Hey guys it's Nate aka The Foot Accountant and welcome back to the channel. It's been a pretty crazy weekend of content inside of FIFA 23 with its trophy Titans promo bringing us the 90 plus team of the year foot birthday or prime icon pack. We had the Ozil SBC yesterday but have we seen all of the good content so far and will the rest of this week kind of quiet down and maybe not as exciting of a week in terms of content. We'll take a look and talk about that today because if that's gonna be the case I think there are some cards right now on this game that we might have a potential to invest in for some price rises in the next couple of days. I also wanna look at what should happen today on a Monday of content even with the market maybe rising as early as this morning. So if you're excited for the video today if it helps you out I'll drop a thumbs up on it and of course subscribe if you are new. Let's take a quick look back to yesterday because yesterday on FIFA we did get a WSBC and a couple unexpected ones starting off with the Ozil end of an era. This is one that so many people were looking forward to and EA pretty much delivered with this card. Five star skills, four star weak foot, a high low work rate change is very nice. The stats on this card are really good considering the price that it is and the fact that he kept the five star skills because the links are not that amazing but 99 vision, 99 ball control, insane traits, finesse shot, flares, flair passes, swerve pass, he has like all of the passing traits which is very very deserved. A nice card for Mesut Ozil, only about 140,000 coins to do. It's not very difficult with an 84 and 86 rated squad that is very easy to craft over the next couple of days. I mean the only part about this that you maybe say is an L is that his Winter Wild Cards SBC had five star five star so we had the five star weak foot in there as well but for German links for some Arsenal fans that is an Ozil card that I'm sure a lot of people are going to be doing and it is a nice upgrade and a nice price for me. I'd also say there if that one is something you want to do go ahead and do it. Now yesterday we had upgrade packs as well which is weird because usually we get sorts of upgrade packs on Monday like today. That also is making me wonder what in the world is EA going to drop today but yesterday we had the silverware smelting upgrade and the trophy crafting upgrade right? Kind of going with this trophy Titans theme. Guys, this double 80 plus upgrade, this I think is our upgrade pack for the week. I don't expect if anything it would be a small upgrade pack today on Monday. I think this is our like repeatable upgrade pack that we are going to be getting this week. So you need 10 commons and one rare. It's not a terrible price. It's not as good as the 80 plus times three but it is a bit cheaper. It's about 5000 coins per pack so that is a GG from EA and unfortunately this pack is not unlimited repeatable because it would be really nice if it was but you can turn in a squad of non-rare golds or sorry non-rare bronzes and silvers to get a pack that gives you exactly what you need to do the trophy crafting upgrade. Also the first SBC ever with the word crafting in it maybe. That's kind of interesting but I just wish they would not have made this available only seven times unless that's going to repeat daily which I'm sure that it might. These are out for 27 days. Now one big part of this as well that could lend those upgrade packs to not being the only upgrades that we get this week is these are attached to a milestone objective. The trophy crafting upgrade completionist which is very very nice. This one to me I think is more completable than the 80 plus when they put out during centurions but you get a couple packs along the way here for and a couple icons as well as Shemsheko base, Ballak base, Barnes you get some icons and packs along the way for completing this so that's out for like 27 days which is a W in my opinion but the fact that we had those upgrades released might mean whatever upgrade packs we get today may not be as good so we'll take a look at that of course when we talk about today's content but I want to talk about the market first because practices are already starting to rise on some special cards because with content being a little bit quieter yesterday and of course already getting upgrade packs in that 90 plus that really the big SBC that is now coming gone is that 90 plus icon pack that was the big SBC that was causing a lot of panic and striking a lot of fear into kind of like the market on this game over the past couple of days but now that that is all arrived it's like okay what's next and that's really the question that I'm asking and that's what I'm feeling right now what is next for the market on this game because it's full birthday is over guys right full birthday was a really good promo in terms of all the content that we are getting it was super grindable with objectives and SBCs and all of that but I really think what EA are kind of doing right now is they're gonna kind of slow the content down a bit before team in the season and we see them often do this before really really big promos and when the content slows down and there's still a lot of demand for people to play this game I think the market could do really really well this week and that's why I was just looking at some live cards because some of these cards have already started to go up in price as I think the market is getting ready for some of these live cards to get upgraded and live cards are always some of the first investment that's why we talked about them in the last couple videos because I knew that when the market was gonna start to turn back up a little bit if the content kind of allowed that then that was gonna be the case right Barela yesterday on Sunday was around 250k at its lowest and now you can see rising up to about 270,000 coins because these guys have games tomorrow and on Wednesday right we've got road to the final cards back in action so for the cards that are playing they are playing for a plus one upgrade for qualifying to the next round so no upgrades for these will take place this week they will all take place after next week's second leg games for all of these cards but if any of them that are playing like maybe I don't know Fofana still is one that kind of interests me I was really trying to get him at like 350 or something like that yesterday he was like 354 that would have been a really good price to pick him up you know the Barela is up already Raspidori at like 195 I think okay but I just don't know how much rise potential we have here just because he's a very very invested in card now these road to the finals and some of these fantasy cards are already going up so it's a bit tougher to invest in these Park Jisung 560 right I think some of your fantasy upgrades I don't know if they're gonna happen today or tomorrow but get ready for some upgrades today on FIFA as well I think we're gonna get the five star five star plus two upgrade on Thomas Moynier today because the showdown upgrades on Mondays and Tuesdays is very common from the weekend games hopefully it's today on Monday but watch out for this card being really really hyped today as so many people would like to try him out after he gets a five star five star boost and his plus two upgrade for Dortmund beating junior Berlin on the weekend now why are we talking about road to the finals and live cards because they're already going up now what part of the market could we actually invest in right now I'm looking at the impacts cards of the trophy Titans and here's why you might be like Nate why would I want to invest in these cards right now if they are still in packs what would be the reason to invest these cards well first of all these cards are incredibly cheap but we know why right we know why these guys are super cheap it's because the pack weight on these cards is higher than we really ever expected it to be on icons and we know that pack weight is really impacted by these the junior icons right or what people kind of jokingly called the little bro icons right this is the little bro long because it's 92 the bigger one the big bro is 93 rated right it's kind of fun to have different versions of these cards for some of them but for some of these guys I really feel like like these are icons man and these have dynamic images with them holding trophies and their prices are already down so much to where their other icon versions were and if you think about it we get a lot of the packs apply every single week on this game on the weekends because foot champions is the most popular game mode it gives out the best packs and EA gifted everybody qualification again this last weekend so so many people got rewards during the weekend and even this morning on Wednesday I think that is going to bring some more demand especially after as the masses get the rewards today right Mondays are always big rewards they because not everybody knows they can finish their games they just stop at their rank and that's why you see the market rise pretty nicely on Mondays is because people get rewards they get coins open packs and you see prices go up because people want to go and try some new cards and I think that with the supply really ending throughout this weekend I don't see a lot of new like packs being added to the store apart from some untradable ones during the rest of this week and without really any leaks that we have right now like there's literally zero leaks for like upcoming content that is like I guess worrisome for me if you know what I'm saying like there's no big icon pack that's looming they could come soon all for a notorious with the just had W rebound here I just bought one at 1.31 he is up to 1.4 so we love that these cards are moving if you take a look at some of their prices like let's take a look at a bird camp I was just looking at him yesterday bird camp started the day on Sunday at about 490,000 coins kind of where he is right now he had a spike up to 550 he went all the way back down to 500 and then went back to 525 but these guys are fluctuating a lot in price who's another one Roberto Carlos had a spike yesterday I bought a Roberto Carlos late on Saturday night right here about 700k he spiked it to 760 which is not much profit but it is a decent bit right but you see these cards are starting to fluctuate a bit because their icons and their rare and I think if the content is going to be a bit drier this week and there's not going to be as many insane things these cards will be the most exciting thing that people want to go on in the game and to try out of course grinding some objectives but there's not as many objectives as for birthday and there's not as many SBCs apart from the ones that are still existing from the foot birthday promo as well so that has me I mean it does seem a bit risky guys because when how many often times do we invest in a promo team on like a Monday morning or you know this early in the week not very often but with the way the content looks this week if EA do kind of slow down with the content a little bit I think this is going to be our best opportunity for a lot of these cards especially if it's one that you want to get into your team and try out for a couple of days I don't expect the market to do absolutely incredible things over the next couple of days and like I'm not expecting like Philip Lam to go to like 700,000 coins or anything crazy like that but I think we could see some nice you know 10% rises on some of these cards just because the content might be a bit lackluster throughout the rest this week and let's be honest guys icons are just icons anytime icon packs are dropped icon SBCs are dropped everybody is interested in icons because they are you know they don't play real life anymore it's not like they can go get a team of the week next week and get a new card and yes we expect different types of icons to be released still throughout the rest of this game but like icons just hit different FIFA they always have they always will and that's why I'm super interested into looking at some of these cards I've already invested some of my coins into a few of these that I think have good rise potential in the next couple of days so the risk here is EA drops really good content and we see those cards drop because either packs apply or panic selling kind of happens right what's the good content that could make these cards not go up well the first thing is you think about Mondays we've gotten like those year-in-review player picks or campaign bag player picks recently well currently we have a year-in-review player pick that is still here until tomorrow on Tuesday it doesn't go away till tomorrow so I don't think they would drop another one of these today unless they really wanted to a different type of player pick pack but even then those are really cheap SBCs and probably wouldn't affect most of these icons since they're on the mid to higher tier market so I really feel like today is not a bad time to get on some of these cards now again I would tell you do not hold them for very long as I've been trading with a lot of loms I love this guy he went up again Sunday morning from Saturday night Sunday morning was great I got all these at like a hundred to a hundred and five thousand coins selling them all into the 120s and 130s big W profits in this guy I know a lot of people are investing in this LAM and again let me point this out if LAM LAM today could be impacted I think he's the most popular card that is in this release but I do believe this LAM card might be impacted a bit because of the upgrade to Thomas Moyniere so I know that LAM can play left back as well and Moyniere cannot play left back but with Moyniere getting a 5-5 today that mate I'm not buying any LAMs today and I might regret this decision because this guy has been so good to trade with but with Moyniere potentially getting his upgrade earlier this morning I don't want to risk it with this card I'd rather risk it with some of the other ones that I see being very hyped but as we go throughout the rest this week content just looks to be kind of mid so don't hold on these cards forever like I was starting to say because team of the season is not that far and we could get more SBCs of course EA trying to drain coins from our clubs and stuff like that if EA were to release any information about team of the season whether it's voting pre-team of the season warm up to tots that sort of stuff you we know that that's gonna start to create some panic but until we see that sort of thing I really think that these cards are gonna do pretty decent unless EA have some pretty crazy content in mind which I just I don't know guys I really don't so I don't want to waffle on any longer but if there's any cards that you see to look like we're good investments there I think those are decently safe even though the pack weight of these trophy tight ends is a lot higher than we would have ever expected it's got these prices a lot lower than we would ever expected and I think creates a decent investing opportunity there now speaking of content today on Monday right we already had some upgrade packs but since these upgrade packs are tied to objectives are they really going to be the only upgrades that we get this week you know I've gone back and forth on this I know at the beginning of video that I said and I kind of thought that these might be the only ones I could see them being the only upgrade packs that we get I don't remember during Centurions if we had anything else dropped besides that 80 plus during the first week or if we didn't but you know I could maybe see a player pick that's being dropped today maybe some sort of SBC they drop alongside of this but again without any leaks there's nothing really to expect besides that those selector packs right and those are technically player picks but those are player picks that you can save right there was an 84 plus and a 75 plus selectors pack which we'll check out here in a second after I pack something sick or not what's my this is my first 80 plus double am I really gonna get nothing oh two dupes love that I absolutely love that but these are I believe the only packs that are added to the code right now that we really haven't seen but an 84 plus player pick and a 75 plus player pick that you can save as a pack you know maybe that is coming today but that's just kind of the only other potential SBCs that we have kind of like you know a tangible leak or a code that's been added to look at and think about so it might be a really quiet Monday today there's no other player SBC leaks though of course could be surprises by all means EA could drop something in the game today that's just kind of surprises us but it might be a quiet start to the week with all of these things considered here now I do want to talk about fodder we have not talked about fodder yet and this is a big part of the market that has had some fluctuations but it's down again and I think if you guys want to buy some 86s this 90 plus pack it does refresh at the end of the week and I think that again if the supply is gonna be kind of ending today all of these 86s on Saturday remember they went from 13k to about 17,000 coins and now we're looking at 86s back down 14,000 coins maybe even 13k on a bid really good potential here I think if you want to stock some in the club if you're gonna do any more SBCs throughout the week 86s to 88s especially 86s at 87s are back down a little bit again I think they could rise throughout the duration of this week 84s 85s and in 83s for that matter as well it all just depends on what other SBCs we get to see if these cards are going to rise up I still love that low tier part of the market for an investment soon just not quite yet it there's nothing that has been dropped there's no team of the season warm-up yet to make those cards go up for packs that we're trying to save but when that switch flips we will be all in on the low tier but for right now it's just not here yet and I also want to talk about investing in a team of the week as well because team of the week usually start to rise out of the weekend a bit I'm actually kind of a big fan of a few cards this team week first of all Benzema Lebedevsky as 92 rated cards if you take a look 92s have dropped a significant amount right a lot of these guys Casimir 99k rushed 96,000 coins a lot of these guys are cheapest 92s because Lebedevsky and Benzema are dragging the fodder prices down there and also 93 closer 96,000 coins a nice card with a nice upgrade inside of the trophy titans team but he is the cheapest 93 in the game at 97k so that's not a bad look even for fodder or just as an investment because it's the most usable closer we've ever seen De Bruyne is going to be really rare from this team of the week Raphael layout tons of 88 rates in his team of the week it's crazy but some of them are really usable too Wynaldum, Sane, Medina and Laia were all pretty usable I think if you want to get in on some team of the week cards might be a decent time to do that early this morning before some of them could probably go up a bit more during the rest of this week so I'm pretty bullish on the market to use the the economic terms there I'm really bullish on the market now you could also be like Nate I don't want to mess with stuff that is in packs and you could look to out-of-packs cards you could look at some fantasy foots maybe there's somebody that's getting an upgrade this week that has not been upgraded yet like Fabian for PSG is rising because he's finally getting an upgrade he was like 170s 180s and now he's basically 200,000 coins so a really nice rise there I saw Ruben Diaz was really really cheap for a moment yesterday how much is he he's like 720k he's 760 now so there's still a lot of fluctuations on the out-of-packs market if you want to trade there with maybe some foot birthday cards right if there's any foot birthdays that are low Bruno Gamerash I saw was really low some cards are going up a lot but guys like maybe Genduzzi could be a look from the many of these being extra rare Emerson's under 100k he's like 99,000 coins Darwin Nunez no shot 560k wow for the five star skills version 565,000 coins for this card what was he yesterday he was between 550 and 600 well I guess he just dropped off a lot when that icon pack came out on the weekend but kind of use your best judgment on trading and stuff like that with out-of-packs cards at this time as well because I think there's a lot of opportunity out there for a couple quick market bounce backs this week not something you wouldn't hold on to for very long but something you might be able to quick flip and trade with throughout this week so I'm not going to sit here and talk forever because it feels like content's really slowing down but I mean I would be fine if EA surprises with something they maybe some sort of upgrade pack maybe some sort of cool objective we still have the draft objectives that are going on at the moment so there's some gameplay to grind there but for me this week I'm going to be pretty market focused and market heavy trying to grind the trades and grind the flips as well as hitting the upgrade packs trying to pack some of these trophy Titans cards and we're just kind of waiting for like team two right we know we have some some team two leaks already but we'll probably get more information about team two later on and we'll see if EA have anything up their sleeves for some content this week that would be crazy and different but for now I feel pretty bullish on the market I have invested in some cards we're probably going to invest in some more and see if we can pay off some dividends get some dividends off those investments here in the next coming day so that's going to be the video for me today guys if you did enjoy it smash thumbs up on a comment below if you have any questions and subscribe if you're new it's been Nathan with accounting catch you guys today in the stream peace


I hear you, Eileen. Is that better? Let me turn this up, see if that's the issue. I was having some issues before that's why it took me a while to get on, but I'm all good now. Okay. Can you hear me now? Yes. There's Eileen. I'm going to be back in a minute. I think Nathan will be a few minutes late joining, but, and Nathan's having some audio issues. He looks like he's logging out and logging back in. So as soon as he is on the call, you can call the meeting to order, or if you want to wait a few more minutes, we're still expecting Melanie to join late. And. I think that's it. Jeff will not join today. So Nathan is three, 2330. Actually now. Let's see here. We only have. I only see two people besides me. Right. Yeah. So let's wait till Nathan. Is. So we have enough. Correct. Correct. And Nathan, if you would try your audio and visuals out, it would be great. I saw him for a sec. Hi, Nathan. Can you hear? Yeah. Great. Computer. Okay. No worries. I'm glad you're here. Let's see here. So are we ready Eileen? We are. All right. I call this meeting to order. Good afternoon and happy. It's March 1st. So because of COVID, I have to read this. This intro. So due to the provisions of the governor's executive orders in 25, 20 and in 29, 20, which has been certain requirements of the Brown act and. In the order of health officer of the county of Sonoma to shelter in place to minimize the spread of COVID. The art and public places committee will be conducting today's meeting. Members and staff are participating from remote locations and or participating. Appropriate social distancing. Members of the public may view and listen to the meeting as noted on the city's website. And as noted on the agenda. Members of the public wishing to speak during item. Number. Number three. Public comment. Or by pressing. Star nine on their phone. And then they will be giving the ability to address the committee. The recording secondary. We'll take a roll. Chair. Right. By chair. Here. Member. President. Member Baumgarten. Partner. Sorry. And member. President. And member. And member Jones Carter. I'm so sorry. Member Jones Carter. Okay. Hey. She just joined us. She had to miss all the beginning of my stuff. And then Tara. Did you have an announcement? Yes, thank you. Before we get started. I would just like to acknowledge Monica Bryant. I would like to acknowledge Monica Bryant. Who's term recently ended on the committee. I want to thank her for her over four years of service. And recognize her for her support of the arts in Santa Rosa. And in the community. So on behalf of the public art program and the art and public places committee. With the city of Santa Rosa. Thank you, Monica, for your service. Thanks, Tara. Okay. So we're going to move on to. I would just like to acknowledge Monica Bryant. Who's term recently ended on the committee. So we're going to move on to. I lean already did world calls. We'll move on to public comments. If you wish to make a comment via zoom, please select the raise hand button. If you are dialing via phone, please press star nine. Raise your hand. Each speaker. Has three minutes. A countdown timer will appear for the convenience of the speaker and viewers. Please make sure you to mute yourself when you're invited to do so. Your microphone will be muted at the end of the countdown. We have, do we have any comments from the public who wish to make comments? We have any raise hands at this time. Let's see here. If there are no public comments, then we'll go ahead and we'll move on to the next item. Proval of minutes. Copies of February 1st, 2021 meeting minutes have been distributed for your review. Are there any additions or corrections to these minutes? If not, do I have a motion to approve the minutes as written? Hold on. I have a correction. I noted that my last name was spelled wrong under committee member reports. So that was all. I will make that correction. Thank you. Do I have a motion to approve minutes? With the Christian. With vice chairs, Christian. Corrections. So moved. Do I have a second? I can second. Great. All in favor. Okay. Proved as a minute meetings are approved with the correction. Hi. Sorry about that. Moving on to the next item. Schedule five. Number five scheduled items and we have 5.1. And that's going to be the 21 22 annual work plan and recommendation. Expedenture. Tara will be presenting the draft annual work plan and. Well, this expedition plan will be for the next fixed fiscal year, July 1st, 2021. Tara. I'm going to share my screen so that we can follow along with the document that was attached to the agenda. Which is the annual work plan. And recommended expenditure plan for the year. 2021 22. Hold on one moment. I'll share my screen. Okay. Can everybody see that? Okay. Thank you. So this is a typical for the public art program in early, a new, the beginning of a new calendar year. To start planning for the next fiscal year, which runs July 1 through June 30th. In terms of what the public art program. Public places committee will be working on for that year. And the anticipated expenditures to go along with the draft annual work plan. And that will be for the next fiscal year. And we will be implementing that work plan. This year is a little bit different because we recently. Endeavored to. Draft and then subsequently adopt a new strategic plan for the next four years. So you will see that obviously reflected in this plan, but I'd like to go through a little bit of. A little bit of what we're going to be doing in the next four years. So we're going to be looking at what are in this draft work plan and expenditure plan. And then answer any questions that you might have about that or the dollar amounts. So. Like I said, typically early in the year, we go through a process of kind of looking at what we may be doing. What funds we have and what projects. And sometimes that includes input from the community. Sometimes that includes input from. Different opportunities across the city organization in terms of large scale capital projects where art could be included. Or partnerships with other divisions or departments. So this year, like I said, is different because there's a. We adopted a strategic plan for the public art program, which really directs our operations for the next four years. And lays out the recommended expenditures or anticipated expenditures to implement the plan. So number one on this work plan is the. First full fiscal year implementation of our strategic plan. And then we're going to be looking at, we're going to be looking at, we're going to be looking at, we're going to be looking at, with the recommended expenditures along with that. The main four categories that are strategic plan. Kind of grouped items in our community. Engagement and input. Governance and administration. Programming and projects and PR and marketing. And under each of those are. We're going to be looking at the implementation of this first, this first year of the, of the plan. So you will also notice some asterisks. Buy some of the items. And so I wanted to call out and explain. How we have kind of combined this overview of our annual work plan. And the strategic plan with our normal operations and those expenses. And so in each year, the public art program has certain expenses for sculpture. Sculpture and public art program or I should say public art collection, maintenance, maintenance of our collection. We have expended expenditures, expenses for ongoing contractor, contractors or consultants, or temp employees. We have expenditures for regularly scheduled or anticipated projects, That aren't specified at the time, but we know we want to spend a certain amount of money on projects each year. And so those that that generally those are those are shown here with the asterisks is and and those are recurring a cost that we already had in the public art program. They're built into this plan, this way, so that you can see the whole picture of what type of work we will be doing in the next year. The reason that they that that you may notice that this number of the total recommended expenditures for this next fiscal year is maybe different from what you saw in our strategic plan, which summarized year by year expenses for the public art program to implement the strategic plan. This is is that that that amount for the fiscal year 21 22 combined with those regular expected kind of recurring expenses. So, because what the strategic plan did was essentially only put in additional costs to what the program already had. That's what it is showing will that the implementation plan for the strategic plan only calculated additional costs over and above what we were already doing to run the program. So that's why those numbers are a little bit different. And I can kind of go through in that in more detail if needed but I wanted to call that out to be transparent on that. You know the projects that are called out here under programming and projects. There's there's a lot of projects that we're going to try to undertake this next year. I think a lot of them will be things that are done with with partnerships that's called out as one of our approaches, obviously, but we have our ongoing maintenance there. We have commissions and grants to artists which essentially serves the purpose of the projects the actual public art projects we would be doing. So that's the outsourced work meaning our contractors built into it, as well as our ongoing maintenance. So that that's really the main part that the main emphasis of this annual work plan, but in addition to that I wanted to briefly touch on a couple other items that are included under number two artists and city planning and projects this actually was included on last year's work plan, but last year's work plan was really hindered by the pandemic starting shortly, shortly thereafter or yeah shortly thereafter so. So there weren't, there was not much movement on this item last fiscal year, although now we're starting those conversations so I included it on this year's or I should say next year's annual work plan. So that we can really consider these as as priority items to consider in the public art programs. Participation so the two specific items that I feel like are really realistic goals and projects for us to be involved in in some way, even if we don't know exactly how yet are the two that are listed there the general plan update that the city is now starting, which is a process that will essentially create a new general plan for the city. A general plan is a, you know, a policy guiding document that looks at the city's future over the next 20 years. So we're looking we're talking to the team in with the city that is spearheading that effort and figuring out how we could bring an artist on board to be a part of the process of writing and developing that plan, and also what public art and engagement opportunities there may be in that process. So the other opportunity is for the San Rosa Avenue corridor plan implementation that is a plan the city's had for quite some time and we have an estimated timeline of that beginning in the spring of 2022. There is an opportunity for an artist to come on board, potentially to be a part of the design team and or to be included in designing or providing input for artistic components of that plan. So there, there's a variety of amenities that will be a part of that project that may include benches or bike racks or crosswalk art, but there's also mural opportunities potentially at the highway 12 over crossing. So those are two projects that I feel are deserving of the public art programs involvement in a way that I think is exciting for the program to consider having an artist be brought on board as part of the team in the development of projects. But we don't have a clear yet idea exactly how that will look what funding would be needed. So I hope to bring back to this committee, more concrete proposals for both of those things as we move forward but I wanted to make sure they are included on this work plan. The remaining items on the list three, four, five and six are all in progress projects that will continue through this next annual work plan period. And they include the imagine art and old courthouse square project, the Fifth Street parking garage project, the Depot Park public art project and returning the Asawa art panels to courthouse square. So with that, I would be happy to answer any questions from the committee. Do any committee members have questions for Tara regarding this item. If so, please physically raise your hand and just a reminder at this point it's questions only no discussion. Melanie. Oh, within a category. I have a heading like programming and projects 187,500. So are we, how do we know what's in each one of those little bullet points, or is it money that can move around, or how does that work. Yeah, good question. And then look at, let's see if I have it open, you can look at our strategic. Can you still see my window did it switch to this other document. Okay, thanks. If you look at the strategic plan in the back of the document there's the implementation plan. And then there's one of the documents is the expenditure implications and, and you can look through there to see where those dollar amounts are going to show up like for instance, conduct a public art audit is budgeted at $25,000 for this next year so that's, that would be this first bullet point line item. And so on and so on so you can find the numbers within the strategic plan document, and then. And then some of the items were not included the dog that the line item is included in the strategic plan but the dollar amount is not because like I said before the strategic plan only captured new costs above and beyond what we already anticipate each year. And so you won't see those so for instance ongoing maintenance is about $50,000 a year and commissions to and grants to artists is about $50,000 a year so. So I can provide the committee with a detailed breakdown of that if you'd like to see that but it's all there in various places. So that's a follow up question. So, is it your feeling that we would approve this today or do we have some time to review this. The request is for this to be approved today, since we are putting in our budget requests to the city to go through the budget process, however, the committee needs more time and isn't comfortable with approving it today we can make accommodation for that. Lisa you're on mute. There we go. I thought I saw some other hands do we have other questions. Yeah. I wonder, can I talk. Oh yes, only see a little bit. I was curious about you bringing up bringing in the opportunities for artists to come on both those projects to advise and to have input and design, which I love that I wondered. The money included for that already over the money had to be. And are the other people that are involved is their funding also included in here are who are the other people that are involved in planning. Yeah, that's a good question. And essentially, no, the answer is no to basically both of those we don't. We don't know what funding is yet available and from from the kind of host departments that are running the project. And we have not included the funding in this work plan and expenditure plan. There, there are potentially some available funds from those from those host departments or through grants and potentially the kind of public art fund reserves what what we have in the bank so to speak could be allocated for those future projects. Can I follow up the question just in this how these things work with me not knowing. I'm bringing artists in and like I'm asking about the other people that are on the commissioner already doing the work, or slated from other departments, assuming they're not designed people is like is it a request to be or is like, who grants that kind of access and also weight of decision making to that artist. Yeah, we don't fully know that structure yet. One of, yeah, one of the ideas that we have is just structure both both projects, but in particular the general plan as somewhat of an artist in residence type of program where the artist is in residence with the city of Santa Rosa for the purpose of working on that project. What it looks like and what structure we create for that is, we would essentially be starting from scratch we have some great. There are some great examples from other cities and other organizations who have done similar type projects that we would be looking at. But yes, we would be creating everything for fresh for us here. Yeah. Thank you. Nathan. I saw you had your hand up. Yeah, could you just tell us a little bit more about the Depot Park public art. Yeah, and so the Depot Park project was started I believe three and a half years ago. And there was funds set aside for an artist to come in and work with kind of work in conjunction with some planned refreshing of the landscape there that the parks department was going to be doing. And so we have a current contract with an artist to put in a piece of art in in that space. And because of the kind of the work needing to be done in conjunction with the landscaping was held up due to some plans needed to be drawn up for the actual landscaping and any changes to the site. And unfortunately we just got hit with fires and the pandemic and it really slowed down any work that could be done on the park itself. So we still have an interest from that neighborhood from the River Square Association from the parks department and from the artist to continue working on this project so we have just restarted some conversations about how we might move forward now. We don't have much more to report. Okay, and that today. Just so I can be correct so the funds have already been put set to the side and they are not included in that's correct. Correct, that is correct. Okay, for that one. Okay. And do I have anyone else have any questions for Tara. Kristen looks like she has her hand up.  I guess it's more of a housekeeping item. Well, just correction of a spelling error. I believe under PR and marketing that third bullet point is supposed to be launched social media, not. Yes indeed. Thank you. You don't know what long scene social media. I might not be up on the new hip lingo but my next question had to do with under the programming and projects aspect. I know that it's really dog hearing that money so that you know we could have further dedication as needed. The partnerships. That bullet point was a little broad for me so I just wanted to understand what could fit into that bucket, essentially, and if that is, I, I've heard before from partnerships that we've had with creative sonoma and I kind of wondered if that would be an ongoing annual amount, but I didn't see a bullet point next to it. So, if it was kind of building off of that and expanding, or if you had a new idea for the partnerships there. You know I think that let me pull this out so I can try to answer that. Hold on one second. Okay. The partnerships that are called out here are really referencing the strategic plans reference to partnerships. So, if you look at the strategic plan in. Let me find it. The partnerships show up quite a bit in our strategic plan, knowing that it helps us leverage our resources by joining forces with with others. So, I believe under the few that there's a few places where where it shows up like I just said but I believe under. I'm trying to find the right section just hold on one second. Here. So, if you're looking at the strategic plan here why don't I put this back up on my screen here. Okay, can you see that now. Another goal to neighborhoods are infused with art and community leaders across the city champion arts programming under strategy a bring art into serious areas of the city. Then tactic to leverage partnerships to increase impact that's where that $10,000 shows up which is what that line item is on our annual plan. I think that that is calling out to make sure that we are doing what it takes to partnership to partner with organizations that can help us in this area, and that may mean that we have. Some of the projects that we're partnering on but it may mean that relationship building to establish those partnerships as well so there's a couple places in this plan where partnerships are called out. And the relationship building that goes along with that with some expense with some dollar amount behind it. And I think that we, we want to make sure that we are providing adequate support to make sure that that that will happen so if that's, you know, costs for hosting meetings, or if that's costs for making sure that people can participate in the types of activities that we're planning with that partner, we want to make sure that there's funds for that. Does that answer your question. Yeah, and, and just further kind of stated that this is a, again, dog hearing of money that will be allocated towards a use that we have set aside in our specific plan that isn't fully defined yet so there's flexibility with those dollars. Very well stated so essentially all of these things with a very very few exceptions are new new expenditures new programs new items that will need development. And so when there is a project that will be coming back or a structure for how we might be doing partnerships, those things will be coming back to the committee and potentially will be addressed, perhaps through subcommittee work with the committee or, or other types of engagement so that we can, we can get those things developed. I can one more question. When we are talking about the goals of including an artist in with the general plan team or with the implementation strategies for the Santa Rosa Avenue corridor plan. Which, who do you think would be most relevant to send. To send recommendations for where we would like to see an artist's input at that stage. You know if we really like. I, I just think about other general plans that I've seen and I was like, Oh, it was great when an artist had input at this stage if I want to share that with the city. Who should I send that information to. No, I don't know that's a good question. I think that right now we're in the very early conversation phase, just with the key staff who are leading the project. And I think there'll be a lot of opportunity for public input as the plan goes forward. At this point I would encourage you to work with me as we are drafting our potential framework for how an artist can be included in this. So there will be more opportunity for the committee to provide that input as well as perhaps the subcommittee like I said so I think that right now, I mean you are welcome to go they have a website they have a great website it's called Santa Rosa forward. That is the new website for the general plan and there may be information on there about getting involved, just as a member of the public. But I like I said I would continue I would encourage you and any other committee members to work with the process that I hope to be leading to develop this component of it and then sharing how we may move forward from there. Great. Thank you. Melanie. What's our budget here, when does it go from. What was that budget year is that what she's asked. Oh, Melanie, are you there. I think she asked the budget year, which is July one 2021 through June 30 2022. Did you get that Melanie was that your question. Okay. Yeah, we can hear you now. Okay, so John July one to July one of 22. Is that right. Essentially. Yeah. Okay. So what so what something that shows up in 22 on a strategic plan. Why, like the public art audit is showing up in 22. So why do we have all the $25,000 in there in that. Yeah. Yeah, so this this shows you that when we were putting together potential costs for this, we, we split it up over two fiscal years, knowing that there's probably a part a and a part B to the work that needs to be done. So over in the notes, we noted that potential costs would include, you know, resources to support an actual audit, but then also opportunity and implementation support. So we divided that up over two years. Okay. Thank you. This is just questions, not discussion right. So that's what you told me, okay. Exactly. Do we have any other questions. I do. This part is, is it possible with like partnerships and those kind of things that we would be developing. Can those do those have to just be individuals or arts professionals or can we partner with schools and other kinds of public or, or private, I guess they could be bodies with a variety of ages and generations, or even senior type things. Yeah, I think all and above our opportunities. I think in general, our past partnerships have been with organizations either nonprofit or for profit businesses, and mainly focused on, you know, providing services to the community or doing a project that we can leverage our services to achieve so, but, but I think looking even beyond that and looking through the lens of really what we talk about in our strat strategic plan, in terms of bringing arts to folks that maybe have not had the same access previously and distributing some of our concentrated resources away from core places like downtown that has seen a lot of art and reaching out to other parts of the city so I think that that what that will help direct the types of organizations and, and folks we would want to start partnering with. Great. Thank you. One, one, one other thing if there's no other question that this moment I'll just share I forgot to add in some of the background for our, the public art fund itself, and the, where is it. And just so you know, kind of like our art the patterns of our kind of revenue that come in each year, as well as kind of what our anticipated balance is of the public art fund as we start this next year. Right now, our anticipated balance of the public art fund by the end of this year so by June 30 2021 is looking to be about $790,000. That that kind of goes along with the revenue we see come in over the last few years are fees from in lieu payments so developers who opt to place artwork on site do not pay into the in loop fee but they also have the option to pay their same requirement as a fee to the city's fund. Those in lieu revenues have been between 65 and 75,000 each year for the past few years. And then we also the public art fund also receives 1% of our capital improvement project city funded capital improvement projects and park development fees and those have ranged between, well right around 35 to 40,000 each year for the last few years. There's exceptions to that so like when we do a large project like courthouse square those, sometimes those funds come in separately from that projects 1% amount so sometimes there's an anomaly kind of where one year will get $100,000 more than our average because of that special project. So, the way that generally that our outlook is for for the next four years as we're implementing this plan we have a relatively healthy reserve in our public art fund. We have, you know, modest revenue coming in, but there's kind of an expectation that we will need to be using some of the reserves each year to implement our strategic plan. So, you know, each year I'll be reporting back kind of that same information so you know kind of where our balance ends up. But that that is just a kind of bigger picture view of how, how the budgeting looks like Nathan you had another question. Is there a way to access kind of information about those in lieu arrangements or do those need to be made privately with the developer in advance of any kind of hearing. So the way that that program works the public places committee is not involved for the most part with that prop program and with how that works. There's a developer who has a project that meets the criteria for needing to fulfill the art requirement, which that criteria is that has to be a commercial project. So excluding residential, including industrial with a valuation total construction costs or project valuation of $500,000 or more. And then they receive that information usually in the planning stage of their project. They receive the information as to that we have a requirement and what their options are. And it's usually not until right around the time that they want to receive their building permit that they would then decide if they want to find an artist to do artwork on site for their project or if they want to pay the in lieu fee instead. And but the APPC has no role in sort of facilitating. No, those kinds of things I'm kind of I'm trying to get a sense of, you know, sort of within the purview of my role as a committee member if like how I can sort of broaden the pool of applicants to these opportunities. Yeah, so the thing with the private development projects is the city has very little to do with the selection of the artist for those projects it's not a city project. So the developer can hire any artists they want, as long as they meet the criteria that stated in city code. Or they can purchase an already made piece of art as long as criteria in the code. So very rarely is there a call for artists that that developer issues for their project. Sometimes they do that that that that's not to say nobody does sometimes that does happen, but it's not. And just to be totally clear there aren't any calls for submissions right now through through the city for there is for our fifth street parking garage project that's okay right now. Deadline coming up. Okay, thanks. That's all that's all. You're muted Lisa. Thank you Melanie. Any other questions from committee members. If not, then Eileen, do we have any public comment regarding this item. Yes, we do. Mr Eric Frazier, I'm going to go ahead and Mr Frazier I will be sharing a screen for you in just one moment. Mr Frazier if you could just confirm that your audio is working and that you're able to see the timer and introduce yourself if you so choose. Yes, thank you. Good afternoon. Oh, you sound perfect. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Yes, Eric Frazier with Greater Cherry Street neighborhood Association. Of course we're all excited to see what projects materialize for the southwest corner of the fifth street parking garage. And we're wondering if it's going to be complimentary to the neighborhood mural that's on the northwest corner of the parking garage. But I did have some questions just about the budgeting process. So, looking at the strategic plan we do note that the public art audit is funded coming up here. And we want to and reading over that general plan we got the sense that the definition of art is sort of expanding and should expand to include all sorts of different types of art assets. We're wondering if that includes like architectural assets and natural assets. So, for instance our neighborhood as well as a lot of neighborhoods that bring the downtown, have an exceedingly high diversity scale, where you can see, you know, multiple types of trees and flora is that a consideration from an artistic or from an art inventory point of view, the same with historic sources of historic structures and things of that nature. So, looking to see a more integrated approach. I know that there was a little bit of friction that we had just in trying to understand our, you know, through the eyes of our neighborhood association with the execution of the mural that we have on the fifth street parking garage. It never seemed to show up in any type of registry to direct people into our neighborhood to see the public art that's abundant here including the artwork that's on the junior high school as well as hue patrols murals on his buildings and so on and so forth. And so we want to make sure that that audit includes all this artwork or all these things that are, you know, valuable to our quality of life. In this art audit going forward. So, so that's really important. The other issue that I wanted to bring forward was just this question about your PR and marketing efforts. I noticed that the strategic plan calls for a pretty comprehensive, meaning that an omni channel type and approach. But yet I see in the budget approval that you're really talking about social media and website and stuff like that. Obviously it's good to have, you know, it's essential to have a good website. Social media though only reaches a small percentage of people. And so we really rely on that print media products to inform people, perhaps by way of strategic partnerships you'll be able to do a little bit more. An omni channel marketing outreach. Thank you. That's all for my comments today. I appreciate your work. Thank you very much. Thank you, Mr. Frazier Frazier. Tara. Yes. Okay, there we go. Did you have any response or would you like, should we move on. Did I. Tara's on mute. I'm sorry. If the committee members would like me to address any of the questions that the member of the public asked, I'm happy to attempt to do so. Or you can move on to your comments. Okay. The only one that I, he did bring up the architecture, which that would be with the cultural heritage committee. If I'm correct. I think the, the question was, will architecture be included in the audit that we're doing our, our audit has not been fully developed yet in terms of how we want to approach that but the intention is to look citywide at all public art that has been done, and using a public art lens to define public art. So we want to get a sense of where all of the art is in public art is in Santa Rosa, whether it was city funded or not. So it would include community murals that were done outside of the public art program. So it would also address ongoing performances or cultural activities traditions things like that that that are not necessarily traditionally included have been traditionally included in our audit or inventory before. There are other types of art meant public art meant for public consumption in public places. So, architecture has not we have not addressed or decided whether or not that would be included if we do include that yes we would definitely want to work with the cultural heritage board or, or others to make sure we have the information we need. Nathan just out of curiosity who's tasked with settling those questions of definition. Probably myself might be happy to work with the committee and perhaps this is another opportunity for a subcommittee to to do some work on this project that's one of the next things once we get this annual plan approved is to start checking about how the committee wants to be involved with working on these projects and subcommittees might be a way to move forward with that. And it's just one more sort of broad point of clarification. How are subcommittees formed. We, I think we would be creating what we want for this committee. This committee, you know, we, the general rule is for a subcommittee that includes members of a city board commissioner committee is that there usually are just two members members of that committee. We have the larger committee of a PPC on a subcommittee. So as not to run into any quorum issues or brown act violation, but whether or not it's a working committee with staff and committee members, or if it also includes members of the public or other members of boards and commissions those are things we have not determined and I would be looking to see how other groups function and see if there's some good models we can look at for that. And then that'll end your task with kind of establishing those groups and organize. I would definitely be involved with that. And I, I think for to kick off the conversation more so perhaps at the next meeting, I would be happy to bring back a variety of options or structures that the city has used already that perhaps we could look at and then get committee input at that time. Thanks, Nathan. And did you, Kristen. I would. So to follow up with Nathan's comments, I would be interested in hearing just some lessons learned or success stories from other boards about breaking down into subcommittees and maybe working with other boards. I know just thinking about the cultural heritage board they have a very strict adherence to identifying buildings that are within a period of significance. And so that is pretty clearly defined but I know that the cultural heritage board is undergoing a, a survey of all of their properties within the downtown and so I would like for our committee to be aware of that when it is finalized. So I would like to have impact on how we think about art and potential locations or how we talk about art within the downtown as a destination.  Yeah. Am I still muted. Okay, sorry about that. Thanks, Kristen. Do any of the members have any other questions. All right. We can move on. And do I have a motion to approve the 2021. 2022. We have a question first. Or do I just need to finish. Okay, go ahead. Maybe I'm maybe I'm wrong. Okay, no. Just to clarify so emotion needs to be on the table and then discussion can occur. Okay. Thank you very much. Thanks Tara. So is there a motion to approve the 2021 2022 annual work plan and recommended expedient spender plan. So moved. So moved. Do I have a second. Second. Nathan thank you. All right. So let's go ahead and we can have our discussion is now open for this item and committee members wishing to comment or discuss please physically raise your hand. Melanie. So it would be helpful for me to have this strategic plan lined up with the budget so we can. I mean, I know the document is there, but so that we can see them, you know, all at the same time. To as a resource. For me anyway. I know we've done this in the past really quickly, but I. It's helpful for me to get the information in advance so that I can review it and then, you know, have an opportunity to approve it. So that's something I'm hoping to say. Okay. Thank you Melanie. And anyone else. No. All right. Okay. So let's go ahead and if there's nothing more that we're discussing. I would like to call a vote to approve. The 2021 annual work plan and recommendation expert in plan as presented. All in favor. Right. Got Nathan. Okay. Any opposed. Opposed. Opposed. Yes. Okay. Do we have. We have enough to pass. Correct. Yes. Okay. Just to be clear that it's a question of. Sort of waiting to see the document. For me. Yeah. Yes. I mean that seems reasonable to me. Yeah. So the motion passes. Passes with. That was, I didn't see everybody. I'm sorry. I lean. Sorry, I had to unmute myself. So I'll just do a quick. We'll call. Vice chair keeper. Yes, I. Member Baumgarten. Hi. Member Jones Carter. Sorry. Oh, you just would say if you're opposed, I would just say nay. Member Jones Carter. And. Member. I'm sorry, as Darian. I. Thank you. So the motion. Did you call chair point. Oh, I am so sorry. Hi. So the motion passes. I would be happy to provide that documentation that you're seeking Melanie. So that I can share that with the rest of the committee as well. So you can see those numbers lining up. I'd like to see them also. Thank you. Of course I can send that. Okay. So let's see here. So next item on the agenda, 5.2 project updates. And Tara will present updates on the current project. Okay. I just have a few very brief updates today. Obviously we've been busy with. With lots, with lots of things. We've been busy with. But just to give you the latest information about the imagine art in old courthouse square project, we are still working to finalize the artist services agreement with the selected artists for that project. And to make sure that that's approved along with all of her insurance documents. Then the call for artists for the fifth street parking garage is still open. The deadline to apply is March 15th. So if you have any questions, please feel free to post them in the comments section. And if you'd like to get up for that, if you'd like to share with anyone, it is srcity.org. Slash. Fifth. Street. Garage art. And our regular scheduled conservation and maintenance is continuing. With some regular cleaning and waxing of some bronzes we have in our collection, which is still open. We have a lot of bird droppings on it. We have a lot of bird droppings on it. We have a lot of bird droppings on it. We have a lot of bird droppings on it. And then we have the 12-piece and Julia Park, which was tagged recently and also has a lot of bird droppings on it. One of the exciting things that come out of, comes out of shelter in place and all, all the fun virtual world we, we live in now is that we have transitioned our annual activities. So, you can check it out on the inside out there website. You can find it from the main page of inside out there. Com, or you can go directly to the page by going to inside out there. Com slash national dash arts dash program. So Jessica Rasmussen, our contractor who does all of our city events and we received, I believe a little over 200 participants this year. I think there's a, actually 198 actual participants. So each artist submitted a digital image. It is all up on the website organized by classification, ranging from professional artists to youth artists. There are also this year's award winners listed on the page, which go first place, second place, third place in each classification as well as a best of show award and an education award for a youth entry. We are not having our traditional awards ceremony like we normally do, but we are trying to figure out some online offerings that we could provide while the show is up for the next two months, whether that's some kind of like artists, talk back or discussion, panel discussion with, with the award winners. I would also like to thank Anne, our new committee member for being one of the judges this year. She worked with fellow judge, remarking to look at all of the entries and come up with the award recipients. So thank you, Anne, for your participation. It's fun. I believe those are all of my updates for today. I have one question. You're muted again, Lisa. But yeah, yeah, sure. Sure. And the question was on the fifth street parking garage. I remember we were talking about it before that you could be, you went in Sonoma County artists and I had someone from the bay area that asked me about it. Just not even knowing I was on this committee, just if I knew anything about. If we would be supporting people that actually could drive here to work on it, but wouldn't need my new lodging was an issue. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I just wanted to know what did. Yeah, the eligibility is North Bay. Or I think it says Northern California. So it's pretty broad. Okay. That's Sonoma County. We were encouraging Sonoma County artists to apply, but it's open to a much broader regional area. Go ahead and move on. Okay. So let's see here. That's number. Six committee member reports. Do any committee members which to make a report at this time? If so, please raise your hand. Any reports out there. And we'll just move on. To department reports. Tara, do we have anything for department reports? I do not have any tonight. Thank you. Alrighty. So there's none for there. Then that means an adornment. So the next regular meeting of the art and public places committee is scheduled for. Wait a minute here. What was that date? We should have that right on there. And that was. I believe the next meeting would be April 5th. Okay. There we go. April 5th. I just wanted to make sure that that was it. I should have had that on there. Okay. So we got April 5th, 2020. And it will be at three 30. Okay. Meeting is now adjourned. Nice to see you all. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you too. Well, you know what? I did have a question of the Melanie. I don't know if we can ask you or not. Or what Melanie was regarding. I was slightly confused. And it just came to me after, it just came to me. I don't know. Melanie was asking for the breakdown. Was she referring to the. What we received on Thursday. Or Wednesday. From Eileen. Or the other person that was there. The draft. Yeah, I understood that you were requesting additional. Information so you could compare the strategic plan. Budget estimates. Okay. And then we'll move on to the next meeting. And then we'll move on to the next meeting. And then we'll move on to the next meeting with correct, correct. Your plan, which I can provide and send to the committee. My only question is whether or not I'll be able to provide that to you as a follow-up to this meeting and attach it to this meeting's minutes, or if we have to wait until the next public meeting to share it because it has to be available to the public as well. So I will find that out and let you know when I can get it to you. Okay. And it's not just by projects. Cause I know we had. Yeah. The date would be just for this fiscal year one, one fiscal year at a time, but it won't be broken down within that year and months or anything else. We don't have that information yet. Cause we don't know. The timeline for each project. Okay. That's, I probably figured that. So yes. Okay. Cool Leo. Okay. Bye. Bye. Thank you. Bye bye.