If the higher starting level of GDP were maintained, the cumulative loss of GDP would more than halve to around 8%.12 “The Third Quarter” Looking to the second half of the year, what might we expect? In the May MPR, the MPC’s scenario foresaw a sharp pick-up in activity, with quarterly growth rates of 12-13% in each of Q3 and Q4. These increases were driven, in large measure, by the assumption of a phased relaxation of lockdown measures, and accompanying policy support, between July and September. To my mind, two paths are possible in the second half of the year. One involves a negative feedback loop from higher unemployment to lower spending, the other a positive feedback loop from higher spending to lower unemployment. The first poses a downside risk to the outlook, the second an upside risk. As things stand, it is unclear which of these scenarios, or feedback loops, will prove the more potent. The negative loop has its roots in the labour market. So far, levels of employment appear to have fallen less rapidly than output. Against that, the number of furloughed workers has exceeded expectations, perhaps by in excess of a million people. This is good news for household incomes in the short run, as the income loss from furlough is far lower than from unemployment. Indeed, this might help explain some of the greater than expected strength in demand in Q2.
Data has been weighted to the known offline population proportions for age, gender, government office region, working status and social grade. Respondents were asked, “as a result of the coronavirus pandemic, would you say that your household savings have increased, decreased, or stayed the same?”  Chart 13: Sterling deposits held by households and PNFCs (monthly flows into M4ex) Households  £ billion  PNFCs  60 50 40 30 20 10 0 -10  Jan - 19  Apr - 19  Jul - 19  Oct - 19  Jan - 20  Apr - 20  Sources: Bank of England and Bank calculations. Note: Chart does not include flows into non-intermediate OFCs’ M4. 14  All speeches are available online at www.bankofengland.co.uk/speeches  14  Which of these two paths will play out in practice? Back in May, the MPC observed that the balance of risks to the outlook was skewed to the downside. Subsequent positive news on demand has, in my opinion, more than counterbalanced the rise in downside risks to employment. To my mind, this leaves risks to the outlook slightly more evenly balanced than in May, if still with a downside skew. “The Fourth Quarter”  Looking beyond 2020, there is plainly a high degree of uncertainty about the economy. That in part reflects uncertainty about the virus and the policy responses to it. But it also reflects uncertainties about the path of the economy itself.