One autumn day in the mid-70s, a friend from school days from the United States came on a visit. As always, we talked firstly about politics. To my astonishment, he declared that the murder of millions of Jews by the national socialist was an invention. Invented by Jews themselves to blackmail the Germans. I was outraged and decided to find out the truth, to question Germans and Austrians who had lived through these events. Until then, I only knew what the victims had said, the survivors. But how did the Germans and the Austrians, prominent people as well as the men in the street, see the murder of the Jews? How did they find out about it? And when? I wanted to research this. I wanted to substantiate. Not all the people I wanted to speak to gave me an answer. Those who remembered the truth and testified before the camera are also witnesses before history. This film took more than ten years to make. Many of the people I interviewed have since died. Peter von Meisner, born in 1920, grew up in the Sudetenland and in Austria. His father, under pressure from the national socialists, had to emigrate to England. During the war, Peter von Meisner became a soldier and afterwards he worked as a journalist. Herr von Meisner, you are a Sudeten German and during the Anschluss you lived in Linz in Austria. What did you witness there? In the same street where the grammar school is and still is today, there was a shop with sweets, confectionery. And I used to go there every week to buy some sweets with my pocket money, Zuckl, as they say in Austria. And about a fortnight, three weeks after the so-called Anschluss, I went there.  Until then I had absolutely no idea that the owner was a Jew. He was a very nice, very polite, a bludging man. And I wanted to go into the shop and at that point the stormtrooper blocked me with his leg and said, Can't you read? I said, I want to buy some sweets. There's nothing to buy here. I went across the road to the other side to see what would happen next. And I'd scarcely reach the other side when the shopkeeper came out of his shop and he was wearing all his war decorations from the First World War. He had the big silver medal of courage from the Austrian army. That is one of the highest decorations a private can have and a whole row of other decorations. Shortly after that, a stormtrooper commandant came along with a group of stormtroopers. Four men, armed, guns, pistols. They shoved the man back into the shop, slammed the door, and there were noises coming from inside. A racket, shouting. Obviously, they were beating him up. And shortly after that, the door opened. The shopkeeper came out. His head was bleeding. People looked at him. He was almost in tears. And his medals had been ripped off. And one of the stormtroopers had a pistol in his hand and was waving it about triumphantly, as if it were some kind of booty. And then the shopkeeper said, please leave me the pistol. It's from the war. When I was wounded, it was washed in my blood. Heinrich Setzler experienced the night of the pogrom, 9th November 1938, in Baden-Baden. Herr Setzler, you experienced the 1938 November pogrom here in Baden-Baden. What did you see? Yes, I came to Baden-Baden purely by chance. And as I was walking down Sofianstrasse, or Ale, I suddenly saw a procession of men marching past, escorted by German police and some uniformed party members, stormtroopers and SS. Then I noticed that some people were really shocked by this pageant, especially because right at the front there was a young man carrying a placard. We Jews are Greater Germany's misfortune. The Jews were then taken to the synagogue. A very famous, magnificent Jewish synagogue had been built here. There was a broad stairway leading up and at the front there was a small landing. The Jews were then taken up there and had to form themselves into a tableau. A Jewish prayer mat was spread out and then suddenly a ruffian went up to the well-known lawyer Dr. Hauser and beat him to the ground. There were similar scenes going on inside the building, too. So the synagogue attendant, Orakantor, had to read out a chapter of Adolf Hitler's Mein Kampf. The Horst Vessel lead was also sung, allegedly. That's what I heard. Then the Jews were taken to the Hotel Zentral, opposite, and there they were given.  Then I heard that the Jews were taken to the railway station at about nine o'clock, where they were loaded into cattle wagons and taken to Dachau. Wolfgang Scherler, born in 1921. During the war he was a lieutenant and company commander. After Stalingrad he became a Russian prisoner of war. He was a lieutenant colonel in the Bundeswehr after the war. I was seventeen years old. In the middle of the night we heard a terrible noise. We lived near the synagogue and we ran to the window, and in the street we could see a horde of stormtroopers going past. And they had dressed themselves in prayer shawls. They had draped them around themselves and some had the rolls of the Torah under their arms. They all broke into wailing and lamentation. This scene made a very deep impression on me. Somehow it seemed unreal. The next day I found out that they had set fire to the synagogue. They had burned it down. First the police and the fire brigade game. And then the stormtroopers stormed into the synagogue. Probably poured petrol onto the oak benches and set the synagogue alight. Alexander Primavesi, born in 1926. Enthusiastic member of the Hitler Youth and National Socialist. After the war he became a police officer. During Reichskristallnacht, that is the night of the 9th to the 10th of November, in the morning some of us a few schools got the day off, so did I. Other schools were led through the town by their teachers. I grew up in a small town. There were 10,000 inhabitants. And there were 160 Jewish people also living in this town. The shops there were devastated on the morning of the 10th by stormtroopers and SS men. Articles of clothing were strewn about the street. The male Jews had been taken away. They were taken to so-called labor camps or concentration camps until they signed over their assets to the state. Then they were released again. The town synagogue there was on fire inside. I saw that with my own eyes. The curtains, the prayer books, the rolls of the tour and so on had all been thrown on the floor and set on fire. How many people were killed in this pogrom? According to present-day historical knowledge, 90 Jewish townspeople were killed in the pogrom. Klaus Hornig, born in 1907. As a lieutenant during the Polish campaign, this lawyer refused to take part in atrocities against civilians. He expressly instructed his company that paragraph 47 of the military criminal code gives every subordinate soldier the right to refuse to carry out an illegal command. Until the end of the war, he was in Buchenwald concentration camp because he had berated a murderer as an SS lout. Dr. Hornig, were you there during Kristallnacht? Did you witness Kristallnacht? I witnessed Kristallnacht in 1938 here in Munich because I had moved from Tria to Munich in order to resume my law studies after a break of eight years. And I mainly saw it in Theatina Strasse, where the elegant shops were. I saw how they were completely wrecked. And in Hildensberger Strasse, I saw how the Jews were being brought out of their apartments. The furniture was also being taken away at the same time and the Jews were then taken to Dachau. To the concentration camp? To the concentration camp, yes, that's right.  They didn't intervene, you know. It had all been arranged by higher authorities so the police were not allowed to intervene in any way like stormtrooper mobs who were carrying out this action. What did the people there say? People were just standing around gawking so in other words, as if it served the Jews right. Wolfgang Dorschel, born in 1911, worked in his parents' hardware wholesale business in Weimar. As a supplier of construction materials, he moved to events in Buchenwald concentration camp. On the night of Kristallnacht, the so-called Kristallnacht, in the November pogrom, the Jews were taken to the concentration camp? Yes. Did you see the arrival of the Jews? The Jews arrived in trains and were brought in via the so-called Prince's entrance and the Mercedes trucks were standing outside. These old three-and-a-half-tonners they had in those days were trained from Leipzig. This train from Leipzig was mainly full of Jews who came from Brühl. Leipzig was a center for furs and there were a great many Galician Jews. They came in the old costumes with long curls, etc. And when they came through, they were not allowed to walk. They had to run and leap onto the wagons and if they weren't fast enough, the SS beat them with sticks. They didn't have whips, the SS, that is a fallacy, but most of them had canes and they thrashed these people with them. Then a train came. Then a train came This train came from Frankfurt am Main. Frankfurt am Main is generally known as the city of high finance and these businessmen were coming with their elegant fur coats and with the so-called, what we used to call a pee, a bebe. You know, the stiff round hat like Englishmen still wear today and they too were shoved together exactly the same and rushed onto the wagons and transported away. Hans Siegmann was an occupied Warsaw as a soldier and witnessed the conditions in the ghetto after the war he was a legal official. Herr Siegmann, during the war you lived near the Warsaw ghetto. What was the ghetto? The ghetto was an enclosed part of the city and it was a very small town and it was a very small town and it was a very small town The ghetto was an enclosed part of the city of Warsaw. How was it enclosed? Partly with barbed wire, partly with wooden fences. Were there centrists? Yes, there were. Who lived there? The people who lived there, there were only Jews living there. How many people were there? Well, I would guess about a hundred thousand. I would guess, about a hundred thousand. Did you go into the ghetto every day? Not every day, no, perhaps once every two or three weeks. What did you do there? We were a motorized column, a vehicle convoy and there were repair workshops in the Warsaw ghetto where we used to take our vehicles for repair. Did the Jews work for you? The Jews did work for us. Were they good workers? They were good workers, yes. Did they get something to eat and return for doing the work? No. What kind of food rationing did they have? The Jews, yes. I can't say, in any case it would be very little, it certainly wasn't much. How did the people look? Well, emaciated, run down, starving and ill, more than ill. Did you see people lying in the street? People were lying in the street, yes, and some were dead and some were near death. Were the people afraid of you? People were not afraid of the Wehrmacht, but they were certainly afraid of the SS. How did they tell the difference? Well, the difference was, as they said, among the Jews in the ghetto, the soldiers with the national emblem on the right-hand side, above on the chest, they were good, but the soldiers who wore the national emblem on their left sleeve, up here, right, they were bad, and that was the SS. Did you see the SS brutalizing people? Yes, I saw that a few times. Did they beat them? I saw that a few times, yes. Did you see shootings? I didn't see any shootings, no. Were people begging for food? Yes, begging for food and also for drink. Why for drink? Probably because the water or anyway the ration of liquids was really meager, there was not enough to manage. You must bear in mind that there was, I would guess, about 100,000 people crammed into that quarter, and I would doubt very much if the water supply there was always good, and that's probably why they had to beg for drink, too. Did they beg from you, too, for food or drink? Yes, the people in the workshop, sometimes for a cigarette or any kind of tobacco, but certainly sometimes for bread. How did people survive there? Do you mean the people in the workshop? No, not at all. Generally, how did they survive? By trading. There was a lot of bartering going on. There would be one man with a pair of pants over his arm, and he would trade it for a pair of shoes, or someone who had, let's say, a pair of shoes, and he would trade them for potatoes or food. That is if anyone had anything to trade. Did you also see dead bodies on the street? There were bodies lying in the street, yes. Did you talk to your comrades about the conditions in the ghetto? Sometimes we talked about it. In fact, some pictures were taken. I was not the only one to take pictures, others did, too. What did your comrades say? Well, they were all saying the same, that it was human slavery, that mostly people just couldn't understand, that they were crammed in, and they were starving, and lying dead in the street. Was it obvious to you that this was a systematic action to starve people to death? Yes. It was a systematic action. Because the ration in a food had been going on for almost a year in the time when I was there. Yes, so things didn't get any better. It was the contrary, in fact. Things probably got even worse. Was it clear to you that this was a case of mass murder? Yes. I didn't see mass murder in that sense. I saw a few corpses on the streets or people who had starved to death. And then once I saw a hearse and they were picking up the dead from the street and loading them for want of a better phrase onto a wagon full of bodies, and then they carried them away. And according to stories from people who were also in the ghetto, they were said to have been buried in mass graves. When did you see Jews being mistreated? Yes. I was on the transport to Russia. We were transported to Rostov. And on a little station just before Charkov, I saw a freight train. And it was only later on that I realized that Jews had been loaded onto this and had been taken to the extermination camp. You took photographs in the ghetto. Have you still got these photos? I still have the photos, yes. Would you show them to me? I'd be glad to show them to you, yes. Here in the first photo you can see a woman lying, probably dead, covered with a blanket. In the next photo you can see the entry or exit to the ghetto guarded by a Polish policeman and here is the wooden fence in closing the ghetto. Here is a beggar rather ragged with a saucepan. He is probably begging for food. And here you can see a little market. They are trading with wood. Here again you can see the fencing around the ghetto. The next picture shows a young man with a plate in his hand who is presumably also begging for food. Here you can see a hearse being drawn by hand. Here is an old woman, stuffed to death, probably dead, again covered with an old blanket. Here is a young girl with her brothers and sisters. Here you can see the tram which traveled only in the ghetto with the Jewish star on top. This photo again shows the Polish part and here again is the Polish part, both connected by a bridge. Where this ghetto comes in here it's a kind of long narrow bit. The bridge was built so that the Poles did not have to come into contact with the Jews. Here again you can see a little market where trading is going on. Presumably these are potatoes and this is wood. The next picture is also the entrance to the ghetto where you can see the sign saying prohibited, infected area, no stopping allowed. Ludwig Wolff, born in 1903 during the war director of a mattress factory in the Warsaw Ghetto. I was the chief executive of a branch in Berlin and one day I was informed by the owner that apart from my factory in Berlin there was also a factory in Warsaw for me to manage. And he settled down in his flat in Baden-Baden and he told me, plain and simple, in the east there are millions out on the streets. We must not miss out. He had already set it all up but there was nobody from the firm there. It had all been organized by a labor exchange in the east which was to make the useful workforce in the ghetto available for the war economy. And so there were already 160 Jewish men and women designated and they were to bring everything with them. What was that? Sowing machines, their hand tools and so on. So I mean, 26 sewing machines were brought in for us. How were these people paid? Do you really think if they had to pay they would have set up a factory? The workforce had no choice. The workforce belonged to the SS. They were the property of the SS. At the start that meant that we, the firm, had to pay off the SS for each one but I never saw any evidence that anything was being charged. And then you see over the next few weeks there was such confusion. It just wasn't possible anymore. So to cut a long story short on the 15th of April, 1942 I was sent to Warsaw. I was picked up at the main railway station and taken straight in. My room was already booked. Everything had been arranged. I was taken in through Gate 2 of the ghetto. The street which there was called Szybowska and at number 25 there was a large factory where everything had been seized for the firm. It was all prepared. As I said, the workforce had already been designated. The tools which they had to bring with them from home were also already there. Everything was already there. And then a Pole who spoke good German was engaged. Together with his wife. His wife was work supervisor and he acted as interpreter. As I spoke no Polish, I couldn't speak to the people. Work began. No question of meals or anything. You see, nobody bothered about how the people were to live, how they were to work. If somebody fell down, they just couldn't care less. They were given nothing, paid nothing, no food. Why did they work there? Why did they work there? Well, in the eyes of the people there to work for a German company would mean you lived longer, you see. They knew that they had to die? Of course they knew that. It was obvious. By April 1942, they all knew. Even the Jews, every one of them, they knew what was going on. What was going on? Extermination. Extermination of the Jews. Not only Polish Jews, they were being deported from France, Holland, Belgium, from Germany, understand? And many came from Hungary, Czechoslovakia. How many people lived in the ghetto? There were over half a million. Did you see people on the streets? You mean sleeping? Yes, did you see them on the street? Of course.  Today it's very hard to even talk about it, you know, what was done. We got provisions on the black market and set up a kitchen at the back. But nobody had to know about it. We could give people at least some soup to eat at midday. There were 160 people. And the women in the course of the day, of course they brought their children with them. That's understandable. So anyway, we were able to help to some extent. If that had got out, the whole firm would have been found out. And us too, of course. Did you see people who had no work on the streets? The streets were packed with people. It was like this. On my first visit to Warsaw on the 15th of April, I went through the streets with the owner and another executive from the South German works and a relative of the owner. So we were five in a sort of a line. So we had to wend our way through. And then somebody heard us speaking German. This was a Middle-Aid woman. She threw herself at us saying, I was a piano teacher in Berlin. Help me, please help me.  That was normal behavior in the ghetto, between Germans and Jews, you see. The ghetto was blocked off. Did you see checkpoints at the gates? Of course I saw them. What was that like? Naturally, with the Poles, I often had to leave the ghetto to go to the government offices. And I can only talk about one case. As we went in through the gate, it was gate two again, with a group of Jewish workers. There were children there, too. Some workplace or other in the city. And they were being taken back into the ghetto. And people were being searched for food or whatever. And one of the children, a little boy of perhaps eight or ten, had some food. A couple of potatoes, carrots and so on. And the German police sentry lifted him up in the air and hit him on the head with a stock of his gun. You asked me about the relationship between Germans and Jews in a company, like the one we're talking about. You know, if you walked into the work rooms and saw these frightened people there, you know, they were fully aware of what was going on. Every woman, every child, every man had the fear of death in their eyes when a German came. The atmosphere in the company was terrible. That was the worst thing for me. And then when you came out, our offices were opposite on the other side of Shibovska. Number 30, former Jewish café. When you crossed the street, how the people shoved each other, one behind the other. You know, they were seeking refuge, but they didn't know where to go. They were being chased through the streets. And then what was going on in the meantime? For example, I saw, when I went out once, I didn't like it, I didn't do it often, there were these three completely naked children about two or three years old with these bellies, swollen heads, protruding eyes in the gutters, lying on the pavements and gulping the filthy water. This ghetto sewage, three years old, still children. Perhaps they were even younger than that. Children who must have been thrown out by their parents because they simply couldn't feed them anymore. Lying there, completely naked. I stood on the edge of the curb and next to me stood a Jew in a robe, a beard and so on. And he noticed, obviously, from my clothes that I was a German. And then he said in German, half German, half Yiddish, my God, what are you doing to us? And once I had a conversation with a judge from the regional superior court from Poznan. He'd been a lawyer in the days of the Germans. And as an old man, he was packed off to the ghetto. His face was highly intelligent. But there was such fear in his face. You know, the fear of death, not only for himself, for his family, for his wife, for his grown-up children, for his grandchildren who were all there together. You have to imagine that.  They had everything. When you came home into the arms of your wife suddenly, suddenly, right into this hell, there are no words to express it. You know, not even a devil could behave the way our good compatriots behaved. Walter Manaschek, born in 1957, historian at the University of Vienna. For years he has been occupied with the role of the Wehrmacht in the extermination of the Jews. Unlike in the east, meaning the Soviet Union in Poland, in Serbia the army started the final solution of the Jewish question in the autumn of 1941. How was this mass murder carried out? This mass murder was performed by execution commanders of the army and was done under the military pretext of shooting hostages. Were the gas chambers in Serbia too? There weren't any gas chambers in Serbia, but after the army had shot all the Jewish adult males in autumn 1942. This involved about six to seven hundred thousand men. The women and children were left over and in the winter of 1941-42 they were interned in a concentration camp very close to Belgrade. In March 1942, thus after a few months, a gas truck came from Berlin to Belgrade and within two and a half months eleven children had been murdered in a gas truck in this mobile device. Can you describe how this gas chamber looked? This gas chamber was this gas truck which in the National Socialist terminology was described as a cover-up, as a delousing truck, as a special truck, as a special vehicle was a converted sour truck. As early as the end of 1939, such gas trucks were being used to kill mentally and physically handicapped people. And where were they made? They were produced in Berlin in the forensic department of the Security Headquarters. And since the invasion of the Soviet Union in summer 1941 they had also tried to introduce new technical innovations on these trucks, such as sending the exhaust gases directly into the inside of the truck. Earlier steel flasks with carbon monoxide had been used for this, which was a very complicated undertaking. And then in autumn 1941, 40 trucks with these new technical developments were tried out in the Sachsenhausen concentration camp on Soviet prisoners of war. When these trials were a success, at the end of 1941 six prototypes of this gas truck were produced and used in the East. How did they look inside? Externally there was nothing remarkable about them. They were completely normal gas trucks. Inside these trucks there was an area of about 10 square meters. And benches were installed there. The Jews were placed on these benches and then a lever was thrown. Then this compartment was hermetically sealed and then the driver of the vehicle pulled a gas lever on the outside so that the exhaust gases were then conducted directly into the interior. In Serbia what happened was that the Jewish women and children were informed that they were to be transferred from the concentration camp to another camp. So the people came in voluntarily for this resettlement action. And in Serbia this gas truck drove up every day for two months, stopped in front of the camp and the people got in. Then the vehicle was closed and drove over the Saberbrook to Belgrade. After the vehicle had crossed the bridge it stopped briefly. An SS driver got out, the vehicle engine was stopped, then the gas lever was pulled and then this journey of death went on through the middle of Belgrade and during this journey the women and children were suffocated. Once the vehicle reached the military training ground of Belgrade in Huala the people in the gas truck were already dead. They were unloaded by a Serbian prisoner commando group and buried in mass graves. This involved about six or seven hundred thousand women and children who were suffocated in this two and a half months killing action. Alfred Spies, born in 1919 was the senior state prosecutor in Düsseldorf, was counsel for the prosecution in several trials of national socialist criminals including both the so-called Treblinka trials. Spies, a senior state prosecutor, you represented the prosecution in the two Treblinka trials before the jury court in Düsseldorf. What was Treblinka in fact? Where was Treblinka and what was Treblinka? Treblinka was the largest of several extermination camps constructed in Poland in the course of the so-called final solution to the Jewish question. Treblinka lay some 100 kilometers northeast of Warsaw. What happened to the Jews there? As the name says it was built for extermination that is for killing Jews.  What is the difference between a concentration camp and an extermination camp? Concentration camps sometimes also had extermination areas in individual camps but they were primarily built to imprison political and other prisoners and were not inevitably geared toward the killing of these prisoners. In fact a great many prisoners did in fact return from concentration camps. What is the difference between Auschwitz and Treblinka? Auschwitz was firstly a pure concentration camp but was later expanded to include the Birkenau extermination area, expanded into Auschwitz-Birkenau and was then a concentration and extermination camp. While Treblinka was just an extermination camp it had been built only for the purpose of killing Jews and also it was only an action for a year and a half. It was you who indicted Stangell. He was commandant of Treblinka. After Himmler, Heidrich and Eichmann he was called the fourth worst war criminal. Why was he called that? When we look at the chain of command for the final solution then we know that Hitler gave the order for the final solution that the leading organizers were Himmler and under him Heidrich while Heidrich was still alive. He was assassinated. Then the commandants of the extermination camp were immediate subordinates, inspectors and so on were sent in but the commandants of the extermination camps were then in this ranking shall we say fourth from the top. I see a plan of Treblinka here on the table. How did this plan come into existence? This plan was produced on the basis of the main hearing in the first Treblinka trial in 1964-65. I must point out here that the Treblinka extermination camp was raised to the ground after an uprising which took place there in August 1943. There were no drawings, there were no documents even the foundations of the camp were gone and only on the basis of witness statements and also the details of the accused in the first Treblinka trial were we then able to produce this sketch which we did as accurately as possible and then of course we watched with particular interest in 1970 the statement by the camp commandant, Franz Stangel after his extradition from Brazil and it's still very vivid in my memory when I recall how Stangel came here and we laid this sketch which we had produced in the first Treblinka trial before him. And Stangel had to know whether it was correct or not because he had fitted out the camp to the last detail and to this day I can see him sitting before me and going over the sketch thoroughly for almost a quarter of an hour, if not longer. And he only looked up at me once and I can still see in his eyes the astonishment and a certain admiration too when he said to me Mr. Prosecutor, this sketch is completely accurate and then he was fully prepared to tell me all about the mass killings in detail and he mentioned that when activity was at its height in summer, in certain summer months when lots of transports came when we had to work from early in the morning until late at night and he said to me, Mr. Prosecutor, when we had to work from early in the morning until late at night under floodlights in Treblinka up to 18,000 Jews were killed daily. Franz Stangel, the commandant, told me that himself. How was this camp organized? How did this factory of death function? The extermination camps in Poland were basically all structured according to the same plan. Each camp was split into three zones. One was the so-called accommodation camp. This included the living area for the SS people, the Ukrainian sentry units allocated to them and inside the accommodation camps were strictly ghetto-ized again for the so-called labor Jews. They were Jews who had been selected from the transports in order to use them as a labor force until they were killed. Separate from the accommodation camp again divided off was the so-called reception camp. As the name implies, reception camp, because that was where the transports were received. From the reception camp, they're then led from the undressing area, undressing area for women, for men. They're then led the so-called tube or as the Jews called it, the stairway to heaven into the actual killing zone. That was the so-called death camp where the tube emerged into the gas chamber building in which the Jews were then crammed into six chambers and there they underwent the dreadful death by suffocation, hundreds at a time. After the killing, dead bodies were originally put into large graves with a capacity of up to 100,000 victims, later on in order to get rid of all the traces, they began to burn the Jews on a grate.  The Jews were in fact tricked by telling them they were being resettled to a hospital. This was none other than a place disguised by a red cross where people were shot in the back of the neck, where the Jews were then murdered by a shot in the neck and fell into a burning pit where documents and such like were also being burnt at the same time. What kind of gas was used? In Treblinka and the other extermination camps in Poland, apart from Auschwitz-Birkenau and Lublin-Meideneck, the victims of these extermination camps were killed by the exhaust gases from an engine. And in fact, in Treblinka, there was a motor from a Russian tank, a T-34, which had been captured, converted and installed there. In the concentration and extermination camps, Auschwitz-Birkenau and Lublin-Meideneck, the killing was done with Zyklon B, so these Zyklon B cartridges were thrown into the gas chamber. Odilo Govachnik, that was the leader of the whole Reinhardt action, which covered three extermination camps, Treblinka, Sobibor and Belsen, insisted that his system for killing with motor exhaust gases was the best, and he always protested about the fact that he was forced to use Zyklon B. The death by this murder by means of motor exhaust gases was dreadfully cruel. There was even a report on it, the famous Jakstein report, in which an SS officer described how it looks when one opens the gas chambers with the dead bodies sprawled all over each other and cramped up, and the victims had piled up where the strongest had climbed to the top in their struggle for air, and the weakest was underneath. How had the bodies removed from the gas chamber? In Treblinka and in the other extermination camps, the gas chamber doors were opened after the killing had been done. Actually, the gas chamber doors were like our modern garage doors. They flipped up and over, and then the bodies, which were all cramped up against each other, were pulled out with sticks. And then, two or three bodies were laid on a stretcher and were taken to the large graves by the so-called death Jews. These were labor Jews who were brought into help with the killing procedure in large mass graves. The death Jews, that was what they were called because they were there at the killing, they had to take the bodies to the graves and tip them in. And in the graves, there were also other Jews who had to lay the bodies next to and on top of each other so that there was room for as many bodies as possible in the grave. And now, while these bodies were being carried to the graves on these stretchers, the so-called dentists were busy. They were Jews armed with pliers who had to break out the gold teeth of the victims, and this gold was then collected later and purified. At the end of 1942, beginning of 1943, it was decided that instead of committing the Jews to graves, they would now go over to burning the victims on a huge grate. The grate was simply several concrete sleepers on which rails had been laid. And the victims were then taken to the graves and the victims were then burnt there. The ashes were crushed, and some were also used for building paths in the camp. And that happened, as I said, around New Year 1943. In Stalingrad, the fortunes of war had finally turned against Hitler, if I may put it like that, and people were now reckoning that the Russians could one day occupy this zone and they didn't want to leave any traces behind. Kurt Franz, born in 1914, had butcher and cook, commandant of the Treblinka extermination camp. Sentenced by the Düsseldorf district court for joint murder of at least 300,000 persons, for murder in 35 cases of at least 139 persons, and because of attempted murder, to life imprisonment. Kurt Franz has since been released. He has never admitted before the German judicial authorities that he was the commandant of the Treblinka death camp. Franz, it was quite clear that Treblinka was a death camp. Yeah, a camp where people... Yes, people died there, or were killed there. By gas? By gas. By gas. Here is a plan of Treblinka. People were brought into the camp here, and wagons. I think there were always 20 wagons. Then the doors were thrown open by Jews. You had already been initiated by, I don't know, Stengel or Ebel. I don't know, I didn't see Ebel. And then they were all unloaded, and the Jews were brought down here to the square. I don't recall if there were two barracks or one. I think two, one here and one here. And the people were taken into the barracks and had to undress, so far as I can say. Strip naked? Yes, naked.  That was in this corner, here. Schuchemil did that. I was very angry with him, because he caused me a great deal of trouble. And then all of the Jews, to be honest, I did not see or hear of any children. Then the Jews were taken out and into a so-called tube, which was completely camouflaged with fur branches by the camouflaged commando. Everything was covered with branches. The commando was led by a deputy troop commander. I think his name was Zitov, who was entrusted with all that, so that it was impossible to see in. Then they were taken in, up to the so-called gas chamber, where they were gassed. That's how it was. And that's the fact. And I stand by that. Did you see mountains of corpses? Did you see? I certainly saw. You could see it by looking hard, but you had to make a special effort to see. I could have gone there. I had the opportunity, but it was too awful. I could not bear to see the people burning. They were laid on a grill and burned. What happened to their ashes? I couldn't say. I only know that earlier on there was no grill. In the beginning, before I got there, there was no grill. That was somehow set up by another deputy commander. Then trenches were dug. These are the pits for the bodies. Pits were dug, and I suppose the bodies were buried with cranes. That is, the bodies were carried there. They were carried down from the gas chamber, as I remember it. And then I think, after a while, there was this grill, and they were taken out with this crane, this excavator. They were taken down to the grill, and then brought out and laid on it. I did not pay any attention to this. They were brought out and placed here, and then the bodies were burnt. And then I think sieves were set up like sifting sand. And the ashes were sieved through them. And whatever was still too big, too big to go through the sieves, I think that was either crushed or crumbled, so that it all somehow disappeared. How was the gas produced? As far as I know, at that time I did not see, but I know that somehow a French lorry was involved. If I am not mistaken, it was a sour or a sour motor. And then the exhaust gas was conducted into the cells. The cells were on the side. How long did the people in there suffer? You know, I really couldn't say about that either. There was talk about it. It was, I think they said it was four or maybe ten minutes, but I really could not say I was not responsible over there. There was a senior troop commander, but he wasn't really a troop commander. He was some kind of senior watch sergeant. In Treblinka, they were all policemen. Mattis was responsible. In Belzek, at that time, an SS man never did the work, which this Mattis was then doing in Treblinka. So you saw gassings in two camps. You did not see, but you were there. I did know that it happened. I do know that, yes. And nor was I sent to Treblinka, in my opinion, in order to make it known, because that was all done secretly and on the quiet. That is why everything was covered up, too. But I knew. I had already seen it. Been outraged in Belzek. And in Belzek at that time, I was with the Lieutenant who had come from Marburg in order to investigate something there. Or my opinion, they wanted to bring in a new gas, maybe capsules or whatever, to carry out the extermination. And it was another deputy commander-leader or a senior commander-leader. I don't know what his name was. He was there. I can't remember any of their names anymore. Anyway, at that time, I went to the Lieutenant in Belzek where it was possible for him to arrange for me for me in German to be relieved. You did not want to participate? I did not want to participate. And I also thought this would mean death for German. And that also meant death for this Alexei, me and Alexei, the Ukrainian, who was then shot. Did you know SS Boils? Who? SS Boils. A certain Boils. He was in the SS, and he did not want to join in, and he scratched out his Boils, and then he was transferred out. Did you know him? No. Into Blinker? No. Boils? Boils? I didn't know him.  The women, yes, yes. They were the gold Jews who took the gold. They were the dentists, people who ripped out teeth. Did you know that? I have heard about that. I did not see that. No, was I responsible for that? That was an internal affair. Up there, Mattis was the man in charge. Here, where the Jews were accommodated, that was... Now, where was it where the Jews were accommodated? No, here. It was here. The Jews were accommodated here. Kutner was responsible for them, and I was responsible for the sentry patrols, and that was over here. That duty was all shared out. Kutner would not have listened to anything I said. Kutner was already, at that time, chief of police. That is the most senior rank. Did you see how things were handed over? Clothing, for example, and gold. It was done here, here in the barracks. All the things were, everything was sorted here. These were the sorting barracks at the platform, and the clothes were simply piled up. They were then somehow sorted by the Jews, by the work Jews, and the glasses and things were sorted. That was done openly. That could be seen. Definitely. That was here on the square. The German ranks. Which service did they belong to? Well, in Treblinka, it was the police. With a few exceptions, they were people who were active in the General SS. And the Waffen-SS? From the Waffen-SS, there was only an accountant and me. I was in the Waffen-SS. Myself. Then there was another one. His name was Willy Metzig. We called him Bubi. He was the accountant. He was responsible. He was in the Waffen-SS too. Were there others Ukrainians? They were all Ukrainians. And then there were so many German speakers, I think. You can't call them Ukrainians. I think... Ethnic Germans? I cannot say that either. I think they lived in Russia beyond the Urals. There were so many people, I think. And they spoke perfect dialect, like Württembergers in dialect. I think they had been settled there as long ago as their parents. Grandparents. But they spoke perfect German. They were... Yes. Perhaps they were ethnic Germans. We used to call them captive Teutons. That was how it was. Herr Franz. Half a century has now passed. These mass murders happened half a century ago. What are your thoughts on them? If I had known at the time what was going to happen to me, when I left the army and transferred to the SS, then I never would have come to the SS. Why? For the simple reason that I cannot bear the thought of what I witnessed. This Belzec. Why were people killed there? Were they criminals? No, I wouldn't say that. Because if that was the case, then I never would have had this conversation in Belzec with the woman and her daughter in their lives. The daughter was begging for the mother's life and the mother was begging for her daughter's life. Herr Franz. Why were these people killed? But they were civilians. They were inoffensive people. I have never in my life anywhere ever had any problems whatsoever with Jews. Although, and I must stress this now, the accessory prosecutor Dr. Dr. Dr. Dr. Joseph Neuberger said that as a young man I had been present in his apartment on Huttenstraße in Dusseldorf and threatened him but I did not even know the man. I have never had anything against Jews. For example, I played handball with Jews at Rattingen 04. I played handball with Jews in the stadium in Dusseldorf in Dusseldorf, Matabi. I played handball as an opponent. There were never any problems. I did not see any difference between Catholics or Protestants or Jews. In Rattingen, I had a pal who was called Balak. I think there is still a restaurant in Rattingen, Hubertesstuben. He was my friend. For example, again in Rattingen I went to the Grüne Eck as this pub was called with my wife. I was still very young then, 18, 19 or even younger and I went there with my wife when we were still young for dancing. This is what we did in those days. He was called Hirsch, Kurt Hirsch. Herr Franz, in Treblinka and in Belsen too, women, men and children were murdered. Thousands, tens of thousands. What did you think at the time? I was against it, really. What happened in the beginning was that, for example, in Belsen that no one could not have known what would happen there. Then I think trenches were dug. When I got there, nothing was going on. That was in March, 1942 when I came to Belzak. At that time I didn't know what was going on. I had no idea at the time for what purpose. There were the demarcation lines, the old demarcation lines between, I think, Austria and Russia. There between Belzak and Rava Ruska was a demarcation line. I do know that, but until then I really had no idea what was going to happen. What would happen if I received the same order today? Never. Never again. Hans Wilhelm Mönch, born in 1911. Untersturmführer in the Waffen-SS. Refused to select prisoners who were unfit for work for the gas chambers and went to Berlin to demand a transfer. This was refused because it was privy to a state secret. When Auschwitz was liberated he was taken prisoner by the Red Army and handed over to the Polish authorities. In January, 1947 he was the only one of 40 accused to be released by the Krakow court for the reason that he was absolved from sin and atonement. In 1943 it was already becoming apparent that Himmler and also the entire German war effort could not do without the labor force. One simply could not afford to. In general destroy this great potential of, as we said, millions of Jews. Simply to annihilate them as had been done previously in Meidenek and Treblinka and the other extermination camps in the protected territory. We could simply no longer afford to do this. And everybody who was fit for physical labor was separated out before the gassings. Straight after the arrival of the transports they were selected. And this selection should have been or was done according to orders done by experts by doctors. So how were they selected and why? On one side those who could work unfit for work unfit certainly and that included children. Women and children women and children and also children capable of work. For example mothers who were young and strong but with several young children who were calling for their mother when they were selected then they were so as not to interrupt the selection process they were also then selected put with their children among those selected to be gassed. How did that happen? There were large rooms prepared which were camouflaged as shower rooms a sort of large shower room. Then the people were brought in sometimes they were also pushed in and then the doors were slammed shut. And from above these through these are right next to these pseudo showers cyanide gas without tracer color was led in. Did you see how the people died in the gas chamber? At first there was nothing to see the doors were very large barn type doors and there was just a small spy hole in them through which the people who were meant to be supervising could supervise the procedure or could check whether the gas had taken effect. I never looked in during this should we say during the phase when people were dying I was not in the right frame of mind I was not strong enough to look inside only when the commando came and opened the doors so that the gas chambers could be so that the doors were open not the doors through which they had entered but the doors on the opposite side which were just as big and when the extractor fans were running I looked in this spy hole and saw they were in a tangled heap cramped up and then lying curled up on the floor and saw how they were dragged out with poles instruments by special command on the other side of the well where the doors were open and loaded on the trucks to be transported away and for reprocessing in the crematorium so then the doors on the other side were opened the gas came streaming out yes first there were extractors running extractor fans what does that mean ventilators first the gas was connected by ventilators and then the doors were opened and then the bodies were hauled out with poles so the people who worked there were not by this gas streaming out no they also had not all but I think certainly most of them had clothes over their noses wet claws and they were pulling them out how long did this gessing take as far as I can remember a relatively long time because you can't just estimate that but it was generally said we reckoned on 10 minutes then you can be quite sure it's all over but then we still waited anyway because there was no rush because there would always be plenty of time before the next load came in fact there were several crematoria several gas chambers running at the same time so we were not under orders to gas people in rapid succession but there were several gessings in each gas chamber each day during 1944 during the big transports from Hungary and Holland there were naturally there were gassings every day when normal operations were going on everything was postponed until the night then there were only gassings during the night I wasn't a camp doctor but I was assigned to the camp as a hygienist and I primarily I had nothing to do with these gassings but when the large scale gassings came in in the summer of 1944 and there were simply not enough personnel doctors then they fell back on everyone at this great Auschwitz complex who had been doctors and had nothing directly to do with selections they were drafted in then to help out and were detailed to do this and then you watched as it happened and I refused to do so Dr. Münch how is it that you refuse to do selections the work to which I had been assigned was something with which I could identify to some extent as a hygienist in the camp ensuring that the hygiene conditions were reorganized that was something which was completely compatible with my medical knowledge but I could not bring myself to collaborate with these killings in the gas chamber and so I refused did you speak to your colleagues about the gassings yes of course I was in constant contact with them what did they say I was still acting as a hygienist and of course it did happen that we spoke about the gassings strangely what we really talked about were the shortages and the problems which we had because of the fact that a certain amount of the reports had to be improvised because Auschwitz was not in fact primarily a gassing camp and as to the fact that the Jews had to be gassed or shall we say there was certainly no doubt among those who actively collaborated with the fact that the humanitarian ethos with the medical ethos they were not responsible since they had each come to terms with this a long time since there was no longer a question one had agreed to do it and it was now so long as it went all right part of it that is everyone was trying from his own point of view and from his own options to justify the whole matter of these gassings that was the view, the official opinion of people who were all convinced that the gassing, the extermination of the Jews was right and the gassing was the best method until then that could be found to do this that was their opinion there was no discussion on that and in that sense it was not open to debate in 1919, doctor and lawyer in Vienna after the Anschluss of Austria in 1938 she helped Jews to amigrate, she was denounced and sent to Auschwitz as a political prisoner where she worked as a doctor I personally actually got the first real impression at about the end of August 43 it was a very hot night I couldn't sleep and went for orders out of the block for some fresh air and there were these at that time it was still trucks open trucks full of people driving along the ramp in the direction of the crematorium and the people were screaming obviously there were some people who knew what was going to happen to them which was not the case with everyone and the last vehicle was a Red Cross fan I was told later that the SS man drove in this van who had the cans with the Zyklon B and I saw them disappear into the crematorium and about 10 minutes or a quarter of an hour later the flames were leaping out of the chimney black smoke coming out and then I realized now these people had been killed and their bodies were being burnt Dr. Lincoln's you are a privileged prisoner there a doctor did it ever happen that you spoke to an SS doctor about the glassings of the Jews yes I spoke to several of them about it one was Klein from Siebenberg and Hermannstadt who often visited us female doctors on Sundays and talked to us and once that was the time of the hungry transports when uninterrupted day and night these flames were coming out of the chimney and you could even see the fire outside the crematorium from a distance and I was standing right next to him and he was watching that and I said to him how can you reconcile that with your Hippocratic oath and then he replied because I have sworn a Hippocratic oath I cut a festering appendix out of the human body the Jews are the festering appendix in the body of Europe and must be cut out that was one of the conversations were there any other talks one talk with Mengele was actually only indirectly about the gasings when I right at the start when he asked me why I was in the camp and I said because I tried to help Jews flee abroad and then he said so did you think that was possible and I said to him then sometimes it succeeded by bribing the Gestapo and then he said yes of course we sell Jews we would be stupid not to do that so that was the attitude when we get something out of it and we let them we could let them go and it was quite obvious that the rest will just go under whether they were gassed or killed in the camp in reality it didn't really make much difference how they died because the camp itself meant death with or without the gas chambers 80% of my patients died did you see the selections yes I saw two kinds of selections firstly those in the sick parades which took place every 4 or 5 weeks and then the selections on the ramp and the railway tracks which went right past our camp you could see them going by and stopping the masses coming out of the wagons an SS doctor was always standing there and he used to wave and he made a selection according to facial features any layman could have done that just as well he used to let any person who looked quite strong and fit for work into the camp it was completely arbitrary there were always some kind of group coming in it also happened that once for example beautiful young girls were brought in by a camp doctor because it made him sad that they were going to be killed but to describe that as selection well that's completely meaningless the camp was constantly being filled up again and when there was no more room for anything they went straight to the crematorium and the terrifying thing for me was that when one of these trains came in and there was no more room where we were my patients were lying 3 or 4 to a bed there were no blankets and no sheets and no medicines and nothing at all and the thought that here comes some more was simply terrifying and then one was shocked at oneself because the first thought was don't let them come to us and the second thought was yes but if they don't come to us then they go to the gas all we saw was that masses of people came like the time for example of the hungry transports 5 to 600,000 people within 6 weeks and if they had not been killed there would have been there would have had to be a whole city we should have seen food transports coming in nothing of the sort where were they then here and there small groups went back and forth taken to the armament factories but the vast majority were only seen coming in and they never came back Walter Soswinski born in 1905 after the Anschluss of Austria in March 1938 he was deported to the Dachau concentration camp as an opponent of the national socialists and later to Mauthausen and Auschwitz after the war he was director general of the Austrian national bank for a time it was actually a miracle in itself that when we arrived in Auschwitz all of a sudden 300 German prisoners were arriving and they were all politicals this was at the time of year that was summer 1944 you know it was no longer possible such numbers of political prisoners were no longer seen in Auschwitz what we went through I myself was in the construction management on outward roads so I had the opportunity and I went to see these trenches because crematoria were no longer sufficient they used the trenches what was done in the trenches that's where the gassed Hungarian Jews who would come at that time in the great transports were thrown into these pits and set on fire criminal I could only do that because I had the chance as head of this construction commando in Auschwitz of going outside too and the others too who did not have this opportunity they could smell it because when the bodies were being burned there the smell that well even though we had very little to eat it put you off your food because the stench was dreadful the stench of the bodies the burning bodies not the bodies the burning of the bodies there was a sickly sweet smell which is terrible also we always knew what was going on because the SS didn't keep it to themselves the way it was going they could already tell that things were coming to an end and that the army not all but part of it had been talking about it so that was no longer a secret for them did they give any kind of explanation as to why they had done it yes there was an SS man there were SS people who told me how they had come to do it voluntarily, compulsorily it was certainly not simple to explain in Austria for example young men were brought into the SS during 44 whose fathers had been killed in the camps so that was going on too you know but the typical thing was a talk with an SS man who said well we grew up like that the priest that is the clergyman who gave us instructions he said well it was the Jews who killed Christ you know and so that stuck in our minds of course and for all the others too that is not the explanation but that was his justification justification that the others had told him that the Jews were guilty of something namely of the murder of Christ although the people were really not at all pious so you can't say that was the reason for it but that was an explanation for him a justification for him that he needed selections no but certainly the result namely those leftovers one example two Hungarians came into the commando in Auschwitz Jews of course who had been taken out of the selection because they were engineers and it was believed that something like that was needed in the construction management too because the building was going on forever and one of them asked us now I want to know where my wife and children are then we said don't you know where they are haven't you been listening to the television because we risked our lives against the English French and Russians you mean radio not television don't you radio yes radio haven't you heard he said no we're not interested in politics right we say you are if you ask where your wife and your children are and that was in those dreadful days when the gassed people were being burnt and so you could smell it you see that is that so I knew that he had come with his wife and children and they were now all dead so he was the only survivor because he had a trade which meant the Nazis believed that they needed him for the constructions Mika Mongeau married to the painter Franz Mongeau who was killed as a half Jew in Buchenwald concentration camp she hid the artist Jullo Levin whom she had befriended until he was discovered and taken to Auschwitz in 1942 and murdered there as a Jew pictures by both painters hang in the Dusseldorf city museum I was at the station Stettner station in Berlin and I saw train standing on the tracks with Auschwitz on the front I thought Auschwitz Auschwitz so I went to the ticket window and asked what is there a train to Auschwitz here yes he said every day at such and such a time there is a train to Auschwitz I thought then I could and can anyone go on it he said yes anyone can go you can buy a ticket so anyway I made up my mind and told my husband that I wanted to go to Auschwitz the reason was that I had a female friend whose brother had been in Auschwitz for a long time but he was able to ride and also receive parcels he was a what do you call it a jeweler he was involved with diamonds he was a diamond cutter in Antwerp in Antwerp and of course the family had paid so this SS man accepted the parcels with gems yes with gems or diamonds I'm not really sure of the difference exactly so I got this address and I also wrote to this SS man but I always made out that I was interested in my brother and so then he wrote yes come down sometime and we set a date and so I went to Auschwitz and on the way there on the fields everywhere there were prisoners in prison uniforms mainly women working in the fields and then in the town there were all these small troops of prisoners guarded of course by SS men with guns and they were dragging some kind of heavy load or pulling carts and he kept on driving them on hurry hurry hurry and these were such emaciated figures that were shocking and I looked each of them in the face and thought perhaps it's Ulo Levin then I went to the camp on the bus and at the time that I had agreed with the SS man I went to the camp only into the part where the officers and the sentries lived right at the front and then I talked to the SS man we talked about the brother that was the excuse and he was saying which I found really ironic yes if it wasn't Saturday tomorrow Sunday I'd take you with me to the works and you could talk to him yourself but you can't do that right now as if I would believe that the prisoners got Saturdays and Sundays off so anyway I had to act as if I believed that and I turned over in my mind whether or not I should mention something and ask about Ulo Levin he was also strange for us what was going on there I still had some hope that he was working there somewhere as a carpenter and it might be possible to find something out so I asked him later and he said yes he would make inquiries but of course I never heard anything but now I couldn't go back home until the evening and he invited me to come to the SS officer's mess in the evening my train was not leaving until just before midnight and there I was I had to pass the time somehow I was with a soldier who had a cart a sort of little cart and I asked him if he could take me with him to drive around a bit and we drove around a part of this camp and that was really dreadful on one side the barbed wire and the watchtowers and on the other side were countless barracks with company names on top all the big companies you can think of which ones? I can't remember it in detail now but AEG and lots of others I didn't take it all in anyway they all had their barracks there and then it suddenly dawned on me why a normal passenger train went there every day because all the German employees of these companies worked in these barracks you know all the office work the factories they had those somewhere else they weren't open to the street but these offices and the employees, the managers they were all there they processed orders and I don't know what else they were traveling back and forth yes of course it's like that in any business what was the officer's mess like? in the officer's mess in the evening there was a tremendous hullabaloo blaring music but what was interesting for me was that it was a large hall which was painted about halfway up the walls it was painted with a continuous freeze with these scenes from the middle ages dancing maidens and knights from the age of chivalry and such like so then I spoke to the SS man I said that's really wonderful what you've got here all these pictures he said we have plenty of Jews who are painters we made them do that for us and after that he went in the meantime they were all getting more and more drunk and I was very much on edge as soon as he was gone I just ran away and went out and went to the railway station and went home Helmut Frank born in 1923 as a soldier he became a Russian prisoner of war after the war he built up a company and became managing director of a paper factory Dr. Frank when and where did you become a Russian prisoner our beloved Fuhrer sent me to Russia very quickly and at 18 I was called up and 18 months later in August 1944 I was in Bessarabia that's somewhere in Moldavia near Kishinev in Romania I was taken prisoner at the end of August 1944 now I had had the misfortune to take a few splinters of shrapnel in the leg in the calf from a grenade a few days before at first things didn't go too badly but because we had to march for such a long time in the dust and huge marching columns as prisoners to the east the dust settled into the wound it got more and more swollen and that was lucky for me because of that they didn't take my shoes off me because they could hardly take the shoe from my foot because they were so swollen at least that one leg and I got quite a fever after about three or four weeks and the frontline soldiers were not so mean as others found behind us so I was taken to a military hospital and delivered and the fever was getting higher and higher gradually I began to get I was really unaware of things and not because it was so horrendously painful but because I was obviously already in a condition which stopped me realizing things so much but some things still allowed me to be aware to some extent despite the reduced grasp of reality that a series of doctors had so fast were giving me a wide berth because they had obviously said to themselves there's nothing more to be done for this one so I just lay there until one day an attractive young female doctor came in she came up to my bed unlike the others and she said how are you doing in German that was something that really struck me it really stood out and then I also noticed that she spoke with an accent which reminded me a bit of Yiddish which I was used to hearing in Vienna because we had friends who were from who also spoke a bit of Yiddish so without more ado this woman looked at my leg and immediately five minutes later she gave me two injections and injections were harder to get at that time than anything else in short, even giving injections was a small miracle and I took that in too despite my reduced grasp on reality I managed to take this in anyway this woman remained by my bed for nearly 24 hours she was only away briefly I don't know how many injections she gave me but there was no end of them I also had something to drink and some kind of pills and some kind of bandage on the leg so anyway after these 24 hours I felt a lot more alert again and I took in my surroundings a little and of course I began with my little saviour and had conversations with my beautiful little saviour and we were together she kept coming back to see me for eight, maybe even 14 days and it turned out firstly that she was Jewish which I had already guessed on account of her accent and that she had studied in Heidelberg Heidelberg the fine which was still dear to her heart and she was not just a doctor but also a human being who had seen the medical profession as a vocation too otherwise she would not have stood by me since I had obviously been more or less a hopeless case she saved you life she certainly did save my life there's no doubt in my mind what I really regret is that well it was my inevitable fate as a prisoner after two, three weeks I was thrown out that is sent back to a POW camp into a transit camp and so I lost sight of this young woman doctor from Heidelberg that is who had studied in Heidelberg who was now something like a second lieutenant or a lieutenant or something and that is what she did for me and I really regretted that because after the war after going home and after life had got back to normal I would so have loved to have talked to this lady and I would have said my dear child thank you from the bottom of my heart if one can in any event simply say thank you in a case like that because she really did save my life in that drafty barracks in dire conditions I was lying on a plank bed and she came to me like an angel as I see now looking back and she said I'll bring that lad back to health myself and that was that I often used to meet Jews at the start of my imprisonment we had a Jewish attendant in the prison camp in Czechoslovakia who really made an effort for us German prisoners of war in that he provided good food to some extent and then later too in prison in Russia in Azerbaijan I came across Jewish doctors both men and women who were very good to us that is to ensure that the regulations were always observed as far as possible even if they usually or very often did not achieve what they wanted to achieve how did the doctors behave with the prisoners very correctly I myself also spent a long time in the military hospital when I was sick for the first time I was at death's door with dystopia fluid retention edema so the Jewish doctor often came to my bed and looked after me and then when I was back on my feet again I was assigned to him in the sick bay in his hospital barrack as an assistant and this was in fact after he had discovered that my father had been a doctor I must say this particular doctor has stuck in my memory he was a Jew and came from Karkov and the most shocking thing for me was when he told me that in the war his wife his two children and his mother in Karkov had been shot and according to him the SS had done that and to me it was somehow astonishing the way he behaved towards SS men which some of us prisoners were because every time one of the sick SS men came he said I'll write you a sick note I'm giving you two days off work and giving you permission to rest in the barracks because you SS men shot my wife and my children and my mother so this was an act of charity yes certainly two days off for prisoners was an act of charity and I must say once I must just add once we were in a camp which was somewhat remote there was no medicine that was only available a few kilometers away on the other side of the Kura and once he raced out at night himself across the river and fetched the medicine for a prisoner of war who else was allowed to go what kind of distance was that yes, that would have been about six, seven kilometers on the other side of the Kura the main camp and the hospital was on one side on the eastern side and our camp was a subsidiary camp on the other side of the Kura on the far side Ursula Fenig widow of German officer Heinz Fenig a prisoner at Stalingrad and came home in 1956 Frau Fenig, your husband was taken prisoner by the Russians in Stalingrad at the same time as Field Marshal Paulus was he injured yes, he had frostbite in both hands and in both feet was he treated yes, he was operated on in a Russian military hospital what happened my husband weighed 80 pounds at that time and the doctor had told him he couldn't have an anesthetic he would never have survived it there were no local anesthetics available and then the doctor operated just like that as we say here, it was like vivisection my husband was laid out on a table four nurses stood around him with a linen sheet so that he couldn't move and he was then able to follow the operation for half an hour and then he passed out the doctor used a paring knife and a hook to rip out the joints and then laid the skin flaps over them and with that, the operation was over then they put a dressing on and two weeks later he moved to a different military hospital but first he spoke to the doctor again he asked him how come he spoke such good German and so the surgeon explained to him that he was a Jew and that he had lost his whole family in Germany but that he had just acted in accordance with the Hippocratic oath he could certainly have just left him to rot gangrene would have been the result and he would simply not have come home what did your husband tell you about the doctor as a person all he told me was that he was a marvelous human being that he had been compassionate and also he told him that my husband was, after all prisoner of war and the very first person that he was after all prisoner of war and the very picture of misery what more can one say did you keep in touch after the war no that just wasn't possible it was impossible because there was no contact with Russia my husband didn't even know his name


In this video tutorial, we're going to show you how to make a very nice scatter plot in Microsoft Excel. We'll even include a trend line for you. Let's look at our data. There we go. Here's our data. Before we learned how to do the correlation coefficient, which was 0.80 approximately. First, you have to highlight all the data, the x and the y. It's all highlighted. You're going to be inserting a chart. Go to Insert, okay, and you can see all the charts that are available to you. Make sure you click on All Charts, you can see everything. The one you want is called the XY Scatter. That's a scatter plot, and it's an x and a y. You see it already. Say okay. Right next to it, you can put it on a different page. You've got the scatter plot, and you can see all your points are here. You should actually count it, make sure you get everything here. But you can see some of the key points. Here's the person, that was the one whose performance was a 1. See the person with a 1 whose high school average was 60. That was the lowest high school average. Look at the person up here with the highest performance of 10, and that's the person with a 97.5 average. See the person with 97.5 and a 10 performance? This point, every point is accounted for. Now you have what's called a scatter plot. This is a researcher looking at this scatter plot, would say, hey, this looks like a positive linear trend. Which isn't that surprising when you saw the correlation coefficient of 0.8. Yeah, it's positive and it's a strong linear trend. Notice, now let's say you want to draw a line through this, the best line. We'll learn about regression lines later in the course. Easy schmeezy. You cook on any point. See, once you have that symbol on each point, you need to get all the points accounted for. Right click. Right click, right click on your mouse. Remember, right click. Okay. And now, see it says add trend line. That's what you want, a trend line. The line is going to go through these points. And you want it to be linear. And scroll down. You can even have it put in an equation, which you're going to learn about called regression equation. You don't need that right now. You do want to display the r squared, possibly. Here's your r squared value. Okay. So now, again, notice, make sure I got everything I want. It's linear. I want a linear line. I want to see the r squared. And again, something just may want to see the equation. Right now, we don't need it. Click up here. And there it is. You see that line going through your points? Actually, two points are on the line. Most of the points are off the line. We're going to learn about how the line is drawn mathematically. Okay. But now you have what's called a trend line. That is called the trend line. You have the r squared up there, 0.6408, which you can calculate yourself by taking 0.8005 vr. And squaring it, you'll learn in regression the r squared measure is very important. It's called the coefficient of determination. Goodbye.