems a really nice guy and he's certainly got a very good football team there. How nice is that to him? That's brilliant. Football is an amazing industry. It's an amazing industry where the friendships you build up over the years and everything else. Even now, people used to kick lumps out of you. If you met them at a function, they can right over it and talk to you and all that. Mick Harfer is a prime example. Mick was on the phone to me the other day. You can tell Mick. Thanks for that. Mick was a prime example. We used to fight like cat and dog with two teams. He's phoned me now and asked me for certain things. It's an amazing industry to be in. That's a touch of class. I think most managers down the years have been good. Obviously they're old one or two, but that was a touch of class. That's a lovely story. That's just about it for part one of this week's Everton show. Don't go too far away because after the break in the company of Dave Unsworth and Graeme Sharp, we look ahead to the Premier League visitor Leicester City at the weekend. Welcome back to part two of this week's Everton show. I'm in the company of David Unsworth and Graeme Sharp. The end of season awards back in May, Roy Vernon was inducted into our Hall of Fame. He was the latest Everton giant and this is why. Sharpie, when we talk about the great number nine at Everton Football Club, Roy Vernon often gets overlooked, but he was the captain when we won the league in 63 and he was clearly a class centre forward. Wonderful centre forward. Obviously he talked to people now who obviously saw him play. I was unfortunate he didn't see him play, but they would regale you the stories about how really good he was. He was one of the ones when I first came down, you know, when he said, oh, you'll never be as good as Lachford, Royal, Dean, Vernon, Pickering, and they used to beat you with that stick, but they used to, you always made sure they knew what it was like to be an Everton number nine and what you had to follow and Roy Vernon was up there with the best. I don't know, you've got a real sense of history as well about this Football Club, Dave. Absolutely. I mean, Roy, another legend of the Football Club and I just love the stories of our number nines. It's great to talk about what's gone before and that's something special about our club and how famous our number nine shirt is and one of the best here and fantastic and it's what makes our club proud when you talk about traditional values of actually what a shirt and what a number means to Everton fans and, you know, pity the number six wasn't the same. I've seen you before, Dave. You really enjoy the company of former players, don't you? Even Snods and Diamonds. Well, I wouldn't go that far, Dad. I wouldn't go that far. No, quite seriously. No, I love it. It's great. I mean, I mean Joe's company every day so I've got no option really. No, it's great. And what we do really well here is we look after our former players and we're so respectful and I see Colin Harvey on a match day and you see former players coming back and what we do is we treat them right and we treat them well and that's why every player who leaves here never falls out of love with us because we do it right and we're respectful and we appreciate what former players have done for us particularly, you know, with our legends, like World Burning and all the number lines that have gone before. Well, from the heroes of the past to one that we hope will be a hero of the future, it's time for this week's My First Feature. In the seat is John Joe Kenny. Mi Clio. I've still got that now actually, so I'm still flying around and that. I think they were Rumbro as well and I'm back at Rumbro, so not too bad. Custis was there when I was five. I played on the Scotty Rowley when I was younger, so I loved the day when I was a kid, yeah. I used to love a bike when I was a kid, so I was like, I'm going to get a bike and a five-hand to me cousins. That was my big one. Spei went in mum dad me my sister. I still love going around and going on a slide and all that was a kid, so I used to be a bit of a pain, but I loved it when I was a kid. I'm a rabbit dog. I used to love the tweenies in that when I was a kid, so I'd call my dog a mhalo. I was like, I'm sad, I don't like to be fair, so. Oh yeah, he's my dog. Ryan Lettson. He's a really unique fit. About 10 years I think. I think he played Crewe once on the Scotty and we were blind in the centre of it, so I thought my Crewe was going somewhere else then, but I thought it was back, back to the back. It was with me dad. I just thought it was a bit of a stinker, so I looked to the line, I was there, and I could see that look. I thought, I'm in trouble here. So it's probably my dad. I know he's my biggest fanboy. You know, he lets me know one of. I'm at the best of games. Another young player there, Dave, who's impressed you consistently, John Joe Kenny. Yeah, been terrific. Since I've been back at the club for the fifth season now I think. Yeah, fifth season. He's been in the under-23, he's been around the under-23, he's been under-23 captain. Been a standout performer, gone through all the age groups of England and been one of England's best players as well. So just a natural transition into a first team environment. He's been training with the first team for a period of time now. I thought last night he had a great game. We'll see a better John Joe Kenny. There's still a lot more to come from him as well. He's a terrific local lad. He's a great guy. Great in the changing room as well. He was captain for a reason. He leads from the front. He defies his years really. He's a great guy. David's elevation to the first team has given Francis Jeffers the opportunity Sharpie to run the 23s. He seems to have taken it like a duck to water. He has. I was just saying to David before an interval, looking back at Frane as a player, I would never ever thought that you would go down this path. But fair play to him. There comes a time when you've got to make a decision. You decided to go into the coaching side. Dave's raked some highly. So listen, fantastic for him. Absolutely fantastic. If he can take some of his experience and give it to the younger lads, all well and good because he was a fantastic striker. If you listen to Frane Jeffers, he's a fantastic striker. The runs he used to make as a player were brilliant. So if he can teach the lads some of what he had, you know, fantastic, fantastic. His first game was the chequetry trophy game at Lincoln City. That was always going to be a tough game because they are. But that's why we're in that competition. Yeah, we're in the competition. Obviously to win any game. But it's a great tactical and physical challenge for our players. Particularly when you're playing Land of the Giants which was the other night. So it's a great physical battle. And it's won, you know, just saying to Sharpie, the equivalent when we were young was when you played Marine Reserves or First Team or Rochdale Reserves and you used to get battered. So that's the equivalent. And I think it stands our young players in great stead for a long period, maybe in League One or League Two. And apparently second half, I've only watched an hour of the game. But for the most of the second half, we did really well and stood up to that physical challenge. Because you have to. It can all be free-flowing, pretty football from goalkeeper to scoring a goal. There's more than one way to win a game of football and certainly the lad stood up to that challenge and we're unlucky. They really did play well in the second half. We're going to start the countdown now to our Premier League visit to Leicester City at the weekend. We caught up recently with former Leicester City goalkeeper and surprisingly he said that Jamie Vardy is the fox's mental watch. He's obviously the end threat in regards to hitting the ball on the back of the net. He's probably the one that's most likely to do so. All over the pitch I think Leicester have the quality Marine Reserves is another player that stands out that he can create something from nothing. And I think that what's interesting about Leicester is how well they've performed over the course of probably two seasons now, particularly the back end of last season with the style of football that they play that everybody knows about. There's no secrets but people find it really difficult to try to contain them. That's because of the individual talents in players like Mares, the pace of Vardy and let's not forget I think people underestimate how important Shinji Okasaki is to that side. His work rate, the distance he covers in the game is phenomenal. The pressure he puts on in the opposition's backline he's constantly at their heels. He's not allowing them any time on the ball any forces mistakes time and time again. And if he doesn't force a mistake he often gets in a tackle and wins possession really high up the pitch. And that's where Leicester are really, really dangerous when they're able to win the ball when the opposition's on an attack and catch them out of ways, catch players out of position and they're so ruthless and they're so quick in that transition. Leicester City, Sharpie, like ourselves with a new man sitting in the dugout Claude Powell I thought it was a surprising appointment. Everybody obviously had his time at Southampton. I don't think he was one of those who played attacking football, you know but I think you look at his managerial record certainly in France. He took Lyon I think a little bit of success so he's got the the pedigree if you like but I'm not too sure if the Leicester City fans were too enamoured with the choice I don't know what they expected you look at the players they've got they should be doing better but I think they're a little bit surprised with their appointment. You're looking forward to it Dave? Always, always. It's another great challenge. We all know the success they had a couple of years ago and the majority of their players are still there from that great season so tough game but our players should have nothing to fear we'll concentrate on ourselves and we'll pick a team to win and we'll go there with the backing of thousands of Evertonians and hopefully we're standing in front of them and we'll go to the game all jovial and all celebrating a win so looking forward to it but nothing to fear. Certainly is a game to look forward to and by the way there are still tickets available for our next home game in the Premier League against Watford at Gooderson Park on the 5th of November. Prices start at £39 for adults, half price for juniors Visit EvertonFC.com ring the box office or the old traditional way simply call into the box office at Gooderson Park and that's it for this week's Everton show thanks enormously in a busy week to David Underworth also to Graeme Sharp do join us again in 7 days time.


Hmm We have to talk Octopath Traveler It might be the best switch game it might be the best game on the entire platform a platform I own almost 50 titles for point 50 different games on switch and this one Yes, this one might be the best of course in the middle of me editing this video Beat them ups that guy had to upload a video about how Octopath Traveler is the best switch game. I'm not copying him. I promise but damn you Damn you man All right Let's get back to my conversation of why I think that this game is the best in the series so Octopath Traveler it is a game about eight characters eight stories eight Paths as the name suggests Octopath eight paths and these characters all have their own standalone storylines in fact That's actually one of the criticisms a lot of people have for Octopath Traveler is that these are standalone Storylines there's not an overarching story that really connects all the characters at the end you you go around the map You pick them all up and then you just go on to chapter 2 and you just keep going from there until each storyline for each character is complete but see Herein lies the beauty of this approach It's never been done before that is what I really love about a lot to patch up with the the Criticism against Octopath Traveler. It's actually to me one of its greatest strengths It is not about an overarching storyline It is about these eight individual characters and their eight Individual journeys whether it's with Ophelia or Cyrus or Tressa or Albarac or Primrose like there's so many Characters in this game to care about passionately that it's hard for me to even express things in a coherent matter I don't want to spoil this game for you because it is a game truly to be experienced It is one of the few games I will say the storylines alone are enough to justify a purchase and That's what's crazy to me is because typically a story is not enough to justify a purchase for me I care about the gameplay mechanics. I care about the music. I care about the art direction and the thing is is this game actually delivers and every aspect I care about gaming in Spades now I need to note that obviously Octopath Traveler is not gonna be for everyone Do you not like turn our turn based RPGs?  Animations and and that kind of presentation style, you know, you've seen videos of it by now Okay, then this game is probably not gonna be for you and I understand that some people think the writing is terrible and That the story, you know without the storylines interconnecting none of it really matters and also I get it. That's fine But I don't care what you think because this is my video man my video about this game encompasses the whole of what Octopath Traveler means to me I grew up playing traditional turn-based RPGs like Final Fantasy and Chronal Trigger and I started to fall off as I got older because I sink literally Hundreds hundreds of hours in to turn-based RPGs in fact even just RPGs in general from the Witcher 3 to Xenoblade Chronicles 2 Some people consider Breath of the Wild an RPG. I sink lots of time into these games And so I just don't play very many of them because I don't have that kind of time But it's rare that a game comes along that makes me create the time to play it. No folks I am not hundreds of hours in the Octopath Traveler. I wish I was I don't have that kind of time But I wish I was but it is basically unless I am live streaming a different game The only game being played on my switch since its release has been Octopath Traveler I can't get enough of the story the characters the music So my my first experience on to my traveler came in the demo There was the demo last year then there was the prologue demo this year I didn't carry any of my prologue data over I started fresh with a character I'd never played in Ophelia, but before I got to that I picked up this bad boy from Best Buy and big shout outs to be righteous who Somehow was able to get me a collector's edition copy of this game on day one as a late birthday present I don't know how he pulled that off It's impossible to to get this version anywhere that it's almost impossible just to get the physical copy But reality is that the very first experience I had with the full game was the sound selection CD So the collector's edition comes to the sound selection CD I immediately put it in my CD player in my car as I was driving my kids back from You know a town that's about 20 minutes away and oh my gosh this music that it just gripped me and it would not let go Just listen for yourself. I mean this music man from the battle music to the individual character music to the towns So the traveling music to even music when you're in the shops all of it It's just it's like the best of what I grew up with combined with today's technology in today's instruments It's amazing to me that they packed this kind of soundtrack into such a unique package of a game And yes, I admittedly love the art style I know the art styles I love it or take a thing But it does it for me and what it does it for me by bringing back the classic JRPG turn-based styles of the past with like Final Fantasy 6 and Chrono trigger and then adds these extra visual elements on top from the snow drop in the background to the light shafts to The the smoke effect or even when you're in the town You're in Tressa's village and look at the water. The water is super realistic Yet somehow that realistic looking water does not feel out of place in Octopath Traveler because Octopath Traveler is a game that just sucks you in and despite being this bright based thing Makes you feel like you're part of this world like this world is real this world exists this is a world you could travel to and enjoy adventures in and That's why the blending of these different realistic effects with this 2d art style works So well because it draws you into that world and it's so rare to me that a game Actually draws me in a lot of times. I feel like I'm on the ride I mean I'm experiencing the journey of another character But in this game because of the different past and the choices I make it makes me feel like I am these eight Individual characters experiencing these eight different stories now speaking of the story themselves each Character in the game all eight of them have their own story arc and their own story arcs are different and unique From all the different ones and a lot of them are based around their background Ulburek as an example used to be a knight He was a knight that defended the king and there was another knight that did some bad things and Defeated Ulburek and Ulburek kind of went into retirement and just was protecting a little village until one day He gets out and protecting the village and defeats these bandits and it turns out these bandits are kind of sort of working for that Other night and it kind of inspires Ulburek to be like alright I I can't let that one moment in history Define me as a knight I need to get back out in the world and I need to make things right and I know that sounds like such a cliche story of times, but that's just one of eight journeys from Hanat and and trying to Get her master like her master is in danger and her master was her mentor growing up And she needs to go out in the world and save him from an adventure that he might be in danger in and then you have Ophelia Oh Ophelia. Oh Ophelia. Yes The story feels like it's straight out of frozen for a little bit and complete with snow and everything but the she's adopted and and by by this Priestess is bishop like person who has a daughter and you become like a sisters and you're trying to save your sister from herself as your as like your adopted father is going through a sickness and All you want to do is do everything you can to show your appreciation for them Picking you off the street and providing for you for 15 years of your life It's just it's this amazingly gripping story that really draws you in and each character has these great background stories that lead into the whole story now as I said The game isn't perfect There are certain caves you go in that feel like you've been in that cave two or three times before But because of the story elements in the game I ended up not carrying so much because within those caves Not only were unique enemies and unique boss fights But also unique NPCs and I found myself at least so far in the game Running through and talking to these NPCs like crazy I don't know what it is about this game's story But I can't pass an NPC without seeing what they have to say and even if it's that irrelevant NPC That's a soldier off in the corner doesn't move the entire game There are characters that have these path actions that you can find out these extra details about the background of that character That's really flesh out the world and make these characters not just feel like your everyday passable NPCs But rather real living breathing people that have a life and a story to tell and while you can't go down the path To figure out their story, you know a story is there just like people you meet in the real world You hear a little bit about them. Maybe you've eavesdropped Maybe you met them out at a club or something But reality is you don't really know them but you know a little bit about that journey and I guess social media is a good way to look at it too You might follow someone on Twitter and learn little bits about their life And it might make you want to learn more, but you're not living their life That's not your life. That's not your journey But it makes them feel like they are living breathing characters like they really exist and adds to this whole aspect of Feeling like I am part of this world this Octopath Traveler world and what's interesting to me is How they're gonna take this and move it on to an Octopath Traveler too I want this game to sell so well There's a second Octopath Traveler and and what are they gonna do that? There's gonna be eight new characters eight new journeys Or is it going to explore a more connected storyline with the current characters in there and taking them on new adventures? I'm so connected to these characters. I don't want them to vanish in a sequel But if they do I'll probably fall in love again with a whole set of another eight characters Or maybe they're gonna go from Octopath Traveler to Quinn Tufflet Traveler. Alright, I don't know what I'm even talking about at this point And then there's the battle system I'm not gonna tell you that this turn-based battle system is the most unique battle system in the world Turn-based combat's been around for a long time and we've seen a thousand takes on turn-based combat But what I love absolutely love about this turn-based combat is just how perfectly it melds itself with the characters from the characters abilities To the characters weapons to even the break system We've seen a system like this before but I love how each enemy has its own weakness and that weakness can sometimes correlate To specific characters that are dealing with certain story arcs And then you weaken that till you break their defenses and then you just take them out with massive giant attacks It is such a unique feeling to me compared to other turn-based combat where I just don't care This is the first game I have played in my entire life where I don't mind grinding You guys know what grinding is that thing where it feels like you're wasting hours and hours of your life Just to level characters up and level abilities up And you wish you could just move on to the actual important story thing or the next important boss fight But you feel like you need to spend all this time grinding. I mean Zelda 2 had that issue A lot of action adventure games actually have issues Unibike Chronicles 2 is that way up as a lot of JRPGs in general are that way We got a grind and generally I don't enjoy the grind It's one reason why I don't like you might sink hundreds of hours into an RPG But how many of those hours were you actually having fun and how many of it was he feeling like you needed to work at it Like a job to get to a certain level see an autopath traveler I enjoyed the combat so much that it never really felt like I was grinding. I mean I subconsciously knew yeah I'm running around this area to attack enemies and grind But I enjoyed the combat so much that it just didn't matter and there's always unique abilities You know you have one character that can like steal money from other characters in the middle of battle like oh You know you have another character that unveils abilities Obviously you have healers and then different types of healing You have Tressa who can like self heal and return like get her own SP back And then there's the the whole man that the attack system so cool where every turn you do an attack It gives you like a point like an attack point And when you get get up to four of those attack points stacked you increase the the power of your spells your attacks It pretty much anything your character can do to Make more damage be done more healing be done more curing being possible. It's just an amazing System to me that works very well with the break system that is being used on the enemies They have a break point you also have an attack point and it works in tandem to create something beautiful And the enemy designs are just very interesting and very different a pirate very much looks like a pirate a bandit Looks like a bandit and you might think bandits and pirates to two pieces of the same public the same But they don't because there's unique personalities involved. There's unique story lines involved unique boss fights involved Haven't even gotten to the story of hate it.  Oh my god the huntress. I should say sorry Don't want to take it away is a female character And that's another cool thing as you're building out your party and you're swapping characters in and out to do Different stories every time you're swapping it even just one character out for another it changes up your entire Battle strategy because each character's got these unique items these unique abilities that just change everything You could actually run a party if or a half of this game of just Female characters one is the last time you could say that about any RPG Any RPG and it's not just female characters to be female characters They're female characters that have stories that are related to those characters and you can do the same thing with male characters It's oh man You can't tell I love Octopath Traveler and now this is where we get into the controversial statement This is the best game on switch My favorite game of all time is breath of the wild I make no bones about it breath of the wild has been my top dog forever And I debated on saying that this is the best game You know switch exclusive wise because I've always argued mario plus rabbits kingdom battle My favorite game on switch in terms of switch exclusives Even more than mario odyssey even more than swatoon 2 even more than mario tennis ace is not that that's a high hurdle to climb but the thing is is I think I actually like octopath traveler more than breath of the wild For now i'm going to leave it as Octopath traveler is my favorite switch exclusive game to date I'm not going to talk about if it tops breath of the wild for me until I put more time into it because it took a Long time for me to decide that breath of the wild is my top of the mountain So I need to put that hundred hours in that I plan to put into this game Over the course of the rest of this year and come to a conclusion at the end of the year About whether or not octopath traveler. They're truly tops Breath of the wild for me But here's one thing I can say Not only is it my favorite switch exclusive game right now It's might be my favorite jrpg of all time and I'm not just talking turn based jrpg I'm talking all jrpg's I've ever played keep in mind No one's played every single jrpg including me But of the ones I have played both growing up and in the now even zeno bay chronicles 2 This is a better game to me than those games. Well polished great great story great art direction great music great battle system I mean the game is practically perfect for my taste Is it a perfect game? No, no game is perfect And I could probably come up with ways that I might do things a little bit better But that's all I can come up with was a little bit better And that's what makes me think that I might actually enjoy this game more than I enjoy breath of the wild because in breath of the wild I could think of big Sweeping things that I would do better in that game or do different a second time around But I'm not too bad traveler if I'm myself going I Really love this game the way it is. I don't like you want an overarching story that connects all the characters great. I don't So at the end of the day, I just want to hear your guys's thoughts on octopath traveler Have you picked it up? Are you waiting to pick it up our turn based combat games now for you?  I've heard several arguments about how I'm waiting for a price drop $60 is too much for this arch style. I'm just like no Oh my gosh play the game this if any game in my life was ever worth full price It is this game Oh my gosh. Oh and did I mention if you could somehow get the wayfarer collectors edition It's got this really cute pop-ups of all eight characters in their hometowns Isn't that awesome. I mean seriously. Oh my gosh. This is Oh man primrose. Oh man Just all right folks. I hope you really enjoyed my look here at octopath traveler my thoughts my opinions I'm not going to call this a official review. I don't I don't even how you review a game that you love so much I just want to start a conversation about how much I love this game Get your guys's thoughts on it and See where we all stand in the world of octopath traveler. You guys let me know Now if you excuse me, I need to actually get back to play and sing in fact Do I know how much I mean look at this I don't know if octopath traveler's physical cart has left my switch Since I bought the game. I better get back to traveling


Hey there, Chad Bondra here for High University Libraries. If you're looking for sports law journals, you're looking for information about particular issues in sports law, this video shows you how to find sports law journals on your topic. So when you get to HinoLine, if you're looking for sports law journals, you'll first click on the Law Journal Library, and then go over and browse by subject. We're just looking for law journals that deal with sports law. Scroll down some, and then here we have sports law here. And it gives us a little bit of a search box. We're going to start broad. And let's say we're just looking for morality, and does a search there, finds 201. If you want to, we can actually go click search within the results. And let's say we're looking for college, right? And leave everything else along.  So now you can see it's looking for college in sports law and morality. And we want to go in and search within results. We can do maybe look for a coach, go down once again, and click Search. And so now we're getting down to 66 results that way. So a good way to kind of limit your search for law journals that deal with things like sports law, entertainment law, things like that. So a great resource to find full text of the actual article, just click on there. And then you can browse by issue on the left-hand side or just click the next page here to read what you're looking at there. So a great way to find law journals for your subject area. Hopefully this helps you understand how to find sports law journals. If you need more help, look for the contact link on the business blog. I'll be glad to help you anyway I can. Take care and have a great day.