Team keeping clean. What's going on? It's engraving here with another video and in this video I'm here to share my post game thoughts from the crazy crazy game we watched last night Oh, that game was wild man shout out to the raiders because I certainly underestimated them I did think that we were gonna see the week one Ravens that we've been so used to seeing and we just been spoiled by And I thought this thing was gonna be a blowout I said 45 to 17 I was obviously dead wrong and the raiders they went out they earned it They got the victory. They took care of business and the Ravens just simply didn't and When you think about it something that some I guess it's kind of like bitter sweet almost When you think about all the mistakes that the Ravens made just a lot of the poor decisions that were made today by the staff and just For them to still have a shot to win this game in overtime Like they they still had chances to win and for when their backs their backs were literally against the wall Literally against the wall and they still ended up having a shot to win this game So that's that it was a frustrating game. It was a crazy game a lot of emotions But again, like I said shout out to the raiders man. They took care of business. I was hoping to play Spoiler hoping the Ravens will play spoiler to the raiders raiders getting fans in their stadium, but they didn't But it's all good again. It's one game. It's one game This is a long see an extra long season cuz 16 game before after this first loss It'll be 15 games left, but it's a long season longer season cuz we got 16 games left Anyway, where do we start?  It was a big problem both our guys on the end Ronnie Stanley and Alejandro Villanueva They were both getting dogs they would get in dog all night and One of so many people's concerns heading into this year Especially like during training camp and stuff so many people concerned was offensive line one because they hadn't got time to play together and practice together because This guy and that guy were out and that guy was missing And then there were concerns about when people actually did see them play like Alejandro Villanueva It was said that in training camp and practicing stuff that he was getting beat man He was getting beat bad even by a rookie a daffy away And we didn't know like whether that's to really just say oh a daffy away It's nice like that or Alejandro Villanueva is just struggling like that So in this game, it was just rough man. It was rough literally all game long My money mainly in pass protection, but it was it was so bad We saw a preview of this in the Washington football team game And there was only one drive and so it was a small sample size But that small sample size it showed us reality that this offensive line got a long way to go So that's something and it's crazy because You almost feel like like Raven's got to get it with these guys that they have right now They got to figure something out because they don't have much cap space. Yeah, you can make some stuff happen But you don't have much cap space So you're limited on what you can do Now, um, this was another reminder that we really miss Nick Boyle We miss you Nick Boyle because Nick Boyle served as an extra offensive lineman We noticed those blocking skills are out of this world for a tight end and we miss you So get well soon We just miss you man, please come back Oh boy, Tyree Phillips He won the starting left-guard job and now the starting left-guard job is back up for grabs again Because he got hurt Hopefully it's nothing long-term. I'm sure we'll find out sometime today what the status of his injury is it obviously hasn't come out yet It's 9 0 5 a.m. Right now.  They are inexcusable though Those two fumbles you cannot do that. They are inexcusable and then on the on the second one He just when he fumbled the ball. He just said that he was frustrated But you got to finish the play you got to finish the play Because even though you lost the ball, you can't just sit there man. You got to finish the play So the two fumbles they were big As a part of this game as far as Lamar passing he did a good job passing the night And he was trying boy With one thing that was missing from this game the downfield shots. I think he only took three He only took three one was the same pass that he threw the De Duvenay from the Washington football game But it sailed out of bounds and it was way past Duvenay anyway And another one was to Mark Andrews where he just threw it a tiny bit too tiny tiny bit too far Tiny bit too far. It was like so close But then the in the other one was the Sammy Watkins Those are only three deep shots that I remember if there were other ones, please let me know But those are the only ones that I remember so not many deep shots this game But at the same time, how can you take any deep shots if you don't have any time to throw the ball? So again offensive line is it's big man. It is a big concern But Lamar look good his passes look good He made good decisions as he always has even though people try to run a narrative that he doesn't but as he always has He continues to go through his progressions. I don't know why people say that he doesn't go through his progressions, but anyway So that yeah, that was Lamar he he didn't scramble much what he passed like 200 some yards but yeah, he as With his game it was fine minus the fumbles that you can't do that. That's Especially close games like these like fumbles are inexcusable any game You can't fumble any game, but they certainly don't help in a glint in a game. That's like this So he got to clean that up and he got to clean up that tweet that he tweeted last night about them fumbles Because that sure wasn't team keep it clean. But anyway Tyson Williams I Remember watching the game and I was like man Tyson Williams just from the eye test He just looked so much better than little tabious Murray now again The tabious Murray is his first game. He's not too familiar with the Raven system. I get that but Tyson Williams just he looked better That's what it is. He looked better and in the first half Tyson, of course called that beautiful touchdown was a great run and They ran him a decent amount of times, but then in the second half I was like, man, I don't know this him much like what happened to Tyson Williams. What's going on? And yeah, he did have that that fumble where he I think it was a he caught the ball and he fumbled the ball out of bounds And then there was the pass that initially When Lamar thought I'm like man Lamar, you really missed Tyson Williams wide open. What a bad pass But then team keep team keeping clean Let me know in the live stream, which I appreciate everybody coming through to but team keeping clean Let me know like no Lamar was actually leading him Tyson Williams just stopped and I was like, oh, I Didn't know that because I hadn't even seen that But in the what in the second half he had two carries first have he had one. I mean first have he had seven carries 64 yards in a touchdown and he had two catches for 23 yards But in the second half for a second half and overtime he had two rushes for one yard and one catch for six yards So you just completely stop using him And again, he looked a lot better than Latavius Murray did granted Latavius Murray even got that touchdown But still it took him a little while to get the Latavius Murray He was he was pushing but Tyson Williams to me just look so much better And of course, he's more comfortable in the system too But why did we just stop abandoning Tyson Williams? And it's not like we can be like, oh, well, the Ravens were down. So maybe that no what they went in the halftime What was it like 14-3? I think What was the score at halftime? I don't even remember but Ravens were up and then they and then they got the ball. They got the ball back after halftime So it was like, come on, man. What is going on? But he did struggle in past protection on Lamar's I think the second fumble. I want to say it was a second fumble Tyson Williams just completely like whiffed on the block completely missed the guy And it's crazy because in preseason, he looked a lot better in past protection But tonight it was a struggle and I know some people made the comments They were like, hey, this is this is where Levy on bail would be great at because he is good at our past protection so um Tyson Williams had nine carries last night a total of nine Latavius Murray had ten So I really hope this and of course you you It just gave me flashbacks and I know it's just a it's one game But the way that they divvied up the carries. It just gave me flashbacks of last year When they did this with Ingram JK and Gus where they didn't go with the hot hand They they stopped going with the hot hand and they just they did they wanted to divvy up the carries evenly like Okay, we don't want to make anybody mad. Let's just give everybody their fair share and Again, Tyson Williams looked a lot better than Latavius Murray did and that's not I'm not taking a shot at Latavius Murray Because again, I know he's not familiar with the system too much. It ain't been long since he'd been here But Tyson Williams just he looked so much better a lot more explosive a lot quicker He was just fitting so much better last night and the Ravens just stopped. They just stopped And that's on Greg Roman man That's on Greg Roman. There was some questionable decisions like the fourth downplay with Latavius Murray where they didn't get it I just I remember watching the play live and I was thinking man I know they're not gonna give it to Latavius Murray I know Lamar's gonna keep it and then either try to look for his own lane or throw to somebody But they gave it to Latavius Murray and I was like, whoa Why they did they really did that? I didn't like that at all, man Because I just thought he last night to me He didn't look like a threat and again, I got to repeat it because I know it He's not familiar with the system. He's not comfortable in the system, but he just didn't look like a threat to me last night So I just I felt like Tyson should have had more opportunities Was it that the fumble John Harbaugh was like, you know what nope? Mm-hmm. You you want to fumble the ball even though it went out of bounds.  Yeah, you you're done. You a lower round pick and you fumble. Yeah, you're done But if you high pick or you are quality high quality free agent or whatnot You get a pass And it's true. We've seen it before I never forget. We are Mike Wallace. I forgot. I think it was a regular season game I forgot whether regular season free season. I think it's regular season though But Mike Wallace and receiver they signed in as a free agent He had fumbled the ball and I'm like they can't take them out They gonna take Mike Wallace out.  It's like, nah, of course they didn't But Janarian Grant who was a shifty shifty punt return explosive guy fumble gone Cyrus Jones Who had gave the Raven some nice returns nice punt returns? He start fumbling cut done done So it all just all just depends on where you are sort of in the pecking order So maybe that's why I'm gonna say that's why Janarian. That's why Tyson Williams Didn't see much action in the second half even a trend cannon in the one run that he got He's boy that boy took off man It got called back now because of Eric Thomas and they said he was holding but trend cannon He looked even better than Latavius Murray too. He ain't been around long But just that the explosiveness man that explosiveness is big Back to Greg Roman and and my apologies in advance because I feel like we gonna go on for a long time But we got a lot to say and a lot to talk about But back to Greg Roman he in this game is It's just it can be very frustrating when there's such a lack of adjusting because We saw literally from jump from start to finish in five quarters We saw the offensive line struggling all game long Crosby was beasting Unique in Gakway he was beasting for the time that he was out there Carl Naseeb he got on in he got in on the action too They were just having a day man that defensive line was having a day and it's crazy because We went into this game like thinking alright It's gonna be the Raiders offensive line that ends up being garbage man. These boys they they missing guys the Richie and Cognito They got so much inexperience These do I think combined all five of them combined got like a total of like 64 starts in the NFL So all these Ravens about to feast Nope It looked the other way around Look the other way around But anyway with the offensive line struggling as much as they were Literally from start to finish you would think that the offense They would try to counter that and they did a little bit Because they came out in the spread formation empty backfield So that sort of spread that well, that's an attempt to sort of spread the defense out So if they pressuring you if they sending guys and whatnot you spread them out It's like okay. We got to take a step back a little bit didn't work But this I thought I was hoping and I know we only do one per month So I but I was still hoping that they would they would hit their quota last night And I was hoping that they would actually exceed their quota because I think that would have helped but they did not run that one screenplay Not one This is something that we've been talking about for years man for years whether Ravens are winning whether Ravens are losing They just do not Implement the screen game into their game and that could do wonders for them There's something so simple it doesn't to me is it's just it's the simple things with the Ravens so many times it's the simple things and We um, we did see the the passing game it looked better It looked more competent it looked better, but it's just simple stuff little additions here and there man Little additions here and there will go a long way super long way um Now, uh, oh, what was I about to say? Mark Andrews Mark Andrews he had a pretty quiet game and When it was crutched clutched crutch time crutch time crunch time clutch time He ain't show up perfect pass from Lamar to Mark Andrews in overtime He just he let he let Jonathan Abram knock it out let him knock it out and I was just like man This is the this is the rap that he has Because again, we know he makes a lot of plays man makes a lot of plays But it's the big moments man the big moments in games That's when Mark Andrews just sometimes it can be a struggle man I don't know what it is. It seems like a lot. I was just talking to my guy JT a little minute ago and Something that he brought out. He said it seems like this team a lot of it is just mental man It's mental It's mental and I could see that because like I said, I feel like it's just so much simple stuff that Could be fixed. It's simple solutions to a lot of their problems simple stuff But sometimes it seems like they overthink stuff And it's like no, you ain't got to do all that Something that we have been hearing this offseason and I know it's just the first game But I don't remember seeing not one play like that But something that we have been hearing this offseason from Greg Rome. Yeah, we're gonna have Lamar under cinema Gonna have him take snaps under center. It's like, oh, okay. Let's go Because yeah, the pistol formation is cool shotgun is cool empty is cool But under center if you got them taking plays under center or calling plays under center playing under center then You would be able to uh, that would diversify your offense that much more That would that would make it wide open that much more what your offense can do that much more Nope They didn't do it didn't do it So it was just like Again, it's one game, but just to not to not see one snap under center and again, let me know if I missed it Because I but I sure don't remember not one not one Hollywood He had a good game.  It was just crazy Sammy Watkins Overall, he had a pretty good game made his impact right away with the Ravens He did have a couple of drops But he certainly made up for it with some big plays The yaks that he was getting Uh, the deep pass that he caught with Lamar through that deep pass and it was coming to sammy. I was scared Like straight out. I was I didn't know what to expect though I did not know I was like, I don't know man. Let's see And he caught it though and I was like, oh Yes, let's go So shout out to sammy Watkins, man um pro shape Wasn't hardly out there tylen Wallace. I don't think he was I don't think he really got a known offense at all I don't remember seeing him on offense at all. He certainly didn't have any catches, obviously Uh, Devin Duvenay, he was out there, uh, quite a bit. Um Josh Oliver, he was out there a little bit then Didn't do anything. Lamar did throw him that one, uh, passing the end zone But it, oh, he would he would have got whacked if he would have caught that. Um Tomlinson again, he was just used in that nick Boyle role. Uh Uh Yeah, that's that latavius murray again. He got his touchdown. He just he just looked didn't look explosive Um, but again, hopefully it was just because he wasn't comfortable But but that now he's not really an explosive runner like that.  He runs really high. Um But yeah, he's not really too explosive You know, he got he'll get you them yards.  Um And yeah, that's that would be everybody on offense Uh special teams before we get to defense. Um special teams. Justin Tucker. He's the best man He is the best um Just the the clutch factor the consistency He's the best that bill's game our last game that counted before this one Obviously in the non anomaly, uh, the wind was blowing like crazy Like crazy Well, he missed him too field goes.  But anyway, um, he did a phenomenal job Sam cook He did a great job pinning the rate of shout out to tylen Wallace um for Down in that punt inside I think inside the definitely inside the 10 Maybe it was like at the five or the seven yard line. Don't even matter though, but That was good. Uh kick returns Devin duvenay, um He was doing this thing but on punt returns Devin duvenay And I was I was very like a little surprised that they left him out there Even after he fumbled that punt return But hardball. Hey, well, we we agree on something here hardball because I told y'all that with me When it came to punt returns I would rather have somebody that was explosive back there Rather than just somebody safe And Devin duvenay his hands are good, but again, he dropped the one last night James crochet. He ain't dropping that Well, he might but not he ain't dropping that But Devin duvenay He'll give you a chance. He'll give you a chance for an explosive play at the in the return game. James crochet He won't Because his hands they certified But his speed is not So, um, I like them having Devin duvenay back there And john hardball must too because again, he did not bench him after that fumble And I was like, oh, okay, because I thought whoa Better not you better not get in the doghouse Devin Um, but yeah, they got too much injuries and all that to put Devin in the doghouse, man You you you can't afford that Uh, but special teams They they were pretty good man and even on the kickoff coverage against the raiders They had Henry rugs back there because they were just looking for a spark Because he wasn't getting involved in the uh in the offense early on um But man it's oof It's crazy, man. Um Defense Oh defense. Wow. Where do where do we start? um The pass rush wink was just like Wink was like, man I'm I'm I'm gonna send for Then he started looking around like that.  He's like, uh, I gotta send six. I gotta send seven. I gotta send more. I gotta send more. I gotta send more I gotta send more. I gotta send more So initially he started off with just four and Wasn't getting home. So he was like, all right Throw that out the window. We done everybody go everybody go And that's cool sometimes but literally all the time Situational football man every game is not going to be the same. There's going to be some games where that works There's going to be other games where that doesn't And you just you just you just got to adjust accordingly, man Yesterday again, they they lost in overtime. So they had chances, but Felt like yesterday both offense and defense have sided the ball It was there was a poor poor adjustments being made poor adjusting um Because yeah, they just both greg roman and wink They they just needed to adjust better I'm not up here on fire Greg roman or fire wink But they they certainly got to do better and they they got to do better fast because you got kansas city coming in the crib next week So I would think He could we'll talk about that later though. But anyway, um Derek Carr had a phenomenal game Phenomenal game and an interview of course. Yeah, there is an interception on his stat sheet, but it was by no means his fault at all that I was just watching the uh the replay of that play this morning And that was a beautiful route by Willie Snead It was a beautiful route should have been a touchdown beautiful route perfect throw by Derek Carr And Willie Snead just dropped it And hollywood tweeted him.  And that's what it looked like man. Um, but he uh I just wish we could have capitalized man And that was that was Raven's problem, man Not capitalizing. That was another problem that they faced last night Not capitalizing um But yeah, Derek Carr he played really good man stepped up in the pocket a lot avoided uh avoided sex for the most part Even when when pressure would get there a little bit. Um, he just stepped up Did a phenomenal job of doing that all game. Uh, did a phenomenal job finding his guys giving his guys chances um Taking some risks Taking some risk, uh, he He did a good great job by Derek Carr, man Again shout out to the raiders, man. They took care of business And I know they they got some things that they probably concerned about on that and too because again the game went Over time so both both teams could have won both teams could have lost Both teams did got had did things had things that they did great both teams had things that they did poorly um Josh Jacobs, he came into this game sick. Um, and he He was like up and down With his play he did uh have the touchdown, but he did he didn't look him look himself So he definitely wasn't a hundred percent. There were a lot of times when he would come out of the game um, but he just Yeah, he didn't he didn't look himself But obviously what he was last night was enough for them to win. Um But yeah, so he'll I'm sure he will enjoy resting today And maybe even on tuesday, but Drake can drake he came in and made some plays. Um, they had him involved in the passing game a bit too Uh, so that was good for them, but really Forget all that other stuff, man Dan walla Dan walla This guy Dan walla Just That was the most frustrating one of the most frustrating parts of the game last night Probably the most frustrating part for me Well, offensive line was extremely frustrating too, but dan walla, man We know who dan walla is ravens know who dan walla is specifically because they the ones that drafted them. Um Drafted this six six wide receiver with all this speed But again ravens when it comes to tall wide receivers ravens don't know what to do with them They get lost in the mix. They like all this guy's over six foot two. We don't know what to do It have every time Guys over six foot two ravens don't know what to do at wide receiver Never fails never fails um, so they uh, they they transition him to tighten And he started coming along as a raven, but then obviously all the other stuff happened But then excuse me Then he got cleaned up and whatnot And raiders grabbed him. I think he was on ravens practice squad or something But john grudin's love what he saw from him picked him up and boom rest was history So knowing that history Especially as a as a coach in the nfl I really thought that wink was just gonna have a plan for dan walla I really did but Brandon Stevens, there was some time where he did. All right on he did good on him, but There was other yeah, he actually did pretty good on him, but They didn't hold him man They didn't hold him with Dan walla somebody in the live stream. They mentioned they like man You got to chip this guy every single play and that's true Because it just disturbs the timing and the the the connection with him and their car. It throws it off just a little bit Just a little bit But no, they did it a tiny tiny bit, but they didn't do it consistently um He just all game.  You got me beating up the mic at a frustration, but I was like we're not gonna uh Do anything about this guy All night literally all night long From the start of the game To the end of the game Nothing So I was just like man This is just crazy uh, so They just all night All night and it was like man It's somebody anybody anybody But nobody So he went off of course, um, and it just I know so many people They brought up there like man, if Dan Waller went off this week, just imagine next week But we we talk about next week when we talk about it. That'll be soon though. Um It's just crazy man. Just lack of lack of adjustments, man Because in the first half I even gave them I gave them a pass. I'm like, okay. No, no problem. They did they They dealt with Dan Waller the best they could. All right second half adjustments. They gonna fix it Nope Nothing. In fact, it got worse And Dan Waller didn't even do as much damage as he was supposed to because he dropped a lot of passes. He dropped like three four passes So it should have been worse should have been worse, but um Who else uh Rugs rugs didn't really do too much. She really didn't do anything until that last catch That because he had one big catch uh toward the end of the game um Who else uh 89 Excuse me 89. It looked like 89 had won the game uh chris westerie to where he uh In preseason every preseason game He made some nice plays, but he also gave up a big play every single preseason game He gave up a big catch every preseason game Same thing happened here. Just carried it over. He made some nice plays Throughout the game almost had a pick made a nice tackle in the backfield Um, he was doing this thing, but then he gave up that huge catch at the worst time But shout out to brandon stevens for effort Shout out to him for effort and that's something that we got to talk about now is just effort um That play could have been a touchdown But brandon stevens made the tackle and the guy his 89's knee was down and the ball hadn't crossed the plane yet So they got stopped at the one Derek car tried to qb sneak the following play. Nope. Raven stopped it. They stopped for progress Then raiders got a false start. So they backed him up five yards and then on the third down That was the willy snee play There willy snee ran a perfect route Derek car through a perfect pass Ball went flying up in the air. Um It went flying up in the air and then anthony avery came down with Pick but you know ravens, obviously they couldn't take advantage of it. They didn't take advantage of it Then they gave the ball right back a little more from the ball um But effort brandon stevens he saved the game Because had he given up on that play Game would be over He'll be over But it wasn't um marlin humphrey overall For 99.99 of the game. He was amazing This guy is amazing Amazing Whoever he was on They weren't making a big play Whoever he was on then whether it was rugs whether it was walla Whether it was renfro, whoever it was they were not making a big play And a lot of times they weren't even catching it But there's only one marlin humphrey So Derek was trying him But it wasn't working even had that he even had the interception But he didn't know it was an exception and I know i'm sure looking back at the film He'll be frustrated, but live it was like he he ain't even know He was just uh celebrate. He didn't even realize and live I I didn't even realize I was like, oh I thought it was just incompletion. I thought the ball hit the ground, but he had it He had it that would have been some good field position too But that play at the end the very last play I I just couldn't man I couldn't and I've seen people say oh man this cuz marlin was tired Oh man, it's cuz the defense was tired these guys have been playing in Four quarters and then they played overtime too. Oh man. They you gotta give him a pat. No, man He gave up on that play And so many people. Oh man. Well zay jones. He had all that separation on him. He had him beat There was no way marlin humphrey was catching up with that The play was not over the ball was not caught the play was not done That last play was inexcusable, man inexcusable inexcusable He gave up and I oh man. No, well the the safety the safety chipped him on accident So that created all this separation. Why should he chase him for no reason? No Because you never know what could happen again. The play had not been made yet the the Y receiver could have fumbled the ball could have bobbled the ball He could have dropped the pass. He could have done so much could have happened But marlin humphrey just stopped. He literally just stopped stopped Stopped I saw some people saying oh Marlin Humphrey did that because uh because he had he had a bet on the raiders So that's that's why he stopped you want to win some money But that was the most frustrating part for me last night Not even not even at the ravens lost Not even at the offensive line Uh, well those were frustrating things and not even a day on wall Even though all three of those things were frustrating That marlin that marlin humphrey play just had me like so confused And I was just like what what is what was that? What was that and I was just like I I I I couldn't believe it Because I'm like no not marlin humphrey Not a hundred million dollar cornerback Not hump. No, no way. It's that this can't be But it was Um, but besides that he had a phenomenal game Uh, the pass rush They couldn't get there all all the blitzes. They weren't getting there um just Wasn't it was they they weren't doing that thing last night on the pass rush, man Uh, just in houston early on in the game. He looked really good, but then he like disappeared after that Adafi away He had a really nice second. He showed that speed that we need um So he needs to be out there more He needs to be and I don't know he's a rookie, but he needs to be out there more And we have some different Combinations that we can use as far as pass rush. They just got to find the best fits, man They got to find the best fits and they also got a uh Because unique. I know my guy uh from slicing rice mat. He brought it out last night about unique and gakue's comments on uh Being a pass rusher for the ravens because he said they They put you on the field and then they keep taking you off. It doesn't allow you to get into a rhythm That's true, man It's like a gift incurred and a gift in the curse of having Good depth uh at at the pass rush that outside lying back and whatnot It's a gift in the curse because yeah, they want to have a good rotation have guys fresh But at the same time you also want guys to be able to get into a rhythm And that's what anything you're doing That's why I remember um With joe flacker when the ravens first draft the limo um And joe flacco, there'll be a lot of drives. We'll be like oh yikes. What's what's going on? He ain't got no rhythm But then there will be some drives with joe flacco's moving the ball downfield Moving it moving it moving it then they'll be like boom.  What what you want me to do? Like i'm in a rhythm. We're moving here like well i'm sure that was going on in his head. He didn't say that loud but And that's really with any quarterback I mean any player but especially quarterback Quarterback, what are the quarterback? They're driving down the field and you're like, oh come out. We're gonna take you out Bringing the backup It's like come on, man but That's why I I could completely understand yinikin got quite on that because uh past rusher He may be getting a feel for that offensive lineman. Oh, what what works against this offensive lineman? How can I beat him? Let me try this move. Okay. No, let me try that. Let me try this rush. Let me just But if you're not getting consistent opportunities against that offensive lineman It's not gonna work most likely I mean it can still can still possibly work but You're gonna have less knowledge of what can work against him Because you have less experience so um But yeah, all the blitzers and stuff there was a lot of plays where There was no safety help over the top Um, a lot of guys left in one-on-one situations. Um, a lot of Darren waller being wide open It it it was just frustrating, man. Um Raiders drops really saved the day for the Ravens Because raiders had some they missed some opportunities because they were dropping the ball They were dropping the ball It's crazy that it actually was well Ravens did have their drops too, but Raiders were dropping the ball this game No, Josh Jacobs. He had a drop uh, Darren waller. He had a couple of drops um but This game was something man Patrick Queen He had a pretty good game. He got a little quiet Um through different times of the game not that he can make a play every single play But he had that nice sack where he disguised it perfectly blitz perfectly. It was just beautiful um Malik Harrison He had a uh, he had a really nice tack I think it was on was it on no it was on Josh Jacobs Because Josh Jacobs came out of the backfield there and caught through the pass to him He caught it and Malik Harrison came out of nowhere. I don't even know where he was there. He came out of nowhere Um, I thought it was gonna be a big game for him going against Josh Jacobs, but Excuse me It wasn't a big game for Josh Jacobs because again, he was he was sick. So he was off um Renfro Renfro He was nice man Nice little route running nice slot guy He he did this thing Even caused a pass interference on Tay Tay um Today there was one passing interference on Tavon with Tavon just did not turn around and I was like, oh boy But then there was another passing interference.  Well, actually no the Tavon young passing the second Tavon young passing interference called the one that was in the middle of the field Not the one on Renfro, but the one no I think is on 89. I think that was a really bad call but the the Patrick Queen one where they called uh Unnecessary roughness, I think It and Renfro ran into Patrick Queen And they called unnecessary roughness on Patrick Queen That was bad. That was terrible actually um But calls weren't the reason that the Ravens lost this game They they weren't even with those bad calls. They they they weren't the reason they're Ravens lost this game Ravens got a bad call called for them as well. Um I cannot remember what it was though I can't it was something that was really bad And I was like and I mean we said it during the last stream till like that was a terrible call Yeah, because it was a terrible call I forgot what it was though. I forgot what it was uh, anyway, um, anthony avid He had a uh, he had a quiet game. So that's a good thing No, of course, he had to pick too, but besides that, he had a quiet game So he wasn't like getting picked on anything like that. It's not that I noticed. Um, we talked about Westview Brandon Stevens Um, he was uh, he was up and down Up and down again. He's a rookie. They're around draft pick rookie Used to be a running back used to be a cornerback now. He's a safety slash corner back He just a defensive back. Uh, he had an up and down game. Um But yeah, man, uh, these Ravens they they certainly got some work to do And like I said, it's it's this it's the simple stuff, man I to me, I think it's the simple stuff That will make the biggest differences. Um, it's the simple adjustments. Um, just simple fixes those stuff here and there, man They uh, again, this team is is is capable of a lot. Uh, but it's it's gonna take an all out effort Because with the guys that are out with the guys that are injured, um, everybody got to step up that much more The players, um, they got to execute a lot better. Um The coaches they got to execute a lot better to They got to execute a lot better to so Got the chiefs next week. So we stay in the a of c west. Um, so that should be a uh, very very good opponent there Coming to your crib Coming into your house Coming into your trap Anyway, team keeping clean I love you all I noticed when went kind of long, but it was first game of the season And there was just there's a lot to talk about and I probably ended up missing something too that I'm gonna remember later on And be like, oh man, why didn't we talk about that? But I can't think of anything right now Like I'm really trying to think if there's anything we were missing. I don't think I don't think there is anything right now, but I'm sure there will be something. Anyway, I love you all If you made it to this part of the video, you can just let me know what your most frustrating part Uh of this game was for you. What was it that really had you like? And what did you like the most We don't want to just focus on the negative. What'd you like the most about this game thing? I would say that I like the most about this game was like I said despite despite the struggles despite the Shortcomings, um They They were still in it They were still in it despite everything.  I love y'all. I appreciate y'all we out


People come to virtual experiences for a variety of different reasons. While some users might be very competitive and very good at gaming, others might just be there to socialize and take it easy. Part of good app design is letting users with different needs come together. This isn't just helpful for people with disabilities. In fact, one way you can facilitate this is just by providing a communal space where people can self-organize. For example, seated or stationary users, users with small spaces, or folks with a VR setup which allows them to move around the room. These things can make a big difference in a multi-user collaborative environment.


Tezal Seville Home of the Flamenco, Tapas and the bullfight, Seville is known for its vivacious zeal for all things pleasurable. Taking your Tezal course in Seville, exposes the trainee English language teacher to the lifestyle of one of the most charming cities in Europe. Settled by the Romans 2,000 years ago, Seville is an ancient city with a broad range of impressive architecture reflecting its colorful past. Situated on the banks of the Guadalquivara River, Seville's location has influenced the importance of the city as the last navigable port in Spain with access to the Atlantic Ocean. Seville was an important post in the transatlantic voyages to the New World in Latin America and to trading routes with North Africa. Seville is the principal city in the region of Andalusia and for many is the jewel in the crown reflecting the diversity of the region's Roman, Moorish and Christian past. Within easy reach of Seville are the glorious cities of Granada and Córdoba each with their own monumental landmarks contributing to the fascinating makeup of Andalusia, one of the most striking regions in the whole of Europe.


Let us start as a warm-up. We have gone through tensor product ok. So, this should be the tensor product of E cross E by E cross E. What do we mean? E is a two-dimensional irreducible representation. I am taking a tensor product of two-dimensional irreducible representation with basis states I 1 and J 1 and this second E with basis state I 2 and J 2. So, the corresponding reducible representation will have a four-dimensional basis state and any arbitrary vector V if I write it as a column as alpha, beta, gamma, delta it should be understood as alpha times I 1 cross I 2, beta times I 1 cross J 2, gamma times tell me J 1 cross I 2 and then delta will be J 1 cross J 2 ok. And then we have also understood how to write the projector for any of these irreps. It depends on the characters in the character table for the irrep E. I want to find what happens to an arbitrary vector. If I take the arbitrary vector to be this sorry this gamma should be same as this gamma. If I take an arbitrary vector and the projection for the E-dimensional irrep is this, if I do this on this I end up getting this side which means I have two independent basis ok. If alpha and delta are equal and opposite beta and gamma are 0 then I will get this basis state. If beta and gamma are non-zero, but alpha equal to delta then you will get this basis state. So, there are two linearly independent basis states which is what you should get for a projector of a E-dimensional irreducible representation because the rank of this projector has to be two, there should be two independent basis. Is that clear? We did this I am just repeating it so that you can recall what we did before the last week what we did so that we can get going ok. And similarly you can also show that the projection operator corresponding to the irrep A 1. If it operates on the same vector V it will give you a linear combination of this ok. Projection operator for A 2 will give you a different combination which is orthogonal to this and it is in fact orthogonal to this and this ok. So, the A 2 is also one-dimensional projector and you end up getting a projection operator. Projection operator gives you this basis state and what will this basis states called? These will be the basis states which are called binary basis right. If you are looking at just the basis primary basis it will be either I 1 J 1 or I 2 J 2 for the E-dimensional representation right. If you want to look at the A 1 basis binary basis then the binary basis will be I 1 I 2 plus J 1 J 2. If you try to put them as position coordinates and if these two are different vectors you can call it as R 1 dotted with R 2 ok. So, that is like a scalar which is like the unit representation and if you have A 2 projector then you get a cross product that is like your R z comb is that here ok. So, with this warm up let us also recall how to since I have already said this now you can see that the A 1 irrep in the binary basis will be a dot product of two vectors in the x y plane which is x square plus y square if both the vectors are one in the same and it could also be just z square that could also be a binary basis. These are the primary basis z R z it can be x and y it can also be pure rotations does not distinguish for you whether it is a polar vector or an axial vector y. To see whether it is an axial vector you have to do a inversion or a mirror transformation which is an improper transmission. If you are not doing that you will not be able to distinguish it. So, in this case you can say that x and y if it transforms like a irrep which is two dimensional e R x R y also will transform like a two dimensional irrep e another way of seeing is that the sigma v character is 0 ok. So, in some sense that you can have both are equivalent basis here. If you go to binary basis this we have I have also tried to ask you some product of what was the product? Product of A 1 times e if you take a tensor product of A 1 times e then the characters will get multiplied right. The characters get multiplied they are all anyway one it does not really matter you get back e and the basis for A 1 primary basis is z primary basis for e is x y. So, you can get binary basis as x z comma y z ok that is a two dimensional basis, but each one is a binary basis ok. Why are we doing all these things? That is the next question you can ask why are we spending so much time in understanding position space primary basis position space tensor product giving me binary basis right. So, you can ask looks like a routine monotonous thing we are doing is that some meaning to it ok. So, that is what I am trying to stress now that whatever you attribute to the position space you can look at physical observables in nature. What are the physical observables? For example, if I take the electric dipole moment you all know electric dipole moment of two charges equal and opposite charges separated by a distance r is q times the distance between them right. So, what is the nature of that electric dipole moment? Is it polar vector or axial vector? If I write electric dipole moment as q times r vector is it polar or axial it is polar right it is a polar vector. So, this is one nice observable which is which comes into play whenever we put in some interaction in the energy with these electric dipole moment into picture you do need them ok. So, these are observables and then if I ask this observable belongs to which rep suppose I give you a system which has C 3 v symmetry system has C 3 v symmetry ok. You can straight away say that P z observable belongs to A 1 irrep just looking at the z component any polar vector z component will belong to the A 1 irrep ok. Similarly, P x P y belongs to every observable which I am going to do. I can start trying to associate whether this observable belongs to a particular irrep given a system with some groups symmetry. I am going to confine myself to discrete symmetry ok. So, for example, let me just confine to C 3 v and let me say that the symmetry of the system is C 3 v and then observable one of the observable is your electric dipole moment vector you can say that these components of the observable z component belongs to A 1 irrep P x P y belongs to A 1 irrep. Similarly, you can also look at magnetic dipole moment you all know magnetic dipole moment. So, magnetic dipole moment involves a cross product between current density and the position vector once it involves cross product what is it? It is an axial vector ok. So, if you write magnetic dipole moment d v this is going to be an axial vector. So, now tell me where the z component will belong A 2 irrep of course, M x M y belongs to E irrep. In fact, C 3 v does not seem to distinguish the x and y component whether it is polar or axial z component it does distinguish ok. So, every observable which I am going to write in nature I can categorize which irreps it belongs to for a given system with the symmetry which I am looking at. If I am looking at a harmonic oscillator symmetry then I have to look at it as a C 2 group symmetry and then I have to see which one it will belong to and so on ok. So, now I am doing a C 3 v and I am looking at the observables ok is this clear? So, as of now these all belong to your primary basis am I right? I have not really talked about binary basis it is just primary basis whatever happens to the components of your position space vectors will happen for any of these polar vectors any of the axial components of the vectors in position space you can again attribute it to the axial components of your other observables like magnetic dipole moment ok. So, this is primary basis. So, I am just trying to justify the bottom line all observables can be associated with irreps ok. So, why we did this elaborate exercise is because we want to look at interactions involving operators for these observables whether it will trigger a particle in the ground state to go to the next higher state excited state and so on if you want to understand you need to associate irreducible representation to the observables is that clear? That is the main reason why I have brought in the basis states not only basis states binary basis obtained from tensor products. After that you do a projector and get the binary basis we have done this elaborately and the reason for it is that it will help us to understand what are the observables associated with binary basis that is the next question you can ask right and that is coming from tensor products ok. You can take 2 vectors vector 1 with r 1 and then you can also take r 2, but you can do a tensor product of this. So, this has 3 components essentially I can write a something which is Q ij if I take the ith component of this and the jth component of this. So, this is something which I can do if I want to make it trace less I have to subtract something, but let me just write it as up to some tensor. Let me not even call this to be Q let me call it as a tensor tij. Is this reducible or irreducible? It is reducible whenever I take a tensor product the corresponding vector space will be 9 dimensional which I have written like a 3 cross 3, but it is reducible and then you will have to do the projectors, appropriate projectors if you do P e you will get something if you do P a 1 you will get something if you do projector a 2 you will get something and they will all be binary basis of the revs which you have is that right. So, you will get those binary basis out of this. So, one of the examples which I have just I am sure you have all seen quadrupole moment tensor when you did this expansion in electromagnetic theory course right. Quadrupole moment tensor xx component if you try to write explicitly you will get this answer, yy if you write it explicitly you get this answer, zz is this answer it is traceless that is what I said the quadrupole moment tensor is traceless and you can also show by symmetry that this gives a 3xy and xz component and yz component are like the xz in position space up to overall factor multiplying it which depends on the charges and so on. Now, look at the basis binary basis which we went through. So, now if you want to say which component belongs to a 1 can somebody help me out if you look at this x squared plus y squared analog of it is qxx plus qyy ok.  So, now tell me what will be the e representation is that right ok. So, that will be the binary basis representation which corresponds to your quadrupole moment tensor components. So, this belongs to irrep e this belongs to the summation belongs to irrep a 1 you can also have separately qzz this is a 1d irrep and what about a 2 someone is that right is that a 2 or no should be no yes or no qxy will belong to your a 2 irrep. So, I have given you some kind of a feel for. So, you can still go further you can find the tertiary basis. What does tertiary basis be obtained from? You take binary basis tensor product it with one more basis primary basis and then start doing projectors and start finding the tertiary basis ok yeah I did not. 2z squared where is it 2z squared which one? qzz qzz there will be a z squared minus r squared yeah. So, r squared is like a constant I am taking it as a constant. So, then z squared is the basis anything shifted by a constant I am not worried yeah then you will get back this no ok. So, in some sense you can also write a linear combination if it is a one dimensional basis in some sense that is another way of doing it ok, but here you cannot do that here there are two independent basis there these are two basis, but then you can also play around with two linear combinations of the basis right yeah ok. Any other question? Yeah I am just taking that r squared is a universal constant out if you remove that then qxx plus qyy will exactly transform like the a1 irrep and qzz will transform also like an a1 irrep that is all I am trying to say. Even if you take a linear combination of two a1 dimensional irrep it should not really matter yeah. Any other question? Is this clear? Is the motivation clear? We had gone through the drill of doing character table, drill of finding y basis states, y binary basis, y tensor product. Now you can associate every observable either to a primary basis or a binary basis and dot dot dot it can go to tertiary basis you know you can start looking at things yeah. I thought it is like a cross product like rz, so I was thinking that it should be like we do not have any basis here right. I have not written or it is not allowed can we check it? If you take xy maybe it is not right yeah what you are saying is probably not right. So this is a question mark whether it belongs to a2 or not or it is something which has no meaning in this particular group. Some other group it might have meaning but what you are trying to say is that in the character table xy part we never had yeah I need to see y but I think xy is not allowed right. If you do the c3 operation on x and y you get a linear combination and xy will not have eigenvalue as 1. So I think xy is not allowed I agree with you. So this one does not have any place to fit in in the c3 we character table but this is a way to do it like you write it out look at the binary basis table the stable and see where the observables can fit in which irrep it can fit in that is the theme of this showing you yes q xy does not have any place to put it I agree.


Hello and welcome on ST Motor Control Workshop dedicated for a new Motor Control Warbench version 5. Why did we decided to make Motor Control Workshop? Firstly we have a new tool version of Motor Control Warbench and secondly there is many many application on the market which requires such solution as you can see on the picture. There are three main points of the workshop. Firstly we will characterize a free-phase BLDC motor. Second point is practical quick and easy development of Motor Control application. And third point is how to move smoothly from Motor Control evaluation to farther development. It means we will teach you how to quickly move from the beginning to the final application. Here is some prerequisities of the Motor Control Workshop. You should have laptop with Windows OS, with admin rights and access to USB port. Then install it our MC package. Third point is USB cable and some hardware Nucleo F303 and XNucleo for Motor application. BLDC motor and power supply. You will see this flowchart during all workshop sessions. We are going to fill all parts from the basic hardware setup to final Motor Control application. Now let's start with hardware getting started. So we will connect all boards together and test our hardware. First lab is test of used hardware with binaries and ST software. And test install it package and related software. It means testing drivers, Motor Control Warbench, install it packages and IDEs. Now let's move to completion and connection of boards.  Nucleo Board with ST SM32 microprocessor motor. In this case it is Jimbal and power supply. On the Nucleo F303 there is also a stealing programmer for programming. Now we have all boards connected and we have to test it with binary file. You can find it in this folder. So it means see users, your username, documents, workshop slash hardware test. You can see here hardware test binary and hardware test Motor Control Warbench project. How to send binary to microprocessor. So you should click, right click on this hardware test binary, send to note F303. It means you will send this binary directly to the microprocessor. If you see blinking the slat on the ST link, it means it is programming the binary to microprocessor correctly. Here is some description what you can see in front of you. So on the ST SM32 Nucleo there is reset button, user button, which we will use for the testing. Green light for indications and potentiometer for speed regulation. Blue button is used for start motor, stop motor and acknowledge a fault if some fault occurs. And let indication of means the software is in middle state, on in run state. Fast flashing it means that fault is active now and slow flashing is, fault is over. It means that fault occurred in the past but now it is only indication that the fault was triggered. And potentiometer for speed regulation. There is description of the testing firmware. Here you can see that the software is in middle state. You can run the motor in two ways. First is by blue button. If you push the button it goes to run state and motor runs. Then you can use potentiometer for speed regulation. And you can go back by the button again. Or you can use motor control war bench monitor. It means that you start the motor from the IDE and it goes to the run. You can use slider in IDE and back to the stop button. If some fault occurs it goes from run to fault. Let indicate that fault is active. And if the fault is over it goes to this state. And you can acknowledge a fault by blue button. Here is another another point. If you press the blue button longer than 3 seconds it will go to pole pair test. And after 25 seconds it goes back to middle state. So it was a binary. And now we will open the project from motor control war bench. So you can found it in the motor control workshop folder. Slash hardware test as we mentioned. Or you can open ST motor control war bench. And click load project. If you open motor control war bench. So now we can see interface and motor control war bench. So first part is a window where you can start a tune motor. And second point you can go to monitor. Which means we will play with the motor. If you are in the monitor first point is to select comport of USB driver. And click to reconnect. If there is a note green note firmware. STMC SDK version something. It means that the board is connected. On the right side there are buttons for playing with motor. So start button stop button. And fault acknowledge and select speed.  And if motor is running and everything works correctly. It is off for this part. And success for this session. At the end of this session there is some notification. As you expect the new versions of tools are coming. It means that IDEs could have different graphic interface in the future. But don't worry functionality and principles remain the same.


This has something to do with espionage, we had Nigel Dunkley, a spy, and I would have liked to have given over the work from him to another former spy because you also recently decided to move to Berlin and I would like to ask you what is different in the post-Snorin situation from whistleblowers I think it's a very interesting time for whistleblowers post-Snorin Obviously he knew the risks he was running because the US has been waging a war against whistleblowers anyway for the last six years Obama has tried to prosecute or successfully prosecuted more whistleblowers coming out of the intelligence agencies in the US than all his predecessors put together since 1917 So if that's not a war on whistleblowers I don't know what is and against that background Edward Snowden still took the steps he took which was to expose to the world this global panopticon surveillance state and I think post-Snorin is going to be even more difficult for whistleblowers so unless you're pretty much an Uber geek and can really work your way around internet security there's a very high likelihood that you will get caught now before you can actually make it to the media I was going to invite Jamie to come up and read a letter from Snowden so it's fresh news Jamie gonna read it Yeah we want to have an artistic intervention Okay we're keeping the mic back here for the rest of the ride I'm not sure why I'm reading this but I'll do it anyway After that we should sing a song It's been one year Technology has been a liberating force in our lives It allows us to create and share the experiences that make us human effortlessly But in secret our very own government, one bound by the constitution and its bill of rights has reverse engineered something beautiful into a tool of mass surveillance and oppression We've come a long way but there's more to be done Edward J. Snowden, American And then you have an email from your husband You're working on this on a daily basis too Can you say something about the specificity of working on this in Berlin? Why Berlin? Well because we had people like Waohaul on 30 years ago talking about informational self-determination and to protect your data public data open and then private private and they made this to a culture and of course the CCC was born and oddly enough after that KGB hack also 25 years ago the CCC moved to Berlin and then fomented this kind of culture here which meant that when this did happen when Laura Poitras was working on her film she happened to be in Berlin because she had less surveillance than Hassel in the States Jake used to come here and hang out with us at the Telecommunist in Stamthus or at the Republic and do talks so it was common for them to feel at ease in Berlin that culture, that community was already here it didn't just happen overnight, just to answer your questions Do you have a small problem? Yeah, we have a problem NSA is spying on your phone You need to destroy this phone right now I think in terms of why a lot of whistleblowers are attracted to Berlin it's precisely because of what we saw when we went to the Stasi Museum earlier today it brought back flashback memories for me because it was very similar to what MI5 was like even in the early 1990s when I was recruited so I think why people are attracted to Berlin because we have something called the Stasi Museum not the Stasi HQ and that is the simple answer that you got you managed to get rid of it by people power Actually you have to pay more attention to the back of the bus If we are going to talk about Rosa Parks you can't ignore the back of the bus This discussion of what makes Berlin comfortable for all of these people that are dealing with surveillance often tends to forget that there are actually people that have been surveilled not by the Stasi but by the BKA in recent years for using terminology like anti-dentification like that's still something that you can be surveilled for watched telephone, telephonically surveilled in Germany now, so like the West German archives have not been opened up but people still do get surveilled and charged with things like terrorism and that happens today in Germany and we should not forget that because this idea that's a paradise of freedom we cannot just talk about the Stasi and ignore what's happening in Germany today I'd like to ask Christian Humboldt of Transparency International about what does it mean that a secret service brands itself on transparency we're seeing a shift in the meaning of transparency in the post-Snowden world I think we see a big transparency discourse by many people in power you use this word, the word this is really on vogue but to me like the main difference first of all transparency and privacy are two sides of the same coin for me and the difference, the criterion is the criterion of power because those in power should be transparent and those powerless need the privacy and I think that's very much what we saw already at the Stasi Unterlagenbewerde the spirit of the law we have there that was a film clip by Simon Klose one part of his documentary project about the magical secrecy tour my name is Leslie, I was a co-producer of the tour and I wanted to tell you a bit about how the project worked and what we discovered by making this journey through Berlin on a bus we basically were making a trip through Berlin with a group of people who were included hackers artists activists ex spies a whistleblower a lawyer some of the people that you saw on the bus already a number of people coming together traveling through Berlin for a full nine hours traveling into the history and present sort of world of surveillance culture and having a discussion about it on the bus trying to learn from one another what is actually going on and whether we believe that Berlin deserves this right to be say the call itself say the global capital of processing and reacting to and resisting global surveillance so just to give you a sense here we are at Teufelsberg the former NSA listening station with Nigel Dunkley who was a passenger on our bus and gave the tour there with one other person he's a guy who was a former spy for MI6 he was working at Teufelsberg during the Cold War and as he was telling us a bit about his work there during the tour because I was standing next to a Russian guy and a tech person and a historian I was listening to what he was saying but I was also because of the heightened awareness state we were in doing this tour on the first anniversary of the Snowden leaks also paying attention to these other things like why is Nigel's hand roughly facing in the direction of Moscow and what about this graffiti what does it tell us about the volatile history of a place like this sector of Berlin and possibly therefore also the volatile future of this part of Berlin and what about that radome that radar dome up on the left what was that radome designed to conceal in terms of technology and which direction was that listening device usually pointed in when it was working there these are the kinds of things that happened because of who we were on the bus the fact that we came together to experience the surveillance culture of Berlin but also sort of listening to each other and maybe widening our usual perspective of things so I'd like to argue that Berlin has a history of surveillance that is more varied and complex and interesting I guess you could say in shorthand than that of any other city in the world today that makes it a very interesting place to consider what's going on in the global surveillance situations that we're in and also possibly to react to it in different ways it's not just the history of Berlin but also the current communities that are in Berlin and the current things that are going on in Berlin that give it this special stature so really our mystery tour was about this intersection between the past and the present of the dozens and I wish I could tell you if I had time I would tell you all the places we considered going on our tour because there are dozens and dozens of fantastically rich possibilities we had to limit it to a few that we could actually do with 60 people on a bus in one nine-hour period and therefore we ended up with this selection of destinations which are in shorthand but just to give you a sense the inevitable visit to the Stasi Museum and Archives in former East Berlin on the other end the TB stands for Teufelsberg where we just saw the former NSA listening station TM stands for Transmediale offices where the bus departed HQ times 2 that was just a shorthand I put up for capturing the fact that this was the address it happens to be the offices both of Google and Daimler so that's where we discussed some corporate espionage and also corporate spying on corporate surveillance we went up to the BND Bundesnachlichendienst Germany's Foreign Intelligence Service down to the topography of terror former headquarters for the Gestapo and the SS Nazi German times and then past the USA Embassy one of over 150 embassies in Berlin of course embassies are there to protect their citizens but are also legendary hotspots for espionage so that was a natural thing to include on the tour so this just to give you a sense of the map we gave some actually programmed tours in certain locations where we actually visited things very carefully with an expert usually actually every time with someone on our actual bus the whole day so we have a continuing conversation but we also had a lot of loose time on the bus itself to talk and process these things and get into debates I just showed the clip from Simon that was about being on the bus so I'll give you a flavor of that the bus I would say became another site in Berlin temporary yes, rolling yes but moving among these static sites it kind of created another moment in the history of surveillance culture hopefully what we were doing was bringing a higher level of consciousness of the surveillance history and present surveillance situation of Berlin by our combined forces and carrying that consciousness around somehow so for what that was worth it was filmed by Simon Klose and our mediator on the right was Christopher Gansing who is the artistic director of Transmediale who along with NK Project were my co-producers for this event while we were on the bus going out toward the Stasi archives right at the beginning Christopher said to everyone on the bus okay you guys don't forget this paradox of seeing which is that when you look in one direction when you focus on something and you're trying to pay attention to it and learn from it there's automatically going to be something you're not seeing there's going to be the inevitable blind spots and these aren't just the blind spots from the mechanical reality of our bus but the conceptual blind spots because I'm used to seeing something this way someone else usually sees it this other way and we all know that even as we're very sure that we're right often the more certain we are the less likely we are to actually understand something more completely so we also reminded ourselves that Snowden in his revelations revealed colossal blind spots which were very important not only for revealing the technological realities of our times and some of the geopolitical realities of our times and other things but also for giving us the sense that we are now able to see things that we were blind to before but we also wanted to be very careful not to let that be something we would take for granted but also make an effort on this tour to actually use Snowden leaks as a way to motivate ourselves to look anew at Berlin but also to not get too comfortable with the idea that we actually understood anything so we're trying to look in a fresh way so I just with the little time that I have with you I just wanted to mention two different ways of seeing that I think are valuable that we took away from this tour I think there's many many more and if I had an indefinite amount of time I would tell you about a lot of others but the first of the two that I will tell you about is captured by my slide showing Nike hindsight glasses just to stand for the concept of seeing behind you, seeing historically looking into the past so this is a really interesting thing about Berlin that history doesn't function the same way there I think that it does in other places but I just want to in order to kind of activate the importance of Berlin's history I just want to put a pin in a couple of moments I think everybody already knows what these moments would be you could probably name them already but let me just put a pin in these moments without elaborating and just so that they're on this conceptual map so that we can be aware of them I think maybe actually most people would say that the history of Berlin's surveillance culture really begins in the 20th century but I'm going to propose to you that it actually starts earlier than that when Berlin was the seat of the kingdom of Prussia and the German Empire and that there was a kind of authoritarian form of data collection of mass population under the statesman Otto von Bismarck and that this, I don't know what you would call it say a preemptively antisocialist state is actually maybe the first interesting place to look at the history of data collection in Berlin I'm going to flip forward here we're now in the Wannsee conference house this is in the Wannsee district of Berlin this is a building where on January 20th, 1942 Reinhardt Hedrich, then director of the Reich Main Security Office convenes a meeting with 14 other higher ups in the Nazi government to coordinate and plan out extermination of Jews in Europe and note that this document which I think now rates as one of the major documents concerning the datification of humanity was supplied to the meeting by one of its participants that's Adolf Eichmann and this details a number of Jews in each territory that is either occupied and controlled by Germany or not you see the total on the bottom line to zusammen over 11 million so all together over 11 million I'm now flipping fast forward to after the war we're now standing in East Berlin in the Stasi compound which is the headquarters for all of the Stasi in East Germany and we're facing Haus 1 which was among many other buildings in the compound this one is the office was the office of Eric Milke who was the head of the Stasi for over 30 years I'm assuming I don't have to say a lot about the Stasi everybody probably has a pretty florid set of ideas about it I'm going to move along to this image from 1985 showing Toyvilsberg NSA listening station in full throttle working 24 hours a day we heard an interesting talk about Toyvilsberg last night no need to make any kind of sexual pun about the three radomes to the right I guess Freudians and feminists will go to town on that but I wanted to say 1961 actually this is an interesting little detail it was in July of 1961 that this site was discovered by Allied spies as an interesting place to listen out for what's going on in the eastern block or at least that's what they claimed they were listening to so July 1961 the top of the hill of Toyvilsberg is discovered as a promising fruitful place to listen out one month later the Berlin Wall goes up August 1961 starts on August 13 but this picture is obviously from a bit after that November 9, 1989 the Wall comes down just want to quickly say that I think this is a really important moment in the history of the world and the history of Berlin but in particular with this topic about whether Berlin deserves to be considered a capital of reflection on the significance of mass surveillance in the global digital era and preparing responses to it it is interesting to see that the Wall comes down in 1989 really at the moment when the emergence of digital culture just starts to take off so just as it's healing itself from this split and restitching itself together Berlin has also got in its post-wall DNA if you like the beginning of the digital era so now we one year later the former offices of Eric Milka are now a museum which we visited and one of the passengers on our bus asked when was the NSA going to be a museum when is the head office of the NSA going to be a museum and while it's not yet a museum it is true that Toifelsberg the former listening post is a sort of museum like place where you can go and you can paint there you can visit it and it's a privately managed historic site reunification I'm going to go forward because I only have a few minutes left to get to a really interesting point this is just a display of the German constitution I think anybody looking at Berlin from the magical secrecy to a point of view can't help but notice first of all how hard it was for Germany to gain these incredible points that are made in its constitution and therefore how poignant it is to go and see an abbreviated form here in this public display you can read the articles of the constitution and see just how not healthy some of them are that we now realize thanks to the Snowden leaks particularly the one on the left there that looks really tiny it's sort of in the middle distance but the smallest one article 10 my personal favorite which says something like privacy of letters posts and telecommunications shall remain inviolable with the word inviolable normally meaning not to be tampered with under any circumstances so one other way of seeing that we really got to appreciate on our trip through Berlin is the artistic way of seeing and this is a drawing by Leonardo da Vinci of the human eye and sight lines and peripheral vision being kind of figured out for the first time I want to propose to you that artists whether they're digital artists or artists working in painting or any other art form can sometimes also supply incredible insight that help us to see into blind spots in ways that historians and more logical approaches to reality do not so this is incredibly valuable to supplement one way of looking with another for the purposes of this congress with its title being a new dawn I just wanted to go back to a painting first exhibited in Berlin 200 years ago still hanging there in the Art National Gallery and it's by Casper David Friedrich it's called The Monk by the Sea no one is really sure if it shows a monk it could just be anybody but I think post the magical secrecy tour he looks a lot more like a hacker than anything else and that this is a really interesting representation from today's point of view of the concept of a blind spot this is just mist and fog and clouds with maybe a hint of transparency and enlightenment in the distance so even artwork that is from a pre-digital era I think can be seen completely anew when we think about it in these terms and show us things that may suggest something about our own priorities and our own vulnerabilities maybe also provide some inspiration and another area that's very rich in Berlin of course is the performing arts I just want to note here one very interesting theater the Schaubrinne theater in in west part of Berlin this caption for this photo should probably be something's rotten in the surveillance state of Denmark this is Lars Eidinger the great staggeringly great I would say actor portraying Hamlet at the Schaubrinne and this is Shakespeare's great tragedy about surveillance and the toll it takes the toll that surveillance and self-censorship take on a person and a family and a whole society the existential and ontological crisis that results when someone is forced to ask should I change my behavior and pretend to be myself just act myself and perform myself and if I do that for a while what if I mistake that self for my real self and will I go crazy and if I'm crazy is life worth living and I really think that this is a great Shakespeare play about the very problem also this staging is extraordinary this is a Thomas Ostermeyer production with a lot of soil on the stage this is really Berlin production of Hamlet the soil is very thick every time they try to put something in it like a corpse or a symbol of power like the sword or the crown or just tears of grief or what have you it doesn't stay in there it just keeps popping up it just keeps coming back on the surface of the stage they can't get anything to go into the past I think it's a really interesting insight this is a peripheral vision from these artists what is really going on in Berlin is that the history of this place can't quite stay historically it comes up into the present so all of these things we were talking about earlier from the historical vision standpoint they are very much vibrant and febrile and alive in Berlin in ways that make it possible for them to serve a wider understanding just wanted to thank Lars also this great actor for serving as our for being in this photograph taken by a surveillance camera at the American Academy in Berlin and we use this as a publicity image for the magical secrecy tour on our tour we had some great artists as well who widened our perspective one was Michelle Teran she had an interceptor set up inside the bus we had these monitors and what happened was she was able to capture some private CCTV footage so that as we're going around Berlin thinking about government surveillance and corporate surveillance and the rest she was giving us flickering images of private surveillance happening around us wherever we were moving with the bus at Toyfelsberg we have in the Radome a special performance during the tour by Jan-Peters Sontag the sound artist he built some special equipment which was able to capture some electrical activity in the stratosphere so we sat and listened to this extraordinary crackling and whooshing really strange kind of music of this stratosphere which also through into perspective a completely different understanding of the history of the NSA listening post and how what normal listening would have been like at this location not so long ago we ended our tour at Seabase Space Station where we had an interesting discussion about the future of transparency and privacy I think the creative artistic environment that we were in helped to promote a really interesting playful discussion which was useful at that moment to sort of imagine different possibilities and it would have been a very different discussion had it taken place at say the Stasi Museum or someplace else next month at the Transmediale Festival in Berlin we will be talking about the magical secrecy tour in more detail and there will be a pretty interesting panel about it I hope if you're interested you'll come and see some of the further videos from Simon Close about this tour I personally I'm very interested in participating in order to talk about another thing that I think is very useful about this journey we made to apply to the current discussion coming out of the post and debates and questions about how to respond and that is I think we hear a lot use this term panopticon the global panopticon and he just used it in the video clip as well and without all due respect to everyone who uses this phrase it's really a problem because what's going on today is categorically different from a panopticon in ways that are actually unfortunately I think a lot worse but I think if we don't get the right name for what's happening we're going to be in trouble so it will help us to actually address what's really going on if we find the right language and if I do have more than one minute I will tell you do I have more than one minute one minute okay so I would love to tell you juicy detail about the panopticon idea but I guess you'll have to come to Transmediale and Berlin I don't have time here let me just wrap up by saying these are fast changing times we're moving ahead quickly and it can be heroic and feel good to have our focus firmly set on a particular goal and to be working toward that as we think about what's the right thing to do next and where do we want to head but I think if we learn anything from the magical secrecy tour which was sort of based on this very simple equation of Berlin in its current and former and peripheral ways plus Snowden what we learned is that it really does help to look at the past to look in corners of your field that you wouldn't consider necessarily initially to be useful and interesting and to try to see things in as varied a way as possible in order to work through that humongous blind spot separating the monk from the or whoever that is on the coast of the image by Kasper Friedrich to the relationship between that and the clear open sky that apparently is somewhere out there beyond thank you


Last week we briefly looked at the many lines of evidence that humans are causing global warming. We also looked at how all this evidence has resulted in an overwhelming scientific consensus. However, a small minority don't even accept that global warming is happening. So this week we're going back to basics. We'll examine the many different indicators that our planet is warming. We'll look at the heat building up in our climate system and how that affects heat records and sea level rise. We'll look at a growing contributor to sea level rise, melting ice. We'll talk about the challenges of putting together a global temperature record and we'll even look at what's been causing some recent intense winters in the northern hemisphere. I'm here at the University of Ottawa where one of our presenters is researching the cryosphere. Standing in the snow, it might seem a little weird talking about global warming. But remember, global warming is about the temperature averaged over the whole planet. Even while the planet continues to build up heat, some places will still experience cold. So let's look at some of the myths casting doubt on the basic reality of global warming.