Good evening everyone. And it's always a pleasure when you tie up of beyond law CLC with legal, legal elites and under the ages of Adi Lakshmi Lovamuti. We have taken sessions, which have a different fascinating aspects. And Miss Adi Lakshmi was the connecting point for connecting us with Sringhar Murali who is an important resource person, not only for legal, legal elites, but also when we have been collaborating on the legal knowledge sharing. And as we know that Miss Sringhar Murali has been taking different perspectives of law, which are not only relevant for the purposes of a common man, but also as we find that the legal journey and the legal minds also get eliminated. Once these rights parks have been ignited by persons like resource person of Sringhar Murali. And today there's a fascinating topic of what we say setting aside of the fraudulent CLD without the resorting to the civil code. This aspect looks quite fascinating. And during this legal journey sharing, it will be always quite eliminating as to how it can be done. And it will also not only help the persons like lawyers to understand, but also common man as to how you can come out of the legal trappings of the civil code. And I will not take much time, I will request Adi Lakshmi Ma'am to share the insights regarding Mr Murali as well as knowledge sharing and then we will request Mr Murali to share his knowledge. Adi Lakshmi Ma'am. Thank you so much my dear brother Vikas. It's so nice for legal eagles alike to get connected once again after a long time with the beyond law CLC. And today Shankar Murali sir is very well known, almost all parts of India for this legal knowledge and his wish to share his knowledge free of cost. Sir doesn't take even a single pie for sharing whatever may be the platform, whether it's online or offline. He shares his legal knowledge that he's an exponent in civil law, but he tries his hand sometimes on the criminal jurisprudence as well. Today he has such a great fan following and he's a godfather for all the young lawyers and young law students down south. Today he has been traveling to north and in fact he had recently had an opportunity to meet Vikas and he met and was very happy. COVID-19 had done so much of harm but for the legal fraternity it has done lots and lots of good. And one such goodness is connecting us towards every one of us networking has gone in a larger way and also acquiring the legal knowledge on platforms like this and also the creations of YouTube's to know the sessions even though we missed due to our busy schedule. And today one of the pertinent topic which as Vikas told sir is going to deliberate with us and I wish every one of you is we are going to have a very good session and on my personal behalf I wish my elder brother, our godfather, pattern of legal equalization, our own respected and beloved Shankar Modi sir, thank you so much for joining in on this platform today. On behalf of every one of you, on behalf of beyond law CLC and on behalf of legal equalizing, I extend a very warm welcome to our most respected and beloved faculty of the day, Mr. Shankar Modi sir. Welcome sir to this platform. Thank you. Thank you to Mr. Thank you Vikas ji and Ajay Lechmi madam. Normally I used to take classes for those who are all clacking the judicial exams, students and mainly the raw lawyers. But this is the first time I am going to deliver a judgment on the topic which is burning topic, whether a fraudulent sale deal can be set aside without resorting to the civil court. The law on the subject is well settled. If I want to set aside any document which is against me, if the document is allowed to be in existence and if it cause severe embracement to me and the document is void on the face of the raka, then my remedy is to approach the competent civil court to file a suit for declaration that the document registered is illegal, null and void and not binding on me. This is section 31 of the specific relief. So, all of you know and will quite concur with me. Filing a civil suit and get a remedy that from is a cumbersome process, is a cumbersome process. Of course, to vindicate our legitimate right remedy, we can approach the civil court. Suppose you are the owner of the property, you have not at all sold the property in power of any third parties. You are in possession and enjoyment of the property. You are holding the original sale deed and all the prior title deeds with you. But in one ill fated day, some person can impost by making false personation executed a sale deed in power of a third party in respect of over property. You are not aware of the same. There are chances of impersonation, lot and lot of cases are pending on the subject before the various courts in India. I was wondering why the innocent purchase shall be punished? Is it not amount to causing insult to him? He did not anything wrong. Some person fraudulently executed a registered sale deed. In order to set aside the same, then why should I approach the civil court? Why should I engage in an advocate, pay him a piece and to pay the court fees to set aside the document? And I have to all along wait for the result of the case. Getting a degree from civil court, it may take minimum 5 to 10 years. Thereafter appeal, second appeal, SLP. For no fault on the part of the innocent owner, he is compelled to, he is dragged into the arena of the dispute. So is there any law then how to set that right? How to prevent this menace? So, I have conducted a case before the High Court of Judicature, Madurai Petch, and obtained an order. Because my client's property was sold by an imposter. My client who was in America, taking advantage of his absence in India, is adjacent to owner in conspiracy within some third party. President to service a registered power of attorney, as if my client has executed a power of attorney in his favor to sell the property to my adjacent owner. On the basis of the fraudulent power of attorney, my property was sold in favor of my adjacent owner. Then he occupied my place. On my client's return from America, he was shocked and amazed. And he made a roving inquiry and to his dismay, he came to know that his property was illegally sold. Then he has consulted many advocates. Invariably all of them said the only proper remedy is to file a suit to set aside the sale deed by paying court piece on the amount to mention in the sale deed and get recovery apposition. Then he enquired and finally he came to me. I have produced all the records. In the power of attorney, the photograph of the imposter is fixed. It is not made yet. And his identity card, some voter identity is mentioned. Then we obtained the information with the right information act. And the information was furnished with that effect. The voter ID issued to my so-called power agent is a fake one. He is not at all in existence. He is only a fictitious person. Then we filed an application before the registrar to set aside the fraudulent sale deed. And he conducted a roving inquiry, obtained all the documents. We have produced the original sale deed, revenue records, everything. And they are not in a position to produce the document. Here I would like to tell one thing. Whenever any document is, sale deed is presented for registration. It must, the recital must contain warranty of title. Suppose the sale deed recites like this. I, the owner, hereby convey the property which is all along under my possession. And I have been issued, but I am selling this property to the inverter. This is not a warranty of title. The title deed must state how the vendor acquired title to the property. What are all the prior title documents? How the property was dealt with by the vendor? Whether his name has been muted in the revenue records? So if it contains, then it is a clear case of warranty of title. In the fraudulent sale deed it has been alleged, the original sale deed is missing. They have obtained a certificate from the concerned police that no non-crisable certificate. Based on that, my property was sold illegally. Then the district registrar conducted an inquiry. And he came to a conclusion that it is a fraudulent registration. But he said, it is not within my domain to decide the title to the property or to set aside the fraudulent sale deed. Because the only proper remedy is to approach the certificate. That is the order passed by the registrar. Then straight away I have filed a petition. I don't want to approach the civil court. Because I know being a civil lawyer, it will take years together. Then finally the matter was listed for final hearing. Based on the Satyapal Anand's, which is the state of Mathya Pradesh, the law has of now. Once a document is registered fraudulently, the only remedy open to the affected party is to approach the civil court to get his remedy. Then I have narrated the power of the registrar under section 34 of the registration act and rule 55 and rule 162 of the registration act. What is the power of the registrar? Whether the registrar has got power to inquire before registering the document. Then I quote section 34 and rule 55. Though it is not within the domain of the registrar to decide the title to the property, whether the executor has got the right, absolute right to convey the property, yet he has to satisfy himself that the person appearing before him is the vendor, is the executor, verifying his other card ID and other things. Then only subject to the satisfaction that the person appearing before him is the person professes to be. Then the registrar may register the document. If the document is registered casually without examining the person appearing before him, then in the IAEA of law it is not at all an act of registration. Apart from that, rule 118 of the registration rules says, if it is brought to the knowledge of the registering authority that a particular document is fraudulently registered, then he can make an entry in the encumberment certificate, namely Book 1, that the document is fraudulently registered, there cannot be any further information. That is enough. So I have requested the Honorable Court. Let the registrar make an entry in the Book 1, that is the encumberment certificate maintained by him, that the so-called fraudulent registration is fraudulently registered, it does not convey any title in favor of the purchaser and there cannot be any further information. Apart from that, section 82 deals with penalty for false pressionation. Seven years imprisonment is contemplated, that has been ordered. So the very object of choosing this topic is for the benefit of the legal fraternity and especially to all the civil lawyers. This is a very good interesting subject. I am going to cover the registration act and the rules framed therein the specific relief act, particularly section 31, transfer of property act, particularly section 55 and the various decisions of our Honorable High Court and Supreme Court. My humble submission is, you must know the distinction between void and voidable document A document which is void and the fence of the record, it does not declare to be void by a competent civil court because the document by its nature is void. Suppose any misrepresentation made as to the contents of the document, you may have a loan from your friend, you may be an illiterate person. Instead of executing a mortgage deed, your friend may obtain a sale deed. Then it is voidable at your option. Then necessarily you have to file a suit to set aside the sale deed that maintenance and it is not to execute a sale deed, it is only a mortgage deed. Suppose you are having undivided share in the property, your brother sold not only his share but also including your share he has sold. Naturally you have to file a suit to set aside the sale deed so far as your share is concerned because your brother may take, there is a water partition I have telling you to my share. So the disputed question of facts, the disputed question of facts under the contractual duties and obligation of the parties is not well within the ambit of article 226 of the constitution of India. But in the case of fraudulent sale deed, your duty is cast upon the registering officer to verify whether the executant is the real owner or not. If you file in his duty, then we can approach the high court under article 226 of the constitution of India. Then let us see what is your sale deed? Sale is defined in the section 54 of the Transfer of Property Act. The sale consideration may be passed present or in future. Normally under the contract act, agreement without consideration is void. But here there is a promise even without receiving the sale consideration one can execute a sale deed acting on the promise to pay the sale consideration in future. So sale deed is a document which transfer ownership. The transfer is complete and effective upon the completion of registration of the sale deed. After executing the sale deed, the vendor is divesting his title to the property and the ownership process to the purchase. Pursuing for a moment, I have executed a sale deed in favour of some yet. He has promised to pay the, he has paid certain amount as balance amount and promised to pay the balance sale price in future. But thereafter he failed to pay the balance sale consideration. Then what is my remedy? Can I impeach the sale deed on the ground that I have not received the entire sale consideration? I cannot because under law I am an unpaid vendor. My legal rights and remedy is to file a suit for the recovery of the balance purchase money under section 55 subclass 4 small b of the Transfer of Property Act. And after obtaining a degree, a charge will be created, a statutory charge will be created on the property conveyed till the balance sale price is paid in full. This is the well-settled position of law so far as unpaid vendor, right of unpaid vendor is concerned. Suppose sale deed was executed without consideration or with path consideration. The possession is retained by the vendor himself. The original document is retained by the vendor himself. The intention of the vendor is to pass title only on the payment of the entire sale price. Then title will not pass. Title will not pass. So registration, Prima Vesi is the proof of intention to transfer of the property but not the proof of operative transfer. This has been held in Kalyapuramal v. Rajagopal 2009 for SCC page 193. 2009 for SCC page 193. This is the very landmark judgment. It gives right on the unpaid vendor to impeach the sale deed on the ground that it is not his intention to pass the ownership on the death of execution of the sale deed because the purchaser has to pay the balance sale price unless the balance sale price is paid. It is not my intention to convey the property to pass the ownership. Now, I may be listed in this way. I have paid the entire sale consideration. The sale deed presides. Entire sale consideration is paid and I have executed a registered sale deed in favour of cash. Please note my sale deed contains the registration. After receiving the entire payment I have executed the sale deed. Can I unilaterally cancel the sale deed already registered in favour of X? I have presented the document unilaterally to cancel the document already executed in favour of X. The registered verified the same under registered. Then what is the remedy open to the purchaser X? There are two cosets. Number one, whether the vendor who has received the entire sale consideration without the knowledge and consent of the purchaser can present the document for registration, cancelling the sale deed already affected. If such cancellation of registered sale deed is registered, then what is the remedy available to the purchaser who has paid the entire purchase? Can we compel him to go to civil court to file a suit to set aside that the cancellation of the registered sale deed is illegal and unlawful? What is the remedy? The first one, so far as vendor am concerned under law, I have no authority because sale deed is a bilateral document. It is not a unilateral document as in the case of bill or settlement. There is a corresponding reciprocal process, applications. My purchaser has to pay sale consideration, I have to execute the sale deed. Once I have received the entire sale price, I have to execute the sale deed. It is a bilateral document. Having received the entire sale consideration on my own, I cannot unilaterally cancel the sale deed already affected by me. Number one. So the document is void. It is a fraud.  But rightly or wrongly, the document is registered. Cancellation of registered documents is registered. Then the purchaser filed a repression in Rajil 2.26 for the cancellation of the sale deed stating that I have paid the entire sale price. I was injected into personal property. My name has also been mutated. But illegally my vendor thought my knowledge unilaterally cancelled my sale deed. That has been registered. It is a sale deed on the basis of the record. Cancellation of the sale deed is null and void. Not binding on me. Cancellate. This matter came before the full bench of the Honourable Andhra Pradesh. In Yannala Malleshwari and others, versus Anathila Siamandagos, this is a full bench decision. 2007-1 CTC page 97. It has been held by majority that the registrar has got power to receive, present, to receive the document, cancellation of the registered sale deed. There is no flaw in it. He did his duty. Registration had the empower scheme to receive the document. It may be a cancellation of the registered sale deed. But the dissenting view is very apt. It has been held that the registrar has no power to cancel the registration of the document already registered. Since the registrar becomes a pundit's official once the document is registered. If a person sold away the property belonging to others, then it would be a fraud on stage. If the original owner is asked to go to civil code and get the subsequent sale deed cancelled, the declaration would be adding insult to the injury to the work. So that is a dissenting view. Later in Satyabhaal Anand v. state of Mathya Pradesh, 2015-15 CTC 263. The supreme court gave a conflicting decision by Honourable Justice Deepak Mishra and Honorable Justice Sathananda Gouda. Justice Mishra said, the registrar has got power to register the cancellation of the registration, the cancellation of the registered sale deed, because the registration act empowers him. But Honorable Justice Adhananda Gouda said, no, no, no, it's a fraud under statute. Once a document is already registered, cancelling the same immediately is fraud, it is anality. Then the matter referred to full bench, three bench. Again it has been considered and it is reported in 2016, 10 SEC page 767. 2016, 10 SEC page 767. The Honorable Justice Deepak Mishra judgment was affirmed. So the majority view is, registrar has got power to cancel the registered sale deed already affected. The only remedy open to the party affected is to approach the competent civil court and get his address. Is it not shocking? Please read the judgment in full. That is the case, the petitioner who has filed the petition was allotted a plot by a Punjabi cooperative society. In the bylaw of the society, if the plot already allotted and the sale deed was executed in respect of the sale, if the allotted failed to construct a building within two years, then automatically the plot will be resumed by the secretary of the society and it will be reallotted in power of other persons. The repetition has not constructed the building within this escalated time frame. So therefore that prompted the secretary, straight away he went to the registrar, presented a document for cancellation of the sale deed. It is known as the extinguishment deed that was registered. Then he filed the repetition. Then the court said, no, no, no, this is only a disputed question of facts. It cannot be gone into under Article 226 of constitution. We are not here to decide the private parties, independent rights, go and approach the civil court. So this Satyapal judgment case is only on the voting, the bylaw of the society empowers the secretary of the society to cancel and present a document for registration, cancelling the sale deed and the tea effect. There is no rules in the Mathya Pradesh registration rules, preventing the registrar from registering a cancellation of registered sale. After the full bench decision passed by the Antar Pradesh Yannala Malleshwari case, rule was amended, thereby the registrar is prevented from registering cancellation of the registered sale deed. If the both purchaser and the vendor filed a document for cancellation of sale deed, then it can be registered. Unilaterally it cannot be registered. Similarly, our Tamil Nadu government has also passed a circular by the inspector general of registration. The Tamil Nadu government amended Section 34A of the registration act whereby the purchaser is required to sign the sale. So based on this Satyapal judgment decision, invariably all the high court in India passes an order that whether it may be a fraudulent registration go to court, forgetting for a moment the decision of the Satyapal case is on different votings. Then what about Section 554 subclass B of the transfer of property act? It confers a right on the unpaid vendor to sue for the balance sale price. He cannot impede the sale deed. He cannot file a suit to set aside the sale deed. Suppose the aggrieved person owner has put the order of the high court or supreme court, I have to file a suit to set aside the sale deed. Normally the practicing civil lawyer, what would we do? We cannot file a suit to set aside the sale deed because we have to pay the court piece on the market value of the property and the data filing of the suit. It may be heavy. In order to avoid the payment of court piece, we use to file a suit for declaration that the registered cancellation of sale deed is illegal and not binding on me. We will file a Section 25D and tentatively value the subject matter of the same and we will pay the minimum court fee. So someone issued the defendant appeal. He will not allow us to proceed the case. What they will do, the defendant, he will file an application to reject the client on the ground that the payment subject matter of the suit was improperly valued under the insufficient court fee. So reject the client. Please keep in mind, when you are not a party to the documents, when the document is fraud on the face of the record, when the document is not binding on you, you need not pay court fee on the market value of the suit property or on the amount mentioned in the sale. You just simply ignore the sale. You can very well file a suit for declaration to declare that the registered cancellation of sale deed is illegal and not binding on you. You are fully competent to value the subject matter tentatively and pay the court piece in accordance with your tentative evaluation. He will file this application to reject the client. Then we will argue and file some pretty certain authorities. Then the application will be dismissed. Again, he will not allow you to continue further. He will file, as against the order rejecting his application, he will file CRP, then SLP. Then he will file another application to compare the signature. Our case is that it is not my signature. It is a fraudulent signature. Then he will file, no, no, no. He came and took the document. Only for the purpose of filing this case, he has alleged that it is not his signature. Compare the signature. It must be compared by the expert. Then we are quite sure that it is not our signature. Then we will say, yes, we will, I will subscribe my signature that it be compared. Then he will file another application. If the signature is not his contemporary signature, then this process will go for another two to three years. Even that application is dismissed. Or the expert opinion is produced that it is not our signature. He will not be satisfied. He will file another application for appointment of advocate. Stating that after the sale in his favor, he has developed the property, made some development. That has to be, the physical picture has to be taken note of. So one after another, by filing interlocking application, your adversary will not allow you to get a degree in your favor. So it is a cumbersome process. Why the innocent purchaser must be punished? So this is the right time. Our Tamil Nadu government as far as now has amended inserted section 22B of the Registration Act, empowering the registrar to cancel the document which are fraudulent, which are fraudulent. Normally, the disputed question of facts cannot be decided. Registrar is not a quasi-judicial officer. But in some cases, there are fraudulent registration. So now the government of Tamil Nadu gave power to the registering authority to cancel the fraudulent registration. Now, earlier, the High Court of Madras division bench in ER Kalaiwan versus the Inspector General of Registration, 2010 Madras page AIR 2010, page 18, it has been held that the registering authority has no power to register cancellation of registration documents, cancellation of sales deed filed unilaterally by the Pandora. So as I said earlier, a document which is void, it need not be declared as void. We can simply ignore. This has been held in Prem Singh and others versus Birbal and others 2006 by SCC page 353. Then what is the object of the registration act? The full bench of the Honourable Madras side. In the case, Latif State Lion India Limited versus Mrs. Hadija Amal reported in 2011 to MLJ 569. The object of registering a document is to give public notice to the public at large that the document has been executed to prevent fraud and forgery and to secure a reliable and complete amount of all transactions affecting the title to the public. The object of the registration is not to not merely to collect revenue, it becomes part of public policy. It becomes part of public policy. Document which is against the public morality and public policy is void. Section 23 of the contract act says the fraudulent deed is void. So I am confining the right of the innocent owner of the property to file his repetition under article 226 of Constitution of India for the cancellation of the fraudulent deed. Or he may approach the consent sub-register registering authority with the request that by producing all the documents that the document is fraudulently registered, make an entry in the uncomparent certificate that the document is fraudulently registered and not to and prevent further alienation in future. So these two options, I will answer Mr. Rasho after this session is completed. Now two options are available to the unsold vendor to impeach the fraudulent registration either to approach the registering authority by quoting rule 118 of the registration rules or approach the high court under article 226 for cancellation of the settlement deed. Is there any permission under the registration act? Under what circumstances the register can refuse to register the document? Section 1 of rule 162 of the registration rules contemplates 19 grounds, 19 grounds on which the register may refuse to register it. But all of them are trivial in nature. But rule 55 relative with the section 34 cost upon a duty on the registering authority regarding to identify the executant or the person presenting the document for registration. Now there is only one judgement that is from our Honourable High Court. 2016, 1 CTC, Page 673, 2016, 1 CTC, Page 673 that is in the Asset Reconstruction Company India Limited, Asset Reconstruction Company India Limited versus Inspector General of Registration, 2016, 1 CTC 673. This is a landmark judgement delivered by the Honourable Justice, Mr. M. M. Sundres, ASCII, and now he is Supreme Court Judge. He gave a judgement. In that case, a registered power of attorney was executed by the one-a-half in favour of his power agent. Part of all the acts done by the power agent is embodied in the set power of attorney. In the set registered power of attorney, the power agent has not been given any power to alienate or execute sale deed on behalf of the principle. So the registered power does not empower the power agent to execute sale deed on behalf of the principle. But an unregistered power of attorney is there which empowers the power agent to execute a sale deed on behalf of the principle. Then the power agent prepares a sale deed on behalf of the principle stating there is a registered power of attorney and there which I am fully competent to execute sale deed on behalf of my principle. The registering authority without perusing, he has not produced the unregistered power of attorney because in Tamil Nadu, power of attorney has to be registered. So based on the registered power of attorney, he has presented a document executed a sale deed in favour of some acts. The document was registered. Then the principle, who is affected by the fraudulent registration. Straight away, he has filed a writ of mandamus for directing the registered to cancel the sale. Initially, the mantelor of the red petrion is corset, senior advocates from both sides where are you in length. Then the Honourable Justice set. A duty is cast upon the registering authority to produce the document before registering the document. Production and examination of the document is the part of the registering authority, duty under rule 23 of the registration rules. He failed in his duty. There is a violation of procedure. So he cannot take shelter. This is not a solemn act of registration. It is not a solemn registration in the eyes of law. When the power of attorney does not empower the power agent to execute the sale deed and become the principle, the registration of the sale deed by the so-called power agent in favour of that party is illegal and the sale deed is void and unable to be cancelled. Straight away by invoking Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the order was passed for the cancellation of the fraudulent sale deed. So documents which are voidable, necessarily we have to approach the civil code. But the documents which are void and depends on that account. So the document is presented fraudulently by making impersonation. It will not bind the owner. He need not go to the civil code to get his remedy. His option is now open, either to approach the high court or to the cancelled registrar if the particular state government empowers the registering authority to annul or cancel or resign the document already registered which are all fraudulent in nature. So these are all the decisions now referred to by me are all greater significance. So in future please do not approach the civil code. It is a cumbersome process. The document is fraudulently registered. Approach the concerned registrar or to file a red correction. Definitely you will get a favorable remedy. With this I conclude the session. Though the topic is very small, it involves a lot of legal aspects. And if any question is posted in the chat box. Vikas ji, Vikas, Vikas, Vikas where is Mr. Vikas? I will ask you madam, are you hearing me? Haritha, should we open the chat box? Can specific performance suit filed without issuing notice to opposite party? Mr. Raj posted a question. Can specific performance suit filed without issuing notice to opposite party? Without serving any notice, suit for specific performance will be dismissed Before filing a suit for specific performance, the purchaser has to express his readiness and willingness to purchase the property. Section 16c of the specific impact is very clear. Unless the purchaser express his readiness and willingness to purchase the property, he will not succeed. He has to plead that he is always ready and willing to perform this part of contract. Who is posting this question? Ashok. Answer to Mr. Ashok. If revenue record is written in favor of your purchaser, you can approach the concerned registrar by producing a document that you gave power only in respect of a particular platform. Whereas the sale deed in favor of the purchaser includes the plot which is not mentioned in the power of Patani. And you can also impeach the sale deed by approaching the concerned registrar or to file a repression to set aside the sale deed so far as the portion which is not mentioned in the power of Patani is concerned. I can read it. Thank you. The situation made without agreement is valid which is executable. Mr. Ashok, he has read this one of Vinoth. The message he has been read of Vinoth, principal executing power of Patani. I answered some questions, Mr. Ashok. You can pass up all the questions to me and I will send it to you. Mr. Ashok, Vinoth is asking, in 2008 principal executing power of Patani deed in favor of the agent for selling the land belonging to the principal and gave the sale consideration to the principal. However, the agent has fraudulently sold the land in favor of his wife in 2009 itself. What is the remedy for the principal when civil suit or to approach district court? One second. So once he gave the sale consideration to the principal, there ends the matter. He can execute sale deed in favor of his wife. It cannot be questioned by the principal. Once the principal, after executing the power of Patani, receives the entire sale consideration, it is open to the power of agent to sell the property in either in favor of his wife or in favor of any third party that cannot be challenged. If no sale consideration is filed, then the principal remedy is to file a suit for the recovery of the sale consideration. He cannot impeach the power of Patani. Suppose the power of Patani is canceled, thereafter the sale was affected, then the sale can be impeached by the principal. So without canceling the power of Patani, without sending a notice to the power of agent at any intimating the cancellation of the power of Patani, the principal has no right to impeach the sale deed already affected by his power agent. It says if the mortgager had deposited the property to some other third person, disposed of the property to the third person, however the title deeds are with the bank and it is reflected as a mortgage. What is the remedy? It's not on the chat. It's on the YouTube. YouTube. Please tell me again. What if the mortgager disposes of a part of the property to some third person? One second. Please repeat it again. What if the mortgager disposes of a part of the property to some third person without the knowledge of the bank, though the title deeds are lying with the bank and it is reflected as a mortgage. What is the property? What is the remedy? The remedy of the bank is just to ignore the sale because once mortgage is executed, the bank becomes the security creditor, with the knowledge and consent of the bank if the property is sold, the property is deemed to be sold subject to the mortgage. The bank has got every right to proceed against the property even if it is sold by the smarger. The sale is subject to the mortgage. Even otherwise nobody can sell a better title than what he possesses. Normally once mortgage is executed, it does not prevent the owner of the property to income at the same to sell it. He has got every right. But before selling, he must intimate the same to the mortgage. This is section 68 and 69 of the transfer of property. Even if the mortgager wants to lease out the property, he has to get consent from the mortgage. But there is no prohibition under law. He can sell it. But the sale it must contain that the property hereby conveyed is already subject to the mortgage and you have to redeem the mortgage. Then only the sale is valid. Mr. Ashok, what you are dreading. He said that I am the owner of two different plots in same Khasra. I sold few square yards from... Answer. That has been answered. These are the questions I will just check it out on the YouTube. Yes. If an owner of a property realizes that some third party name is not in the mutation entry, does Limitation Act apply on this and who should approach? But it's also on the YouTube. Please tell me again. If the owner of a property realizes that some of the third party names have been mentioned in the mutation, does Limitation Act apply on this and who should be approached? Once some third party name is muted in the revenue records and the moment he came to know from the data of knowledge, he can straight away approach the consent of Dasildar, our revenue division officer, to remove the entry and seek his remedy. The period of limitation, so far as the cancellation of the illegal entry, Limitation Act does not arise because this is a wrongful act. For the wrongful act, each and every time it gives Khasra action, so there is no time limit. There is no limitation. Section 23 of the Limitation Act, I think so. Even otherwise, this is Kuldeep Singh has also held in Supreme Court that fraud initiates everything. Yes, yes, fraud initiates everything. Fraud is intended to gain illegally. Now, this is the last question. What to do if a genuine document is cancelled to expatriate by the lower moot support based on a fraudulent model? The second last question. Yes, yes, yes. Genuine document is cancelled, expatriate. You have to file an application to set aside the expatriate degree or to file an appeal. By putting forth all your defence. This is if someone has fraudulently given a surety for a loan taken by a company. Company defaults and surety is invoked. What is the remedy for the original owner of the property? What is the surety for which he is given fraudulently? Repeat it again. If somebody property is given a surety falsely, then it will not bind with the original owner of the property and he need not pay any amount to the facts. Because he is not at all a surety. Somebody has given his property a surety. It will not bind him. If any action is taken by the bank, straight away he can file a red petition restricting the bank from proceeding against his property because he is not at all a surety. And his property was given fraudulently a surety. Even he can lodge a criminal complaint also. Another question is that it is not with the topic concerned. So, we are not taking. So, thank you everyone for staying connected with us. And friends, tomorrow we will be having a session on the service law part series with Mr. P. S. Raja Gopal on dispensing of the inquiry proceedings. What are the trappings? I will thank Ari Lakshmi, Lokmoh Murti and the legal elites, Mr. Shingar Murli, who have been always a pleasure connecting with us on this platform. One last question. One last question. One Mr. Chandrasekar is supposed to answer. Vanda received the entire sale consultation and received the document. But run away after prescribing the document before the fundraiser and sold the property to others. Then what is the remedy? Once the document is executed by the Vanda, before ever registering the same key left to the place, you can compel the registrar to file compulsory registration of the document. If the document is subsequently sold, you can file a suit for specific performance compiling the Vanda to register the document in your favor. And you need not ask for cancellation of the sale deed because the document is subject to your sale. Thank you everyone. Stay safe, stay blessed and do stay connected with us tomorrow at 6pm for the Part 5 of the Service Law series by Mr. P. S. Raja Gopal. Thank you.


Welcome to All Hands Update. I'm Petty Officer Tyrell Morris. The Navy's newest class of surface combat and warships, Latoral Combat Ships fill a crucial role in the six core areas of the Navy's Maritime Defense Strategy. Latoral Combat Ships, or LCSs, provide forward presence, deterrence, sea control, power projection, maritime security, humanitarian assistance, and disaster relief response. LCSs are also capable of changing primary missions via modular mission packages. Packages include surface warfare, mine counter measures, and anti-submarine warfare. With the modular packages, LCSs are able to conduct freedom of navigation, theater security, maritime counter piracy, search and rescue, and maritime domain awareness patrol operations. For more information and a virtual tour, log on to All Hands Magazine online.


Well, Muslims believe that God has a white promise. No, I'm just joking. I'm just kidding. I'm just kidding. So in Arabic, as well as Hebrew, there's something I've got to understand about the grammar. So every noun in Arabic, and in Hebrew, has a gender assigned to it. Every noun. Sometimes it's obvious what's known as natural gender. And again, this is also a point of contention nowadays. But traditionally, a boy was masculine. So why that is the word for boy, or in Hebrew, get it? So the Islam-Ishana, the demonstrative pronoun, would be masculine, right? So even the demonstrative pronouns in Arabic and in Hebrew are gender-fied. So I would say, had that, while that word, this is masculine a boy, right? Or in Hebrew, I'd say, zeh, yeh, this is a boy. Natural gender. But sometimes there is no natural gender, right? For example, the moon, no natural gender. So arrows in the distant past, and Jews in the distant past, they would just assign a gender. We don't really know why they would assign male or female, but they would just assign gender. So they decided the moon is masculine. And the sun is feminine in Arabic, right? So God does not have a gender. The verbans is lasa, comispe, he shape. There's nothing like God whatsoever. There's nothing like God. So nothing in creation resembles God. So for male and female, for black and white, if we're made of matter, if I'm standing on something, if I'm reading, none of these things apply to God. God is completely dissimilar to His creation, essentially. But the word Allah is grammatically masculine. It has a lexical gender. So because it has a lexical gender of masculinity assigned to it in the Quran, it says, he is, he is, right? It doesn't mean God is male. And anyone who says God is male, Muslim scholars would say that's anathema. That position is not acceptable. They would consider that blasphemy to say God is male or female. But God uses the masculine pronoun because the word Allah has grammatical gender. The grammatical gender of the name of God is masculine. It does not mean that God has a natural gender. What about the image of God? So that's interesting because that is in Genesis 2. And there's also a hadith of the prophet. So it's not in the Quran that there's a hadith of the prophet where it says, basically, God created Adam. And here Adam does not mean the person Adam. It's generic, the human being, Adam, right? God created a human being in His image. So Muslim scholars and minorities also use this verse. Minorities do not believe in divine incarnation. He is anti-entropomorphism. Minority says the meaning of this, as well as Imam al-Qazadi, they both say that the meaning of this is what is this image of God? The image of God is the ability to reason. That's God's quote unquote image. God doesn't have a physical image. So God created the human being with the ability to reason. Just as God has infinite knowledge, He's qualitatively omniscient. Human beings also have that ability. This is our differentia to use Aristotelian nomenclature. What makes the human being different from the animals? It isn't my physical strength. You know, put me in a room with a line, I'm done, right? It's not our, you know, my eyesight. The eagle can fish underwater for two miles up in the air. So what makes this different? We build skyscrapers, we do trigonometry. It's because of our intellect. So that's the so-called image of God according to Maimonides. And according to Imam al-Qazadi, who's sort of the Maimonides or Aquinas of Islam, because God doesn't have a physical image. It's the ability to reason. You know, of course there have been anthropomorphists in Islamic history who say that although you've got as limbs and he sits on a physical throne and things like that, but it's considered a deviant position. He's according to the normative Sunni and Shi'a understanding of theology.


We're back here inside the Cube. This is Silicon Angles flagship program. We've got the Advanced Extracted Silicon from the West. We're in Las Vegas. This is day two. Towards the back end of day two of three days of live wall-to-wall coverage. I'm John Furrier, Dave Vellante at Wikibon.org. And I got to say, we go where the stories are and there's a lot of action. We just talked the cloud. Now we're talking the storage. Dave, what's your take here and choose our next guest? Well, so we're seeing a lot of enthusiasm from HP. We're at Dave Donatelli this morning. I tweeted out, John, that Dave was relaxed. He was concise, clear, and funny. You know, it's not really... Yeah, let him retweets on that. Yeah, I think I did, actually. So, and our next guest is great. Milan Shetty is here. He's the vice president and CTO of HP Storage Milan. Welcome. Thank you. Thank you, Dave. So, John. Good to see you. I just saw you recently. We did a deep dive on the announcement that you guys made today, which was awesome. You locked us in a room for eight hours and injected us with Kool-Aid. We came out, we were still alive, but so great announcement. You guys are very enthusiastic about it. So we're going to talk about that, the three-power all-flash array, some of the other innovations that you guys are doing. But again, welcome to theCUBE. Thank you. Thank you, Dave. Thanks again for having me here. Yeah, so let's start with the announcements today, the all-flash array that's been anticipated. You guys sort of indicated that's the direction that you're going. We heard Dave Donatelli today talk about the trade-offs that customers had before you guys came in. So why don't you recap that from a strategy standpoint? What you guys are trying to solve there? Sure. So when we look at the fact that the new media flash has come into the marketplace and it's a magnitude of order, much faster and it's got low latency than the disks. And how would people use it? And that's who we have been thinking about that from an innovation standpoint quite a bit. And there are three things which came to mind when we did all of the investigation. First is that how can we apply tier one features on flash and get all the data services on the flash stack so that people don't have to worry about the endurance aspect of the flash and also get the maximum performance they can from the flash. So that was one aspect. The second aspect of it was that it's not all about just the performance and the latency. How do we address the feature sets which go along which people know about the tier one functionality and get that going. And third, how can we make it cost effective and also provide the resiliency and the cost factors as well as the endurance factors and how do we balance those equations. There are, so we saw in the marketplace that were pure high speed performance, you know, having like a race car but no features at all, no rear view mirrors and no tier one features, a new management paradigm that kind of market is going on. And the second, there were people who had the two controller node architectures and they were just inserting flash in their existing architecture and it was not performing as well. So the question was that how do we bring in and multi-node architecture improve the efficiency of the multi-node architecture in terms of getting the best latency as we can and provide all the tier one services, snapshot, replications and just name it which we've been delivering on our platform for a very long time and how do we put all those three things together was a key element and that we brought that with the announcement which we did today. So that's what you mean by features? You're talking about a rich storage management stack that you've built out for a decade because the startups can say, hey, we have features, we have compression, we have deduplication, maybe some will say, oh, we am a stack from another third party. So double click on that a little bit. What features are we talking about? Absolutely. So if you look at, when people talk about the endurance of the flash and everything, right? So we have thin provisioning capabilities built in into a three-part stack, right? So first of all, don't do as many writes unless it's necessary. Provision, in the process of provisioning, don't do writes to the flash array. Then we have thin reclamation and the thin detect capabilities that if we detect the, there are a bunch of zeros, we don't even send that to the array at all. So we minimize writes. So it's all the data reduction techniques which already existed. Then there are richer services around snapshot, cloning, and white striping of three-part so that they make sure that all the IO goes across more than two controllers. So it's a four-controller architecture. It controllers scale out architectures and just spread the load around across all the resources available so that you write fast, but not only write fast, but write only what is needed and absolutely needed. And that along gets the life of the endurance and it's all built in. It's all built into the package and it's the same software stack from an architecture standpoint, for an high-end array, the low-end array, with the 7200, 7400, the mid-range array, as well as the all-flash array. So getting the uniformity of management and also these rich data services which already do data reduction techniques so that you're not wearing out your flash are very critical component and we built that all in the controller and now it's available in the all-flash array. But so you guys made a lot of momentum in the marketplace, made a lot of momentum around the notion that you had a modern architecture. I mean, you attacked traditional tier one and really did a very good job at that. But so people are going to look at this and say, well, wait a minute, Milan. You guys, this is a disk-based architecture. You designed this to solve the problems of spinning disk and now you're bolting on flash. What do you say to that? Yeah, absolutely. So we supported SLC and MLC drives in our three-part stack for a very long time. What is unique about the 74-ply or 50-platform release disk that we actually optimize the three-part stack to make sure that it reads the media as a different media than the disk. So we optimized a whole bunch of stuff in the how the internal buffers are allocated, how the IO stack works on the SCSI layer, how the IO stack works on the Fabrician. There's a lot of software. And I would go to say there is about somewhere around 500 to 600,000 lines of code in the software stacks, which are the standard software stack, like the fiber channel stack and the ice-coated stack, which are not needed in flash. So we optimize the entire code path. So when we released the flash optimized 7450, there are a lot of work went into not only on the multi-node architecture stuff which you can leverage, but also optimizing the stack so that the IO path, so it's not like a wide, I use the analogy of the wide-water rafting, kind of the data is going back and forth with the different buffers and different buffers between the fiber channel stack, the ice-coated, the SCSI stack, and down. So we optimize the entire code path, which is why the latency which we are getting is one of the best latency we are getting from the read standpoint and the write standpoint. It's only going to get better. So that optimization to your point about the, whether it was, whether flash is used as a different media and all the algorithms which existed and all the IO path which existed in the standard fiber channel stacks and the SCSI stacks, we optimized all of that. And that's about half a million lines of code path which has been optimized and which is why we're getting the throughput and the latency which we are standing behind. And the spec numbers which we drew out has been the best in the industry, which we came out of it. But again, to summarize, it's the optimization of the code path in the standard for protocol stack without the applications knowing what's happening has been very free to how we delivered these numbers. Now another point that we debated and let's sort of have a summary of that debate here was the cost. So you got this architecture, got an ASIC in it, a lot of benefits to the ASIC but it's not a blank sheet of paper architecture. It's not a scale out shared nothing architecture. We had that kind of interesting discussion. Why are you confident that you can compete on cost with the startups? Sure, so there isn't, so first of all, I think all the primitives and the design center which 3Power was built on. So if you look at the history of 3Power, 3Power is built for the storage service providers. So a lot of the stuff which we talked about and that was the genesis of the service provider. I said today that I have the 3Power red herring in my office and I go back and read it every now and then. It's all about utility. Absolutely, but if you look at the characteristics and it was built for the service provider and if you look at the characteristics of what people were looking for the service provider was they want to have that thousand customers, 2,000 customers, 10,000 customers all going to the same array, right? Then they wanted high IOPS at the time. They also wanted low latency at the time. They also wanted guaranteed and sustained latency, right? And so if you look at all the characteristics with the storage service provider or the SSPs wanted, they are the same characteristics which flash as a media requires. So what happened was from the design standpoint and the day one designs of the 3Power standpoint it was always optimized for. So we released a feature called the priority optimization, right? You can guarantee IO bandwidth and latency to your multi-tenant, to each of your tenants, right? And it was already built out of multi-tenant architecture. So this was a ground up design for how the IT was going to be in future, right? Whether it was a virtual server, whether it was a physical server or whether it was guarantees throughput or the latency which is required from the stack. So which is why it was very much more easier for us to adapt to flash because flash as a media is more or less an adjacent requirement to what the service providers always needed. So which is why this architecture, the work we had to do was an incremental work to get the flash as a media. And most of the work had been around we didn't have to change the core mesh architecture or anything, what we had to do was just optimize the standard protocol stacks to make sure that they don't spend time waiting for IO to be sent out to the media and which is why we got the numbers which we got. Now, there are to your point about the scale-out architectures, right? There was the, there were- I'll try to get a question, don't worry. You're on a roll. So the scale-out architectures are one of the problems when you haven't shared nothing architecture. I said that the three-partisan shared all architecture. In the shared nothing architecture, every time there is a shared nothing architecture, there is a trade-off which folks necessarily don't realize is the shared nothing architectures have to do some kind of data protection scheme. And generally that data protection theme is a replication to a different node or something. So every time you do that, right? So you are reducing your latency by half.  You're suffering your- Make copies. Making copies, right?  Your latency is now half. Your bandwidth has been shrunk. And if there are some scale-out architectures, actually keep three copies of the data. So all of those numbers, latency, bandwidth, and the throughput just gets worse two times or the three times. And not to mention the rich services which we talked about. So it's an inherent disadvantage. The pure scale-out non-shared or shared nothing scale-out architectures have. Okay, well we're running out of time but I've got one question in. I think that's a good conversation. I don't want to interrupt that. But I wrote a post yesterday in Forbes. Dave Donatelli and Craig Nunez in the headline. I couldn't get David Scott. He was just so busy. He's been busy all week meeting with customers. I asked him the question about why is software defined storage so hot? Donatelli's comment was, storage is an operating system now. So, and then he went on and on. So one of the comments. Go to Forbes.com and search on HP if you're interested in reading that post. But I want to ask you in short to end this segment, why is software defined storage so hot? And what does Donatelli mean about storage and operating system now? Sure, so the folks who are the, say let's say a first time sand buyers. Folks who have outgrown their director at storage but not yet ready to make and hold some investment into and full sand fabric. Or folks who have been using who want to have a backup strategy but not yet ready to go to and dedupe appliances and everything. There is a transition path for them where they can use their internal disks and be the first time sand buyers or be the first time dedupe buyers. And they eventually grow eventually grow from there into an external attached storage and external attached dedupe appliances. So what software defined storage provides is a bridge for folks who are transitioning or not only the enterprises which are transitioning but also small and medium business which are transitioning from and direct attached model to the external storage model. So that bridge never existed in the past. And that's what the store virtual VSA and the store once VSA provides them to transition from the internal storage to the external storage. And that's why software defined data center is hot. And Craig Nunez said he's going to come on theCUBE shortly today and I think he's coming down today but he saw you take back it's a whole new paradigm shift. It's a whole new rethinking. So software defined storage, there it is big announcement yesterday we're from the HP storage three part continuing to lead the transformation with great products and performance and the business side are very profitable growing with it under the HP Donna Deli group in the enterprise. We'll be back with more coverage here shortly after this break. This is live from HP Discover the SiliconANGLE with you on theCUBE right back.


A couple more examples involving volume of prisms and cylinders. In this example we want to find the volume of a rectangular prism that has had a hole drilled through it. And you'll notice that the hole happens to be a cylinder. So what we're going to do here is we're going to take the volume of the prism and we're going to subtract the volume of the cylinder. And what that will do is it'll give us this darker shaded region that's around the hole. So volume of the prism, let's start with that. The prism is a rectangular prism, which means that the bases are rectangles. So in order to find the volume of a rectangular prism, I'm going to take base times height of the rectangle times the height of the prism. If you look at your picture, you can see that the rectangle is a 6 by 5 rectangle. So 6 times 5. And you can see that the height of this prism is 4, so I'm going to multiply by 4. And then the volume of the cylinder is going to be pi r squared because that's the area of the base times the height of the cylinder. Well, if I look at the picture, it tells me up here that the hole has a radius of 2. So pi times 2 squared. And the height of the cylinder is the distance from the top to the bottom, which is exactly the same as the height of this prism. So it is a height of 4. So now if we multiply 6 times 5 times 4, we get 120. And in the second set of parentheses, 2 squared is 4 times 4 is 16 times pi is 16 pi. And this question didn't ask us to do exact or approximate. So if it asked to stay as an exact answer, we would just leave it as 120 minus 16 pi. If you want to put that in your calculator and approximate it, you would get about 69.7. And again, both of these should be labeled with cubic units. So just, again, remember that this is the exact answer and this one here would be the approximate answer. In this example, we have to work backwards. If you read what it says, it says that we're going to find the radius of the base of a cylinder if the volume is 126.7 cubic feet and the height is 10 feet. So basically what we're doing here is we are given the volume, we're given the height of the cylinder, and we want to figure out what the radius is. So remember that the volume of a cylinder is the area of the base, which is pi r squared times the height of the cylinder. So I'm going to plug in what I know. The volume is 126.7 and then I'm going to leave it as pi r squared because we don't know what r is and that is multiplied by 10, the height. Now this is just an equation that you're going to solve for r. So the first thing I'm going to do is get rid of the 10 and the pi and I can do that in one step because it's multiplication pi times 10. So if I divide by 10 pi, it's going to cancel out the 10 and the pi. I have to do exactly the same thing on the other side. Now I'll just tell you when you enter this in your calculator, be really careful. Make sure that you do 126.7 divided by 10 times pi, which is probably going to involve you using parentheses around the 10 pi. The other thing you could do is enter 10 times pi to get the decimal and then do 126.7 divided by that decimal. What you should end up happening or what should end up happening is you have r squared on the right side and if you do 126.7 divided by 10 pi, it's like 3.99. So we're going to go ahead and just round that to 4. And so the last step for solving for r is to do the square root and we get a radius of 2. And because this is in feet, we would say 2 feet.


When it comes to God's healing power, there is no man-made technique or gimmick to apply. It really is as simple as putting your faith in God's promise. Expect a miracle. What are you believing God to heal in you today?


In the weird circle, in this cave, by the restless sea, we are met to call from out the past stories, strange, and weird. Bellkeeper, hold the bell, so all may know we are gathered again in the weird circle. The date was August 31st, as I remember, and I had just heard that Sir John Rowell and his daughter had leased a villa here at Wan Le Pan for the winter. I hadn't seen Sir John since I had been in London four years ago. Naturally, I was anxious to see my father's old friend. I walked across the sands in the pouring rain to the lonely house on the cliff, which he had leased. I remember wondering at that time why any man would choose such an isolated and cheerless spot, but then my taste for his villa might have been dulled by the constant fall of the rain and the dreary, overcast skies. I knocked on the door and then waited. It seems I waited some time before his Arabian servant. Yes. Is Sir John Rowell in? Who is calling, please? Mr. Lansing from London. Mr. Dennis Lansing, the second. Come in, please. Oh, thank you. I don't see why you had to rent this place for the entire year, Father. It's depressing. Please, to be seated, sir. I announce you. Thank you. Well, perhaps I have reason to my own, Phyllis. Oh, I don't doubt it. But there would have been a million places in England which would have served your purpose just as well, I'm sure. Mr. Dennis Lansing, the second to see you, Sir John. Dennis Lansing, show him right in, Kiora. Show him right in. Another one of your head-hunting friends, Dad. You'll see, Phyllis. You'll see. Sir John. Well, come in, my boy. Come in. Let's have a look at you. Well, well, you've grown up since I last saw you. Oh, the inevitable result of years, sir.  Oh, how do you do? Hello. Well, do I look like a head-hunter? Oh, not in the least. Phyllis, Phyllis, stop flirting with the young man. Go upstairs and change for dinner. Even in this villa, you can't expect to come to the table and address. Oh, Father, really? The first time I've had a chance to be amused, I'm sent out of the room. You'll have plenty of chance to talk to Dennis later on.  I'd be delighted. I'll see you then, Mr. Lansing. Yes, indeed. Hey, what are you doing in this part of France? Is your father with you? Well, the family's in England. I'm vacationing here for two weeks in a pension near the casino. A pension? Why don't you stay with us? Well, really, sir John, I wouldn't think of it. Why wouldn't you? I insist on it. Yes, I insist on it. Chiara, Chiara. Yes, sir, yes. I'd like you to pick up Mr. Lansing's luggage after dinner. Yes, sir.  Madame Corfez. Madame Corfez, oh. And, uh, Chiara. Yes, sir. Prepare the left wing for Mr. Lansing tonight. He'll be staying with us. Yes, sir. We'll do it, sir. Well, how's the hunting going, sir John? Famously, famously. Phyllis and I just came back from India, as a matter of fact. I hear. Tell me, Dennis, have you ever seen any of my trophies? Oh, no, I haven't, sir, but I've heard my father talk about them. Well, you have a great star, great treat in star for you.  Would you like to see it? Yes, as a matter of fact, I would very much. Well, come along then. We'll have just time enough before dinner. Ah, this is the room. Well, let me light a candle first. Ah, there. Better do it. Hmm. Yes, you have quite a collection here. Nice looking lion's head in the corner, eh? Oh, that's a beauty. Yes, I got that elk in the north last winter. What a tremendous spread of antlers. Yes. You know, Dennis, it took only one shot to pin it down. Oh, fancy shooting, sir John. Yes, record shooting under the circumstances. And what's under this cover? No, don't look there, Dennis. Oh, what? What in heaven's ne... Why, it's a human hand. I... I haven't restricted my zeal for hunting to the animal kingdom, as you no doubt realize. Yes, so I see. Oh, it's horrible looking. You should have seen the man it belonged to. Well, I didn't mean to pry, sir. I realized that, Dennis, that no harm's done. You would have seen it sooner or later. It belonged to an enemy of mine, a man I met on one of my many travels. But how did you get the hand, sir? Are you sure you're interested, Dennis? Well, yes, sir. That is, if you feel like telling me about it. I don't mind. His name was Maggard. He was of the Yellow race, the head of a fanatical cult. My wife met him on one of our journeys. He fascinated her. He talked her into killing herself in order to destroy her earthly body and liberate her souls. My father once told me something of all this. Yes. There was quite a scandal in London at the time. She wrapped herself in old oil rags. He gave her the flame in order to set those rags on fire. I hadn't realized it.  My daughter Phyllis was only ten then. Didn't they jail this man, Maggard? They couldn't find him. He left the country. But I found him. I hunted the four corners of the earth for him. Just as I've hunted for wild beasts. And when you found him? I staked him to the wet earth and cut off his hand. And left him there? Yes. To die. But why have you got the hand chained to the wall? You probably won't believe me. But that hand is alive. Oh, nonsense. Nonsense. It's not nonsense at all, Dennis. My life is safe only as long as that chain holds that hand. But how can a severed part of a body retain life? I wish I knew. Did Annabelle? Well, you'd better hurry down. He already hates to be kept waiting. He's quite a cook, you know. He doesn't want his food spoiled. Look, Sir John, the hand. I could have sworn it moved. Yes. It does. Frequently. Come along. And oh, Dennis, don't say anything about the hand to Phyllis. She hates the thought of it. You have my word, sir. I won't mention the hand at all. Well, Dennis, what do you think of Kiora's cooking? This is any sample, Sir John. Your man, Kiora, is the best cook in France. Oh, you haven't tasted anything yet, Dennis. Wait till Kiora makes one of his famous curry dishes. He's quite an expert on curry. Do you like curry? Well, at times I do. It's a little peppery for my taste. Oh, don't say that to Father. It's sacrilegious. I think your pardon letter came just now, Sir John, for you, under door. Another one, Kiora? Yes, sir. Another one. I say should move now. Phyll, Dennis, will you excuse me? Suppose you young people take your coffee in the parlor. Oh, of course, Father. Sir, I will join you later. Kiora. Yes, Sir John. What time was this letter delivered? Oh, here, let me carry your coffee tray for you. Thank you. Now, how does it happen that we've never met in London, Phyllis? Well, the last time I was in London, I was just coming out of Pigtails. Oh, I would have liked you in Pigtails. You're nice. Tell me more. No, honestly, here, sit down on the window seat, and I'll tell you more. I love to sit on this seat and plaster my nose against the window when it's raining. Oh, I like rainy weather. Oh, so do I. Do you? Amazing. We like the same thing. You know, people who like the same thing ought to get married. Oh, silly.  You're awfully sure of yourself. Well, I once swore that the first woman who called me a headhunter would be my wife. You are nice. You said that before. If you're going to be my wife, you'll have to broaden the scope of your conversation. You beast, beast, beast. Dennis, it's Father. Oh, what is it? I know you live, but you're chained. Chained to the wall. And you won't break loose. Never, never, never. You won't break loose. Oh, my God, sir, I'm that dreadful hand. Quickly, Dennis, to the trophy room back here. But what's happening? You'll see. This way to the left. I'm right behind you, dear. Oh, Father, Father, stop it, stop it, darling. You'll only make yourself ill. Beep, beep. Open that door, Dennis, quickly. We've got to get him out of that room. I'll strike you. I'll strike you again and again and again. Father! Hold him, Dennis. Sir John. Sir John. Let me go, Dennis. Look, look at it, Dennis. Look at the hand now. Look at it. It's moving. The fingers are grasping the air. It wants to grasp my throat. Oh, no, Father, please come away from this room. Please, Father, please. Come along. Come along now, sir John. Come along. Help me with him, Dennis. He's fainting. Oh, Father. Phyllis. Phyllis. That's better. We'll have to carry him ourselves. There now, sir John. Sir John. It's no use, Dennis. Every time Father goes into the trophy room, this happens. Every time he sees that hand, he has an actual physical fight with it. A fight with the hand? I've wanted him to get rid of that thing millions of times. He makes himself ill over it. It'll destroy him this way. Here, let me carry him to the living room. Can you manage? Yes, I can manage. I think we ought to call a doctor for him, Phyllis. He's in a self-hypnotized coma. Dr. Flobear, he lives about a half mile down the road to the left. Good. Here now, sir John. Lie down here. I won't be long, Phyllis. Just let your father rest here on this sofa. There, he'll probably sleep until I get back. Dennis. Yes? Don't stay away too long, Dennis. I'm frightened of being alone in this house. Which way do I turn to go to the doctor's?  Oh, about a quarter of a mile. It's not far. Oh, hurry, Dennis, please. I will. I'll be back shortly. Phyllis. Phyllis. The hand. The hand. Oh, please, Father, you mustn't think about it. The chain and the hand is unlocked. Unlocked? Oh, what's the difference? A hand can't run away, Father. Please, Phyllis, please. Lock the chain. Lock it. Go now. Unlock it. All right, if you want me to, of course. Will you be all right alone here? Yes. Yes, quite all right. Only you hadn't sent Keora into town. No. Phyllis, Phyllis, help me. Help me. It's the hand. The hand coming for me. Crawling on the wall like a scorpion. Closer. Closer, nearer. Nearer. It's coming for me now. I hope the doctor hasn't gone to bed yet. Oh, swear, Monsieur. Que belly vous? I'm sorry to bother you, Monsieur. My name is Dennis Lansing. I'm an Englishman. Yes? Come in, Monsieur. I should have known you would be English.  Lady Phyllis Rowell sent me to fetch you. Her father's very ill. Sir John, what would be ailing him? Nervous shock. Again? He keeps imagining that his severed hand and inanimate piece of flesh is alive. Rubble eye, dear, no? Maybe it is only imagination, doctor. But the result of that imagination is tangible enough. Lord Rowell was in a state of coma when I left him. I will be right with you, Monsieur Lansing. I'll get my bag. You see, I just returned from a visit to another piece. Oh, hurry, doctor. I don't like leaving him alone in that house. It's so gloomy there it can play tricks with your mind. Yes, my bag. No, for my coat. May I help you, doctor? No, no, thank you. Are you ready, Monsieur? Quite ready. My carriage is out in the back. Already hitched. Am I long? We French are more cautious than you English. We do not enjoy getting wet. It is this way, Monsieur. This way. Tell me. Why did not that servant, Chiara, come for me? Oh, he's in town, getting my luggage. Yes, eh? Come on. I would not trust that one, not for a moment. I have warned Lord Raoul of him long ago. And here is the carriage, Monsieur. Climb in. Eh? Eh? We will be there in a short time now. Oh, here we are, Dr. Plobe. Eh, the rush is dark. And Dr. Raoul was waiting for us in the living room. Well, I thought so, too. It is a wet night. Wet night. This way, doctor. Come along. You know, that's funny. There's no light. Eh, perhaps Lord Raoul turned the door so he could sleep. Well, perhaps. Yes, perhaps. They do not answer. No? No, no, they don't. Phyllis! It's Dennis and Dr. Plobe. Let us in. Oh, look, Dennis. Dennis' father's dead. Dead has been murdered. Dr. Plobe, my father's been choked to death by... by the hand. Where is he, my dear? At the sofa in the living room. Come along, doctor. You can take a look at him. I'll light a candle. You're right, Dennis. Father asked me to go to the trophy room to be sure. The hand was locked safely to the wall. As soon as I left him alone, I heard Dad screaming. When I came back, looked best what I saw. Eh, let me examine him and they'll... Here's a candle, doctor. Thank you. There, there. Phyllis, try to control yourself. You're safe now. Father. Father. Phyllis, Phyllis, now stop crying, my dear. It's so incredible, Dennis.  Murder. Did you see the hand? No, I didn't. It was gone by the time I returned. All the lights, but that one candle near the window, were out. Dr. Plobe, is it possible for that hand to be alive? Hmm. And there are ordinary circumstances, I would say no, Mr. Lansing. But these are anything but ordinary circumstances. Then you admit it's possible for this hand to have done the murder? I admit nothing, Monsieur. Only I must judge from the evidence which confronts me. And no human hand ever performed this murder. Look at the imprints on the neck of Lord Rourke. Skeleton imprints. The imprints of Skeleton's fingers. Then the hand is still loose in the house somewhere. Did you see the hand in the trophy room, Phyllis? I never got back there. Oh, Kiora. I have brought your luggage back, Lord Rourke. Yes, Kiora. Lord Rourke is dead. I knew it. I knew it. I told him not to stay in this house. I could feel the danger around us. Could you indeed, Kiora? Perhaps you understand more of this than we do. No, it is pity. Lord Rourke was a fine hunter. Tell me, Kiora, what was in that letter that I received this evening which threw him into such a panic? I do not know, Mr. Lansing. But where did it come from? I do not know that, either. This isn't the case for us to serve, Mr. Lansing. It is up to the police. Oh, not the police. Please, doctor. It will only start an old scandal all over again. And what's mems in it? No, my father wouldn't have wanted it.  He wouldn't want the old scandal repeated. It's a mystery. Your life is in danger. There's no mystery about it. My father was murdered by the hand. He always knew he'd die that way, always. The hand will remain in this house. I'm going as far away as I possibly can. The lady Phyllis is right, Monsieur Flaubert. How can you be so sure it will not follow her? I know more of East Indian magic than you do, doctor. East Indian magic or not? Doctor, in charter of this case, I will have to report Lord Raoul's death to the authorities to make arrangements for his funeral. My father's body will be taken to Englander. Kiora knows exactly what to do. Nevertheless, I must make the report of his death. It is customary procedure in France. An investigation will certainly follow in the morning. You make trouble for all of us, Doctor Flaubert. Yes, especially for you, Kiora. Good evening, Doctor. Thank you. I do not think it is wise to stay in this house tonight, Lady Phyllis. Kiora's right, Phyllis. You can return with me to Madame Corpais. And leave father here alone like this? But there's nothing more you can do for him, Phyllis. If black magic does exist, I can at least watch over him tonight. But, Lady Phyllis... No, Kiora. I'm going to stay right here. If you both want to leave, you can. I won't leave you, Phyllis. If you want to stand watch, I'll stand with you. I make some coffee, Lady Phyllis, yes? Oh, yes, Kiora, if you please. Then I return to town and make arrangements for our immediate return to England. I don't know what I'd do without you, Kiora. Maybe Kiora fix it so we leave before authorities come, yes? If you can, Kiora, I'd be so very grateful. So late, Phyllis. Why don't you try and sleep a while, dear? I'll stay awake and watch. Oh, if only I could sleep. Well, I can put out the candle in the window. If the room is dark, you'll find sleeping easier. No, Dennis. Or whatever you say. I wonder what's keeping Kiora so long. I don't know. I hope he's not in trouble. He's been gone over three hours. He won't be back till morning. Are you comfortable? Oh, yes, as comfortable as I... Listen. Hmm? Do you hear something strange? No. Listen carefully. It sounds like mice in the corner. Oh, yes, now that you mention it. Like mice or a scratching hand. You hear it now, don't you? Yes, I do. Very plainly. Dennis, look on the window sill. It's the hand crawling like a scorpion towards my father, Crawling. It's going toward the light. Dennis, don't touch it! Don't touch it! Be quiet, Phyllis. Look at it! Look, Dennis! What? I'm going to try and turn off the light. I've got to grab it! The light, Dennis! The light! I've got it! Light the candles for the spirit! I'll light them! Hang on to it! Just hold it until I get a taper! What? Well, there. There. Now we can see... Yes, just what I thought. A skeleton hand completely without life attached to a stick. You mean then somebody... Yes, somebody stole the hand, attached it to a stick, and is trying to frighten us. But why, Dennis, and who murdered father? That's something we'll find out rather soon. Ah! Mr. Lansing! It's Kiora outside. I'm calling to help quickly, Dennis. Out the front door! Mr. Lansing! Mr. Lansing! Help me with this man! Stay back, Dennis! Hold on to it! Kiora! Let me go! I've got him! I've got him! Dr. Flaupere, what are you doing here? Mr. Lansing, help me bring him into the house. You're paying the guards heavily for this, Kiora! He's wounded. Yes, sir. I used knife on him, unfortunately. Bring him inside. Dennis, I don't understand what... I think I'm beginning to. Take his feet, Kiora. Yes, sir. I've got him. Feet. Nothing to be proud of. They are the feet of a dog. Close the door behind us, Phyllis. Here, we can put him down here. Yes, sir. You fool, Kiora! Oh! Hey, sell him prison or school for eternity! That is too late, Mr. Margot. Margot? My father hunted him down and left him to die long ago. Dennis, he can't be Margot. He is, though. He didn't die. He was staked to the ground, Phyllis, but managed to free himself. Kiora suspected the doctor from the first. That's quite right, Lady Phyllis. He kept writing letters to Lord Raul. He, the only one near enough to drop letters under door. When he leaves house this evening, I wait outside for him to return. I hide in bushes. I see him and skeleton hand outside window. Then I see light go out inside. Then I grab him. And a good thing you did, too. Yes, good. Now, you'd all be dead. Dead! Paying for the crime of cutting off my hand. My hand! My hand was cut off! And I was left to die! But, Kiora, Dennis, he has a hand. Yes, Lady Phyllis. Artificial one. Made of wax. I shall get even with you, too. Hey! He will pay in another world for the crime he committed tonight. I go get the police, Lady Phyllis. Yes? Yes, Kiora, if you will. I still don't understand how Kiora knew that Dr. Flaubert was really my god. East Indian has a strange but almost infallible second sense. Yes, I'm afraid they have, Dennis. A very strange second sense. Phyllis and I waited in front of the fireplace for two hours. And finally, Kiora and the authorities arrived. I told them the entire story, as incredible as it sounded, and was granted permission to return Lord Raul's body to England. Dennis, can we really go back to England now? I'll be so glad to get home. Oh, so will I, dear. Though I'm not quite sure what my family will say about my traveling back in the company of a strange man. Oh, stuffy, are they? A little bit. Well, they won't have to worry. We're going to be married just as soon as I have you safely home again. Oh, Dennis, my dear. My darling. You may need good housekeeper. Cook, Mr. Lansing. Kiora, make very good Indian curry. Good Kiora, you're hired.  From the time warm pages of the past, we have brought to you the immortal tale, the hand. Bellkeeper, hold the bell.


Let's hang a couple shop lights if we can get a little more light where we need it. Yeah, I think it was Lowe's About these last one I bought was like that one there and it was 10 bucks with the bulbs at Walmart, but all they had was LEDs and So I had to pay $17 a piece for these now. I've got plenty of bulbs Here I went ahead and bought four new ones because they are 2,900 lumens. So hopefully what we're going to do is we're going to hang One right up here. I'm going to come over about a foot. I'm going to come over about a foot I'm going to hang it. I got to hang it back beside this beside the garage door because you know summertime the doors up locks the light out I had that one up there, but it quit working and And So I still want to put one up there now And then I'm going to put one over there the same way. I'm going to come in about a foot and Because I still got some light there But and I'm going to come in to about where the door the door rail is there the door track and That way it can shine down on My toolbox and then once I get this all cleaned out, of course You know it'll also when the doors down at night when I really really need them It should give because see this kind of covers up the door too But that's no big deal. You just pull the door down a little bit with these You know it will once the doors closed it'll give out You know a fair fair amount of light. I've also got This trouble light I've got that trouble light I've got another trouble late hanging over there that little battery-powered yellow one there. It's been working great man But I've also got this light well it needs a bulb now I do have another one of these See I made this stand work because it was all busted up So I mounted my light on it, but I do have one of these but these get really hot If you set them down to work underneath something or whatever the heat just gets to you, so So I do have a trouble. I saw I'll have plenty of light, but I still want to get one more right here and So I should have went ahead and bought three, but I'll probably put another one of these up here I don't know I would like to go with all LEDs, but they're like thirty nine dollars a piece for the good ones and I would need but two for five of them Yeah, I would need five, you know 40 bucks times five. I can't swing that right now, but someday I'll have all LEDs in here, so I've thought about like the like these ones here, you know running them Length ways instead of this way, but you know it's a small garage, so that'll be fine No big deal. All right, so I Want to fast-forward you through this because really all I'm going to do is measure over 12 inches. I'm going to kind of go as close as I can to this door track and Just put a couple holes up there a couple anchors and I should be good to go so hang tight I'll get you on the stand and blur that door down and Oh, I got to get my ladder in here, too Hang tight guys, and I'll be right with you. Sorry about the lighting guys, but first thing we're going to do Let's just go ahead and open at least one of these up for you. Hopefully my cord Will be long enough from where it's going to go all the way down to my power just Right over there if you look above the grinder. I don't know if you get my power I'd hate to have to run extension cord just for like Five or six inches Okay, so it looks good. Of course we've got our better paperwork here Does you have to hang it? Again, sorry about the light. It's like a break and we've got our chains Which they're gonna they're gonna be very short because like when I Hugging that one and That one and see how short the chain is There's only a couple links So But I'll be hanging them a little lower this time off I look like I said I want to go about even with that with that door track So I'll have enough chain this one here I hope I'll have enough. I've got a I've got an outlet up inside there. Hopefully I can run Run my power cord up into there and like I said this one here is gonna come It's gonna be over in here So hopefully it'll be enough to come down and Into my power strip, but you know, that's left to be seen if I have to run a I do have a short Excuse me a white short extension cord if I need to I can do that. I just hate you know That's why I try to keep everything You know kind of neat back in here. See cuz all this See like all these they're all run underneath the bench this one that actually has a hole to run down through but Yeah, all these run Down here underneath the bench. So this I'm not sure if I'm gonna keep it like this or if I'm gonna go ahead and put a Probably just put a wire wheel on this and then move this down here and do away with that Was my initial plan anyway, so it's probably what I'm gonna do that way I'll have You know from like from here over as a workspace so That should be alright this is a little close to the door when the door is down But I've got plenty of room and I said I'm in Florida So I've got the door open most every day even in the winter time, you know, it gets in the 70s here So all right, so just wanted unbox is for you real quick. All right Like I said, let me get the ladder and We'll go ahead and start measuring holes putting anchors and screws in and we'll go from there Taking it over here to power. I Really don't want to do that right now. I'm a leader had trouble getting balls in that one See so I've got Like these lights are on the switch and the one that's over there is gonna be on the switch and this one is Switch right here And it kills everything there. There's no pool string. Which is kind of handy.  I did come in 16 inches okay, so Just a little bit more Kind of more light over here, but So like I said because I'm gonna I don't need it to come over this way anymore because I want to have a light here so It does seem a little dark over there until I turn the other ones on and Then one once I get one of these up here off plenty of light if I do need more light over there I can hang another one, but I'm gonna go ahead and measure that light Maybe the chains aren't right, but I think it's this You would think these would be straight, but I Mean the chain can't be wrong, you know, I just went to the end of the chain So yeah, look at that. That's why did they do that?  I've tried to adjust that the doors kind of Been in a little bit that weren't for it. It's no big deal Okay, so when I walk in a garage I'll flip this light on and as you can see That one came on That one came on That one flip this little switch. It's on my grinders. Everything is ready to go. So It really lightened it up in here So I'm good with that I Measured that track over there the lights even The track is not tracks a See what is it? It's like 11 inches here and 12 inches right before you get to the to the bend This one's pretty much love so I don't know why They did that but Anyway, so that But the light is his level. It's it's exactly 10 and a half inches on both side So as you guys can see From what it looked like before it looked like this Hey everyone she bear 1,000 here. It's kind of dark back over in here Now it looks like this So it has really helped now. I can see to get my toolbox over there.  I thought I'd hang them up there Until I can get a smaller one an LED four-footer to go across here Which there's plenty of light over in that direction. So what I'll probably do Is bring it like from the edge Like from the edge of that light only down here over to my four feet Then I'll have some light just see then I'll have light over here, too So it'll be approximately about to here. So yes it You know, it lights up pretty good even out to the side. So But as far as these lights go for 18 bucks 1799 plus tax $10 for those Packs a 2 so that's 20 bucks in the bulbs. I do like the bulbs. I do like the looks of them Because they're they're brighter, you know like These ones here Match that one back there But this one This one here right there It's more yellow. I don't like the yellow, but they call it warm. Look. I need a cooler light in here You know to brighten things up more. So once I get one in the center there with that little 40 watt light bulb is I mean, that's what I started working with in here Was that 40 watt light bulb and I asked her to pick me up a trouble late one day. Oh mark one of these and She came back with that red thing over there. Like I said, it wasn't on stand though I the stand was given to him. I just fabricated it to fit on there, but So I used it and then it just got super duper hot and things Throw out some heat. I got an orange one right here. That was her dash Same style just a little They they're just too hot, you know, they're more for like outside stuff. So anyway guys, that's all I'm doing today Stay tuned for a garden update. I think I'm gonna do the garden update It's gonna be the last update. I'll keep going with the sunflowers, but the garden update You can see they're growing. Everything's doing good. It's getting bigger You know, what's the bigger tomatoes and the peppers really start producing real well I may do another one later on, but it'll probably be the last one of those. So Anyway, guys, thanks for watching. Appreciate it. She barely met the man a legend I'm gone for now. Don't forget to check out monkey 1000 channel. Appreciate it. All right. We'll see you guys soon Have a great week. Bye. Bye now


What's most important to me is that there's an emotional quality to the image. I think particularly in this area of subject matter, it's super important for it to be there so that you can't look at images clinically, that you have to experience them in some way. I actually do have a background in public health and epidemiology and I've been working with photography for the last 20 years as a curator. It's sort of a perfect fit for me. My interest in photography is reading about how photography can draw attention to important socio-economic and socio-political situations, of course health is central to all of that. You have a combination of very technical people in the photography field and then a combination of health folks as well. And it's really interesting to see what the differences in opinion are and I think in terms of trying to find a way to come together and answer that, it's been a process. I think each discussion is individual and fluid based on the merit of each individual picture. It's a very interesting discussion that we're all having and I don't think there's anything that there is not one real factor that puts a photograph through. It's a multi-factorial thing that depends on, you know, 100 factors whether or not it's going to be a good photograph or not. I want to look at the poetic magnitude of an image, but I also really, and this is maybe a debate within myself, I also want to look at the clarity of, you know, how much of a punch does this give? And I want to learn something, perhaps even higher ambition to change something about the way I perceive an issue or a subject. I won't have a sense of the kind of underlying psychological territories of what that author is trying to reveal.


I like this, joke premise inaccuracies. Yeah, I mean, as a, you know, if I'm watching stand up and I don't even know if I have an example, but I have an example of one of my own jokes. But if somebody is starting a premise and it's inaccurate, I'm out of the joke now because whatever your punchline is that follows, it's like, well, it was, you know, predicated on this faulty thing that you set up and I have a hard time with it or if it's inaccurate. And I'm like, now I can't laugh at this even if structurally it's well written. What do you think when it works? Cause I would argue that a lot of that, if a joke isn't factually correct, it will get 20% less of a laugh. Yeah, but, but yes, when it works, it bothers me. I just think, ah. No, it's infuriating. Yeah. It's like, you want to throw, you want to just take your tickets and throw them in the air. Like, well, this is what we're doing. You have a five o'clock somewhere, Joe? Yeah, my five o'clock, so I have a seven minute bit where I break down the song. It's five o'clock somewhere. It may be 10 minutes. I don't know how long it is. Pretty long. When it's working, it's 10. Yeah, yes, yes. And I don't do it anymore. I just put it on YouTube. But I have, the joke is that, you know, he says, it's only half past 12, but I don't care, it's five o'clock somewhere. And I'm like, yeah, but that's not true. It may be 5.30 somewhere, but we don't lose a half hour just because we changed time zones, right? This joke was working everywhere, all across the country. It was a hot joke. I posted online, and I don't know, at least for a while, at least for a year, once a day, I would get a comment telling me that there are half hour time zones across the world. And in fact, Newfoundland, Canada has a half hour time zone. If it's 12.30 in LA, it's five o'clock. Who sang the song? Alan Jackson sings the song.  Well, that's- You animals. Well, that's what I think too. And I actually met the guy who wrote the song, Jim Moose Brown wrote the song. He's come to my show now since I put out this bit. Fantastic. And- Since you took him to task. Yeah, yeah, yeah.  I was getting all this heat from everyone else. And now you get it. But it's like, you know, he's like, my point of the song was just, it's anytime after- But my point is I'm an alcoholic. Right, right. And, you know, but see now I have a hard time doing the joke. Like I wanna do the joke sometimes for fun. It's a whole breakdown of the song. And that's the only part. Just add an addendum at the end. That's what I will do from now on. But I just, every time now, I think about it because I'm like, now I'm inaccurate. Now it is five o'clock somewhere. Yeah. I have a joke about trauma, about everyone overusing trauma. And I say, I say what trauma is. I'm like, it's a physical thing. It's not a vibe. But truthfully, between you and me, they changed the definition of trauma in the 80s where it used to be a physical thing. And now it can be entered, it can, and I'm there, I just think they're wrong. Oh yeah. And I don't know if technically, because I have an old definition, if I'm just like, no, I'm standing with that. Yeah, no, I get that. But I also get what you're saying.  And no one, but it also does a comment or, I mean, I think people, if you post anything, I can do an AI of what the comments are gonna be. Do you know what I mean? Oh yeah. Like actually, it's like people think it's a way to score a point. Like, well no, did you see what I did? I told that guy. Oh yeah. Who's getting Gale Force approval that he shouldn't be getting the approval because it is five o'clock somewhere. I have a real problem in the comments. I don't get nasty with it in there, but I do like to comment back because of that reason. I just don't want you to think you can come on. Now, I don't do it on other people's channels, but on my own channel, I just think you can't just come on here and criticize me. It's your property. And not expect me to at least respond. What's funny is when you post the video and then someone will write underneath it, this guy, this guy thinks he's, and it's like, I am this guy, and this is this guy's channel. Oh yeah. Just say my name or address me directly. But like this thing of like, hey everyone, this guy, and it's like I'm in the, you know who I am. Yeah. Don't talk to me like I'm this guy. I'm dusty. Yeah, I mean, I'm so not controversial that people have to say I'm just not funny or I'm boring. I'll get boring sometimes. I had a guy comment that. He said, I saw this guy in Phoenix. He's just a boring, you know, whatever comic. And I go, so boring that you had to come watch another video. He can't, it actually settles his nerves. He uses you like an app to calm himself down. I can't believe that you would come back.  Yeah. Yeah. It turns out you can't listen to anyone about anything. No. Ultimately. I knew that someone referred to a girl from the South referred to Bill Burr as a, he just seemed like a bitter Yankee. And I was like, I don't think I can listen to any because that's not what he is. Right. Right. I don't think that's what Bill is, but. Hey, did you like that? Did you like that? Yeah. Did you like it though? You want more? Don't want to work? Would rather watch videos of me grab assing with people.  This is like when the weatherman says there's a high pressure system coming in. I'm not really used to the green screen.