Hey Virgo, welcome back to my channel. Virgo, let's see what drama you have going on in your love life now. What's going on with Virgos today? This is a Virgo channel only. So if you are Virgo's son when rising your Venus, definitely watch the video. If you want to get a personal reading from me, there's a link in the description box below as always. You can just click that link and that will take you to my booking site. That is the only way to get a reading with me. I will never contact you to do readings. I'll never put anything in the comments. You just click the link under the video and that will take you right to my booking site. Okay, and you book through there. All right Virgo, just remember this is a general reading so be mindful. The messages may or may not resonate. It may not be in continuation of the past reading either. Okay, but it may be. So let's see Virgo. Okay, I'm not going to take those. What are your love messages? What are Virgos? Hi everybody in the chat. All right, let's see. Okay, three of cups, four of cups, eight of cups, eight of wands, the emperor, the emperor is back right at the center of the reading. Okay, six of cups, the king of swords, Libra Gemini Aquarius, Aries, the queen of swords, a match. This is a match and the five of cups. Okay, bottom of the deck you have the Hierophant. I almost forgot what it was called. Okay, the Hierophant. This has to do with commitment, marriage, a very traditional kind of a relationship or somebody and this is Taurus energy so it could have something to okay. Okay, we have someone on the cusp of Aries Taurus could be a significator for you. You know, I feel like whoever your person is, right, it feels like this person is definitely watching you and that they're at a crossroads, they're making a decision about marriage. This person's very passionate about you but the three of pentacles is here. This is the marriage card. This is two people working together as a team, teamwork, either working together on a job or together as far as like a marriage. I feel like you've got somebody here who's going to be communicating with you, Virgo, actually about like a traditional relationship and I'm talking like I know some of you may not want to be married but this person does okay, traditional wedding and they've been thinking about it. This person has just really been contemplating they're very curious about you may even be asking you what do you think about this because I feel like some of you are not looking for marriage or just are okay with just being exclusive with each other but this person is not. They want to put the nail in the coffin here with you like you be their spouse. All right, let me take a look here. I want to see what the love messages are. What are Virgo's love messages? Of course, pay attention to the red flags. I'm going to pull that card out of there because that's such a Debbie Downer. Okay, new love. Wow, a new person. Virgo, this is somebody new. It's true love, okay. Now I know some of you want someone from the past back okay and maybe you just have that person on the back burner right now because you're exploring other options but I feel like you're going to meet somebody new. You're very much though you may not be ready to meet someone new. I feel like you're kind of a bit hesitant to get involved with anyone at this time. It's not that you don't want love and it's not that you don't want to have somebody but there may be somebody coming in here who's just so crazy about you that they're just talking about marriage right away or this is something that they want. Okay, so this person I feel it feels to me like they're very they've been indifferent to love. Everyone that they've met has been kind of like blah carbon copies of one another I just heard. Like they look on Instagram or on social media and they just feel like every person that they meet is a carbon copy of the one before and it's the same old. They wear the hair the same. They dress the same clothing you know they act the same way they speak the same way and this person has a lot of suitors and have a lot of people who are interested in them but they're not interested in those people because they're not you Virgo. You're very unique and I feel like this person mostly is the one these are red flags for them. They're looking for someone special and someone unique that's not a carbon copy of all the others. Now for some they just said spirit just said to tell them that your past person if things didn't work out this person went looking for others but they were looking for you and every other person that they met and nobody was you and they wound up leaving a relationship or the dating life okay because they couldn't replace you and I feel like spirits just saying to tell them that they were trying to they were hoping to meet someone just like you it's a very bizarre thing but I feel like you know either this is somebody new or like love gets there's a recommitment to love there's a recommitment to a relationship so I feel like this person that in this reading here sees these other people who are like carbon copies of each other as red flags and they're not interested in that this person is looking for the one going after that ace of cups and that one is you. Now very well could be somebody you were connecting with in the past where you know they met you but they weren't ready to be with you and they kept dating but see you grew on them there was something about you that was very special and you kind of grew on this person and then everyone that they dated after it's bizarre it's like okay well Virgo's there why didn't you just go for Virgo but something maybe there was religious differences or some obstacles or they just were not ready for that full committed like marriage kind of thing it feels to me like they are it just kind of feels like this person was had to go out and sew their oats maybe they had cold feet but all they're seeing is red flags all they're seeing is red flags I don't even want to clarify any this because that's what I feel like going on this person is showing up here wow they've made a decision here two of swords in the reverse no more blocking no more stalemate this person is showing up it's like taking the lead there's definitely a reconciliation here to bring new love back into this connection if there was love before to it's stirring the pot this is kind of like it feels like it's brand new all over again they want that new that love that that feeling that you had when you guys were first together when you first met so there's a lot of communication there's travel coming in I mean I feel like this person is going to be on top of you messaging you a lot communicating with you a lot with a lot of passion this is the 1111 so it feels like I'm just seeing a lot of ones here it feels like this person is is going to be initiate trying to initiate this passion between you again okay but why are they doing this now because well I mean I don't know if you said something to them or gave them some tea or something but it feels to me like this decision no matter what you said is coming from them because everyone else out there the other people they connected with maybe just very immature or partying all the time or just irresponsible or was just looking for a one night kind of thing was just not taking them seriously and I feel like even though your person wasn't taking your relationship seriously the people they were connecting with after you wasn't taking them seriously and wasn't looking that made them realize that what they had with you was a good thing and is still is a good thing I feel like this person may have been used to people that they would meet always wanting more from them and it feels like either they met someone who wasn't all about them as much as you were or they met others who just weren't like putting them up on a pedestal and this person you know I feel like they became very discouraged because you were giving you were giving and you were loving and you were true as best as you possibly could be okay and now they're thinking about you and you're definitely on their mind a lot so this emperor coming in like the emperors all the kings and one representing fire earth air and water whom a real person is and they're coming in and taking this leadership role they went they go from a king fully to an emperor okay and it's an energy so it's not necessarily masculine or feminine but it's an energy the emperor is someone who is true noble has a commanding way about them not deep not demanding but the the presence there's a lot of respect and this person is commanding respect now in their life you must have been dealing with someone who is kind of PG immature not really grown up but I feel like you're going to get some flowers or maybe a gift you're going to get an apology from this person they want to come in with sincerity and they will be just going to be you might hear something you might hear some news from this person around October 8th which is next Friday there might be some communication there could be something about getting together going somewhere together you going to see them them coming to see you now whether that's long distance or you guys are just getting together meeting somewhere if you live in the same town but you haven't seen each other in a while let's get a card on this emperor what is this emperor okay four pentacles so it feels like this person is holding on they see you they want long-term security this is what they want they're tired of the frivolousness and the people that they've met and you are too Virgo you're kind of like some of you just really don't want to you're just I don't know that you you want love but then you take you step back and you look okay now you got to meet somebody now you got to go through the whole process of seeing if things will work out or if you're compatible it's like the whole you know interview process kind of thing for those of you who are serious about finding someone or attracting someone into your life so it's a daunting task for you and some of you just maybe you're still getting over someone from the past or you're just not putting as much effort and energy into it because you have other things in your life that require your attention or you just really I feel like some of you are like okay well somebody comes along then yeah but you're not really going out of your way if someone strikes your fancy there is someone here that is going to strike up communication with you and try to connect with you it could be a past person and for others if you know that that's long gone and that's done and over with this could be somebody like a new lover coming in this could be somebody you already know or you knew as maybe like I just heard somebody's brother or sister's friend or a connection to family it could be a connection to a father figure as well or you knew somebody somebody here one of you had just only your father in your life the mother figure I don't know I don't see the mother figure I see the father figure when you were children you might have known this person when you were children and they haven't forgotten about you okay so there's something definitely coming up here either you're already speaking to them or you will be sometime around the eighth of October but your romantic feelings definitely coming up again with this person now it could be an error sign if not the energy that I'm seeing here is this person telling you that they always felt like you would be good together they always knew there's somebody saying I'm sorry about your mother or maybe your father sorry about one of your parents I'm sorry that I let you go and I'm sorry yes definitely an apology I'm sorry look at those two cups back there and then we have three cups right here I'm sorry that I spilled so much wine with others when you were there the whole time this person sees you both as a match because the error sign can represent Virgo okay male or female take it however you want there's a match here you guys it's like your communication will be the strongest aspect now that might be a surprise for some of you because perhaps in the past there wasn't a strong communication thing but there's something here about truth telling honesty there's someone here may be unmarried or divorced or a widow it could be an apology I'm sorry about your ex or your spouse who's gone or passed away or left you or something I feel like this person wants to take that person's place we had air all over the reading yesterday so it's back is your person an air sign maybe maybe not but coming through both of you are coming through his air this is true love this is a romantic start happening here okay I feel like this person has always been in love with you maybe you guys didn't communicate or you haven't talked in a really long time I feel like this person has always been in love with you let me take a look at this king of swords okay yeah always keeping it quiet hush hush never revealing their thoughts are how they felt this is like a secret secret admiration secret love a secret lover comes out and speaks oh my gosh so the queen of swords sits here with the seven of swords I'm hearing why did you run away or why um where were you gone where did you go where have you been something along those lines now both of you might have had secret emotions deep down for each other but never truly shared them and both of you might have run away from each other there's a lot of remorse about that it kind of feels like remorse about not coming together at the time when the time was right and this feels like sorry about that kind of thing I'm hearing somebody say I should have taken the opportunity when it arose but I wasn't ready to go full in with you okay I thought it was this person somebody's saying to you I thought I was I I wanted to be but when it came time to get the ball rolling and to actually go and do it I chickened out or I ran away or I just got scared or cold feet or something so there's remorse here or I had some more oats that I needed to sew I wasn't I needed to make sure I got it out of my system you take that however you want yeah look page of cups definitely an apology look see how this little child oh sorry about the children as well something to do with children but do you see how he's holding that big cup with those flowers and look at that it's also sorry about your child somebody apologizing about a child child that used to love to fish or for others it's remember when we used to fish together when we were kids or something we used to go fishing when we were kids let's look at the six of cups here tell me about the six of cups I've been thinking about you I'm thinking about what to say to you Virgo I'm thinking about sending you flowers somebody did send you flowers or sent you a message or something and maybe you didn't respond this person's been waiting but they're also standing at the edge of the cliff they're ready to put something out there there's some boats here waiting for their ships to come in waiting for you to respond maybe you just didn't get the message I feel like this person sent quite a few messages to and cups this back again so cancer scorpio piscian energy definitely in the water energy communicating with you no matter what your person sign is in that watery energy like really very passionate about you but also that passion their actions are passion but it comes from place of deep love deep emotions for you is what I feel like this is where this is coming from this feels mostly like a stirring up of feelings some of you have felt like dry as a pack of bones just not like not feeling that watery not feeling soaked in the love you've just felt dry and this feels like the water getting stirred up within you there's tears I feel there's tears somebody has tears tears of joy this person is coming in here they want to be with you spend time with you take a trip together they want they're gonna they're separating from whomever they were with or whatever this love this dating thing or whatever they thought they were out on this journey seeking they're removing themselves from it because they see everything or all the people that they're meeting or have met have just been nothing but red flags now Virgo did you have any red flags of course not kidding everybody has some red flags okay but I don't think you had as many as the people they were choosing or the people they were talking to or the way other people or another person was showing up I mean you you have your moments right Virgo nobody's perfect here I just want to ask about you I just want to ask about Virgo what's going on with Virgo actually I'm going to pull some cards from here how's Virgo feeling right now oh there's king of cups very emotional you're feeling very emotional Virgo this card was sitting here playfulness you've got somebody here a cancer scorpio Pisces coming in with very playful energy but you you want that playfulness with someone that romance the youth the fun swinging on the swings together going for walks playing playing games not bad games you know not manipulative games like actual games playing at the park together doing fun things a picnic or shopping together you know going to movies or things like that a playful fun okay so your emotions are very deep right now but they're dormant Virgo some of you have really been trying to get in touch with how you feel how you what's going on deep in your heart a lot of you have just kind of pushed those emotions down maybe because you had other things to take care of a lot of you put your poker face on you meet other people you're just kind of like I'm a stone and I cannot be effed with so you're just not really revealing your feelings although they're very tumultuous and you're feeling them very deep you know you're feeling things very deep what else is going on with Virgo oh my goodness these that you know what okay you can't even make this up the king of cups and the eight of wands the king of cups and the eight of wands so those of you who are connecting with a water sign this is a double confirmation that you are definitely one hundred and twenty thousand percent going to be getting communication from a water sign okay whether you want that want the communication or not that's nothing to do with me and your reading I'm just telling you what I'm seeing here it's predictive you don't have to accept communication but I feel like you and this person want the same thing you want to talk you want the romance the passion you want to see each other you want to spend time together okay now that might not resonate for all of you that's just for those of you you know who are connecting with that water energy but you also Virgo you want to travel you are you you want you want to get in your car you know speed down the highway and have your music you want to have fun you want to be happy and enjoy your life you want that passion back let me say what else is Virgo feeling okay but you also want stability some of you are really working on your businesses growing a business you may have a brick and mortar working in a family business keeping that going you're very stable you want to maintain stability and you want to keep that money flow coming in this is like inheritance you might be getting an inheritance or leaving a legacy of family and children or that's something that you want to do this is a card of marriage too but it's a card of safety and security so you're definitely like this is your energy right now some of you may need to travel for a family business or work coming up you may meet a king of cups cancer Scorpio Piscian who comes in wanting the same exact things you want what else is going on here with Virgo there may be news about a grandfather or an older father an older male something that will be discussed between siblings oh my gosh 10 of cups two 10s this person wants to listen I know that we're talking about you here but I feel like you and this person want the same things a good stable steady functioning working wealthy foundation to build from together nice home nice vehicles you know comfort and quality but also love and support and passion and for some of you it's a king of swords okay listen you can't make these cards up they don't lie it's either a water sign or for some of you it's Libra Jebonite Aquarius some of you Virgos you want both you have your eye on a water sign you have an eye your eye on an air sign and see which one comes up first that's what I feel like for some of you oh my goodness all right let's take a look because you know what the air and the air and the water is showing up in your reading and it's showing up over here okay so some of you might have and there is fire as well some of you might have a couple of choices here a double all right so let's take a look at the king of cups and I'll take a look at the king of wands and then I'll take a look at the king of air now there's no king of pentacles here and that is a strong message to me that if you were connecting with a king of pentacles Virgo Taurus Capricorn they are they're not significant at this time okay that doesn't mean they won't be tomorrow it just means right now spirit isn't bringing them up for some reason and they might be working on something with that king of pentacles even though there was Taurus energy there that's more of an energy all right let's take a look at the king of cups what does the king of cups want to say okay I am afraid to contact you okay I bury myself and work to forget you okay king of the king of cups has a lot of fear to contact you if you haven't been communicating with that person they've been burying themselves in work to alleviate their fear they know they have to reach out they know they want to contact you and I feel like they will but right now there's a fear to reach out to you maybe you might reject them or you know give them a mouthful about something what else you don't know how hard it was to let you go okay some of you might have made the decision to let this person go and then in turn they had to let you go I don't feel like they're dealing well with that at this time and that's why I do feel like there is reconciliation they want to come back in to connect with you they're not doing well without you they want that love back again I get one more it was my fault but I blamed you okay yeah and that's what the apology is coming in all those things that I said with that apology let's take a look at the let's look at the king of fire the king of wands Aries Leo Sagittarius what are their emotions here towards you I know I messed up everything okay so many things remind me of you there's so many people there's a lot of people like I said they were trying to do the whole carbon copy thing or fine look for you and others and they weren't able to do that everybody was a red flag they're like nope nope this isn't Virgo nope let me go on to the next one nope that's not Virgo either nope let me move on to the next one sometimes I stay awake thinking about you yeah because that's how they can stay in their mind that's how they can control the the narrative of you and them being together they lay in bed looking at your social media this king of wands or looking to see if you're online or if you've been posting um that weird stuff that kind of stuff you know they lay in their bed at night and they're like thinking of you they're see they're seeking you out looking to see what you're saying if you're with anyone what you're doing who if you who you're talking oh I love you okay well that's definitely why this person is doing that they do love you are they in love with you I don't know about that but they definitely have love for you Virgo all right let's take a look at this king of air Gemini Libra Aquarius and don't forget you guys um I'm here going to be here every Friday evening from 8 to 10 p.m eastern standard time to do super chat readings okay $20 I'll pull one card and answer any question you have so pop on in the chat make your super chat donation with your question in the super chat and I will do a mini reading for you okay all right let's see king of air and please do hit like share and subscribe on your way out if you haven't already okay timing just wasn't right for us okay there was something here perhaps you guys like I said met in the past or you were children or there was um something to do with a child or this person I don't know what exactly the issue is but I do feel like this person definitely had true love for you but they felt as if the timing wasn't right they say us but they mean them because for you for some of you it did feel right and for others of you you're like yeah you're right it wasn't maybe you guys had different partners as the years went by I will wait for a sign from you okay so this person is definitely sitting in a position of grief and remorse and they hope that you will reach out to them or message them um with a nice you know a lovely sweet message definitely I don't think they're going to contact you first for some this king of sorts I feel like you're going to have to be the one to do that if you want you came closer than anyone burgo no one in their life has ever gotten as close to them as you have no one has ever made them feel so safe and comfortable to share their inner things their inner emotions or their feelings than you I don't know if you guys were best friends or what but they couldn't let you get close to them okay not all the way I feel like they're ready to now but I think at the time before they were just incapable of allowing that to happen they just couldn't for whatever reasons but the overall energy for all of these kings is that they've been thinking about you and thinking about this whole thing and this relationship and like I said all three kings are watching you but they are thinking about like they want to communicate and tell you let's do this now I just want to pull some cards here for you and see what your love messages are here for you burgo okay spiritual lesson this person is in your life to teach you a spiritual lesson and know some of you have truly learned some things about your relationships in the past and things like that you definitely have had an awakening or even just some spiritual experiences that have made you realize a lot of things about your path and the people that you love and the people that are in your life you've had major lessons here now for some of you it could be a king of cups that you learned a lot of things from because a king of cups usually has a very gentle uh sweet nature and Virgo you know you can be pretty you know of course a Chinese sign affects your Virgo as well but Virgo like the foundation of Virgo is can be quite analytical can sometimes be harsh can sometimes be very hermit like and withdrawn okay the earth is very solid and slow okay earth signs just very solid and slow but you know like earth earth signs are like earthquakes you know when they move it's like boom you know it's like it's like it's like the way the the tectonic plates move like you know Virgo is very slow but strong that's that's earth energy you know like very dense type of a person type of sign strong willed strong headed in a lot of ways even though you're mutable and easily easily adapt to change you could be very strong headed strong willed where the water is very fluid water is very fluid you know floating down a river or is freed from a boat very fluid and emotional and sometimes wishy washy but very like you know they're intense so all right they're giving me water can crash or it can flow okay water can be a great penetrator water can destroy but at the same time it can be very gentle and cleansing so I went into something there okay let's see longing okay Virgo someone is secretly longing for you I feel like it's either one person or it's three people what's going on here but that's definitely what's happening here I said secret so it could be an air sign okay and there's someone here who is gripped by obsessive thoughts of you definitely Virgo goodness let's see one more but healing this is beautiful old wounds and childhood issues need revisiting so you're healing something here Virgo you definitely are maybe you're healing a past thing with a water sign and you have new people or someone new coming in and for others it's just healing and it's going to re-emerge again all right let me get your advice cards here Virgo's advice hi everybody how are you how are you today this candle I have lit is maple no yeah maple wood bacon I think it's bacon wait no it's it's it's maple like for like syrup pancakes waffles but I can't smell it because my nose is like stuffy so I lit it for you and I know you can't smell it someday we'll have smellivision and then we'll you know we'll all be able to share our scents our lovely candle apple maple scents for autumn all right Virgo's advice wow we have the 10 of cups a happy marriage seek a happy marriage Virgo seek happily ever after be open attract that as well there's emotional contentment here so so be emotionally content content with what you have not with what you don't have right never in a position of wanting or longing re establish or re-establish a loving relationship with your children I don't know who that's for but if you're not in touch with your children or something along those lines your advice here is to get back into a loving relationship with your children or establish one with your child or a grandchild know Virgo that if you have children you raise them very wisely and successfully you did a great job with your kids you may not feel like you did and listen if that's how you feel I get it because I'm a mother as well and mother's guilt is a real thing it's the real deal and stay and and focus on people I mean also that's also for the fathers okay not just the mothers I'm sorry I know I sometimes I forget to address the males here the masculine you're doing a great job with your children and you have been so know that okay and stick with people that you can trust at this time that's your advice people who support you and have your back like when you think of them you know that you can count on them those are your people your tribe if not if you don't have anyone begin to build your tribe okay oh nice Virgo that's definitely you look does she look like anybody here who's listening or someone you know okay stand up for yourself Virgo and your beliefs have confidence in yourself Virgo challenge those who are in power but also make sure you choose your battles wisely okay so don't don't be afraid to stand up and say what you need to say despite any pushback but don't waste your time in frivolous battles make sure what you're fighting for is one of your convictions you don't have to have a conviction you don't have to have 80 million convictions just have a couple or two three or four whatever they might be and stick with those and don't let anybody tell you any differently you can always listen to other people's opinions and advice but if you feel very strongly about a conviction whatever it might be you know stick with it and stand by it whatever decisions you make whatever path you choose stick with it and stand by that decision don't be flaky and don't be wishy washy that's how people know that who you are and that's how people can know that they can trust you because you show conviction and justice wow okay but also be impartial and objective but again stand up for what you believe that's twice so I don't know if somebody you know some of you might be standing up for a relationship or a marriage or something that fell apart maybe there's a lot of people around you who disagree with this relationship but if you believe in it and your person believes in it and you both want to defend your family despite what others say despite what happened in the past there's it's never too late to raise standards you can do it at any time you can make you can change the narrative at any time and if this has to do with a past relationship and you're somebody you guys want to work it out um fight for it stand up for it you can be impartial and objective where you can allow other people to be and hear what they have to say okay but at the end of the day it's ultimately your decision because you have to live with that decision okay but you can try to see all sides of a situation if you need to you will win Virgo if your position is one of integrity if you're coming from a place of authenticity and good intentions and you are true to yourself then it does not matter what anyone else thinks or believes or says okay because you're not out here trying to people please you weren't put on this earth to live up to other people's expectations and they weren't put on this earth to live up to yours how many of you noticed that i quoted Bruce Lee twice today my reading because i'm a big Bruce Lee fan and i quote his stuff all the time i'm just so weird and i called that out because i don't want someone leaving the comments like hey do you know you're quoting Bruce Lee like most people wouldn't know that but some would and then i'm gonna have to ignore you because i don't read the comments sorry i try to read them i don't always get to them so yes that's what i was doing um let's get into the charms oh fork in the road thank god i don't have to eat with this fork i'd be starving trying to pick it up fork in the road for some of you oh i just heard Neptune Pisces i just felt Piscian energy um some of you this is a three prong fork isn't a three prong fork for dessert or is that a four prong fork i'm not sure something this is not four prongs this is three if you have a three prong fork in your house somewhere i know all of you are going to get off here and go looking in your silverware drawer if you have one in your drawer this reading is for you 100 um but it mostly feels like you're at a fork in the road right now between three people fire air and water or you will be okay or you're with someone who's schizophrenic and they show up three different personalities i don't know i'm not making fun i'm just okay maybe i am i just don't know why i would even say that so we're going to leave that fork there um hmm and some of you like you only have three forks you need to go get a set you need to like up your set of silverware i feel like that's silverware you have in that drawer right now is trash it's like would you get it from like walmart or something you need to go to like onida get a nice set of silverware for your your home the details Virgo we want the details we want quality in the details all right so now we're back here with this eagle doesn't the eagle always shows up and of course being from the philly area i always think of the philadelphia eagles so i'm going to have to throw that in there right i'm not really transmitting a message about that but i just have to put that in there but this also feels like the um american eagle and some of you okay i'm just seeing a flagpole so somebody there's a flagpole that was put at half mast for someone that you know could have been military border patrol i don't know somewhere down in nevada arizona texas mexico somebody's down there or lives down there but um american troops maybe you're connecting maybe you're not from america and your person is you're connecting with an american and okay they just gave me this strange message some of you are trying not to be a victim of pray and so what i feel like is happening here if you feel like you're like oh my gosh yes that's me somebody's been praying on me um they're either praying if somebody's not praying for you they're praying on you so you need to be very careful and discerning of what's happening with somebody specifically like if they're not down on their knees at night before they go to bed asking god to bless your heart and keep you safe while you're there not together with you and praying for healing in your relationship then that person is praying on you and trying to get something from you so just keep your keep your wits about you that's not for everybody and that's not predictive that this person coming in is doing that this just feels more like that's for someone specific okay so now we have a horse and so i feel to tell some of you this um you're connected with someone who is of the chinese sign the horse the sociable horse the horse is sociable very sociable person um there's also somebody here that has like a very powerful car or a hot rod or a race car or there's someone connected to horse rating or as an equestrian or does something with horses maybe you have somebody here has um a ranch or a farm where there's horses or you ride horses or go horseback riding or your person and then i just heard okay sometimes spirits funny my guides they tell me things and they just come out of the blue some of you are dating someone who is italian italian they're either from Italy or they're italian-american like rocky baboa that's your you're dating a rocky baboa the italian stallion maybe connecting with someone who's a boxer or does ufc or mma is that the same thing i don't know i should know because i love bruce lee but i don't so i don't have a problem admitting that i don't know what i'm talking about so there's something here with that and i got all that from a horse so i don't know here the horse would be 1966 and is it 66 hold on a minute 1966 and 1978 and then 1990 and then 2002 i think okay i'm gonna leave that there so now of course you have look this is a wine glass and guess what's in it peach schnapps okay so if you like peach schnapps i'm i'm just kidding peach schnapps are my favorite this is actually um i just um they gave me the name i don't know what this is i'm just hearing blood orange blood orange i don't know what blood orange is they just said blood orange okay in a wine glass or in a glass or some kind of all right so obviously it could be like um also like a um like an orangey wine too oh and then they okay so i just had an image of the kool-aid guy punching through the brick wall the f the half kool-aid guy maybe you have like a cocktail called kool-aid or you drink a cocktail called kool-aid i don't know we're leaving that there are you drinking one right now or you're gonna make one okay so we have okay okay some kind of guitar all right there's four there's four strings so this is a base okay some of you used to catch used to go fishing with someone that would catch bass bass fishing they were called the bass master or somebody they called themselves the bass master or they were a bass master but this is um oh i just heard ace of bass okay so we have a yeah a bass somebody plays in a band maybe or plays bass um they might play guitar too but the it's a string instrument we're gonna put it there there's somebody either you maybe you play a string instrument some of you are if you do you haven't played it in a while or you're looking at it right now and you're thinking of a song and you just heard ace of bass and now you're gonna go learn that or some of you um this is your person you're connected to who is somebody's dusting the bass or the dust off their stringed instrument guitar or something okay that's so bizarre um i feel like i want to get another one okay this is a christmas candle for sure christmas candle seeing it's i know you probably my charms are i don't know what my camera let me see my camera doesn't like to focus why is that how do i get my camera to focus you can't see it but you know how i see sometimes people like they put their hand up to block out the behind view but anyway it's a candle and it has a little holly around it okay so it's a christmas candle i don't know what that's about because it's not even christmas not yet but you know it's really strange too because today uh this morning i was at the store and i was looking for candle candle candelabros or candles electric candles for my windows and i couldn't find any which is fine but this isn't actually an electric candle though this is a real candle because the wax is melting okay i don't know we're going to pull another one though because i'm not really sure they're not giving me anything except to say yeah maybe you were looking for electric candles for your windows are you thinking about getting them for christmas or something if you celebrate the holidays the christmas or just somebody leaving a light on for you around the holidays when it's cold weird i just saw i just saw an image of the headless horseman what the i just saw the headless horseman that's halloween what's his name ebb and neezer no what's the headless the heck was his name i forget buck wait somebody's gonna post it in the comments i know wait paul revere no that's paul i'm mixing up paul revere and the headless horseman do you remember like so american revolutionary history was um um one if by day two if by night there's something about a candle in a window like in this october through december season i'm i'm walking away from this the headless horseman what was did he have a name somebody tell me didn't you have like a pumpkin head or something was that a movie oh pumpkin head wasn't that a horror movie i don't watch horror movies so i just remember that maybe somebody's gonna watch pumpkin head or you just did watch that horror movie pumpkin head that's scary i don't do horror movies you would think i would because being a vergo but i don't you know why because i see that shit in my head i see that scary stuff i don't like being scared life is scary enough as it is now i'll watch like thrillers thrillers are fine and i'll watch like serial killer documentaries but i don't watch that slasher crap i i think that's stupid actually that's my opinion though i just think it's dumb all right we got a pair of sunglasses and we have a dinosaur well what do you want me to say about the dinosaur i mean somebody's name is barney connecting with a barney this is a tyrannosaurus rex this is a t-rex speaking of thrillers Jurassic park can i tell you what i'm just gonna tell you a short little story and and some of you um need to go get your glasses fixed like you're sitting there with like one lens or the arm is missing and you still have it propped up on the bridge of your nose i mean come on now go get your glasses fixed when 1992 i read the book Jurassic park before the movie came out and halfway through the book i was having panic attacks because it was so scared because there's a little girl my brother and i used to watch tv show called land of the lost with will and holly and i used to get so scared i was terrified of the t-rex in land of the lost but i was fascinating fascinated with dinosaurs so i read the book i think i was like 21 or 22 and i was like freaking out i was so scared it just triggered all my childhood trauma from that stupid tv show but then i went and i saw the movie like an idiot because my boyfriend made me go see it even though i told him i was scared but i went anyway with him and can i tell you the scene where they're in the jeep and then the the t-rex comes and that one guy before he gets eaten you know like when he was in the toilet or the outhouse like the scene when the dinosaur came real close remember and he was like it only sends you by your movement it can't see i'm not kidding you now it's like 30 years later and i still cannot watch a Jurassic park like Jurassic park movies at all that's not even a horror that's a that what do you call that it's a thriller like i'm telling you trauma will stick with you unless you deal with it one of my other biggest traumas was i used to have dreams of tornadoes chasing after me and then twister came out in the late 90s and i made myself watch that and i got over my fear of tornadoes because i was having even my dreams but honestly like the the dinosaur thing forget it uh i i all i could do is barney back then i could only handle like barney the dinosaur i love you you love me because that was like a nice dinosaur and he wasn't trying to bite your freaking head off so maybe Jurassic park resonates for some of you or you're taking your kids to a dinosaur exhibit or something or you're going to a museum or you have maybe recently isn't there a Jurassic park attraction or in a ride somewhere like at disney or something maybe there's like a roller coaster or attraction or a ride or something now i and they just said there's also a lotus flower here so that's going to resonate for someone either going to get a tattoo of a lotus flower or you have one this dinosaur though it just went away i forget what i was going to say about it oh um somebody's going to be like have a dinosaur head for a halloween costume if you're going to a halloween party or you're thinking of of what you can be t-rex seems to be it well that was fun okay we hit the hour i'm trying to get in an hour for your readings each day so that you guys can just everybody can get the messages so again thanks for watching totally fun don't forget to show up i'm getting i'm saying goodbye you guys right now but don't forget to show up on fridays if you want to get a personal mini reading for me twenty dollars one card you can pay right through super chat i can't give you any refunds because i can't refund from there it doesn't work like that so if you post your question and you don't get it answered come back the following friday the moderators are going to have a list of everyone who posts their question and your name so that if you don't get your question answered just show up the next friday and you'll be the first ones to get your questions answered okay all right you guys so thanks for hanging out that was fun love you all and i don't even know what to call this reading but maybe i'll let you guys caption it we'll see and i will see you guys tomorrow all right bye


I mean, why these guys were armed, what happened? I was working in domestic violence. I was in the preliminary development of Hasid negotiation before Hasid negotiation teams existed in the early 70s.


So, hi, I am Akshay Degwejkar. This is structure versus hardness through the obfuscation lens. It is joint work with Neel Bhitansky and Vinod Vaikunthanathan. So, very structured algebraic problems like discrete log are the bread and butter of cryptography. Most of our modern cryptography, especially the public key kind, is based on these problems. And in this talk, we would like to understand, is this inherent? Right? So, first of all, we know that this structure, algebraic structure is great for functionality. In, moreover, we could say that this structure has been purated in getting cryptography, in the development of cryptography itself. For example, public key encryption really became possible when we assume the hardness of these number theoretic problems like factoring. Similarly, the first zero-knowledge proofs we had were for quadratic residuality. And more recently, as we have assumed hardness of problems on lattices and so on, we have a host of fantastic new applications such as fully homomorphic encryption. Okay. So, it is evident that this structure is great for functionality, but it does not come for free because structured, algebraically structured problems are a bit more easier to solve. And this gives us a trade-off between hard problems on one end, between hardness and algebraic structure. On one end, we have SAT. So, SAT is extremely hard. At the same time, it is very unstructured. Unfortunately, we don't know how to base any crypto on the hardness of SAT alone. Then we have assumptions in mini-crypt. So, these have somewhat more structure. And finally, we come to cryptomania, which is what we would be interested in this talk. Most of the... So, these consists of primitives of the public key kind. So, most of these are based on a handful of assumptions such as QR, DDH, and so on. All these assumptions are extremely algebraic. It turns out that we know some surprising quantum and sub exponential time algorithms for these problems. So, these problems are easier in a different sense as well, that they are unlikely to be NP-complete. The reason is because they lie in these lower, more structured complexity classes like NP-intersec, co-NP, and SDK. So, for now, SDK is the class of problems that have statistical zero-knowledge proofs. For now, think of it as a small complexity class. I'll define it later. So, the first natural question here is, how do we go about capturing this algebraic structure? In this talk, we make the choice that structure is equated with a hardness in low complexity classes. Okay. So, why is this a good idea? So, first of all, we know that most of our assumptions actually lie in these two classes. Moreover, they lie in these classes because they have some deep global properties. For example, factoring lies in NP-intersec, co-NP, because factoring is unique. And quadratic residuosity lies in SDK because of its random-cells reducibility. So, we do actually want to capture these kinds of properties. And finally, we know that some of this structure actually implies crypto. Ostofsky showed that any average case hard language in SDK actually implies one-way functions. So, we do want to understand these connections better. Maybe they are tighter. Okay. So, right. So, this brings us to the main question of this talk, does crypto actually require these structured assumptions? So, sometimes it turns out that the answer is yes. In some cases, the cryptographic primitives themselves imply hard problems in these classes, in which case the fact that the assumptions have to be structured is very natural. For example, fully homomorphic encryption implies hard problems in SDK. And some very special kinds of public encryption schemes and one-way functions also imply hard problems in NP intersect co-NP. But this is quite, this is not understood very well. Let's take the case of public key encryption. So, we don't actually know if public key encryption implies hard problems in these classes. Given that public key encryption is usually based on assumptions which imply hard problems in these classes, it would seem the case, but we don't actually know. Similarly, the case for other primitives like functional encryption, oblivious transfer, IO, and so on. Okay. So, this is the main question of this talk, which cryptographic primitives require complexity theoretic structure? So, basing cryptography on minimal assumptions is a major goal in cryptography. And understanding the complexity theoretic implications of these primitives helps shed light on what the minimal assumption has to be. Again, for the, for FHE, we know that it implies hard problems in SDK. So, it has to be based on problems like lattice problems which also lie in SDK. On the other hand, with one-way functions, we can dream. We could hope to base them on NP hardness alone. Great. So, in this work, we try to collect evidence that structure may not actually be that necessary. So, how do we go about doing it? Let's think of the simple case that showing that one-way functions do not imply hard structured problems. The best way to do this would be to do it unconditionally, which would be in something like even if P was actually equal to SDK, one-way functions still exist. Unfortunately, this is too much to ask for because this would in particular imply proving P not equal to NP. So, we go for the next best thing, which is we try to prove limitations on our techniques. An approach which was pioneered by Impaglia's and Roudic. Okay. So, let me tell you about commonly used techniques in crypto. Right. So, black box constructions are very pervasive in all of crypto. In this case, let's think about how do we construct language in NP intersect with NP using one-way functions in a black box way. Right.  The first of all is a construction, which is a language in NP intersect with NP defined using the one-way function, which only uses input-output access to the one-way function. And additionally, we have a security proof, which says that given any adversary which breaks the language, we can use this adversary again only in an input-output access to invert the one-way function. So, it turns out that we can rule out such reductions. And in particular, Roudic showed that one-way functions actually do not imply hard problems in NP intersect with NP in such a black box way. Right. So, what do we know about these black box separations? So, when it comes to understanding the relationship between two complexity theoretic primitives, we know quite a bit. The landscape is quite well understood about how different primitives are related to each other in a black box way. On the other hand, when it comes to the complexity theoretic implications of cryptographic primitives, less is known. So, basically, we know that one-way functions do not imply hard problems in NP intersect with NP, and they do not imply average case hard problems in SDK. So, we would like to understand these better. For example, does public key encryption imply hard problems in NP intersect with NP? How about IO? Does it imply hard problems in SDK? With that, we come to our results. So, what do we show? So, right, at a high level, this is how the world looks like right now. There are some primitives which actually imply hard problems in NP intersect with NP and SDK, and there are one-way functions which don't. So, we show that public key encryption does not imply hard problems in NP intersect with NP and SDK, the same for OT. So, what we actually show is that IO along with one-way functions does not imply hard problems in either of these two classes. Proving separations for IO is great, because it lets us infer the same for all the primitives which are implied by IO in a black box way. Okay. And that list keeps going. Some remarks. So, first of all, isn't IO very non-black box? I guess thanks, Amir, for giving away the points line. It turns out that we can capture these, why IO does use most constructions in a black box, non-black box way? It does so in a fairly restricted manner. Most constructions first construct some primitive using the one-way function in a black box way, and then they obfuscate it. Ashrova and Segev give a framework of oracle-aided circuits, like circuits which have one-way function gates, which captures such constructions. And so, we also work in this model. And we show that in this model, IO cannot construct hard problems in SDK or in NP intersect with NP. Second, does IO exist? So, the nice thing for this work is it doesn't matter. Even if IO did not exist, we have still learned something. For example, this lets us know that public encryption does not imply hard problems in SDK. And this holds regardless of whether IO exists or not. So, a bit more formally, what do we show? So, most of these constructions of hard, most of these black box separations construct a special oracle world where one of the primitives exists, but the complexity class is easy. And this lets you infer that the complex primitive does not imply hard problems in the complexity class. So, in this case, what we show is that there is an oracle where one-way functions exist. IO, for these oracle-aided circuits, also exists. And at the same time, the complexity classes SDK and NP intersect with NP are easy. Okay. So, because of the lack of time, I would not be talking about the whole thing. So, in this talk, we would show that one-way functions do not imply hard problems in SDK, even worst case hard problems in SDK in a black box way, which in particular means we would show. Okay, good, sorry. So, which in particular means that we would show an oracle where one-way functions exist and yet SDK is easy. I would write it this over. Okay. So, first let me tell you about statistical zero knowledge. So, when we think about the class of statistical zero knowledge. So, when we think about zero knowledge, we think about proofs or prover and a verifier and so on. It turns out that statistical zero knowledge has a nice characterization in terms of complete problems. So, in this talk, we will be focusing on that characterization. In particular, the problem statistical difference, which are shown to be complete for SDK by Sahay and Wadhan. Okay. So, the input in this problem consists of a pair of circuits which define two distributions. So, given a circuit, the output distribution of the circuit is what we consider when the input is a uniformly random input. Okay. So, the problem is we have to determine if the output distributions of these two circuits are close to each other or if they are far from each other. So, if the statistical distance between these two circuits is distributions is small, less than one-third, we have to say no. Otherwise, if it's more than two-thirds, we have to say yes. Note that this is a promise problem. So, in the case where this statistical distance is between two-one-thirds and two-thirds, we don't have to say anything correct. Okay. So, if that is a language in SDK and some x which is an instance, it gets mapped to a pair of circuits. If x is in the language, it gets mapped to a pair of circuits which whose output distribution is far from each other. And if x is not in the language, it gets mapped to circuits which are close to one another. So, let's see how good a hard problem in SDK from one-way functions look like. So, the first half of it is a construction. The construction starts with a one-way function and outputs a pair of circuits. These circuits again make only input-output access to the one-way function. And then the second half is a security proof which says that given any adversary which breaks a ZK, in particular it tells are these two circuits close to each other or far, can be used to invert the one-way function. So, how do we rule this out? There is a very canonical recipe given by Impar Gleason-Rudich which says first construct a oracle for the one-way function, construct an adversary to break a ZK, and finally prove that even given this adversary that breaks a ZK, you cannot invert the one-way function. Great. So, just to repeat, we have to do three things. Design a one-way function, design an adversary to break a ZK and show that the one-way function is secure even given this adversary. So, the first half, designing a one-way function is pretty standard. We would pick a random permutation. It's a great one-way function on its own. The second half, which is we have to design an adversary to break a ZK. So, just recall what the goal is. We are given two circuits. We have to determine if the statistical distance is small or high. So, the oracle, right. So, here's the first candidate. What it does is it first computes the statistical distance between the two functions. Given two circuits as input, it first computes the statistical distance between them. Note that this is not really efficient. It could make exponentially many queries to the one-way function, but that's okay. Then if the statistical distance is less than half, it says no. If it's more than half, it says yes. So, what's good about this? So, what's good is that it actually breaks a ZK. So, at least we are halfway there. Unfortunately, it turns out that this is too powerful. It actually breaks all of NP. And so, it doesn't really help. So, we cannot really show that the F is one way, even given this oracle. So, just to give you some intuition about why it breaks NP. So, on any input X, here's the construction. One of the circuits is simply the verifier. It takes as input a witness, runs the verifier and sees if it accepts or not. The other input is identically zero circuit. So, now, if X was not in the language, these two circuits are identical. On the other hand, if X was in the language, the statistical distance is more than zero. We can actually, oh, sorry. So, we can actually detect this using padding. Come close to half and half, and then it's possible to detect it. Okay, so we need an oracle which is somewhat less powerful than this one. Okay. So, the issue with this oracle is that it is very sensitive to small changes, especially around half. So, our fix is that we would add noise. How do we do it? So, the new adversary to break SDK, again, first computes the statistical distance between the two circuits. Then it picks a random threshold between one-thirds and two-thirds. And if it's less than the threshold, it says no. If the statistical distance is more than the threshold, it says yes. So, what's good about this is that it still breaks SDK. Because to break SDK, all we need to do is to be correct if it's less than one-third and more than two-thirds. In between, we don't really care. The challenge here is that it is also still making exponentially many queries to F. And so, we still have to show that it's not powerful enough to actually break the one-way function, right? So, this is our goal. We have to show that F is one way even given this breaker oracle, right? So, the earlier bug has now been transformed into a feature that this new oracle is actually insensitive to random local changes. And it turns out that for one-way functions, random local changes are sufficient to change the answer the adversary has to give. So, to illustrate, consider the following. That there is a one-way permutation and the challenge is this red box. So, the adversary has to return the position of the red box to succeed. Now, we can do a random change, which is pick a random place and swap these two. Now, the answer the adversary has to give has changed completely. And yet, we can show that every query the adversary makes to these, every query the adversary makes to the adversary, to the breaker oracle, it would receive the same answer with very high probability. And this lets us show that the adversary cannot invert the one-way function, even given access to this SDK oracle. So, this was really quick and dirty. Look at the paper for more details. Okay. So, with this, let me conclude. So, first of all, we showed that IO does not imply hard problems in SDK or NP intersect co-NP in a black box way. Okay. So, the concept of IO has garnered a lot of attention over the last couple of years. It's extremely powerful, and its existence still remains somewhat questionable. This work, interestingly, does not rely on the existence of IO. A few years ago, we would have written a couple of papers showing each of these results separately, but due to IO, we can show all of them in one chart. And secondly, so, this work supports a theoretical possibility that we can construct public key encryption from very unstructured assumption. Yet, the reality remains quite different. Most of our constructions of public key encryption schemes are based on very structured assumptions. There has been some work which has tried to diversify the assumptions behind public key encryption, yet our success has been quite limited. Bridging this gap of constructing public key encryption from unstructured assumptions remains a major open question even today. Okay. Thank you.


There are also conflicting reports that these are perhaps two terrorists, so still information is coming out, but we know for sure that at least one terrorist is killed. And already, as we saw right after the Tel Aviv shooting a ramming and stabbing attack, Hamas very quick to praise this attack, calling it a response within the framework of the continuous retaliation to Israel's aggression against Jenin, so obviously they're trying to tie this, to frame this as a retaliatory attack to what happened in Jenin. And in addition, in the response by the Hamas spokesman, Abdullah Tifel Cano, saying that the guns of the revolutionaries and the resistance will remain open against the occupation and its settlers. And so this does not mean that this is a Hamas-organized attack, but indeed the terror group quick to praise the attack as additional information continues to pour out. I want to bring in Colonel and the Reserves, Alon Eviatar of Palestinian Affairs, expert and former advisor to Kogat and Alon, as we're talking about the context of what is unfolding here, this shooting, a fatal shooting happening just days after the end of that 48-hour operation by the IDF in Jenin against terror infrastructure. Talk to us about the timing of what is unfolding the context right now. Exactly, Benita. I can tell you that this area, this road is known as a place that there were a series of terror attacks over there during the last day period. I can assume that the terrorists were influenced by the wide incitement by Hamas that we heard during the last two weeks. I think that we can show that we can see, sorry, that after the military operation in Jenin, there is a wide campaign by Hamas, especially by Hamas in the West Bank, in order to push outside terrorists who would belong all to Hamas or to another Palestinian terror organization in order to achieve, I would say, achievement, national achievement and to kill Jews. Something that Hamas needs to, I would say, to respond to the military operation which was happening in Jenin. I can remember that after the military operation in Jenin, Hamas called to the Palestinian public to go out everywhere in Tel Aviv and in the West Bank and doing the terror attacks. This kind of terror attacks which happened last hour, this is the kind of terror attacks that you cannot know before, previously, because if those terrorists, we are speaking about maybe two or three or maybe one, but those terrorists start or decide to take a car and take their gun and shoot on the roads, on settlers or soldiers without any previous information, without any clue in the media or in the websites and so on, and it's very difficult to prevent those terror attacks previously. So I can assume that we are in the middle of investigation by the military agencies, but in the end of the day, I can assume that we have to challenge those terror attacks which will be happened or try to happen during the next week or so. Alon, stay with us. I'm going to bring in Guy Azrael, our correspondent here in studio for an update about the developments on the ground. Obviously, a breaking news story. We know one terrorist is dead, any clarity yet on any other potential accomplice, what is known in terms of any searches or manhunts underway as we speak. So more updates are coming in and obviously this is an event that just concluded less than 10 minutes ago. According to the information that we're getting right now, the terrorist approached a civilian patrol next to the settlement of Kadumim opened fire towards that civilian patrol. The patrol officer was not actually hurt in that incident and has returned fire towards the terrorist who then fled the scene with his car where he arrived at the junction where he did a shoot again towards a group of Israelis. The person who unfortunately died was among that group of Israelis and we know that IDF forces who were right there shot back at the terrorist and eventually took him down. That is the latest that we have. Alon, I'm going to come back to you because the Home Front command had ordered residents to remain in their homes and lock their doors and their windows. You know this region well. What kind of messaging is happening right now for the settlement and surrounds? So far we cannot declare that the event or the terror attack was over and finished. I think that still the IDF forces are looking for another terrorist which maybe can going around over there, maybe want to do another terror attack and in order to prevent any option of another terror attack over there in this area, the immediately order to the residents over there in the settlement or around the settlement is to keep down or to close their windows and stay at home till the IDF will publish another or new declaration that everybody can go out. You know a lot of forces with special units with I would say sophisticated equipment and intelligence elements are looking for this cell and we are still waiting for new news. But this is the automatically I would say an order when kind of terror attacks happened in the same way. Colonel, on the reserves, Alon, Evia, Tara, thank you so much for joining us for this breaking news edition. We are going out for a short break before we do that. And a quick update from Ariel Ossiran. Yeah, so IDF Home Front Command saying that residents in Khudumim are not required to stay indoors and hunker down, that the suspected infiltration has been ruled out and residents of Khudumim are allowed to move in and out freely. Ariel, guys, stay with us. We are going to go out for a very short break. If you are just joining us now, it is breaking news edition, a terror attack in the West Bank. One Israeli man has been shot dead in the settlement of Khudumim.  Our breaking news coverage continues after a short break. Stay tuned. This is I-24 News. It was a suicide or an homicide. The Supreme Court dictated that it was a murder. The only solution is, as we have already said, to bring them here. What is behind this so interesting story? Terrorist coverage, international conspiracies, search for the truth. Someday we will know the truth. In the last seven years for the magazine News24 in Spanish, which is broadcast on I-24 News, I reviewed more than 40 reports related to the topic Amian-Isman-Iran, a topic that has all the condiments for you, an international channel of news like I-24 News. Keep investigating until one day the truth is clarified. Our breaking news coverage continues. A terror attack in the West Bank. One Israeli man has been shot dead in the settlement of Khudumim. IDF medical teams had treated him on the scene. He passed away just a short while ago. The terrorist has been shot dead. Still with me in studio, Middle East correspondent Ariel Osaran and correspondent Guy Azrael. This is obviously a developing situation. Bring us up to speed on what is confirmed about what happened with this terror attack. Right, Benito. So still not a lot officially confirmed. We're basing a lot of this from initial information coming out from the scene. But according to at least official information, just about an hour ago this incident began with terrorists approaching West Bank settlement of Khudumim with a car, exiting the car, opening fire towards Israelis there. At least one security guard was among those Israelis. The security guard and others in the area returned fire. And the terrorist enters his car, fled, flees to the nearby Jad Junction where there he gets out of his car, opens fire at a group of Israelis there, begins to flee, and in the shootout he is killed by a group of soldiers that is located in the area. As of now we know one Israeli pronounced that in the scene. Terrorists neutralized and killed as well. Initially there was a suspected infiltration siren in the community of Khudumim. IDF, Home Front Command initially ordered for citizens to remain in their homes and lock their doors. But since then they have issued a statement saying that all movement restrictions have been lifted and that the infiltration suspicion has been confirmed to not be true. And this brings to 25 the number of Israelis killed in terror attacks this year alone for more reaction. We now bring in Yishai Fleischer, spokesperson for the Jewish community in Hebron and advisor to Israeli National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gavir. So the death toll of 25 Israelis killed in this region just this year alone in terror attacks, your reaction to what has happened in just the last hour? Well, we are we've course mourned the death of an Israeli who's been attacked by jihadist terrorism. And we hope that the we're happy that the IDF has already gotten the the terrorist himself. But it's not enough. We have to also dry up the swamp of terrorism of jihadism that has grown within Judean Samaria within also the cities of Israel and is getting a lot of tailwind from the Palestinian Authority from Hamas and from what I even see on on Twitter and on social media as a lot of global justification to kill Israelis supposedly because we're in occupation of our ancestral homeland. But really, it's because of anti Semitism and jihadism, which seeks to occupy take over this whole land. And we got to root out those places, get into those places and clean them out. And if we're not going to do that, we're going to keep on facing attacks over and over again. And of course, the amassment of illegal weapons, the Israeli police estimates at least four hundred thousand illegal weapons just in the Israeli Arab cities. And nobody's even talking about what's going on under the P.A., which which is, you know, in favor of attacks on Jews as their own statements in the last few days. So we got to get we got to take out those weapons and we got to take out the jihadists and thereby get bring back safety to average Israelis and also to average Arabs who want to live in concert with Israel and don't want to see jihadism take them and their children's lives. Yishai Hamas was very quick to respond to the terror attack just a short while ago, praising the shooting, calling it a natural reaction to crimes in Jenin. Would you have expected that this week that IDF operation in Jenin to root out terror infrastructure would have helped quell tensions in the region? Does it surprise you that there has been an attack so shortly after this two day operation in Jenin? Well, I mean, I respect the enemies of Israel and I know that they mean business when they call for the destruction of Israel, they mean it. And if you attack them in Jenin and start to root out, begin to root out the jihadism there, then other homegrown jihadists are going to, you know, attack and they have weapons. We've allowed them to amass these weapons. And so they're going to use them. So no, I'm not surprised at all. We're in for a longer conflict. We have to accept that it's going to be a longer conflict and we're going to have to take the time and the effort to really take back those illegal weapons, root out the jihad preachers and jihad schools and jihad school books, et cetera. And if we're going to want to establish real order here, it's going to take some time. We've allowed the situation to fester. And so it's not surprising at all that there are count that there are attacks by the enemies of Israel. They sense that this government, this army, and this time is such that people want to start really getting into those jihadists and rooting them out. And so they're going to attack. This is a conflict. I don't minimize the strength of our enemies. I don't think that they're, you know, they're weak. I think that they're strong and dedicated. And that's why we have to be even stronger and more dedicated to defeat them. You should I flash a spokesperson for the Jewish community in Hebron and advisor to Israeli National Security Minister Itamar Bengavir. Thank you for speaking to us on this breaking news edition. Thank you. And still with the story, we now bring in Nadav Matzner, the deputy spokesperson for the emergency organization, Mada. And we want to know exactly what you can share about what happened on the scene in terms of emergency response to the shooting just a short while ago in the West Bank. What can you tell us, Nadav? Yes, hello. Less than one hour ago, we called, we got a phone call in a one-on-one emergency phone line about a person who got shot near exhumim, MDA, EMTs and paramedics in a bulletproof ambulance rushed to the scene and with the IDF medical forces, they performed CPR. But unfortunately, they have declared the death of the injured person who was shot by the terrorist. And Nadav, have you got any clarity or update for us on the possibility of another injury as well? Details are emerging, conflicting reports, anything you can tell us? In the beginning of the event, we got a few phone calls that we thought there were probably two victims. But after they reached the scene with the IDF, we find only one wounded and the second one that we thought was the injured, he was okay and didn't get injured at all. So in the end, there was only one victim. Unfortunately, we had to declare death, but the only one in this terror attack. Nadav Matsumada, Deputy Spokesperson, thank you for that update. Appreciate you speaking to us on this Breaking News edition and still with me in studio, a correspondent guy Israel. So a manhunter is underway, although we know that one terrorist has been killed. Any clarity yet on any accomplices? What kind of searches are happening right now? What is the latest development in terms of what's happening across the West Bank right now? Yeah, no information about accomplices at this point. It seems that this was one person in that car that was easy to identify for the IDF forces who eventually took him down. So if there was another person in that car, they would have seen that very clearly. The cars have obviously been stopped. I want to just recap to our viewers what sort of week we've been through here in Israel just yesterday, a shooting attack near Mount Grizine a day before that, sorry, on, yeah, on Tuesday that horrible ramming and stabbing attack in Tel Aviv, injuring at least eight Israelis, a Palestinian who was here illegally ramming into a group of Israelis at the bus stop in the center of Tel Aviv plowing into people standing there and then getting out of the car, stabbing the wounded and looking for more victims before he was luckily gunned down by a civilian. And that comes just a day after another stabbing attack in the city of Nabrak and Amid, all of that, that IDF operation, that 48 hours IDF operation in the city of Genine. Yes, the largest scale such ground operation in the Northern West Bank over the past 15 years, but not one that would hurt the motivation of these terror groups of these lone terrorists to execute more terror attacks. I think the IDF and any commentators were very clear about that, the fact that this operation was meant to harm the infrastructure of the terrorists in Genine to allow more freedom of movement to the IDF as it goes to hunt those terrorists who flee there. That was a safe haven for these terrorists, but the idea was, or at least the understanding was that this is not going to stop the terrorists from executing more attacks. We've seen a wave of terror before the Genine operation, and we are seeing more attacks after Genine. This is not a result of Genine. This is an ongoing wave of terror that Israel is dealing with. Genine was a center, an epicenter of terror that was a big hub, including weapons and terrorists that were in that city, in the refugee camp. So IDF did a very surgical operation there, killing 12 terrorists in the city, but many of them fled. So once the IDF troops pulled out, the refugee camp filled again with civilian population, but also with many terror operatives who continue to operate out of there. In terms of the reaction to the developments just this afternoon, the head of the Samaria Council, Yossi Dagan, is calling for a crushing response from the government, saying this shooting attack illustrates that the terrorist organizations are trying us again and again, even after the operation in the northern West Bank. Talk to us about the pressure right now for the Israeli response. Civilians are being killed 25 in the space of just this year. What is the pressure for real action right now from Israel? It's obviously a terrible situation, and we do have the most right-wing government we've ever had here. So you have, it's not a smart rich of the religious Zionism as a minister who is also part of the Defense Ministry. You have Galant from the Likud as the Defense Minister. You have Itamar Ben-Gvir as the National Security Minister. You have all these persons who are hawkish, and Israel is trying to do whatever it can. It is not going to end with one short 48 hours operation. If Israel wants a more extensive operation, of course, it can do that. That is what was done in the mid-2000s when Israel eventually had enough with an ongoing terror wave that saw buses explode, wedding halls, many other terrible incidents in Israel during the Second Intifada. This is not something that Israel is looking to do right now. Israel has more cooperation with the Palestinian Authority in other parts of the West Bank, in Ramallah, and Bethlehem in other areas that are not as hot as the northern West Bank, and this is an area that is an issue. It is also an issue for Israel politically because it's an ongoing situation that is not going to be resolved any time soon. I think many political leaders should think whether this is a time for unity government to confront this terror wave together, as Israel is of course at the same time dealing with so many internal issues that are dividing the country while needing to deal with this. And we saw this yesterday. So many police forces having to deal with mass protests in Tel Aviv while Israel is fighting such a major wave of terror at the same time. Correspondent Guy Azrael, thank you so much for that update. Earlier in the studio we had our Middle East correspondent, Ariel Osran, and again, thank you to Alon Evietar. If you're just joining us, Breaking News Edition, a terror attack in the West Bank. Israel has been shot dead in the settlement of Kiddal Mim, IDF medical teams had treated him on the scene but he passed away a short while ago. The terrorist has been shot dead. This killing brings to 25 the number of Israelis murdered in terror attacks in the country this year alone. And that is where we wrap up this Breaking News Edition. Our coverage continues. I'm Benisa Levine in Tel Aviv. This is Breaking News.