It is now time for oral questions. I recognize the leader of His Majesty's loyal opposition. Speaker, there's no better place to live than in Ontario. And it's one of the reasons I came here from Newfoundland so many years ago and why I chose to stay to raise a family here. Ontario has always held great promise and great opportunity. But, Speaker, there's a really growing sense out there that things aren't quite right. People are struggling to pay rent and keep food on the table, and some are being forced to leave their communities or even the province just to be able to find an affordable place to live. Speaker, my question is to the Premier. Why did his budget contain virtually no measures to help make life more affordable in this province? Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Well, I'm glad to hear that the leader of the opposition is as optimistic about the province of Ontario as we have been since 2018. Mr. Speaker, the fact is earlier this week the opposition was continuing to talk down the province of Ontario. But let's look at what we have done, Mr. Speaker. When did you start this year? We started back in 2018 to reverse what was a disastrous time frame when both the Liberals and the NDP systematically increased the costs on the people of the province of Ontario. We started in 2018 to cut taxes for people. We took the most vulnerable right off the tax rules entirely. They voted against those measures, Mr. Speaker. We're continuing with the gas tax rebate. Of course, they voted against that, Mr. Speaker. We've reduced the costs for our small, medium and large job creators by over $8 billion. The results have been that over 600,000 people in the province of Ontario now have the dignity of the job that didn't when they shared power with the Liberals. And we have 300,000 jobs that still need to be filled. That's good news for the people. Thank you. The supplementary question. Speaker, the thing is that if you're a friend to the Premier or conservative insider, you've got a direct line to this government. But for your average Ontarian, there's little in the way of help in this budget or anywhere else. In just a couple of days, rent is going to come due again for millions of people in this province. And thanks to this government's massive loopholes in rent control, people are seeing a steep and sudden increase in their rent. Speaker, back to the Premier. With people feeling so squeezed by the costs that are out of control, why didn't he use the budget to bring back real rent control and give Ontarians some relief? How can the leader of the opposition talk about the costs on the people of the province of Ontario when this is a party that supports year after year federal policies which increase the cost of a carbon tax? Now, let's unpack that for a second, because we said and we have continued to say that a carbon tax will cost the people of the province of Ontario on every single thing that they do driving to work more expensive, going to get groceries more expensive. The groceries that you buy in the store more expensive because of a carbon tax. And this is a party that supports a 14% increase in the carbon tax on April 1, Mr. Speaker. So I ask the leader of the opposition, will she join with us in asking the federal government to at the very least, at the very least, pause that incredible increase on the costs of everything for the people of the province of Ontario? Will she put her money whereabout this? Stop the clock. So please take those seats. Order. Restart the clock. Final supplementary. It's time this government started to take a little bit of responsibility for the fact that life is a lot harder for a lot of people in this province five years after they came to power. I'd really encourage the Premier and all his ministers to get out of the back rooms and start listening to real people. Because people are really struggling. Order. And I hear it everywhere I go. And it's not just rent that's through the roof. It's more expensive than ever before to buy a home. This government's plan to build luxury homes on protected land is not going to solve that problem. Speaker, my question to the Premier is, will he act to end greedy land speculation and make sure the dream of truly affordable home ownership is no longer out of reach? Yeah. Yeah. Government House Speaker? Speaker, when we, in our first mandate, brought in transit-oriented communities to build more homes around the incredible infrastructure that we are building across the province of Ontario, and not just in Toronto, but in communities across Toronto that have GO train stations, the leader of the opposition, how did she vote? She voted against that measure, Mr. Speaker. This is thousands of homes affordable housing for the people of the province of Ontario. Now, the Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing has been working since day one to bring more housing to Ontario, and they have voted against every single measure. Now, as I said last week, the opposition, the federal government, they can either support us in bringing more homes to the people of the province of Ontario so that more people can share in the dream of home ownership, whether it's to own a home, whether it's your first rental, more people want to share in that dream. You can either help us or simply get out of the way. The next question, order. Next question, leader of the opposition. Again, Speaker, totally out of touch. Not listening to the real people of this province. Order. Speaker, there's a whole bunch of senior- Clock, stop the clock, stop the clock. Last and leader of the opposition, please take your seat. Stop the clock. The government side will come to order. So that I can hear the member who was asking the questions. Leader of the opposition. Let's talk about a real person speaker. Speaker, this week, CBC News shared the story of an Ontario senior who was charged almost $9,000 in unnecessary fees for eye surgery at a private clinic. And when she started asking questions about it, the clinic through her, Lois Cooper is speaking out now after hearing the Premier and Minister of Health repeat over and over and over again that patients will not have to pay more in private surgical facilities. Her experience and that of so many others shows that just trust us isn't going to protect patients. Speaker to the Premier, will this government refuse that it will this government refuse to put, sorry, I'm gonna start that again. Will this government stop the predatory upselling that is happening across this province? The Minister of Health, Member. Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. And thank you to the member opposite for the question. This government is actually making changes through Bill 60, which if passed will be expanding oversight and patient protection when it comes to people's health. And for some reason, the members opposite don't seem to want to expand those patient protections. They don't seem to want to support Bill 60, but I hope they will because Bill 60 has a whole bunch of protections in it to address situations such as this. For example, any community health centre in the future will have to post any uninsured charges, both online and in person, so people know ahead of time. They'll have to have a process for receiving and responding to patient complaints. And patients cannot be denied access to a treatment if they don't purchase uninsured services. Finally, we're also expanding oversight to the patient ombudsman to include these new centres. All of these things are in place to help patient protections. I would think the members opposite would support that. Good answer. Supplementary. What oversight? What protection? It's not there. That's not right. Mountains of evidence show patients have been repeatedly misled by for-profit clinics that have recommended procedures that people just don't need. It's how they make a profit. This government's health act is going to do nothing to stop this. So we have proposed amendments, Speaker, to outlaw upselling in any form. Speaker, to the Minister of Health, will the minister accept the NDP's amendments to protect patients? Parliamentary Assistant Minister Hart. Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker, and thank you again to the member opposite. The whole point of this legislation is to change the model that was a model of independent health facilities into a model of integrated community health centres, bringing the new health centres and the old ones, 900 of which have been operating across the province for 30 years under all kinds of governments, NDP, Liberal and Conservative, to change that model to make them integrated under Ontario Health, under the auspices of Ontario Health, and with direction which is centrally controlled, centralised weightless management. This is a significant improvement. It will improve access to patient care, and this government is all about doing that, making sure patients get the care they need quickly and make sure they get their lives back as soon as possible. The final supplementary. No, Speaker, Bill 60. Bill 60 is going to make it legal to put profits ahead of patients in this province. That's what it's going to do. Speaker, it is absolutely critical for Ontarians to believe that their government is acting in their best interest. Ms. Cooper's experience shows us how patients will suffer. Under Bill 60, because private for profit clinics are going to upsell and cherry pick their patients. Private for profit clinics, some of which just happened to be major Conservative Party donors. Speaker, to the Minister of Health, who is making health policy in this province? Your donors? When will someone start putting people like Lois first? Parliamentary system, the Minister of Health. Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker, and thank you again to the member opposite. In fact, that is what this government is doing. People like Lois first. Putting patients in Ontario first. We know the status quo is not working, and that is why we are innovating. And there's nothing in Bill 60 which talks about any particular model of care. For example, we had the Kensington Eye Institute come in. Kensington Eye Institute would be a model that could be under this Bill 60. They could be the kind of place that gets established. Kensington Eye Clinic has been giving great care to patients for many years and will continue to do so. So we can continue to build out models, make sure that they are serving patients, make sure patients are getting the care they need in a timely way by the best possible experts who can provide that care. That is what Bill 60 is about. Patient access quickly. Next question, the member for Ottawa West Nippian. Thank you, Speaker. The Old Forge Community Resource Centre and my writing of Ottawa West Nippian provides crucial supports to seniors and people living with disabilities that allows them to lead healthy, independent lives and stay out of the hospital. But they've been trying to survive on 2012 funding levels while demand for services is going up. They begged this government for a budget increase but to no avail. Now, starting Monday, 95 seniors and people with disabilities will go without services because of this government's inaction. Why is the Premier willing to let such vulnerable people lose such vital supports? Do you have the government? The government has seen it. Well, thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. In fact, just the opposite. Since this government has been in place, we have been systematically revamping our services for not only our seniors, but for our most vulnerable across the province. That is why we started off by ensuring that the lowest income earning people were removed from the tax rolls altogether. But when you look at the improvements that the minister is making with respect to senior care, not only in this current budget where we increase the access to the guaranteed income supplement, the incredible investments that we are making in home care and the investments that we are making in long-term care. But we've also heard from our seniors that they also want the opportunity where they can to participate in the economy, in the growing economy. The Minister of Labor has making that available to them as well. The Minister of Education through COVID ensured that those seniors and retired teachers, for instance, who wanted to come back and help us through the pandemic could do that. So it's more than just looking at seniors as exiting the workforce. It's more than looking at them as exiting their time to participate. It's about how we can integrate them into helping us continue to build an Ontario that they left us, a thriving Ontario that they almost destroyed, Mr. Speaker. Supplementary question? I'm sure the seniors in the dementia day program that's being cut will be really happy to know this government is willing to let them work. Speaker, it's not just the old forge. 30 community social service organizations in Eastern Ontario are faced with the same challenge and will have to make cuts thanks to this government's decision. Hospital CEOs in Eastern Ontario called on the Premier to support these organizations because they know these organizations keep people out of hospitals with preventative health care and that they help people get home sooner with meals on wheels and home care. Just $7 million would allow these organizations to maintain their service levels. Will the Premier listen to the hospital CEOs and properly fund these organizations? Good morning, House Speaker. Mr. Speaker, it is interesting to hear the opposition now talking about supporting the hospital CEOs, right? It's just another example of say one thing when the camera's on to do something else. Now, when the hospital CEOs in September asked us to do more to help those seniors who are in hospitals and needed to be in long-term care or other options, the opposition suggested that people would be sent thousands of miles away and they would be bankrupted by the policies that the hospital CEOs asked. And what happened? In fact, just the opposite, Mr. Speaker. When I tour long-term care homes, the residents there say it's the best thing that ever happened. The quality of care is much better. Why? Because we listen to the hospital CEOs. When the hospital CEOs told us that we had to do better on small, medium-sized hospitals budgets, we did that. When the hospital CEOs in Ontario, in Eastern Ontario, in Ottawa- Response? They said we needed new hospitals we came through. When they said that they needed more staff, the Minister of Colleges and Universities came through with a program that is hiring thousands of nurses. When they needed more doctors, the Minister of the Treasure Board Thank you. Thank you. The next question, the member for Barry Innisville. My question is for the Minister of Education. As we know rising inflation costs continue to impact the financial wellbeing of families and businesses across the province and certainly in the riding of Barry Innisville. And the upcoming tax increase of the carbon tax of 14% will also hinder those families. I've heard resoundingly throughout the riding of Barry Innisville they can't afford the rising cost of inflation. They increased carbon tax on April 1st. They're happy to see that our government is doing what we can to keep costs low and of course to fight the federal government on the tax increase. But, Speaker, what I'm also hearing is hope from parents. Hope from parents that finally they're seeing direct supports for them through this government. And I was speaking to Melissa, a mum of three who's benefiting from catch-up payments. So I'm gonna ask the Minister of Education what else is he hearing from parents in terms of the direct financial supports this government is giving to families and students. And to respond, the Minister of Education. Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. I wanna thank the member from Barry Innisville for her leadership in this House standing up for families against the regressive federal liberal carbon tax that is raising the cost on all families and all small businesses in this economy. Mr. Speaker, in addition to opposing that carbon tax by the federal government we are also providing direct financial relief to parents. In fact, we have done it three times. $1.9 billion over the past three years in direct financial relief to parents to help support them and their kids get back on track. We just unveiled Ontario's catch-up payments. I'm proud to confirm 80% of parents have signed up for this $200 payment for every child under 18 and $250 for every child with special education needs. Now, there's still 20% of parents who haven't and I'm encouraging all members to promote this investment on trail.ca forward slash catch-up payments. Apply today, get the relief families deserve. And that's a mental question. Member for Barry Innisville. Thank you and I wanna thank the minister for really understanding the needs of families and students alike. And we know following many years of disruption our students returned to the classroom in person where they know they can best recover their academic, mental and physical health. But our students also need the right investments and supports in order to realize their recovery and prepare them for the success in a modern economy. This means ensuring our students are learning critical life skills and job skills that are rooted in fundamentals and topics like math, reading and writing, something you hear a lot from parents. Ontario students need these skills to find lifelong careers and help us continue to grow our provincial economy. So I wanna ask the minister with all the work that he's also doing, how is he investing in our students so they can be successful in the classroom and for years beyond the classroom? Mr. of Education. Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. I do appreciate this question in budget 2023. We've reaffirmed our commitment to publicly funded schools. We increase investments for Ontario children by $2.3 billion overall, even on a baseline evaluation, it's up $1.3 billion in the year prior. Now, Mr. Speaker, we know there's more to do. It's why we launched a tutoring program. $175 million focused on getting back to the fundamentals and the basics of education, lifting up reading, writing and math scores and refocusing the system back on strengthening skills development in our school system. We have a modern curriculum, mandating financial literacy and coding and transferable hands-on learning that we know is critical for these young people to succeed in the economy. And finally speaking, we're expanding skill trades and technology opportunities, requiring students to now take a tech course starting next September, opening up their horizons and their opportunities to get good paying jobs in this economy. Bons. Thank you. Next question. Remember for Hamilton Melner. Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. My question is for the Premier. Over 98,000 people have signed online petitions calling for a vulnerable person alert. Today I'm joined by the family of Draven Graham, the Ontario Autism Coalition and the Alzheimer's Society of Ontario who came here to support Bill 74. Bill 74, if passed, would provide police forces with an additional tool to bring our vulnerable loved ones who go missing home. Time is critical in these situations and a vulnerable person's alert would provide a useful solution to help protect people. Currently, Bill 74 has been referred to the Standing Committee on Justice Policy. Can the Premier provide us with a date on when this bill will be studied before the committee? The government House Leader. I thank the member for the question. As she said, acknowledged this morning in her news conference with the parents and the grandparents, the bill that was presented to the House was significantly flawed and had it gone to second reading today, we would not have been able to make the changes that the member herself suggests needs to be made in order to make the bill effective, Speaker. So that is why we took the unusual and aggressive step given that there is broad-based support for this to send it directly to committee so that the changes that the member herself acknowledges need to be made could actually be made and a bill could be supported. I did communicate this to the member and to the opposition House Leader on the day that we took that step to move it directly to committee, Mr. Speaker. And again, it is our intention to do everything possible to make a flawed bill, although one that is presented, I suspect, in an honest, good spirit to make it better so that it actually works for the parents of those who are here today and all of those who are watching and want us to make an appropriate change. Thank you. Is that one of your questions? Thank you, Speaker. And thank you to the government House Leader for that answer. Bill 74 looks to fill a gap in our current emergency alert system. Speaker, did you know that six in 10 people with dementia will wander? A vulnerable person alert could expand the demographic of vulnerable people so the alert would be broadened to ensure that people who wander would be brought home and it would save lives. So can the government House Leader commit to bringing Bill 74 back from committee after changes are made so that it can be debated and passed into legislation as quickly as possible? Mr. Speaker, I think that the member knows quite well that with respect to private members business, this government and in the last parliament, particularly in this parliament has been very aggressive in ensuring that private members business, when it is done in appropriate fashion, when the bill is a good bill, when it does have a broad level of support between on all sides of the House that we do order. Despite the hecklings of the Liberal Party, which does not seem to want to talk about this particular bill, you have my assurances that when the bill is fixed at committee, we will bring it back to the House because as I said, there is a broad level of support for the bill. And I think I know the member for Sarnia Lampton. Sarnia Lampton also had talked about some- Response? That he'd like to see in this as well. So it is our intention to do just that. Next question, the member for Markham Union Bill. Speaker, my question is for the Minister- Stop the clock. The member for Beaches East York will come to order. The government House Leader will come to order. Minister of Labor will come to order. The member for Kitchener Conestoga will come to order. Start the clock. The member for Markham Union Bill. Thank you, Speaker. My question is for the Minister of Labor Immigration Training and Skills Development. Every day in Ontario, jobs go unfilled because of a shortage of workers. One senior economist recently said there's a traffic jam of employers looking to hire. Information from Statistics Canada show record high job vacancy numbers and unprecedented labor force participation rate. To combat the labor shortage and to maintain Ontario's economic competitive position within the global market, we need more skilled worker than ever before. So Speaker, can the Minister please explain how our government is addressing our labor shortage needs? Minister of Labor Immigration Training and Skills Development. Thank you very much and thank you to the member from Markham Union Bill for that very important question. Speaker, our government knows that welcoming economic immigrants who have the skills we need is crucial to building a strong Ontario. In 2021, the Premier and I called on the federal government to double the number of immigrants we can select. I'm pleased to share that the federal government met us at the table and together we got it done. Our immigrant nominee program will be doubling in size, allowing us to nominate over 18,000 immigrants by 2025. Speaker, last year we nominated 3,900 skilled trades workers, 2,200 software and IT workers, 1,000 truck drivers and nearly 100 nurses and PSWs. Doubling this program by 2025 means we can select more workers with these skills to fill gaps in industries that need them most. The supplementary question. Thank you Speaker and thank you for the Minister for that response. That's a good news. It's welcome news that Ontario is getting a great to say in how we are addressing key labour shortage across province through our immigration immigrant nominee program. To support our province economic growth and to provide a foundation for next generation, we need to do everything we can do to get the workers that our province needs. It's also necessary to highlight that our government must consider the importance of these newcomers settled and build their lives in Ontario. Urgent labour demands our presence across our province, including regions outside major cities. Speaker, can the Minister please elaborate on how our government will ensure that communities need to have the ability to fulfill critical labour shortages? The Minister of Labour. Thank you and thank you to the member again for his leadership and for this question. Speaker, we know that all parts of Ontario benefit from the skills and hard work of economic immigrants. That is why our immigrant nominee program prioritizes those looking to move to communities outside of the greater Toronto area. To ensure these professionals can start working as quickly as possible, budget 2023 is investing $25 million over the next three years for security and IT upgrades. Through our first working for workers act, we removed discriminatory barriers that hold back internationally trained professionals and we're recognizing their credentials. Our mission is very simple, Speaker. We're going to build a stronger Ontario for the next generation. The next question, the member for Hamilton Centre. Mr. Speaker, my question is to the Premier. Speaker, homelessness is a disability justice issue. We've known for years that people without housing are disproportionately disabled, many with multiple health conditions. This week, a report indicated that from June to November 2022, 22 people died in Hamilton while homeless. Harm reduction strategies include community mental health services, crisis supports and drug overdose supports, which are all inadequately resourced. When people end up on the street, our responses to their complex needs cannot be to criminalize homelessness and then to ignore them in death. Mr. Speaker, the government's budget proves that they do not understand the urgency of this issue. When will the government take real steps to end homelessness in Ontario? Municipal Affairs and Housing. Well, Speaker, I want to thank the member for Hamilton Centre for her first question in the House. You know, Speaker, there's a lot of things that the member opposite has said that I fundamentally disagree with, but there's one thing that I think she can agree with me on, and that's we got a great mayor in Hamilton. We got a great mayor in Hamilton who has signed on to our housing pledge to build 47,000 homes in the city over the next 10 years. But again, Speaker, I fundamentally disagree with her characterization of our budget. Our budget stands up for the homelessness prevention program. It stands up for those wraparound services that mayors like the mayor of Hamilton have asked for. It directly responds to the big city mayors that includes Hamilton. We will continue to work with mayors like Andrea Horvath on meeting our housing target near here. Thank you. That's your question. Back to the member for Hamilton Centre. Mr. Speaker, we're receiving continuous reports in Hamilton that those who died had contact with the system just prior to their death. Of the 22 who died, five were seen in an emergency room, two were discharged from hospital, three were released from jail, and four were prevented from accessing the shelter system. This Patrick system does not work. People are best supported in long term when they have access to fixed permanent housing as an important form of harm reduction. Affordable housing with full access to tenant legal protections is critically important because it's a basic human need and it's under the provincial jurisdiction. Again, to the premier, people are dying in this budget and homelessness in Hamilton. When will the government take this problem seriously? To congratulate the member on her election. Speaker, all members in this house want to prevent homelessness in this province. But this is a government that has taken real action. The $202 million investment announced in the budget has been well received by organizations right across Ontario.  While we work toward that goal, the Ontario Alliance to End Homelessness is pleased to see this significant investment in homelessness services from the government of Ontario. Speaker, I really do hope the opposition joins us and supports our investments. But, Speaker, you know what? There are shovels in the ground across this province building more non-profit and affordable housing thanks to the changes we've made under the More Homes Built Faster Act 2022. The opposition would rather tax those of us. Thank you. Thank you. The next question, the member for Ottawa South. Thank you very much, Speaker. My question is for the premier. The affordability crisis is hitting Ontario families hard. The price of everything has gone up.  The price of hydro folks, it's higher than it's ever been. And families work hard every day. Every day they feel like they're working, that they're falling further and further behind. They're looking for something to make their lives just a little bit easier. And when they see this budget, they can't find anything to make their lives just a little bit easier. In fact, there are things the government isn't doing in our schools and in healthcare that's actually making life harder for them. Instead of making people's lives just a little bit easier, this government is actually making life harder. So, Speaker, to the premier, just why is that? And to reply, the Parliamentary Assistant, the Minister of Finance, member for Bruce Grappler. Mr. Speaker, the people of Ontario work hard and we understand that taxpayers are under pressure. That's why we took action last year in many areas when costs were riding, to keep costs down. With the temporary gas tax cut that we confirmed in the fall economic statement, made permanent, and yet the opposition voted against those both times. That's why this government is taking a targeted approach and we're supporting people while building a strong Ontario for the future. We're investing in Ontario's workers with an additional $224 million to the Skills Development Fund to get workers into those well-paying jobs. We've increased health funding, $15.3 billion over three years and building 50 new hospital projects, expansions and renovations. We're doing that right now. We have the right plan. We're taking a responsible, prudent approach to address the economic challenges and support the people of Ontario. Thank you. It's a supplementary question. Mr. Speaker, the previous message to families is you're on your own. If your child has exceptional needs that aren't being met at school, guess what folks, you're on your own.    And if you're one of the two million people, two million people in Ontario who don't have a family physician or a nurse practitioner, guess what folks, you're on your own. If you own lots of land in the Greenbelt, guess what folks, Premier's got your back. Mr. Speaker, through you, why is this government abandoning Ontario's families in an affordability crisis? Government House Leader to reply? Is the Leader of the Liberal Party kidding me? So let's take a look. Let's take a look. Under the leadership or the lack of of the Liberals, we lost 300,000 jobs and they wanted to transition to a service economy. In fact, Fiat Christford said this was the worst jurisdiction in the world in which to do business under the Liberals. The highest amount of red tape under the Liberals. Inability to get transit and transportation under the Liberals. Our hospitals crumbling under the Liberals, Mr. Speaker. Energy prices. He talks about energy prices. People could not afford they had to make a decision between heating and eating. And this member has the nerve to get up and... It seems somewhat strange that I can't hear the government House Leader because of the heckling from the government side and the government House Leader is answering the question. Does he have more time? He has more time. Order. Order. Start the clock. Government House Leader has a few more seconds. So Mr. Speaker, let me just say this. If the member really wants to do something about affordability, then he can join us in calling on the federal government supported by the NDP to at least pause the 14% increase in the carbon tax by hitting the people of the province who aren't here. The House will come to order. Start the clock. Next question, the member for Halburton, Quarthier Lakes Park. Speaker, my question is for the Minister of Labor Immigration training and skills development. While it is positive and welcome news that our Ontario immigrant nominee program will be doubling in size to expand our workforce, we must recognize that newcomers can be exposed to the risk of exploitation at work. Human trafficking and exploitation are horrendous crimes that often go unreported. Sadly, these crimes are still happening in Canada and here in Ontario. Traffic exploitation exists in many forms and takes advantage of systemic issues such as poverty, inequity, employer discrimination, unsafe working conditions and gaps in employment policy. Regardless of the cause, the outcomes are devastating, resulting in physical, psychological and emotional trauma to victims. Speaker, can the Minister please explain how our government is protecting vulnerable workers from labor exploitation? Minister of Labor Immigration Training and Skills Development. Thank the member from Halburton, Quarthier Lakes Park for this very important question, but most of all for her leadership when it comes to anti-human trafficking in the province of Ontario. On behalf of all MPs, thank you for all the work that you've done. Speaker, our government stands in support of workers whether you are a Canadian citizen or a temporary foreign worker. We will not tolerate actions by employers who abuse workers. That is why our government introduced the Working for Workers Act 2023, which would, if passed, continue to lead the country in providing groundbreaking protections for our workers. Part of the legislation identifies changes that are necessary to strengthen protections for vulnerable workers by establishing the highest maximum fines in Canada. Our message to dishonest and unethical employers is that if you think you're going to deny someone's basic human rights by withholding their passport or central work documents, you will face very serious consequences. The supplementary question. Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I want to thank the minister for his dedication and tremendous work on this file. The Working for Workers Act is a positive step toward cracking down on exploitation and ensuring that the rights of everyone who is working here in Ontario is protected. However, we know from police reports that labour trafficking and abuse of vulnerable workers happens far too often. The reality is that victims are often in precarious work situations and are afraid to come forward. Under the strong leadership of the Premier and this minister, our government is committed to the safety, health, and wellbeing of workers. While Ontario needs workers to strengthen and grow our province, workers need our government to make sure they are protected. Speaker, can the minister please elaborate on how this legislation, if passed, would implement and enforce measures to protect vulnerable workers? Very well. Minister of Labour? Again to the member, thank you for this question. Speaker, for employers who abuse workers, our government will hold them to account for their actions. The consequences will be swift and severe. Currently, labour inspectors can levy penalties of only $250 for each passport or work permit that is withheld. But with the proposed changes, that will rise to $200,000. As well, Speaker, if an individual employer is convicted by the courts of such an offence, they would also be subject to a fine of up to half a million dollars, up to 12 months in jail, or both. Additionally, corporations could be fined up to $1 million. Speaker, through these measures, all workers in Ontario can be assured that their safety is our number one priority and that we have their backs. The next question, the member for London West. Thank you very much, Speaker. My question is to the Premier. Speaker, Barbara Savage is 84 years old and lives in London West. She recently received a sudden and shocking diagnosis of stage four breast cancer and underwent a double mastectomy in February. With tubes dangling everywhere from her chest, she was discharged and told a nurse would come to her home the next day. Speaker, 11 days later, a nurse finally came. When the tubes filled with blood, Barbara's daughter had to Google how to drain them herself. Speaker, does the Premier believe that this is an acceptable standard of home care? Parliamentary assistance to the Minister of Health. Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. And thank you to Member Opposite for the question. No, I mean, this is an unacceptable situation. This should not have happened. And I feel very badly for that person who waited 11 days for someone to come and see them. Our government has made significant investments into home care. A strong home and community care sector is critical to our government's plan to end hallway health care and build a patient-centered connected system. And that's why a few years ago and last year we had invested an additional billion dollars to improve the quality of care and keep people of Ontario in their homes longer with the care that they need. And we like the model at the Southlake Hospital, Southlake at home, which has the home care provider meeting with the person who's going to receive the care in the hospital so they can meet the doctor, the nurse, get the discharge papers, and so that person will know that the person will be there and when. And so we want to make sure that that's the kind of system we have across Ontario so people get home care, which is appropriate, and can stay out of hospital and get well. The supplementary question. Speaker, Barbara Savage's case is not unique. The revolving door of staff in private for-profit home care agencies has left patients like Barbara on their own. When Barbara and her daughter frantically called Peramed, they were told no nurses were available. Thankfully, Barbara did not develop complications, but many patients do, forcing them back into the hospital. Speaker, will this government admit that it's failure to address the home care worker shortage? It's refusal to drop the unconstitutional Bill 124 is putting the health of Ontarians like Barbara at risk. Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. Thank you again to the member opposite. As this government has said many times, the only thing better than care close to home is care at home. And in partnership with hospitals, primary care and Ontario health teams, Ontario is expanding and improving access to home and community care. Through the 2022 budget, the government announced the plan to invest a billion dollars over three years to get more people connected to care in the comfort of their own home. But our government is now, through this budget, accelerating investments to bring funding in 23, 24, up to $569 million, including nearly $300 million to support contract rate increases to stabilize the home and community care workforce. This funding will also expand home care services and improve the quality of care, making it easier and faster for people to connect to care. Having strong community care for people like Barbara is a key part of this government's plan for connected and convenient care. The next question, the member for Niagara West. Thank you, Speaker. My question is for the Associate Minister of Mental Health and Addictions. The people of my riding of Niagara West have seen firsthand the devastating consequences of mental health challenges and addictions in Niagara. We've seen the losses from these challenges and we know that the losses are devastating for loved ones and have a significant impact on our broader community. Our government is committed to building awareness and reducing stigma related to mental health addiction challenges. And I know that through investments in community supports, progress has been made. But the demand for services in my riding and so many others continues at an unprecedented rate. And our government must act to ensure that Ontarians are able to get access to the care they need when and where they need it. Speaker, could the Associate Minister please explain to this House what our government is doing to ensure that all individuals facing mental health challenges and addictions care are being supported here in the province of Ontario. The Associate Minister of Mental Health and Addictions. Mr. Speaker, and thank you to the member, the fantastic member from Niagara West. This gives you an opportunity to speak about the investments that we're making in our new budget and how we're going to help those that are doing the heavy lifting in the province fight against the opioid overdoses. Mr. Speaker, with an additional investment of $425 million over three years, we're providing the community mental health and addiction sectors its first base funding increase in 10 years. By providing a 5% increase in funding across the board for community mental health and addictions organizations, we're stabilizing the sector, ensuring staff can be retained and making it clear to the people of Ontario that we're treating these issues with the seriousness they deserve. I want to end the response with a quote from the CEO from CMHA who said, the budget is an overwhelmingly positive sign that the government understands the strain our sector is facing and we support the Ontarians leading with it. Thank you. Thank you very much. The supplementary question. The associate minister for that response and I appreciate hearing about the significant inflow of cash into this important sector to ensure that we have our able to hire more staff and address the needs of people in my community to receive the care when and where they need it. I know this is a hugely important issue and one that I'm thankful for the leadership being shown by so many in this budget to ensure that we're funding these services in our areas. It's also important though to raise awareness about the urgent need for affordable housing in context where we're trying to support people with mental health and addiction challenges. And one of the most important aspects for health for those who are recovering is ensuring that they have adequate access to housing. So I know that as a government we're taking this need very seriously and we're building more affordable housing across this province. But I'm wondering if the minister could please explain what actions our government is taking to address homelessness and ensure that we're helping vulnerable Ontarians those who are homeless or at risk of becoming homeless. And Minister of Mental Health and Addictions. Thank you Mr. Speaker and again the continuum of care and the housing component that we need to have for it to be effective is extremely important. And that's one of the key social determinants of health. We understand that and that's why I'm so proud that our government is adding over $200 million to the Homelessness Prevention Program to build supportive housing units across the province of Ontario. And Mr. Speaker we're making significant historic investments to expand mental health and addiction services across the province. At the same time, this investment demonstrates the level of our commitment to ensuring the critical wraparound supports exists for those seeking treatment and recovery. This budget is a win for all Ontarians struggling with mental health and addictions issues. We see you and we're here fighting for you. This government is building a recovery oriented continuum of care to meet the needs of the people of Ontario. And the investments announced last week will help ensure that those who get better stay better. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. The next question, the member for Scarborough, South West. Thank you very much, Speaker. Speaker, just earlier this week, constituent of mine, Tonnoesh Saha reached out a student from York University. He was 30 minutes late for his exam. Speaker, despite coming early for the bus, he waited for half an hour extra. And then he was 30 minutes late for his exam. That's just a small example of the reality in Scarborough when it comes to transit because of the delays that we're facing. And with recent cuts to TTC, bus 905 and 9 will have more overcrowding, more wait times, more delays. And it puts so many people in Scarborough in an unfair disadvantage unlike others. And this is because of the cuts that we are seeing from our governments when it comes to transit. So my question is simple, Speaker. What do you say to Tonnoi and so many people who feel that they're at an unfair disadvantage and the fact that we're not setting these people up for success? To apply, the Minister of Transportation. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I thank the member opposite for her question. And what I say to the people of her riding is that residents of Scarborough deserve the same level of transit as the rest of the city of Toronto, which is why our government has put forward a plan to have a three-stop subway in Scarborough. But Mr. Speaker, that member opposite and her party voted against it. You know, Mr. Speaker, our government has put forward measure after measure to support transit expansion and the operation of transit in the GTA. But time after time, Mr. Speaker, whether it's safe restart funding or whether it's capital projects for new transit in the city of Toronto, the members of the opposition consistently vote against it. So, Mr. Speaker, they can't have it both ways. Either they're for more transit and they vote with us or they're just against it. Yeah, supplementary. Speaker, I would like to invite the minister to come to Scarborough and walk with me because my area that I'm talking about, it has six ridings and three subway stations does not do justice, Speaker. This side of the government side as well, who are in Scarborough, who could do better for their constituents. And Tonoy and many other students who wait for so many minutes for hours for their buses, for their trains would not be satisfied with that answer, Speaker. My question again, Speaker, the experts, the advocates for transit are calling for more operating budget increase from this government. We are seeing an increase in violence in our TTC, in our transit system right now. That is exacerbated because of the cuts. We need to invest and address the root causes of these problems. So my question is, Speaker, will this minister and her government invest in the operating budget that was cut by the liberals and now exacerbated by this government as well, Speaker. Mr. Transportation. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Well, I'm very proud of the record of our government in supporting the operation of transit systems. In fact, Mr. Speaker, I don't think there's been a government in Ontario history that's done more to support the operation of transit systems. Throughout the pandemic under the leadership of our Premier, we put more than $2 billion into the operation of transit systems across this province. Why? Because we know that transit is essential. During the pandemic, it was essential to getting our workers to and from home to work safely, Mr. Speaker. And so we put billions of dollars and the number one beneficiary of our Safe Restart funding, Mr. Speaker, was the TTC. We have been there every step of the way, but sadly, Mr. Speaker, for the constituents in the writings of the members opposite, they all voted against that critical support that we provided for transit. Mr. Speaker, we're continuing to build transit in the city of Toronto, including. Thank you very much. The next question, the member for Kitchener Conestoga. Well, thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. And my question is for the Minister of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs. Animals and animal-related agriculture are crucial to the economic stability of Ontario's rural and remote communities. However, many regions across the province are experiencing a shortage of veterinarians who care for livestock, and this shortage puts a strain on the entire agricultural system. Unfortunately, there are service gaps in rural, remote and Northern Ontario that put farmers and their operators at a disadvantage. These gaps create risk to farmers in their livestock as well as jeopardizing the security of our food supply chains. Speaker, can the Minister please explain how our government is supporting veterinary care to underserviced regions of this province? Mr. Beger, Culture, Food and Rural Affairs. Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. And I really appreciate that thoughtful question from the member from Kitchener Conestoga because it's important to recognize that our government understands that to keep our agri-food supply chain strong, farmers across this province need confidence in that fact that they have services when they need it and where they need it. And that's why I am losing my voice because I am talking so much about the amazing partnership that we have with the Ministry of Colleges and Universities as well as my ministry at Omafra. With the support of our cabinet colleagues, we have introduced a new program. It's a collaborative program whereby the University of Guelph and Lakehead University are establishing a collaborative doctor of veterinary medicine. And this is going to be a two plus two program where we're going to see 20 more veterinary students per year look at the first two years at Lakehead University, the follow-up two years at University of Guelph. This is an initiative that is demonstrating that to grow and strengthen their ability to eat. Thank you very much. The supplementary question. Thank you very much, minister. And I want to thank you, but I also want to thank my uncle, Chuck Lockton, who has been a large animal vet not just here in Ontario but also in Alberta and was also a member of the Canadian Food and Inspection Agency and has done so much great work for our farmers across this great country. And it is encouraging to see our government's commitment to funding investments that will increase enrollment in veterinary medicine programs to support Ontario's livestock farmers, Mr. Speaker. The need for large animal veterinarians is pressing for many communities across our province. Therefore it is essential that our government steps up to implement measures to recruit and retain veterinarians across Ontario. As a government, we must do all that we can to support our farmers. Speaker, can the minister please elaborate more on how this veterinary medicine incentive program will assist rural, remote and northern communities? Thank you. For the Agriculture Food and World Affairs. I love the opportunity to stand up and share my appreciation for everyone that has made this happen because on Monday we just hosted our second annual Grow Ontario Food Summit and everybody was buzzing about the fact that we've listened and we've taken action but we're doing more over and above that collaborative partnership between Lakehead University and University of Guelph. Our PA, the member from Elgin, Middlesex and London, is reviewing the Vet Act and over and above the program introduced where we're making sure students are incented. So we've introduced an additional $5 million program that's going to incent and reward people for pursuing a career in large animal veterinary medicine. This is a crisis that we've identified. We're taking action. And this particular incentive program is going to see students who are large animals be receiving $50,000 over five years for working in remote and under-serviced areas and rural and northern Ontario. Thank you very much. The next question, the member from Toronto, Dan Ford. Speaker, thank you. My question to the minister of transportation. The playground at Pape School of My Riding is about to become an Ontario line construction site. Construction that will go on for two years. Parents are worried that their children who lost two years of schooling during the pandemic will face another lost two years unless there is adequate protection to keep noise levels in the classrooms at an acceptable level. Will the minister direct MetroLink to use met world health organization standards for acceptable noise levels in the classrooms? Mr. Chair, congratulations. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I thank the member opposite for his question. I agree we have to make sure that all precautions are taken to preserve the safety of the playground at the Pape Avenue Junior Public School. And I want to assure the parents there that my ministry is well aware of their concerns and the issues. To date, Mr. Speaker, all work around the school has focused on ground and on soil investigation, on utility locating, and on surveying. But we have full confidence that MetroLinks will be able to ensure that all safety standards are followed. MetroLinks is actively working with the TDSB, with the principal of the school and the parent council, to create a construction safety management plan and has been conducting regular site visits and safety reviews. Mr. Speaker, a construction liaison committee, a CLC, has been created and has held two meetings to date to discuss upcoming construction activities, safety, and any additional community concerns that have been raised. Mr. Speaker, we are taking these concerns very seriously. We want to make sure that the environment around the school is safe and we will be working closely with community leaders and parents on this issue. And the supplementary question. Speaker, the Pape parents support the construction of the Ontario line. They're the people who have been stuck in Pape subway station waiting as train after train is passed. They know that we need transit. But so far, MetroLinks will not make a firm commitment to the target that will be met in the classrooms so that children don't go through another two years of disruption. What I'm asking the minister, Speaker, is to tell MetroLinks to set a standard that they will be held to that will trigger action if it has gone over. Because the children need to have a restoration of normality. It can be done. It will require investment. But we need to have an agreed standard. World Health Organization is the right one to protect the children and protect the learning environment. Yeah. Mr. Transportation. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And I'm happy to tell the parents of the Pape Avenue Junior School that we are following standards. We are following Ontario standards. Mr. Speaker, we have prepared a draft health and safety plan that was distributed to the CLC in advance of the last meeting on March 28th to allow the school and attendees time to review the plan that we've put forward and to discuss it at that meeting. But to further mitigate noise concerns, Mr. Speaker, we've committed to placing a noise barrier around the school. And up cupping work has been detailed to the school parent council. Mr. Speaker, I want to assure families that Metrolinx is committed to ensuring that the highest levels of safety standards are maintained throughout construction. Because we all agree, the Ontario line needs to be built. It will take 28,000 cars off the road each and every day. That is essential for future generations. And Mr. Speaker, we will get it done. The next question. The member for Etobicoke Lakeshore. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. My question is for the Associate Minister of Women's Social and Economic Opportunity. Over the past few years, women have experienced hardship as a result of economic insecurity. A greater burden on caregiving responsibilities and a rise, sadly, a rise in incidents of domestic violence. Combined together, these social and economic barriers are significant challenges for many women as they find their economic independence. Women need to be able to connect to supports to develop their skills, knowledge, and experience in order to find a job or start a small business. It's essential that our government takes action to address the unique disproportionate barriers that women face when entering the job market. Speaker, can the Associate Minister please explain how our government is supporting women, not just to gain employment, but to increase their financial security? The Associate Minister of Women's Social and Economic Opportunity. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And thank you to the member from Etobicoke Lakeshore for her question and the work she's doing to help keep women safe in Ontario. It has been a challenging road to recovery for many women since the onset of the pandemic, but we want all women to know that we are on their side and we're not going to waver from that support for them. That is why earlier this week, I was proud to announce with my colleague, the Minister of Labor Immigration Training Skills Development and the member from New Market Aurora that our government is expanding the Investing in Women Futures program. And we announced 10 new locations in Ontario and I'm excited about the continued progress that is to come. Our government will continue to assess women who have experienced social economic barriers to access services, develop skills needed to gain financial security and live safely with a greater sense of security. This program expansion will help more women across the province access life-changing services that will put them in the driver's seat of their economic future. Here, here. The supplementary question. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And thank you to the associate minister. I also want to thank her for coming to my riding on numerous occasions to meet with young women who were interested in the skilled trades and how, what the barriers were to get them to stay in that job. And they were such wonderful women and you just were magnificent at those meetings. So thank you. You know, all women should have access to the services they need no matter where they live. Particularly in rural and remote communities. Long distance and travel are barriers for many women to connect to the supports they need. And that was one thing that was brought up in our conversations. It's essential that there is access to service and supports for women facing economic and social barriers, including those experienced gender-based violence and social isolation. Mr. Speaker, our government must make investments that focus on empowering women to achieve the success they deserve through good paying jobs. Speaker, can the associate minister please elaborate on how this program encourages over well-being, safety, and economic independence for women. The associate minister. Thank you. Thank you again to the member. Last month, when I toured Northern Ontario, I met with women who had struggled to access much needed services due to long distance travel. And Mr. Speaker, women's geographic locations should not limit their access to services. It is crucial that we focus on getting the right supports in place for women who need them the most. That is why the expansion of the Investing in Women's Futures program is particularly important for remote and rural women. The program provides a wide range of flexible services that include access to transportation, developing financial skills, and wraparound supports, such as safety planning, business development, and so much more. I am proud of these advancements because I know they will help many women across Ontario, including those in the rural and remote areas, because I truly believe that when women succeed, Ontario succeeds. That concludes our question period for this morning.


Hey guys, this is Nate, AKA The Foot Accountant. Welcome back to the channel. We have to talk about the big Black Friday promotion that happened yesterday. Everything that went crazy and happened on the market. The market is absolutely flying. Huge market rise after Friday on a lot of the out-of-pack stuff, icons. We'll talk about these record breaker cards and their market movements that happened today as well. As well as all the pack supply. It's a big thing we're gonna talk about today is the just sheer supply that happened with the Flash SBCs, the Lightning Rounds, multiple different types of Lightning Rounds we saw today that we have never had before. As well as the big-time flashback, Aguero, which is gonna be an impact in this market and the objective player, Rodrigo, because that's also a big W in terms of content today. Just so much was going on yesterday on Black Friday and it's really going to affect what is gonna be happening today on Saturday and into the rest of this weekend. Without further ado, let's take a look at the promo team that came out. You guys know the drill. These are the cards that came out yesterday. Only five cards in packs. Only five and you can't see them all right now because they're kind of hidden behind me. I'll just close this down a bit, but actually it's really small then. So we'll just go with this. Mbappe, David Silva, Sancho, Oscar and Falcao all having their own specific record that they broke to get into this promotion. You guys know the drill. These cards that were upgraded. You've probably seen some of the stat upgrades. The biggest thing that I wanted to show is just the boost on the shooting. If you look at all of these cards that they put out today, literally every single one of them is an attacker of course, but they all got big shooting boost. Falcao of course got a massive pace boost, 64 pace up to 83 and then 80 shooting up to 90 shooting. Even Sancho went from 74 shooting up to 83 shot. Now if you look at the records, they do have a lot of goals in, right, we have like most goals in a single UEFA Europa League campaign, youngest player to score 10 champions in goals, that wasn't Mbappe. Youngest to reach 30 Bundesliga goals, right? But assist for Oscar, he's still got a massive shooting upgrade and pace upgrade and then fastest to 200 Premier League wins was David Silva in this new set of players today. So we only got five players today but there are gonna be more coming and that is one thing I wanna mention as well. This was only tweeted on this SPORF website, I believe today, 1.3 million followers, they must be in the know with EA Sports because they said here five more to be released on Sunday. So it does look like we're gonna be getting five more record breaker cards because right now of course we have best of team of the week that is in packs and we also have the record breaker, the first five cards here. But it looks like according to this Twitter page that we are going to be getting five more record breaker cards which is very interesting. Now I wanna point out one other thing about these cards that we had today, right? With Falcao, with Oscar especially, these two cards. I kinda like what EA did with a couple of these cards today and I kinda like the way that EA is going with some of this stuff because they're giving some cards that are past legends or maybe players that aren't really meta but they're very just popular in terms of they have some sort of a past that people know them for like Oscar or like Falcao and Oscar, right? These guys maybe aren't super duper meta, FIFA Ultimate Team players that people use a lot in this game but these cards and these players mean a lot to people on this game and it's kinda like EA is giving this, you know, Falcao, Oscar, maybe we'll only get this one promo card during the year unless they somehow get a team in the season but at least this early on, I like how EA is giving these guys promo cards and they're juicing them up. Now it's kind of a two-fold scenario because yes, EA is giving us some of these cool items that they're making them usable, they're boosting their stats to a place that is really usable but also it's also like, hey, we're just trying to sell packs by boosting up these players for this one promo. This is Falcao, he's gonna get this card like with 83 pace, Oscar's gonna get a huge pace upgrade, David Silva's gonna get a huge pace upgrade on a card that is usually not meta and not used in this game. So that's the point that I like because they're giving us usable players of cards that are usually SBC fodder but I also kind of see it from the mindset of, okay, you're just putting different cards into packs that you can make more promos this year because these cards usually wouldn't get upgraded like this. Like David Silva wouldn't get a special card unless you got an inform, most likely but just the way EA is doing that this year, I guess I kind of commend them on that. So I wanted to kind of make a quick mention of that but again, those are the players that are in packs. Taking a quick look to the SBC section has been a lot of action in here over the day on Friday because of all the flash SBCs that have come out and of course this man right here. Sergio Aguero, 400 and about 50,000 coins for this card. Now a lot of you guys say, hey, why is his overall rating less than his card in this game? This is the same scenario that we kind of had with the Vitzel flashback SBC earlier this year. This is what another one of those EA meaningful moments upgrades where they are referring back to a point in time where Aguero of course back and maybe some of his other days, earlier days because this is dating back to the 2013, 2014 Premier League season. So we're going up 10 pace on this Aguero card.  So the biggest difference here is we went lower on the rating because it was, I guess, earlier in his career but they're going up on the pace and down on the shooting. So this is almost, if you kind of look at it this way, it's almost like a rule breakers upgrade. But of course it is to commemorate that 2013, 2014 season. This SBC is, I think, coming in somewhere around the gamut of about 450,000 coins, which a lot of people are doing because if you take a look at this card, four star, four star with a high agility, high balance with now pace with that still very high finishing and very good attack positioning is going to make this card pretty lethal. Yeah, Footpin says 471 right now for this Aguero card. So that is a pretty, I think it's a pretty solid price for this guy. People are going to be crafting in. And of course people open so many packs on this Black Friday weekend that a lot of people are going to be doing it. This is another player SBC that we got today. Technically it's a Flash SBC record breaker, Moritz Stoppelkamp for his 82 meter long range goal. This is a silver card technically so you should be able to use it in the Silver Lounge. Not terrible content, right? Pretty easy SBC. And then a lot of the stuff that we've seen here today as well has just been these Flash SBC challenges, right? 15 minutes left in this one. We had an 83 plus double upgrade, which was kind of a scam. And then an 83 or 81 plus three player pack which was very interesting as well. That was just the beginning of all the crazy packs that we have seen today. We'll talk about some more packs and supply stuff here in a second. But last scene to cover is the objectives. Two objectives I think today or maybe just one. This was our first week foot upgrade I believe. Our first week foot or skill upgrade that we've had in FIFA 21. Rodrigo got a four star week foot. I think this is the first one, but this is a huge W in terms of right wing players that you can use in this game. Definitely not end game. It's not a live upgrading item or anything like that, but it is a very solid card. It's not super duper hard to do. And I think a lot of people are gonna go out and do this objective. And then also the Black Friday objective with this win five, 10, 15, 25 in order to win some games and get some pretty decent packs. So that was kind of like a W objective. Now they are all untradable, even though here it doesn't say that by the pack. It's as up top in the fine print that it is untradable. But still kind of a W objective content today as well. Now let's start talking about the market and what kind of stuff went on today. The biggest set of cards that I wanna talk about that people are watching today wondering about were these two right here. Of course, the best of team of the week. And then of course, if we go to the front page of Foothead, these record breaker cards. Record breakers and the best of team of the week had the biggest market movements today in terms of just pure fluctuations. Because what we saw on Friday was crazy with some of these fluctuations. Now a couple hours before the content drop. So all of these record breaker cards were released into packs at 2 p.m. U.K., which is crazy. It's way different than normal. Now we're used to. We're used to all cards coming into packs at 6 p.m. U.K., the normal content drop time. But these guys came out early and that kind of made an interesting scenario for the market because people open saved up packs. There were a few promos in the store and you did see some of these cards get supplied onto the market. But what you also saw was people were expecting such a huge amount of supply at the 6 p.m. content drop time with the start of lightning rounds that these cards and the best of team of the week got panic sold hard right into 6 p.m. U.K. They were taking massive, massive drops. Kyle Walker's inform was around 465,000 coins right before the content drop. That was down from about 520,000 earlier in the morning. Now he has since kind of rebounded back and kind of even went down from where he originally rebounded back to. But this guy was 450,000, 460,000 coins on the PlayStation as we were about to head into 6 p.m. content and we were talking about it on stream. We were saying, yo, this stuff is just too low and we could tell that it was panic selling that was driving the price down. So all those people that were panic selling bought back in the first hour after 6 p.m. and Kyle Walker's inform went from 450 all the way back up to 530,000 coins in the span of an hour before the second lightning round came at 7 p.m. U.K. There was a huge buyback on the market. I was able to capitalize on this as a lot of people in the stream were on those rule breaker cards. Jadon Sancho's rule breaker, a record breaker, sorry. I'm gonna mix those two up all the time. We now have rule breakers and record breakers. So Sancho's record breaker went from 300 K flat before lightning rounds all the way up to 375 after that first hour of lightning rounds because the coin supply and the panic selling stopped and people ended up buying all those cards. I flipped a lot of the Ollie Watkins Informs today, bought the Sabah Manga 120 and the panic selling. These wine albums I bought at 31 to 32 K. These marshales, I had to sell kind of all over the place but I bought a lot of these at 61, 62. These Joe Gomez's were bought at 70,000 coins on snipe. So a lot of gold cards today exploded during the first and second lightning rounds on the market. The first, that timeframe where people were panic selling everything, everything exploded after that. It was honestly mental. It was crazy to see some of the bounce back on these cards. Renato Sanchez was another one. Renato Sanchez was another one today. His gold, his inform, not his gold, his inform card was 170,000 coins right before the content drop. He rebounded all the way back up later tonight to 215 K on the PlayStation now getting dropping back down because what is happening now is, and this is the second part and the biggest part of the video that I think is gonna affect what we see into today on the market, is the supply that is going to make the market drop off a decent amount. I think there's so much supply on some of these new, on these gold cards that were in packs and some of these out of packs informs that I think it is gonna make weakling sell off and dropping prices in the future because of all the supply. This is where we talked about and where we looked in graphs in previous years where we looked at a lot of stuff that just continued to drop over the weeks leading into Christmas. We saw a rebound after Black Friday for maybe a week or two and then drops off after that. And that is one very important thing that I wanna touch on today because we had one of the craziest things happen in Ultimate Team today in terms of supply because we had the 50K lightning round which wasn't that many packs. After the 50K lightning round, we had a 100K lightning round, which is normal, right? A 100,000 coin lightning round. Those packs were 250,100K packs. They sold out in like two minutes, right? We had the 125K lightning round after that and then after that, we had a crazy lightning round where they put out two Ultimate packs. They put out 50K packs with no time limit or no pack limit. You could literally sit there and just open 50K, 50K, 50K, 50K. No pack number. It was just a total time limit but unlimited packs for a certain amount of time for 50Ks. That was crazy. And they also did a lightning round for 81 plus seven rare player packs. I totally forget what the cost was. It was a 75,000 coin pack, I think. And it was wild. Like that lightning round, it was three hours after the content drop where we had 50K, 100K, 125. We thought it was gonna be over. Then they came back with even more supply and that's also what they have been releasing with these daily, the Flash SBCs. Take a look at some of these, right? Jumbo premium gold pack. Five rare gold player pick pack, tradable. That was the Aguero, there's the Rodrigo. Small rare gold players pack. That's half of 50K. Then we had the Silver Guy. Mega pack Flash SBC. 80 plus midfielder pack. Rare gold pack plus one rare gold player. 80 plus player pack. Flash SBC rare mixed player pack. I think we have another one coming in like 10 minutes or something like that. But the supply today has been incredible. And one thing that you did see on the market while the supply was happening during the lightning rounds, right? After that first lightning round, some cards hit their highest. We were looking at Hyunmin Sun. Hyunmin Sun was like under 80,000 coins. He was around 78, 77,000 coins on snipe today right before the first lightning round started. There was a lot of panic selling. He got down to that map mark. He went all the way back up to 90,000 coins. Almost 90K before the second lightning round started. When then all that supply came back in, his card dropped a little bit. It rebounded back up because people were still getting coins, buying cards for their team during the second and third lightning rounds. But since the fourth lightning round happened today, a lot of these cards have started to drop back off again because they've just become more and more supplied. And we've seen that with those informs as well. I was showing you the Renato Sanchez and the Kyle Walker. Those are perfect examples of this because Renato Sanchez was 215,000 coins earlier today. And the man is now in the 180,000 coin range under 190. And it's just because purely of all the supply that has come out on this game today. Packs after packs after packs. Yes, people bought all these cards up for their week and leave teams. They're gonna be playing week and league. But at some point it is gonna drop back down. So I think you're gonna see even today, even though we're in Black Friday and the market has gone up a ton, icons are up like crazy, right? Out-of-pack special cards are up like crazy. I do think you're gonna see panic selling today, or not panic selling, but I do think you're gonna see a market sell off starting early today, especially on those best of team of the week informs. There might be some selling into 6 p.m. content. They might rise a little bit after that if we don't have any crazy pack supply or more lightning rounds or whatever. But I do think that it is all that supply is really gonna affect a lot of the gold prices that were in packs unless it's a really meta card. I do think you will see some of those kind of tail off because think about all the people that, again, going back to our Hyunmin Sun example here, Sun went from 78K in the panic selling right under 80,000 coins all the way up to 90, right? He then got, there was more lightning rounds. He went from 90K back down to like low 80s, went right back up to 88,000 coins, more lightning rounds came, dropped down from all the supply back down to the mid to low 80s, and maybe went up a little bit since then, and has now been kind of struggling to get back up at a high 80 range just because there isn't enough demand for everybody to buy these cards for the week in league teams that there was. And if you look at a lot of the graphs, it was like a big panic sell, a big rise, and it's just like this all day yesterday. It was kind of crazy, all of these market movements that happened. So again, if you have your week in league team and you're happy with it, then rock it, right? Because if you have out of pack special cards, like some of the rule breakers today, went up a bunch, some of the road to the final cards really went up a lot today. Road to the final hazard is like 800K right now, which is wild to me considering this guy was like 600 something thousand when he was in packs. Yeah, hazard is 800K right now at the moment. That's pretty wild in my opinion. A lot of the road to the finals went up today. A lot of ones to watches were really, really low today. And they have started to rebound because people have noticed that they got really low and they were looking to invest in them. One person that I was kind of hot on today was Gareth Bale. He's risen back up from about a hundred and he was like almost 100K. It was like 105, he's now back up to 120. So just keep an eye on some of these OTWs that might have games today. I think I was watching Sané because Bayern played today on Saturday. Bayern, he's up, he's 325,000 coins. He was in the low 300s, even lower than 300,000 coins today. But this is kind of an area of the market that maybe got overlooked a little bit earlier today just because the fact that all the focus was on the new record breakers, the Flash SBCs and all of that pack supply. So I do think that pack supply is gonna impact the market content-wise today. I don't really know if I expect anything massive. I mean, there's so much to do right now in FIFA. There's just tons of stuff to do. Flash SBCs are coming out like every two or three hours. Even overnight tonight, we've got a Guerrero SBC. We've got this record breaker SBC. We had new icons that came out yesterday. We got 81 plus double packs. We have got the team of the week packs throughout. The new player SBCs for a Guerrero and stuff like that. There's just a lot to do, especially with the Rodrigo objective. It's Weekend League, a lot of people. There's a new team event. I haven't even looked at that, but honestly, I don't really care about team events that much. But I do think, again, you are gonna see a little bit of a downturn on the market today. Some prices on the really meta cards like some of these icons probably won't drop off that much this weekend. Since these record breakers are impacts until Tuesday, I believe. Best of team leaks impacts until Monday. I think record breakers are impacts until Tuesday. I don't expect a ton of panic today unless EA drops a big time SBC. Now, if you're talking SBC fodder, and I haven't talked about that, it's one thing I wanna mention really quick. Talking about the actual SBC fodder on the game today, 83s before the content drop are like 1.6, 1.7K. Of course, with all of the best of team of the week cards packable from the team of week upgrade SBC, those are now up to 2.2, 2.3K. PK is kind of the guy that I used for my SBC fodder barometer, if you would say. This guy was like 14,000 coin, like 14,250 earlier today before the lightning rounds actually happened. Aguero came out. This guy's now back up to 16K. So doing SBCs is a bit more expensive right now because of the Aguero that came out today. A lot of people are doing that. And honestly, since we have icon SBCs that are in the SBC section, that's just more demand. Even though not as many people are doing those, people are starting to chip away at them because they open packs today. They pack some decent stuff. They say, yo, I got these cards in my club. I could go do an SBC and then they end up going and buying cards to do that SBC. So there is a slight bit of demand for the icon SBCs that are out right now. So again, if you do wanna buy any of these record breaker players today, I would expect some sell-off headed into the 6PM UK timeframe because I do think people are maybe expecting more lightning rounds today. Like John and Sacha right now is 350, I believe. Now if this guy drops on PlayStation down to like the low 300s again, tomorrow I might get interested before the content drop because people might then buy him back and then try to finish out their week and links with him. We do see that often with some of the new promo cards is panic selling into 6PM on a Saturday and then rising after that because either pack supply doesn't come or the content isn't super hype and people buy some of those cards back to just try them out on week and links. So just kinda keeping on that on Mbappe, David Silva, Sancho would be the main ones that I would keep an eye on because I think those are the most hyped out of this new set. Yeah, Sancho, Mbappe and David Silva would be the most hyped ones. Just keeping an eye out for that today. A lot of us made coins today. I hope you guys are in that margin but there was a massive, massive rise in the market. And that was the craziest thing to see was just again all the coins that came onto the game today with all the supply and how that pushed the market so, so high tonight. And I do think it will start to kinda trickle down today on Saturday and especially on a Sunday depending on the content that we see and what EA maybe tries to tease and put out with more content and stuff. So we will see what happens but markets high if you got stuff maybe take the coins on it if you think it's gonna go lower especially some of those golds like maybe Werner's son. I think those guys drop a little bit more, Marshal, Lucas. I think those guys drop a little bit more before they were to rebound again into this next week. So that's something we're gonna be aware of and talking about very closely over the weekend period. But if you guys enjoyed this video smash the thumbs on it, comment down below if you have any questions and of course subscribe to the channel if you're new. Thank you for all the support on the YouTube videos recently. You guys are incredible. And yeah, hopefully it's helping out and I enjoy doing it. So again, happy Saturday. Good luck with your weekend league. It's been Nate the Foot Accountant. Catch you guys later. Peace out.


So we've had kind of a problem with not only the Eutherford Dilemma, but the other dilemma posed by the same, you know, premises. So we had the Eutherford Dilemma, we talked about this last time, and it has a conclusion that theists really don't like that either morality is arbitrary or morality is independent of the divine. And the other dilemma that's caused by this is that something that atheists and agnostics really won't like, namely that there is a divine. So a question is, can we avoid either dilemma? One way to avoid the dilemma, you know, these are both, these are both the duckly valid arguments. So if we're going to reject the conclusions, we have to reject the premises from which they come. Well, let's look at, you know, what they have different. Dealing with the premises two and three, can we reject either premise two or three? Well, we'll look at that one. You know, this is what the premises look like rejected, right? This isn't what they were originally. This is what they look like rejected. Well, if we reject premise two, then what we have is that what is moral is moral because it's commanded by the divine and morality is not arbitrary. Well, how would it not be arbitrary? The only thing to divine command to morality is that it's commanded by divinity. Well, that seems to be just as arbitrary as if it's just commanded by anything else. Or if the divine commanded one thing, okay, but could the divine have commanded something else? So it's hard to see how this rejection of two could possibly be true. And three, divine commands what's moral because it's moral and it's false, that the morality is independent of the divine. Okay, but you got to tell the story. How is it that morality is not independent of the divine? After all, the divinity apparently is going to morality to figure out what the divinity can or cannot command. Well, that's not going to help the theists out very much. Well, let's look over at five and six. What is moral is moral because it's commanded by the divine and it's false that there is a divine. This looks like a direct logical contradiction. It's a lot like saying the elephant is sitting on my bed and there is no elephant. It's at least an absurdity if not an out and out direct self-contradiction. The same thing is true for six. The divine commands what's moral because it's moral and it's false that there is a divine. So we have direct contradictions of both five and six and it looks like direct contradictions of two or three when trying to reject them. So rejecting two, three, five or six isn't going to get anybody anywhere. What are we going to do? Well, the only premise that they have in common is the first one. Either what is moral is moral because the divine commands it or the divine commands what is moral because it's moral. This is the first premise for both the limits. So if the theist, the atheist and the agnostic are kind of get their way out of this, they got to figure out a way to reject that first premise and at least on its surface it looks like these are the only two possibilities. In order to reject this premise, we got to figure out a third or fourth or a fifth possibility regarding the relationship between morality and divinity. How are we going to do that? Well, one way is we could start or maybe the idea is we could start looking at these other theories that have already been given to us by these philosophers and ask ourselves is morality either arbitrary or independent with these other theories? And if they're not arbitrary or independent, if they escape the horns of the dilemma that way, can we talk about these theories with the divinity?