What's up everyone it's your girl Kenzie here from Layton Sports Cards And I'm repping two personal boxes here for Jeffrey each got to 21 22 panini Donress optic basketball hobbies Alrighty Jeffrey. Good luck as always. Thanks so much for hopping in See Yeah, yeah, Bradley. That's what they're saying. It's it's very odd I'm almost positive that they were talking about museum come Double-check with force. We got Jaleen green radar rookie. There we go out of the first pack And we've got out of ten gold Dominators Mike Conley auto. Wow.  I love nice Take a gold bed auto Stargazing KD great start Yeah, that is true, too. He just recently kind of popped off with his popularity Drag it on the Tesla Edwards paint velocity to 79 LeBron James Nice one there for you Jeffrey That is 12 out of 79 on the LeBron what a start Here we go Now we'll see a photon. That'd be crazy. How is that are Williams all-stars? Let's see a photon This would be the box to pull it out of let me tell you Raider rookie David Johnson. Hollow raining three city bay some color coming up bones. Highland raider rookie We've got orange Moses moody to 199 Warriors nice 93 of 199 Fantastic box through either Ustavich 75 years Tim Duncan Get a nice box to start us off here for Jeffrey Brandon Boston, Jr. Light it up Tatum Moses moody raider rookie we've got hollow raider rookie of Kai Jones We're not even halfway now after this will be halfway through the first box These boxes with hot and cold Yeah raider rookie Dale and Suggs and hollow light it up Russell Westbrook Hollow Kyle Lowry Dominator Zion You were saying O'Neill cruise doesn't have autos in museum club, right? Yeah, Miles McBride you'll get your dominators very weird He's out all of them like all the price of less like two months exactly Shingoon hollow Jonathan Isaac. Yeah, but I mean like it's also like a pirate who there's not too many other You know pirates autos after you would think that they would put Prospect in it look at Garza and we've got black velocity to a 39 Jordan Clarkson Nice color coming out of this box for you Jeffy 35 years from Wagner and besides could Brian Hayes, you know, who else?  What's up Andrew box over to your fridge every very nice first box We get out of the second here good luck Santiago Dama hollow drew holiday. I don't sue me for the bulls a D stargazing Join your day off Andrew. We've got 75 years train Murphy Rose all stars insert Jalen Johnson, we've got all stars hollow LeBron and Zion Primo Donovan Mitchell light it up. You called it No, no, we got a super We got gold vinyl here. We go Jeffrey gold vinyl. Show me ready rookie.  Wow Or it's literally just called that. That's crazy Final for Jeffrey. Let's do it. There you go. It takes skill to It does We've got hollow Ant-Man No such thing as luck Hollow raider rookie Kessler Edwards As they hit Jackson hollow raining threes Donovan Mitchell. I know he's one of my favorite players Jesse I've been I've been a fan of D Rose Now we've got oh my gosh another auto gold to 10 optographs of Josh Howard for the Mavs Two gold autos out of two boxes. She's Jeffrey. He's on a roll tonight raining threes It would have been nice to see what where he would have ended up You know if he never heard his knees like he did Reggie Bullock on the hollow Still a heck of a player. Scotty Barnes on the raider rookie orange to 199 Duncan Robinson for the heats 97 of 199 His hops are crazy.  Yeah, awesome. Just a little piece of dust on that giddy. Scotty Lewis 75 years of Karim Abdul-Jabbar That was a cool dual photo. Was that you or Caleb that pulled that was him and Dr. J dual-signed Was it that was really cool? Oh, we've got blue out of 59 Terry Rosier for the Hornets the photography on those pictures, too We're just like insane Great photos Dominator's job book night.  It looks super nice with the magic colors Quentin Grimes. We've got hollow elite dominators of Jason Tatum. Is this a gold? Of course it is. It's Jeffrey's box eight out of ten gold elite dominators Jason Tatum Jeffrey loves gold. That's for sure third gold card. Wow last box here cold vinyl and two golds in one box Kate Cunningham rookie base and last card here for y'all hollow rated rookies. I are Williams All right, Jeffrey. Congrats on those hits. Wow. Thanks so much. We'll be getting these right out to you


Welcome to Toffy TV, it's the news daily. Premier League players today voted to move through phase two of training, which means contact will be allowed in training. The Premier League statement today said that Premier League shareholders today voted unanimously to resume contact training, marking another step towards restarting the Premier League season when it is safe to do so. Squads are now able to train as a group and engage in tackling while minimising any unnecessary close contact. The Premier League's priority is the health and wellbeing of all participants. Strict medical protocols are in place at the training grounds to ensure the safest environment possible and players and staff will continue to be tested for COVID-19 twice a week. Stage two of the returning to training protocol has been agreed by following consultation with clubs, players, managers, the PFA, LMA and the government. So, it was voted unanimously by the clubs. Since that statement came out, the Premier League revealed that there have been four positive tests in the latest round of tests, but they still look at it as the overwhelming majority of players are still fine and COVID free. So, we'll have to see what fallout there is over those four positive test, but clubs moving on now to contact in training. Following very similar pattern to Germany with the Premier League restart schedule for June 20. So, we'll have to see what goes on as we move forward there. John Stones has today been linked with the return to Gooderson Park, a football insider, saying that he is one of the players being considered by Everton manager Carlo Ancelotti. Stones who has been in and out the Manchester City team since leaving Gooderson Park for a fee of £50 million, well £47.5 million back in 2016, got a year left on his deal and Carlo Ancelotti is apparently interested in bringing him in. There you go. He's the latest centre back to be linked with Everton. John Clare Tadebo, Everton are apparently in the driving seat to get him, but Gabrielle has apparently moved closer to a deal with Napoli today or certainly his club as. The Independent reporting that Napoli have agreed a fee of €30 million for the 23-year-old Brazilian currently playing at Leal. He has agreed personal terms with Everton and I thought you've had a medical with the Blues. No personal terms as yet agreed with Napoli though, so people could still be guessing. Who knows? And once again the Everton, Chensill under Moise Keane swap is doing the rounds. Everton we know are interested in under. Marcel Brans likes him. We're interested in getting him in last summer and couldn't do so. Roma are apparently interested in Moise Keane, so people saying that the swap deal is on. This will probably just continue to rumble on as we move forward. I'm finally Everton. I've released a social distance and training video today. You can see that on Everton's website showing Moise Keane scoring goals and Jerry Maynard and Holgate and that. And interestingly, Jarrod Branthwaite and Anthony Gordon also featuring in the training video. Maybe not Gordon, he's in all the time, but good to see Jarrod Branthwaite training with the first team. And because the 23 season has finished, it's interesting that he's being brought back into the group and training with Anciolotti, so fair play to him there. That is it for the news. Daily make sure you give the video a thumbs up. Subscribe if you haven't and if you want more videos, join us on Patreon. See you later.


The Equitable Life Assurance Society presents, this is your FBI. This is your FBI, the official broadcast from the files of the Federal Bureau of Investigation. Presented as a public service by the Equitable Life Assurance Society of the United States and the Equitable Society's representative in your community. Later on in tonight's program, it will be our pleasure to present Mr. J. Edgar Hoover, Director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation speaking to you from Washington, D.C. Are you covered by Social Security? Then would it surprise you to know that your rights under Social Security can be equivalent to 12, 15, even 18,000 dollars, depending on your age, salary and family situation? Rights worth that much are worth knowing about, worth safeguarding. Therefore, as a public service, the Equitable Life Assurance Society will devote this program's entire middle commercial due in just 14 minutes to information on Social Security, information which may mean money in your pocket. Tonight's FBI file, the runaway racketeers. Any serious problems facing every law enforcement agency today, but perhaps the most important one is juvenile delinquency, because unless that problem is at least partially solved, there is no hope that the crime wave will recede. If the juvenile delinquency problem is attacked intelligently, then the constant flow of recruits to the army of criminals will be impeded, and then progress can be made in stifling the activities of our adult criminals. Mr. J. Edgar Hoover, Director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation, will speak to you later in the program about this matter of vital concern to every one of you, whether you are a parent or not. It has been a mistake made by many people in the past that juvenile delinquency was no concern of theirs if they themselves did not have children whose lives they might die. Nothing could be further from the truth. The problem that confronts your FBI and every other law enforcement agency in the nation also concerns you. The night's file opens late one afternoon on the edge of a river which flows through a large eastern city. A boy is walking along a dark pit just into the stream. He nears a group of youngsters who are swimming below. Hey, Finney! Oh, hi, Reno. Hey, swim over the ladder. We're here. I want to talk to you. What do you want? Well, I ain't gonna yell down there. Okay. It's from Yeti's shirt. Will you? I want to wipe off. Okay. You got another butt? Sure. Here. Where'd you get a full pack? I bought it. And that ain't all I can buy. With what? With this. Hey, how much you got there? 25 bucks. And it's mine. Where'd you get it? You know me and Charlie did a job. What'd you do? Roll a drunk? Nah. Want a stick up? I figured out something that's better than a stick up. Now I can't work it no more. Why not? Yeah, Charlie got sick. What's the matter with him? I don't know. He's in a hospital. That's what I want to talk to you. Why? I want to work the same thing over again. I need another guy. You want to work with me? Yeah. What kind of a job is it? Of course you'll tell me if you're in or not. Do I get that kind of dough? Maybe more. Charlie going to be sore out? I told you it's my idea. I'll take care of it, Charlie. Okay, I'm in. Well, get your clothes on. Let's get back to the club. Right now? Yeah. We've got to find a doctor to call. What's the matter?  Yeah, I ain't sick. That's part of the job. The first thing we've got to do is call a doctor. Charlie, you?  I was just asking. You sure you gave the doctor the right address? Just like you told me. Okay. Now look, when he rings the bell, you answer the door and look real sad. Okay. Let him in and remember, open the door real wide so we don't see any standing behind. I will. And I'll take care of the rest. I hope it works. It worked the other day with Charlie and they didn't... Yeah. Then quit worrying in as long as... That's enough. Go ahead. Okay. Dr. Fulton? That's right, son. Well, my mother's in that room there. Thank you. Okay, Vinnie, let's roll him and get out of here. Morning in the gymnasium of the local boys' club. FBI Special Agent Jim Taylor is visiting an old friend. Well, Jim, what are you doing in this neighborhood? Working.  I opened up by myself. Paul, that's what I came here to check on, though. Oh. Yes, a doctor named Fulton paid a professional call. He was flat around the corner last night. He was knocked out by two youngsters. Yes. They robbed him after they knocked him out. Oh, Jim, I'm certain none of my boys would do a thing like that. Well, Paul, maybe you can help me find the two who did, huh? How much do you know so far? Well, earlier this morning, Dr. Fulton's wife called the police. I see. She said the doctor hadn't been home all night. His nurse reported that he'd made his last call last evening at an address in this neighborhood. The police checked and found him there. He wasn't dead, was he? No, but he'd received a very nasty scold. He regained consciousness for a few minutes and told the police he'd been assaulted by two youngsters. Then he passed out again. Well, how does the FBI get into the case, Jim? Well, after the doctor was robbed, the youngsters took his car up to Playland Park. One of the tires went flat, so they abandoned it. Well, Playland Park, as you know, is just across the state line. Yes, I know. Well, what can I do to help, Jim? When Dr. Fulton comes to the hospital, I'm going to get a full description of the boys, Paul. Then, if they're from this neighborhood, maybe you can tell me who they are. I'll certainly try. Fine. I'm going back up to the hospital now. I'll see you later. 3-2-0-9. Who's with me, huh? 3-2-2-0-9. Come on. Let's go. Rick, oh, Rick. Oh, hi, Benny. You in the game? Yeah, yeah, yeah. Can I see you for just a minute? Well, what a plaza. The rest of the stuff from last night's job. Did you sell it? No, not all of it. Why not?  This is no place to talk business. But I thought you said this. Come on over here. He sold everything except this ring and a wristwatch. Couldn't you get nothing for him? I'm keeping the watch. You get the ring. Oh. Let's have it, huh? Yeah, sure. Here. Hey, it's got my initial on it. Hey, look, Benny, I got to get back to the game. Hey, wait. I forgot to tell you something. Well? I've seen Pete Paxton today. He said hello to me. So what? I guess the big guy's got the word how we've been operating. Maybe Pete could use us, huh? Look, if we keep going like this, Pete'll be working for us. I mean it. Why don't we do another job, Rick? Come on, I... On who? I don't know yet. The phone book is full of doctors. Come on in, Jim. Put up a chair. Oh, thanks. I'm trying to lay out the strongest possible batting order for a game we're playing tomorrow. No. Need a good left-handed second baseman? Need a whole infield. Oh. Oh, by the way, did you talk to the doctor? Yes. Yes, he couldn't give us much of a description on either one of the boys.  I see. However, he did give me a list of possessions which were taken from him in the description of each article. Hey, Paul, take a look at this. Right. That list also contains the things that were stolen from another doctor who was assaulted last week. Is that the same boy? Well, we don't know that yet. Well, I guess the doctor couldn't get much of a description either. No. No, he couldn't. But because both assaults took place in this neighborhood, I was hoping maybe you'd spot some of the things on some of the boys who come in here. Well, Jim, we're not getting many boys here these days. Kids want stuff to play with when they come here, and they've learned that we just don't have it. We've got one pair of boxing gloves, for instance. What? Yes, and the baseball season is getting started, and we've got one bat, two old baseballs, and both of them taped up. I don't understand, Paul. How come you haven't got more equipment than that? Well, it takes money, Jim, and people aren't contributing it.  Now, where do the kids go if they don't come here? Well, this time of the year, they go swimming off the docks down by the river. A couple of them get drowned every season, but they're poor kids, so no one cares except their families. That's about it. Paul, what can be done?  Well, it can't be, Jim, unless we get kids to come in. We had some equipment and a swimming pool, where I could break up half the gangs in the neighborhood. How, the many of them? Dozens. And every one of them is rented a cellar. Running their own clubs, you can imagine what they are. Yeah. Well, I'm still trying, Jim. In fact, I'm going out this afternoon to make the rounds of the cellar clubs and talk to every boy I find and see if I can't get them to come here. Paul, if you spot any of the items on that list I gave you, let me know. Seven ball cross-side. No good position. Well, let's see what I can do now.  Who is he? A guy over on Walton Avenue. Oh. I think I can make that conversation. Well, I think I can make that conversation. Think I can make that combo? That's right. Let's see. Well, I wonder if... Hey, see who that is. Okay. Hello, Vinnie. Oh, hello. Can I come in? Well, okay. Hello, Rocco. Hi. Hi.  That's for kids. Well, we're playing a team from the north end tomorrow, and we sure could use you. How much a man are you playing for? Well, we don't play for money. Well, we ain't interested. Hey, make a shot. Will you, Vinnie? You're okay. I think I will try that combo. Vinnie. What? Where'd you get that ring? Huh? The ring you're wearing. Where'd you get it? A sister bought it for him. Yeah, for my birthday. May I see it? What for? Well, I...  You're crazy. I have a list here with a description of that ring, and I... Now, look, Mr. Crawford, you got no... You got any questions, Crawford? Ask him from me. Very well. Where'd you get that watch you're wearing? Huh? If I'm not mistaken, that's one of the stolen articles. This is my old man's watch. He lets me wear it. Sorry, but I don't believe either one of you. Now, look... I'm afraid I'm going to have to report you both to the police. Rico, what do we do? I'll show ya! Oh! Rico, you shouldn't have done that. I mean, what's going to the cops? What do we do now? Well, as long as he's out, let's roll him. We will return in just a moment to tonight's file which shows how your FBI provides national security. Mr. Wilson, I believe you have a question. Yes, Mr. Keating.  We've got three kids. Two, eight, and 11 years old. If I die, does she get Social Security benefits for the rest of her life? No.  As a matter of fact, if you want to get a clear picture of Social Security, why not get in touch with your Equitable Society representative? Full information is the first step in the Equitable Society's three-step service on Social Security. The second step is an immediate checkup on your position under Social Security. What's that for? To make sure all the money you've paid in is properly credited to your account. Your Equitable Society representative will supply you with a special form approved by the Social Security Administration, and will show you what to do with it. This checkup makes possible the last step in this service offered by the Equitable Life Insurance Society. What is that? After you've found out where you stand in Social Security, your Equitable Society representative will be able to show you how a comparatively modest investment in life insurance will build Social Security into full security. In other words, he'll give you an analysis to show how life insurance and Social Security working as a team can give you and your family a future of financial independence, of complete freedom from money worries. There's no charge for this service, no obligation whatsoever. See your Equitable Society representative immediately, or write care of this station to the Equitable Life Assurance Society. That's E-Q-U-I-T-A-B-L-E. The Equitable Life Assurance Society of the United States. And now back to the FBI file, The Runaway Racketeers. Tonight's case illustrates how a young boy who travels in bad company can become involved in a life of crime. It also shows that the commission of any later crime after the first one has been committed is almost a natural reflex. That is the reason why juvenile delinquency in any section is everyone's concern. Because from the youngsters who go wrong today will come the supercriminals, the Dillentures, the Capones, the Carpuses of tomorrow. But that need not be their destiny. There are ways of fighting delinquency and those ways are successful. They do take money and they take people. But when a community proves that it is willing to provide boys' clubs and other clean places where youngsters can spend some hours of decent enjoyment, it is made headway. It takes two things. First, the financial ability to provide those places with equipment they need. Second and more important, it takes long hours of hard work by people who must prove to the children that they understand their problems and are willing to help them solve those problems. That is the main ingredient in any recipe for fighting juvenile delinquency. That single, inexpensive quality understanding. Night's file continues shortly after the attack on Paul Crawford. Rico and Vinnie are walking along the neighborhood street. Rick, I still say you shouldn't have done that. We just stopped. We're getting trouble on account of that. How are we going to get in trouble? Mr. Crawford knows where we live. So what? He'll have us arrested. He's got to find us first, darling. That's easy. All he does is go to my house and to your place. We ain't going to be there. Why not? Where are we going to be? I don't know yet, but we're blowing. Where are we going to go? I told you, I don't know yet. You want to wait, Rick? You want to wait for the cops? No, but... All right, then you better come along with me. But you don't know where you're going. We go to the bus station and we grab the first bus out. Special Agent Taylor speaking. Hello, sir. Paul Ho. Paul Crawford. Oh, it doesn't sound like you, Paul. No. What do you mean? I found these kids for you, Jim, but they knocked me out. When did that happen? About an hour ago. Who are they? One of them is a kid named Rick O. Anderson. The other is Vinnie Franklin. How did you know they were the kids we were looking for? Fulton's wristwatch. You know where they live, Paul? Yes. Anderson Boy lives at 58 West Adams Street. Oh, hold it, Paul. I want to write that down. All right. Okay, go ahead. The other one lives at 118 West Jefferson. 118 West Jefferson. That's Vinnie Franklin's address? Right. Got it. What did the doctor say about you, Paul? Oh, I haven't been to see a doctor, Jim. Got to this phone booth as soon as I came, too. You'd better get over to a doctor's office as soon as you can. I'll go to these two addresses and see if I can pick up the two youngsters. When I'm finished, I'll check with you down at the boys' club. Oh, yes, Jim. What did the doctor say? I just have a new bump on my head. That's all. Oh, have you been to see those kids? Yes. I went by before I came down here. Neither one of them were home for dinner. Well, if they ran away, they can't get too far. I only had about a dollar and a half on them. Oh, I got pictures of each of them. Yeah. Take a look at these, will you, Paul? Sure. Which ones are very good, like this one? I don't know. This one's, uh, pretty good of record, Jim. I'd say, uh, yes. This is the best picture you've got of Vinny. That's well, thanks. What are you going to do with them? Well, my hunch is they've left town. Nice. And if they did, maybe whoever sold them their tickets will remember where they went. I'm going to make the rounds of all the transportation terminals and show everybody these pictures. Mind if I come along? No, if you feel well enough, come on. Well, what? When does this bus get to Boston? Yeah, about another hour. Do you know anything about Boston? Sure. What? Well, they finished third last year. Huh? Third in the American League. Oh. What I meant was, do you know your way around? Have you ever been there before? No, but we'll make out. Where's this bus was gone the other way? What's the matter with you? This is big action, not for me. What? As soon as we get off the bus, we'll head right for a hotel. Have you ever been in one? Just the downstairs part.  The rooms, they got soft beds, stuff like that. Uh-huh. And when you get hungry, if you like, you can have your meals right in your room.  Yeah, sleeping and eating. And I like it better at home. You ain't going home, but we make a few scores. There's plenty of doctors in Boston. When we clip them, then we go home. Not before. Any luck here, Jim? Yes, Pa. Oh, where'd they go? They were sold two tickets on a bus for Boston. Ticket agent just give you there? Yeah, the boys walked in and Rico asked him for two tickets on the first bus that was going out. Hmm. Surprised he didn't call a police saying two kids act like that? Oh, I checked that. He said the bus company was sued last year for aiding in a false arrest. Since then, he's been instructed not to do anything but sell tickets. Jim, is there any chance of stopping that bus before it gets to Boston? No, it arrived there a couple of hours ago. It's too bad. What are you going to do now? Call the Boston office and have them send out an alarm on the boys, as they say. I've got to go up there tomorrow in another case. While I'm there, I'll see what I can do. Boston's a big city, Jim. Yeah, I know, Pa. But if they're still there, I've got an idea on how I might find them. I wish I was home. I'll quit beefing, will ya? What time did Dr. say he'd be? As soon as he could. I told him to hurry. Rico, what? Take it easy when you slug them, will ya? Why?  Man, not this way. Well, I don't want to get mixed up in nothing where a guy gets killed.  But, Rico, I... I'll play it. We'll get behind the door before you open it. Okay. I'm coming. Dr. Chansomino? No, I'm not Dr. Chansomino, Vinnie. Huh? How do you know my name? Because I've been looking for you. For your friend, too. Come on out from behind the door, Rico. Okay, then I'll close it. What's the idea? Who are you? I'm a special agent of the FBI. Huh? How did you know he was here? You were traced to Boston. I had a hunch you'd try the same thing here, so I had every doctor alerted. I told him to call our office if he got a phone call late at night from someone who wasn't a regular patient.  No, Rico. But I am smart enough to know that you two are headed in the wrong direction. Now you're going to come back home with me. Rico Anderson was sentenced to reformatory to remain there until he is 21 years old. Because his companion, Vinnie Franklin, was greatly influenced in participating in the crime he was paroled in the custody of his parents. And now we switched to Washington, D.C. in order that you may hear a vital message from Mr. J. Edgar Hoover, director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation. Mr. Hoover. Good citizens develop. So do criminals. Each is the product of training, opportunity, and surroundings. Both have one thing in common. Their early years foretell their future. Youth is the time to prepare for the full life in the future. Study, work, and recreation with the aid of a good home which earnestly seeks spiritual as well as mental and physical development of its children leads to good citizenship. These are the forces that create a feeling of personal responsibility and equip youth to face the future with confidence and courage. This nation's responsibility to its youth is increasing. It must because of the facts that are stark and revealing. The crime problem in this nation almost exceeds imagination, as 190 major offenses occur somewhere in our country every hour, day and night. It's told in monetary terms, if diverted, could retire our national debt in less than a generation. This is another great menace, the failure of citizenship, and we have a major domestic problem. The call of citizenship today has never before been so clear. Criminals who would rob us of our lives and property, and godless communists who would rob us of liberty and freedom by their deception, present a challenge that calls for action. I know of no better way to prepare for the future of America than to provide now 300 boys clubs of America have accepted this challenge. 300 boys clubs throughout the nation are providing wholesome recreation and constructive activities for boys who are learning and practicing self-reliance, tolerance and fair play. America needs young people like these. It needs youthful viewpoints and youthful hopes. It needs boys who will bring vitality to the homes, the schools, the churches, and in short to every arena of human endeavor. It needs future citizens who believe in God and who recognize the need for moral stability. It wants clean healthy boys who are ready at all times to fight if need be for American principles.  If this splendid organization is to expand and continue to help build the citizens of tomorrow it merits the whole hearted support of serious-minded Americans today. Thank you, Mr. Hoover. In just a moment, we will tell you about next week's exciting case from the files of your FBI. Now, a quick review of the special three-point service offered by your Equitable Society Representative to help you get the most out of Social Security. First, it gives you a clear picture of what Social Security can accomplish for you. Second, your Equitable Society Representative supplies you with a special form approved by the Social Security Administration for checking up on your position under Social Security. Third, he shows you how easy and inexpensive it is to build Social Security into full security. Don't fail to take advantage of the special service offered without charge by your Equitable Representative and the Equitable Life Assurance Society of the United States. Next week, we will dramatize another case from the files of the Federal Bureau of Investigation. A factual account of the manipulations of a hardened hijacker. It's subject theft from interstate shipment. It's titled The Easy Marksman. The incidents used in tonight's Equitable Life Assurance Society's broadcast are adapted from the files of the Federal Bureau of Investigation. However, all names used are fictitious. And any similarity thereof for the names of persons living or dead is accidental. Tonight, the music was composed and conducted by Frederick Steiner. The author was Jerry Lewis. Your narrator was William Woodson and Special Agent Taylor was played by Stacey Harris. This is your FBI is a Jerry Divine production. This is Larry Keating speaking for the Equitable Life Assurance Society of the United States and the Equitable Society's representative in your community. And inviting you to tune in again next week at this same time when the Equitable Life Assurance Society will bring you another thrilling story from the files of the Federal Bureau of Investigation. The Easy Marksman on this is your FBI. This is ABC, the American Broadcasting Company.


nice to meet you very nice meeting you uh fang has yet to arrive yes uh he got delayed somehow i guess but okay it's fine uh so that's in the end you and i can meet and then he can join that's right that this is the co-working space yeah it is okay i'm sure she'll love it i mean this looks pretty oh it decorated yeah yeah it's uh very hipster it's like uh it's not a normal co-working space it's like uh for artists and so forth but it's it's cute it is cute i'll just grab some coffee and this is our administration building as you can see it's also kind of hipster you get business origami you get any number of post-it notes it's shaped very much like a co-working space but not a rc one uh we have another office that's the more artsy one so so yeah let's get started because i have maybe an hour or so yeah sounds good okay so so yeah first thank you for for making the time no thank you for making the time right and um i mean we can talk about a million subjects but i'm most interested in qv uh and and and so what what i mean i've read the paper uh and i've talked with quite a few um people interested in implementing the idea from the social financing side as well as from the public donation side as well as from the extracting promise out of mayor is promising to do to not do something within their term side um and and so on so i mean just for the sake of benefit of the readers and viewers of this recorded video um would you like to outline some of the main ideas and topics that you you're personally now working on our focused and then we can yeah so so um around quadratic voting the thing that we are most interested in is first of all um the idea of having a democratic system that allows minorities to protect themselves rather than uh to have bureaucrats or judges or something like that being in charge of protecting minorities by giving every citizen an equal budget of what we call voice credits that they allocate to support or oppose issues and candidates that they most strongly favor or oppose but not allowing people to just be extremists and dominate an issue because it would become increasingly expensive to have more influence on an issue the more influence that you have uh so that's the quadratic nature and um this can be applied to uh voting situations it can be applied by politicians to poll to figure out positions that might form a legitimate basis for legitimate public decision making it can also be used for funding so if you want to fund local public goods Vitalik Buterin and I worked on a variant of this idea we're rather than it just being a way of voting you would actually have public matching funds that could be given to different local projects or even say to media and individuals could make contributions and the amount that would be received by the say the charitable cause or the candidate or whatever would be the sum of the square would be the sum of the square roots all squared and so what that would mean is that smaller contributions would receive more matching funds from the public and causes that had received contributions from more people would also receive more matching funds so it's a way of overcoming the usual free writer problem where when you have public projects people don't want to individually contribute to them because they would only do it if other people would go along with them so um I've been working on all of those um and uh we've been thinking about applications for everything from funding news media because you know it's not usually well funded just really private means but on the other hand you don't really want the government funding it because it could control the media and undermine democracy um and everything from that to um you know making decisions in local councils and uh at the same time we've also been working on these sort of identity solutions that would be necessary to support a system like that because it requires a notion of different voters and if you don't want that to all be done by some central government authority approving people to participate we've been working on identity solutions as well that's great thank you for the summary who came up with the monica liberal radicalism if I may ask uh me and zoe hit sig okay it's it's excellent thank you right so um if I say I'm a person interested in participating uh in crowdfunding you just mentioned I'm a regular um donating or actually funding uh person on patreon uh and now Kickstarter has introduced a new drip I'm sure that you're aware of many other such platforms and of course Kickstarter is a b-corp supposedly that they drive their social purpose and so on but nowadays we're also seeing quite a few because the technology is out there now quite a few what we call platform cooperatism or with any other name but people are basically putting up their own crowdfunding distributing schemes upon open collectives and other open co-op movements so are you aware of any of these adopting qv I mean from any user perspective I think that's probably what makes the most sense to have the first experience in yeah so um there's a donation platform on ethereum called we trust that actually put a hundred thousand dollars or 500 eth behind matching funds for uh liberal radicalism for donations to charity and there's also a lot of different mostly ethereum based platforms that have been using quadratic voting for various governance things everything from regulating um the process of electing people to do block making within a permissioned system that is used for doing import export regulatory compliance to um commercial real estate developments that are tokenizing real estate and that are governing some of the choices about how to invest the community resources using this mechanism that's yeah there's a there's a wide range of different projects like that so starting this month if you get to spring that we trust IO you can actually have the first experience of qv exactly you found yes so um but I mean I just looked at uh the uh there's the usual suspects such as the Mary and the sense research um how yes uh and which one second yeah sure funds are okay Jerry's phone here hi hi how are you doing no worries Audrey's on the line so we should just jump jump in because she is being recorded here you can come in and you can close the door and you have to actually do this to get it to stay close all right sorry okay now it's me and fun here together hi hello hello no problem it's just fine take your time uh grab something this is very RC hipster place I wish I'm here yeah it is a very hipster yes so yeah I was just looking at this so functions for context uh I'm looking through this um crowdfunding website that is currently applying Glenn's idea of what we called a qv or quadratic voting and here is the um can you see my screen yeah okay so this is basically a matching donation scheme now through giving Tuesday uh and for this month they're matching based on the liberal radicalism idea which uh Glenn just explained kindly for our viewers in short it basically says if you have a lot of money or if you can mobilize a lot of people to donate small amount of money each it's going to be roughly the same by taking the square roots of each donation and matching them accordingly and there's the usual suspects miri sense the ubuntu foundation joining this um crowdfunding experiment I would say but there's also uh African advocacy network as well surgeons of hope and the more traditional charities and of course some the people in between like code for America which I'm not surprised at all as being listed here and so I was just about to ask Glenn how do you how do you think is the synergy between the different uh projects here because one of the underlying assumption in the qv idea is that projects themselves um compete somewhat for resources so that the I wouldn't say winner takes all but the most well known charities or most well known causes or most well known participatory budget items or whatever dominates the resource kind of in a uh network effect increasing returns uh fashion uh and qv is designed to kind of mitigate that so taking this very concrete example of quite a few people funding the the lupus foundation uh and at the moment not much at all um at the African advocacy network how does it help well one one property that qv absolutely does have is that in the in this particular formula the more people that are contributing to something the more the effect of a marginal dollar you contribute on that particular one but on the other hand unlike sort of purely majoritarian schemes um it's not like that's predetermined it's not like oh you have to just vote for one thing instead the notion is you could give a little bit of funding to some things more funding to others uh etc and so the notion is that it should allow sort of for an optimal balance between you not wanting things to be too fragmented because people feel they can freeride on the things that already have momentum and on the other hand things being uh too concentrated because like the democratic process just leads whatever the majority prefers to win right but i mean does it require a overview effect of the current budget situation or do you think that it can also work in an uncoordinated fashion where people just make individual choices i think you do need to have probably some view of what the current funding levels are and you actually saw that on that site they make it pretty transparent what the current funding levels are so that's helpful for the users right so it requires a period of time and just like participatory budgeting actually but instead of dot voting uh you have dots that grow or shrink based on how many dots you you spent on a particular item um so have you actually um visualized this because when i see the spraying we trust i don't see any visualization of the shrinking dots if you know what i mean yeah i haven't come up with a really compelling visualization of it but in some of the articles online i believe there's one where they show this kind of cool diagram which shows i don't know if you saw this one but they show little blocks stacked on top of each other by their height and then that's very very cute yes and so then anything with the same height but then the volume of them shows how much actually comes from the contributions relative to how much comes from the matching so the matching is like sort of the right hand side and the blocks width is how much comes from the private contributions so i thought that was a smart visualization of it oh yeah that's a great visualization so just just think that you have any number of square votes really and that's you can you can buy areas but the areas is going to count toward their height i think that's a beautiful beautiful thing um actually that applies to circles also right it doesn't have to be squares or another thing you can apply it to is is a funnel so imagine like a you have like a triangle and you pour your liquid into the triangle and how high it gets determines how much value there gets you see what i mean yes of course yeah so so and it ties very well with the idea of the the experiment actually that's that's going on because it's a spring right so you can have spring that goes into a funnel and it's all very water commons based yeah liquid solutions okay that's great so i wish people watching this video will volunteer some visualizations because we have real data now and the spring we trust is on the the chain right it's on on ethereum so anyone can take the public chain data and do cool amazing visualizations yeah all right so um fun would you like to quickly introduce yourself to our viewers and and so so that we can we can chat more freely i'm sure right afterwards but it's just i have maybe only 40 minutes after this so so we can maybe switch from topic to topic yeah yeah sure so yeah and my name is phong and i'm a service design consultant at pittis great so i am one of audrey's agenda is open government so i help facilitate the mechanism which is called present participation officers network it's a network of 70 severe servants across 34 ministries yeah and we hope to use that mechanism to cut across the governmental silos and help people to work towards different issues more openly and creatively not just within the circle but also onto the wider stakeholders it sounds a little bit like what at microsoft we call the office of the chief technology officer it's like one office that's allowed to cut across everything and facilitate collaboration yeah great that's radical horizontalism for you yeah yes um and uh and phong helped build this network of people um and each ministry can have a team of people and at a moment we're still using old school approval voting uh to pick every month what's topic of priority to work on uh and because they come from e petition you can also think of it as a kind of approval voting uh where at anytime anyone can decide to counter sign a petition to raise their priority about which that we take a interest in looking at and at a moment in taiwan there's 23 million people and uh e petition network uh online is being used by five million people so one quarter of the population which is not too bad uh and people just um counter sign each other and we have some machine recommendation algorithm like a netflix or amazon uh that recommends similar interested petitions but it's also of course for budgeting visualization regulation pre announcement participatory budgeting on the city level so it's an all-in-one participation platform and so um the the way it works is that whenever there's anything that receives five thousand signatures over uh two months period gets a view uh from all the participation officers and they can explain and defend whether it needs a cross ministry or collaboration and then we do a approval uh voting anonymously on it and then we select two cases every month to collaborate on but each and everyone that reached the five thousand people threshold automatically gets um a binding power to basically being interviewed being talked with by the stakeholders and publish the full um transcript of the conversation and get a point by point response within two months uh from the respective ministry so that's one of the more successful uh direct democracy ish experiments that we do and it's been working pretty well because people essentially when they're petitioning have unlimited number of votes uh and they are somewhat authenticated through sms and so it's difficult to get five thousand sms numbers as you know and so that's the system that we're currently working on i'm just as as you were talking about this crowdfunding idea i was just wondering uh how qv or a similar um design can can help but it seems like when it's just a general setting or priority setting uh and it's not allocation of resources it's kind of um okay to use approval voting now well i think approval voting is better than some systems but i would prefer a qv based system because what i'd like people to be able to express is the same thing that they in other cases express through a protest so when you get it in protest it's a more costly action than just signing a petition but it shows that something's very important to you and so but not everyone likes to protest not everyone likes to be out in public so i'd like a more private way for people to do that so if every citizen had a budget of credits and they could say this issue is incredibly important to me maybe only you would need 300 things like that but if you would need 10 000 or 15 000 if people just say well i'm interested but i don't really care right so at the moment for example at any given moment uh the joint platform may have 100 petitions going on uh and truth truth is that maybe uh after two months only five of them will get the five thousand people threshold that's that's the situation the reality we're now facing so what you're proposing essentially is that um if you can get any number like 500 people feeling that this is really important for some definition really important so much so that they are willing to forsake their capability of petitioning for that particular month on any particular issue any other issue they dedicate their petition resource so to speak on this issue then it only takes you know a square root of our current threshold to basically pin it into our must respond board and the number is going to be very low it's going to be 70 per people basically yeah and conversely like you know you you said you have these recommendation things there might be some people who just are having fun and on the website they click on one and then they follow the recommendation they click on the other and they don't even think anything about it right and those things you might want to require 10 000 or 15 000 such signatures in order to respond because they're not really driven by passion they're driven you know depth of importance they're just driven by entertainment you know what i mean and so you want to have some way of measuring that and the ideas that quadratic voting could help you do that right so from a interface or experience design perspective because we have a professional experience designer here how would that even work i mean medium says you know if you're just passing by you just click on claps it's one each but if you feel really strongly you can keep holding that clap button and it will grow in number would you recommend some interface like that or do you have something else in mind i actually i quite enjoy that medium interface i think it's pretty good i mean i think i think it would be better to have some sort of a token if you can build the infrastructure that's necessary for that but obviously that requires a more persistent identity than just an sms code right so that's the disadvantage of it but i think if you can do that then people don't have to spend so much time holding down the clap you can just reveal it through how they spend the scarce resource right so it would be like a slider or something yes fun was yeah you just raised a very important point like how can we distinguish um if the vote is really valuable yeah am i passionate about that or am i just doing this for entertaining and the question is how can we tell what are the criteria that we can set up to evaluate that well i can show you what it looks like for quadratic voting it might help you see it i can give you a nice um user space let me see whether i can let's do the screen share thing yeah i just need to get my bra i'm using brave to get it here we go what the right address is okay uh it's going to take me a little while to get the website up because i need to find it can you grab my phone from there yeah i just uh i don't have the address yeah i don't have the address saved on right here so sorry yeah the advantage of brave is that it doesn't remember everything that you've ever done but the disadvantage of brave is that it doesn't remember everything that you've ever done so uh okay there we go right it's okay uh it's it's more human uh it proves we're not all exo core texas exactly okay there we go and now i'm in a screen share um here we go did you get it well yes um uh that's great okay so you have a hundred credits left and here are various referenda which you could vote in favor of or against so an immediate tax cut for wealthy individuals and corporations let's say we're opposed to that we put one credit on that background requirements for all gun purchase let's say we're in favor of that but we actually are strongly in favor so we want to put more than one vote on it so you see my votes are going down faster and faster as i put more and more votes on it you see what i mean whereas if i put just one vote on that it just goes very quickly so this measures how much you care about it yeah by making it increasingly expensive to have more votes so that you'll buy votes just up to the point where you care enough yeah and then that will be proportional the number of votes that you've already bought sure and in regards to those you can touch the screen yeah yeah who are those people who set up the the the statements well in this case this was a poll that we did for a political candidate in the united states but um in general it doesn't have to be that it could be actually citizens proposing these things and then once they cross the 5000 you know vote threshold they could be allowed sure yeah so far i do have any thoughts about how applicable or where it could be applicable in our process because i'm very eager to prototype it yeah i think this is a very good idea and i think this also reflects to our conversation earlier last week we talked about when you propose certain things the stage before it is noticing raising awareness yeah yeah and because when you want to propose something it depends on your allocation of attention yes your allocation of attention based on the information uh you receive right and also the people you interact with right but what if um your encode chamber is limited so it prevent you from seeing the um the people's view from other sites even within the same topic yes and i see this is a very uh dangerous move towards proposal so why would like to talk a little bit more is a step before like how can we make sure that we got democratic discourses yeah sorry sorry to shut down i don't know what happened no it's just fine so what i was gonna say is that the voting mechanism itself can help shape the incentives people have to get information under quadratic voting having very extreme opinions is very expensive to do having more moderate opinions is cheaper so the hope and unlike in match standard voting if you take somebody who you really disagree with and you cause them to disagree a little bit less even if you don't completely change their mind that still makes a difference in political outcomes so that creates an incentive for people to talk to more diverse sets of people rather than just the people who they could have a chance to get to truly agree with them you see what i mean when you say it's expensive well it because it becomes more the cost of the votes goes up the more votes that you get yeah in terms of the units of the credits that i was just showing yeah so so i don't think that the voting mechanism itself can solve all these problems of course education is hugely important but i do think that the voting mechanism can help create an environment where the incentives are aligned with that and and it can actually be pretty powerful because if you think about it you know the founders of the american republic they didn't want a two-party system but they created a set of incentives created a two-party system in spite of themselves right because once you have plurality vote one first pass the post it creates a two-party system right and so i think that some of these incentives can filter back into the way that the politics is organized and the process can be part of the noticing as well yeah yeah that's also true that's a very good point which is that actually one thing we found when we use this survey with people is that because they have a constraint and they have to make these trade-offs we often get comments from people that they learned a lot about their own preferences they didn't realize that they cared so much more about this thing than the other thing until they had to actually make the trade-off between them yeah so so just to follow up on that very quickly because when you talk about trade-offs the interface you just showed has upvotes and downvotes that kind of cancel each other out and the crowdfunding experiments the spring is entirely upvote only yeah it carries no notion of compensation right and so are there tangible differences in both mathematics and also in psychology when you design things in a upvote downvote kind of way versus an upvote only way yeah no absolutely so it's it's there's complicated trade-offs between those on the one hand if you have downvotes you have the possibility of censorship that may not be desirable you also have the possibility um yeah so so i think that that's that's a problem it's also can be a little bit more complicated for people but without downvotes if you have things that are genuinely harmful for example a petition that might be hate speech or directed targeted against some group in the population it's actually quite important that you allow downvotes on that as well in order to try to limit the possibility of having potentially hateful perspectives right so it's like signal the you know blockers exactly okay i think that makes a lot of sense yeah in some politics for example this doesn't happen i don't think in the taiwanese system but in the united states there's often something that happens where a very a politician that's very not popular will do well not because they're popular but just because people are afraid of the other alternative and if you could vote negatively on the other alternative that issue wouldn't show up i see i see well that's that's a powerful argument right there um i'd like to show you the uh real interface of petitioning that we are talking about because i think that will uh help massively and that's something that foundry can carry on in the conversation afterwards um so this is machine translated but uh very quickly just to give you an idea uh for example there is someone who's marry x who we know the sms number but we don't reveal it they don't have to be under a real name they can be a pseudonym uh so it's quite like israelian voting uh in this sense i see um they can choose a nickname basically but that's consistent over time there's an identity but that is not mapped into a real identity only that we know there's a sms number behind it okay um and then um they proposed to amend the provision of our public service leave rules um at a moment of petition it was at least half a day for each vacation but they wanted to changed into by hour which by the way takes takes effect this week so i took an hour off yesterday i succeeded yes right it's a successful petition uh and as you can see um there's a timer that says two months within the timer there has to be 5000 signatures and this check passed and the response is done and there's an agency response in each and every uh step um which uh and you can see the supporting argument of each person participating um but of course nobody has the time to read through the 5000 um people's commentaries they used to be foundry's uh largest headache uh in reading through those 5000 um people's commentary uh because sometimes people just you know copy and paste to whatever mobilize them to to counter sign the petition sometimes people just write a lot that has no relationship whatsoever with the petition just text analysis that can help you process that that's right so instead of doing text analysis we just did crowdsourcing so this is the actual interface now that saves foundry a lot of time um basically we have two columns uh underneath every petition that people can uh basically post their supporting arguments on the left hand column and um not exactly counter but other arguments on the right hand column uh and so basically what we're now doing uh is something that is out of the playbook of betterecavik i don't know whether you know the Icelandic experiment from the better party um and so the betterecavik has the same design uh and we took a page by not actually showing um the bars in a proportional to their number of comments because that only encouraged spam and nothing really nothing good happens but so you can see there's 46 supporting arguments and 11 counter arguments and then uh you each one can receive any number of upvotes and downvotes of course there's a flag button for truly hate speech stuff but otherwise we just sort but uh we discovered very early on of course exactly as you mentioned although it takes the troll away because they cannot really reply to anything right there's no reply button so there's no incentive to attack people still um people just you know casually um uh use downvotes to kind of censor um the good arguments um and so we changed the rule now that we take the absolute number of either the upvotes or downvotes so this one having more downvotes actually um makes this show on the top that's interesting so i think this is another area where something like quadratic voting could be interesting because it could make it costly to just censor but on the other hand it could allow you to flag borderline hate speech you know what i mean like that you don't have time to actually investigate and so forth so i think i think that's another potentially interesting thing and in principle you could even unify the two systems together and say that both the signatures of the petitions and the up and downvotes for the arguments could be part of a unified system like you can cost some credit uh to to download something slightly or you can cost some credit to add a supporting argument and it's it's the credit pool uh everybody receive a new every month and then uh it's used basically just to sort the signals not the substantial deliberation which will happen afterward according to found some roadmap yeah exactly so so that's the um that's what we call them voice credits as we think voting is a sort of voice arguments or a sort of voice all these things are sorts of voice and we'd like to have a token that can represent a currency for that voice rather than just a currency for buying things so but but why voice credits instead of voice tokens or whatever because credits is more fungible more square roots no it's just it's just a different word for the same thing okay so so you don't have an attachment to um the the name in fact i wouldn't even call it credits they're just called voice like you know you can just think of it as a unit and in fact we in in the book we use to denote uh the like currency marker rather than like a dollar sign we use a voice bubble ah okay like literally it also literally a speech bubble yeah exactly like like uh what like this one the speech bubble yes except it has it going to the right hand side so it looks a little bit like a queue and so that's like quadratic you know what i mean oh this is this is very cute um yeah so um the gov zero movement um which i'm a a part of um yeah you used to have the first version of its logo shaped like this uh yes exactly that's exactly what ours looks like too okay wow it's interesting independent invention um and um of course we we eventually shifted uh to to this logo just because everybody types gqv the tw when looking at this logo exactly for us that's good gqv government like quadratic voting maybe you should revive you should revive the original one but for a different purpose well i mean i i still have the domain named gqv the taiwan so um it's currently unused i'm happy to donate that to your purpose okay well and i think the v here um which is the shape of a vote uh really actually carries the the idea of quadratic voting also right because it's basically a stamp approval on what um your voice matters like and we can make the dot here you know um proportional exactly as you visualize so this original logo has some uses yay for recycling like it all right another very interesting residence uh that i wanted to mention is that you know many of these ideas in the book um came from someone named william vickery william vickery was a famous economist uh who won the nobel prize and most of his ideas were based on the work of another economist named henry george and henry george has a very deep relationship to taiwan i bet most people in taiwan don't know about it but um george inspired the ideas of sun yat sen uh almost as much as carl marx inspired the ideas of lenin and so there are many elements of policy in taiwan which actually come from the ideas of henry george yes like the least bad tax yeah exactly exactly yes and so uh the book is very connected to these ideas of henry george and uh yeah taiwan scandinavia and singapore the countries that have been most influenced by those ideas so there's a natural affinity i think mm-hmm yes uh i think aside from single tax which is less related um there's also the idea of the citizen's uh dividend i think that's also a george idea and the secret ballot and the secret ballot was introduced into the united states by henry george ah okay right so so i think all of these are very relevant nowadays because we're essentially building a code-based normativity around the same ideas that is uh legal by design instead of by interpretation right uh in george's time it would have to have a lot of um post-fact interpretations and negotiations and whatever to make the system that he designed actually work as intended instead of as people uh you know just uh randomly interpreted to be but but nowadays we get to code these algorithms into code so but a communication effort of course is the most important that we can find the intuitive interface that makes people get it and so that it becomes the social norm and then we compile that into code so that yeah that's the most important thing is that there's a notion of social legitimacy around the ideas and and that's the reason why what we're trying to do with these ideas is not just to go to government bureaucrats but very much like the uh approach you're taking of trying to be open and communicate with the public and engage them because we believe that ultimately these ideas will be successful if and only if they are able to become part of people's widespread notion of legitimacy because if they don't do that then they're imposed by a state and they'll be rejected and if they do do that then anything that the state does will have to follow that because otherwise people will be upset right and so that's why rather than taking the usual economist approach if we just talk to the central bank we just talk to the IMF instead what we're trying to do is actually build a social movement we have dozens of clubs all around the world um that are forming around these ideas we're working with entrepreneurs to experiment with them we're talking to folks like you who can try experimenting with them in participatory democracy we want things that are not just experiments but experiments that people ordinary people can feel and can get a sense for and can come to incorporate into their notions of what's fair so instead of fighting the system fighting the existing reality you're building a new model that eventually makes the existing model obsolete which is the Buckminster Fuller quote that Fenrir always uses in her slides okay that's great I'm happy to donate to your cause starting with the GQV domain we can see where it goes from that well I hope you can also participate and we're gonna have a conference in Detroit in in March and we'll be in touch with you about that we'd love to have you participating in it and to find any place where you can experiment and collaborate with us on experimenting with these things I think that would be very exciting for all of us but that that's awesome I mean March is parliamentary inquiry period but I have a way of appearing through telepresence robots double robotics holograms and the source and so I'm happy to virtually be there and there's also a very quick prototyping system that we work with the cup zero movement called v Taiwan basically every Wednesday anyone can come up with an idea of saying oh how about let's do an experiment this way and everybody just kind of tags alone like literally I think two this week's experiment is the social physics tags from Sandy from Alex Ventland yeah and and I mean it also is a voice credit voice token so to speak because it only measures the volume of your voice and the voice is not strictly speaking quadratic if you count the distance but in any case yes it shows the proximity and how loud people are speaking and how much attention they're monopolizing so to speak and so we can distribute it more fairly in a physical space even if the physical space has its own attenuation parameters we can change those parameters so it's almost like speculative well it's very interesting what you say because actually the one inspiration for us calling it voice credits is the physical voice because in ancient sparta um wait the way that they used to do the vote was to try to incorporate intensity of preference they allowed people to shout in favor or shout against it's a little bit like the clapping thing you were saying and whichever side shouted louder in total based on what you could hear would win the vote and it's it's inverse square right yeah sort of yeah okay but it has some similarities except of course it privileges people who happen to be able to shout right yes and and also I imagine people who stand in a more strategic position yes that's true as well yeah yeah so yeah I mean one of the things that we did in virtual reality is attenuation design so now right now with Skype of course everybody here like it's just two of us so we hear us and equally but one of the experiments we did in virtual reality is to change the position by having people physically walk toward the position they take and then change the attenuation factors and and because it's virtual reality you see so you can normalize people's input voice level to the same level but but then your position determines the sound dissipation and so that's one of the interesting experiments but I can go on and on but what I mean is that it's very easy to prototype new ideas including QV in the VTHA one meetups and even the national petition mechanism if we can find there's a beta version there's a beta website and so you we can also test this dynamic out on the beta website anyway we tried on the beta site for a year for the visualization of the budget of the entire national budget of more than 1300 actually governmental projects and because the ministries in charge were kind of afraid that if they let everybody literally see the relative budget allocation and how it's being executed and all the 1300 cases that they will be swamped with comments and so we only tried an initial pilot with 65 national priority projects before we let people see that actually responding publicly has a lot better properties because for things like social housing which everybody cares about how well we're doing and how exactly which procurement and spendings went on people won't waste each other's time they will actually ask quality questions and once you respond to them fully and in public everybody just found them through search engines and respective authorities don't have to pick up phones each one not knowing 550 people have asked this particular question before so it saves everybody time over time but I'm amortized but in the beginning we have to put it on the beta stage to show to the competent authorities in all the different thirty four ministry that this is going to be a time saver another time was there for them and I think that's a great idea yeah so I think the station I would love to do something like that with QV and you know if you guys have relevant developers and you can do it on your own that would be great and we're happy to consult but also there's now a whole movement we have hundreds of people who are organized around these ideas probably thousands and in the ethereum community and different communities and we'd be happy to find people to collaborate with you if you need support in trying to build a prototype oh yeah like free energy that's great yes absolutely just let us know and we'll we'll connect you to people who would be interested in being engaged right so um yeah I just the last thing I want to show is that this is the official participation uh platform including municipalities the corrective and auditing agency and of course an administration of taiwan is enjoying the gov that tw uh and um if you change the o to a zero as its customary to the gov zero movement you get into the shadow government which is joined the g0v the tw and anyone can just leave their email address there and join the slack channel on the g0v movement at at moment I think it's four thousand people or so uh and uh yeah I'm happy to to donate join the gqv the tw and see what you guys can come up with uh and basically prototype the joint gov tw system with a reimagination of the qv system and we'll see how far we can take from that that sounds great so we'll we'll follow up maybe by email and find the best way to coordinate collaboration okay and it's time for me so uh I will leave you more time and thank you for this hour long chat and I'll just help though everything to youtube to help spreading the cause I really appreciate it thanks so much and if anyone is watching it is interested in being involved we're working on this in taiwan um the movement's called radical exchange and you can find me at glenn weill on and twitter and uh we can be in contact okay thank you so much uh and uh enjoy your time in this wonderful r&c hipster co-working space take care of you bye


Hello there, this is the family doctor You know doc, I bet you've been in my drugstore a hundred thousand times Oh, yes sure and I ain't never seen you eat a chocolate sundae before well that can always be a first time Pete yeah, that's right I reckon but I always says is how it ain't so much what a man does is what he thinks That counts in the long run for as he think of in his heart so easy Exited huh? Oh, yeah. Yeah sure a thing doc. That's it now you take lawyer baits upstairs for instance. What about him? Hey, all right, doc your chocolate sundae. I put some nuts on it till Yeah, well lawyer baits now he goes around town most of the time with a grouch on Least wise he tries to make folks think that way hmm He growls around town yelling all the time that he's going out to foreclose a Mortgage or call a loan or something, but he don't never seem to do it No Ralph Bates is all right. Why sure he is He just seems to get a wallop out of making the folks of Cedarton think he's a tough But deep down in his heart. He don't think so at all of course not so it ain't what a man does It's the way he thinks that counts you're absolutely right feet Say doc, what's the matter with you this morning? Well, what do you mean? What's the matter with me? Well, I can generally get a argument out of you But this morning you're just too dang degradable Yes, I guess you're right again Well, I'll tell you Mrs. Adams has been hankering after that new radio set that just Rankin's had in his window and last night I decided she ought to have it so I took it home in the car and hooked it up before supper and you should have seen how Surprised and pleased she was Gosh the Friday you'd have thought it was Christmas morning. Well, that's a Jim dandy daughter Mrs. Adams is a fine woman. She deserves the best. I should say she does and that reminds me Jess should ought to be coming around here pretty soon to fix my radio Something wrong. Yeah, that sure is I told chick to stop in at Rankin's is on his way back from the blizzes and bring Jess with him What's the drugstore without a radio a feet sure thing, you know, oh here they come now Hello, Jess. You'll just about have time. What seems to be the trouble Pete.   I want to hear them races. That's going on pretty soon Here's that racing for me. Ask me to get mr. May. Yeah. Oh, yes, thanks Well, check. How are you with that? Well, I Golly, what's the trouble doc swore a nut? Yeah, no, no, I'm all right. Give me a glass of water sure thing Yeah, there you are Well, Jess, there's the radio over on that hot water bag cabinet. See what you can do to fix her up quick. Will you sure? Give mr. Rankin a hand if he needs a check. Oh, yeah. Yeah, sure Pete may Huh, boy. What's trouble getting a young boy like chick hopper to beckon on horseway all now doc That ain't nothing. We wasn't gonna bet much just about four bits or something four bits Yes, four bits today and next year it'll be $50 and the next thing we know he'll be into that sort of thing up to your neck Betting maybe a hundred dollars. Oh, no now listen now you listen to me now Wait a sec doc didn't we decide a couple of minutes ago that it wasn't what a man did that mattered It's just the way he thinks. Oh, this is different. Oh, it isn't either. That's the same thing If chick wins he'll start thinking this is easy money an easy way to pick up a little extra spending money if he loses Well, he'll start thinking he's got to make it up. It'll just go from bad to worse Oh, doc golly. You mark my words Pete may if you let that boy bet even 50 cents You'll be starting him on a path that you can't bring him back from Following the horses is a mighty bad start for a boy. Oh gee. I don't see Almost well, that's dandy jazz. How much do I owe you?  Well sure thing, you know How are you betting jazz? Well, I don't know. Let me see that racing form chick. Sure, Mr. Anken Hmm Run around with horse. Hey doc. Where you going? I'm going home turn on my new radio and listen to some I call you singing a permanent language Poor dog he thinks we're sending chick to the dogs just a listening to a horse race Oh You're going to take a run around are you jazz yep, I think I will all right then I'll take soap bubble And I'll take on the cuff. Yeah Well, shall we make it odds or just even well, let's just make it even that'll be easier. Okay with me Hey, listen, it sounds like they're ready to start now, ladies and gentlemen do the courtesy of full being horse food We bring the broadcast the final race the Asma Park racetrack with Bert and Iman at the microphone. Come in Bert Thank you, Jim. Well folks, there's a great crowd out here today, and they're all as excited as your announcer is to Well, here are the names of the next the eighth and final race It's a great sea handicapped before the weather number two jumping jack with Michael sit up number three On the cup never more with Rainier. You're on Mike Ryan Just about to come out of the pattern. Yep. Here they come Hey, hey, it can't be the radio. Oh gee I'm sorry folks. I accidentally put my hand on the wrong button and took us off the app for a second We're trying not to do it again. Oh, I guess I was mistaken folks They're not coming out yet. I think the band is going to play another number. So while we're waiting I'll switch you the microphone in front of the bandstand just to play a pic alone Why don't we get up a band here and see Piccolo takes the lead Leading off the post Getting lined up now Yep in the order we gave you So bubble is a favorite here today in this event Clellan's been doing all right, and he knows this horse now. I'm set of stables by the way Jumping jacks living up to his name. He's acting up at the barrier Getting him calmed down now, and they're just about never more takes the lead on the other thing with it So bubble pulling up at the turn so bubble passes buzzer About nose and nose with nevermore run around is dropping back now Run around is sick.  I have soap bubbles first Second buzzer third on the top is pulling up. I got jumping jack. He's coming up faster than the cup passes buzzer He's pulling up close to nevermore just about a half a length behind evermore Can they come in the stretch? Oh Hey, hey, just for gosh sake do something to that radio isn't the radio. I tell you my horse was coming in. I know he was When did you come in here? I didn't hear you open the door.  Oh Quit it doc. Don't rub it in Some mechanical difficulty at the track prohibiting us from bringing to you the finish of the last race to make an a code Difficulties because of previous commercial commitments We shall be unable to return to the track now anyway And so do the courtesy of Kloppenstein's flower shop chip turn that thing on and Oh Doc for gosh sakes. Can't you lay off us now? Well, Peter just goes to show when you start leading a young boy astray like you and Jeff Rankin have been leading chick here Who me? Yes, you check opera. I mean you nobody else I think idea such a thing these two supposedly Upstanding upright citizens as he did and betting on horse races with a clean cut young lad like you Why it's it's preposterous That's what it is if you never run into these two you'll probably never have known there was such a thing as a horse race All right, dr. Adams. What are you talking about? I used to be a jockey nevertheless. I'd go I'd you you what? Yeah, I was a jockey for three years. I rode the nags all over the country from the last spring when I broke my leg But well, well, I I never heard of such a thing Gosh to Friday. What is the world coming? This is the family doctor I'll be in to see you again right soon. Goodbye


Please honestly ask yourself. Would you actually enjoy that? So in today's video, I'm gonna be discussing why I am no longer vegan Veganism is the right way to go our digestive tract facilitates the digestion of a variety of plant foods The main one was digestive problems very obvious that we are not designed to eat meat Just by comparing our digestive tract to that of an omnivore or a carnivore, right? Obviously I started eating a lot more meat and fish to align with my goals And that probably helped to boost up my iron intake because our digestive tracts are a lot longer It allows us to digest more fibrous foods and absorb the nutrients from those foods and one it was too much fiber My body cannot handle that much fiber if we eat meat It actually can begin to rot in our intestinal tract which increases our risk of colon cancer constipation severe constipation bloating gas and just feeling like I was very backed up they have Giant claws to be able to rip apart an animal and sharp fangs to be able to dig into their flesh and just eat their Bloody meat, you know organs spilling everywhere and blood running all down their face It's very very obvious that if we were out in the wild and we saw a deer We would not be able to hunt down a deer like a lion could you know? It's just like people like to say that we have sharp teeth like and it's only after Changing my diet now and like incorporating animal products that I've been able to gain even more healthy weight Long-term vegans are crazy long-term vegans have mental health issues What did you base that on? Why why are you choosing to say this? It seems like you're just pulling this argument out of thin air based on absolutely nothing Of course now that I'm a lot older and I'm a lot wiser I can reflect on my life in a different way and I can see Just how mentally ill that I still was back then But I'm just saying that it doesn't make them crazy or make them have mental health issues I feel like that's a long stretch just because a lot of vegans can get very frustrated at other people for not Understanding if you have a mental illness, it's so easy to be manipulated or to become obsessive over things Honestly, you feel like that could dig into a deer and I could eat it alive and moreover That I would actually enjoy eating that raw flesh again blood spilling all down my face Without cooking it with that without adding any seasonings or spices to it like Nick and everyone else Please honestly ask yourself Would you actually enjoy that just how mentally ill that I still was back then all of your mukbangs You've eaten this amazing soy chicken and you know Orleans kuchu up all of these delicious amazing vegan meals and two I'm actually intolerant to soy so Why why would you need to cause harm to other animals? There's absolutely no reason Ultimately not being vegan is the best decision for me Trying to show them that there is no need to cause harm to animals. We have absolutely no need to eat animals. I Feel like I'm a little bit late to the party making this video and abuse them and take away their babies You know rip apart families kill animals that are just innocent and want to live just like we do all of my body's energy Was trying to go to digesting this food and like getting things moving, but I just wasn't digesting food Well, I felt so so fatigued But I'd be laying at home in pain and discomfort and just asking myself Why is this happening to me? You know, it's just about trying to open their eyes and help them to make better choices You know better choices for themselves and for the animals and for the planet that we all live on It's trying to bear the whole entire world not to mention. I Still did not have a period. It had been 10 years I was 22 and I hadn't had a period since I was 12 years old like and that is not Okay at all. You are sitting there right now. You have the ability to eat vegan foods You have so much inflammation. You don't feel good. You don't feel good looking pregnant all the time It's kind of ironic because you can't even get pregnant right now because you don't have a period and you've had the ability to go out and have a vegan version of every single thing that you could possibly want so Why why would you need to cause harm to other animals? There's absolutely no reason I literally just like staying inside all day because I feel so uncomfortable and sick and tired I'm just understanding that killing is wrong.


What's up everybody? Jason here for jaskiescasebricks.com. We just sold out another 22-23 Bowman Chrome University basketball 4 box break number 44 Random first letter first name. Now again, actually Ended to be a little personal. I think I got all 13 spots. So one the four extra free spots to make it a total of 17 So it's a little personal break for him So we go man. Good luck, buddy So again, there's two stacks remaining out of this case Left or right if I roll a one two three, we're gonna go to the left four five six for the right There we go And it is a four so one two three four five six you're gonna go to the right side So these are many four boxes will be for the last break number 35, which I'll post up right now when I get a chance Do this personal first here Personal four box here We'll do it just like we did earlier one of those four boxes at a time, which is where the wall Brogdon. Yeah, I'm a fan. I never liked Morris They might get rid of PG though. Yeah, I heard that I mean he doesn't play Yeah Well actually already Nathan Forget it is a personal I can't with more nice 97 out of 99 Everything will be yours buddy actual here The Nick Smith jr. The 150 Tiger you handle cherry white out of 299 redemption buddy Let's go. Come on Victor Come on one B. Then we got Jeremy King. Oh, it's gonna be skewed Henderson. Oh I know you've been chasing the Wamby man. I don't know if you have a scoop though He's still gonna be a lot of your pick though Come on one B Eat your way. Oh, did he really?  He got one out of 99 Sure. All right. Good thing. Good then. All right. Well, I Don't know if it's good So I know he was chasing that a couple weeks ago and he was buying them out with me I'm assuming by now he'd have one. I'm gonna Vincent got a nice tray white gold Felix of par You got Jalen Washington to 499 Kendrick Davis You got the Juan Harris jr. Avery Anderson the last box here, buddy old Chris Murray Very nice 48 out of 50 Couple gold autos here not too shabby Zack Eddie at 299 shimmer Neve Hart will be a Boston to 399 and Alamir dolls. All right, Nathan. There you go man. Pretty solid box couple golds And you did get a scoot Henderson parallel as well all this color. So thanks man That was a little personal there for him. I've another one hasn't been posted yet I'll post another one back up last four boxes of the case Jaspies case breaks.com


What is going on Randy random Randy random Randy random and he's dead. We did it. Okay. Good job everyone God was glad to be a part. He's just walking. Do you have the chair gun? There is no such thing as a chair gun What are you on?  He's a chair gun. All right then. All right then, there is a chair gun. I'm fine. I've been to these things now. I just go along with it guys honestly. Just entertain them. All right, let's go find Dahi and gather together. Come on, we can do this. Let's just get that should we just kill Dahi right away No logic and reason time. Let's go. Detect me. Oh, come on Detect. Oh wait. Oh wait. I have to see everybody. You're getting a bit aggressive Kevin and you have a shotgun.  Come on Who broke the projector? That was me Are you kidding me? Are you kidding me? Oh god someone's shooting. Dan be careful Someone killed him. Oh, I killed him. Get Dan! Get Dan! He hit the one with the aggressive chair. I murdered him with the chair. It was Dan! Kill Dan! I did it. I know it wasn't him. No, it was him. I told you he was aggressive with the chair. So I guess you died. You didn't see anything. Well, I'm kind of wanted the order.   I don't know who hired him. Oh, bowling. Let's go bowling. Someone come bowling with me. Dan, come bowling with me.  I just want to bowl with you. Here's my first shot. I missed. Now you. You aiming for my head. Aim for the pins. Strike! Oh my god, I got strike. I'm really good at bowling. Can you fling these around? Yeah, you can fling them around. I just got a strike on Dan. Oh god. You're good at bowling.  Go on. You can do it son. No rails. Come on. Ryan's being suspiciously normal. Kevin, stop man. How am I suspiciously normal? Stop murdering them with the bowling ball.  I'm nearly on a perfect game. Oh my gosh. What happened? Oh my gosh. Are you still good with that?  Let's go. We did it. We did it. We did it. We did as bowlers of all time. It was the perfect cover.  But I like how I swapped to the gun and I suddenly couldn't kill him. I should have just said the bowling balls. I'm bowling if anyone needs me. I'm on lane one. No, Kevin, not again. You're dying Kevin. No, no, no, no. Not after the last action.  Hold on. I want to see this again. See, I'm practicing. You right click or left click? Right click. Oops. Bowling related injury. Well, can we just execute this guy now? Like he just walked up and killed you. Okay. There's murder happening. Hold on. I'm getting some bowling balls. And what do you do? You do a little sideways motion. You just do from right to left and then right click. What? See, mine didn't move. Look, watch me, Kevin. Stop doing it.  Dad, dad, watch. Oh, that's really cute. That was great. How do I throw it stronger? Well, I'm a detective now, so I can't help you anymore, son. You're on your own. What? No, you think magic ain't all. Who is the traitor? Dad, help me. Help me. You should have helped me. I just want a ball. You're moaning an awful lot. He's just having a good time with his dad. Leave him alone. Oh, no. Trust test, RT. Take a seat. Take a seat right over there. Why don't you take a seat? Take a seat. No, sir, come back. Sir. I don't like where this is going. Come take a seat, Eru. Eru, take a seat. Take a seat over there. Oh, can I just sit down too?  Come in. Take a seat, everyone. For fuck's sake. All right, smoke grenade going down. Whatever happens, happens. Apparently, Eru was the traitor. Oh, I know he said, dude, that's good news. That's always good to hear. Well, fuck, I'm dead. A chair came out of nowhere. I'm starting to believe in this chair gun that Dan was hallucinating about. Yeah, the chair gun is real, okay? Dan, you've gone mad. You can't keep having a hunch and just R-D-M killing someone. I'm right every time. I've been right every time. I have.  I've been, I've guessed three times the crime and I've been right three times. You've been right seven times today and you'll remember the three times you'll avoid. No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. It's weird. The whole server has a hunch. It is Dahi. I got him.  I got him. Wait, he was a traitor? Fantastic. Let's not shoot each other for a change. Let's try and figure it out. I don't know why I just think it's this guy. I don't know. Oh, fuck, he's innocent. I'm the worst detective ever. It's one million percent, Brian, because my hunch has said so. Okay, maybe we should listen to the hunches.  My hunch is kind of kicking in a bit here. Yeah, what's it feel? The hunch is saying it's Brian. It seems to always say Brian for some reason. Brian, I will protect you. Just give me a bowling ball.  Come on.  Someone's dead. Hang on. Brian. What are you doing? Don't shoot me. Don't shoot him again. I can't believe it. I can't believe it. My hunch was right. Colder Daniel, colder, colder, colder, colder, colder. Very cold, very cold, very cold, very cold. Boiling. Boiling. I'm getting mixed methods. Warmer? Colds now. Warmer. Warmer. Warmer. Oh, colds. I'm putting those back on. Cold, cold, cold. All right, warmer. Warmer. I'm the detective again.  Oh, my God. He's shooting. Daniel, I'm the detective and I don't know what's happening. Why is he not returning fire? He just killed someone. Wait, hold on. I'm going to collect your DNA, Brian. Come here. I'm about to scan you. I don't know how. Hold on. What's my heritage? Oh, Jesus. Oh, Jesus. Oh, God, run. Protect me. All right, I'll carry them. Kevin, take my DNA. Ah, your DNA looks like a chair. Jim. We did it. Yeah. What's that thing that used me on the TV to check your ancestry, like my heritage or something? There is one just called ancestry. I've done two of them. I was literally 100% Irish. OK, so no surprise. I'm 100% Ireland and Scotland. They sent a potato in a sealed pack. And no staple through it saying incest. That's it. Brian, hold on. I'm collecting your DNA. Bring me to the bathroom. Let's go back to the bathroom. I need your DNA. And I respect your privacy. Here's my stick. All right, I'm scanning it. Hold on. OK. How does this work? We're going to have a health station here. OK. So whenever we need it, we're going to come back. I probably shouldn't throw a microwave at you while you're in the shower. Yeah. All right, everyone, come to the shower. Why are you wounded, Dan? What happened? Magneto sticks out. People shooting earlier. All right, Dan, get in the shower and heal yourself. I don't know if I trust them. What the? What the? Jim just killed the detective. Oh, no. Do something. Oh, he's already dead? You got him? We should have never trusted them. We should have just stayed showering together and never let them in. You should have just scanned my stick. I was trying to scan your stick, but your stick wasn't working. It's all right. It happened. It's all my fault. Get older. It's fine. Tammy, why are you bleeding? Tammy's dead. Dan, explain yourself. He collapsed. No, explain yourself. He actually just walked up to me and died. Oh, he just walked up and died. Did he? Did he just get it off? It's not even me, but I have to protect myself. Well, Dan just murdered the detective. So take that for what you will. It's not me. After someone just walked up and died. You've kind of marked yourself for death, even though I don't think it is you. But at the same time, everyone killed Dan. I got to clear my name. I don't think it's going to work, dude. I think it's too late.  I was innocent, though. Everyone get the guns? I like the shotgun because it kills them quicker. I don't like the guns. I just like bowling balls. Oh, you can go up here into the crow's nest. Oh, let me come up and do a trust test with you. Don't stand up. Oh, no. Don't move. All right. I'm going to make a little outline of you. Okay. Incredibly. He's just looking at us. Like, what are you doing? He's nodding. I don't think it's Dan. I think you actually, you know what? I do think it is. Oh, DK. Oh my God. What did you do? No.  He just threw him off the crow's nest. He fell. He fell.  I didn't hurt you. You did emotionally. Can you drive the helicopter? Oh, you can. Wait, what? Oh, it's very choppy. It's very choppy. Oh, I want to see this. Good. This is going to be real awkward.  The helicopter just kicked me out. Oh, you're in your murder tower again. I see, Dan.  Really? You're very vulnerable, though. Kevin, don't you dare. I'm just saying I could take the shot. Where's the coin? I want to just flip a coin. I don't flip a coin. I'm trying to find a coin. I'm flipping this RT. We'll see what happens. All right. Stay still. No, wait, why would I stay still? I'm not staying still. Stay still. It landed on don't shoot you. So I'm not going to, but just stay still. No. No, I don't want to stay still. No, I got shot. Oh, I missed the ladder. Oh, my God. He killed himself in his confusion. Good job, detective. I'm the detective. Let's all get in the helicopter. Everyone on the map, and then I'll detective you. I'm not sure what that means, but I guess we're going to find out. Cool. Ladders are fun. Oh, that was you. Someone broke their legs anyway. Ladders are great. Are you good or are you dead? Thank you, Gary. Great programming on the old ladder there. We got three people at the helicopter now. All right. I'm heading up now. Don't worry, detective's on his way. No, no, don't. Did someone take off? Kill them all then. Kill them all. Look, they're jumping. They're killing themselves now. You've upset everyone. Bagel, protect me. Watch the stairs. Don't let anyone up to me. Just let them, they have to wait in queue. No, don't kill them.  Oh, that's too late. Okay. No, we're good.  But you have to wait on the stairwell. The helicopter's coming around. I'm making my way back down. Oh, is it only you in the helicopter now? All right. Everyone on. Okay, Kevin. Yes. I'm the detective. I got to get on. Take my trusty barrel too. I got a few more suitcases now. I'm sorry, Dan. We don't have any room for you. All the freshest cargo. All right. Hop in. Just a few more bits and bobs. All right. I'm taking off. You better hop in. The helicopter just blows up. Oh God, the helicopter does not like the barrels. Wait a minute. No, don't. Kevin. Kevin. I am not there. Everyone meet at the helicopter. We're going to go for another ride. This could work out very well for us. Why am I dying so slowly? I was the best trader ever. You did it. I fell off a ladder. We would never suspect someone clumsy as that. I really had no idea it was you.