It shows a high correlation, with rises in equity prices inducing reallocations into equities. This suggests a potentially significantly pro-cyclical swing in portfolio behaviour. For example, a 10% rise in the S&P on average increases the equity portfolio share by over one percentage point – or around $ billion given the scale of US life insurers’ balance sheets. 6 If done quickly, this could be a potent procyclical amplifier. Similar patterns are evident among life insurers in other countries. A second piece of indirect evidence comes from the behaviour of regulators. There have been several incidences over recent years of regulators loosening regulatory constraints to forestall concerns about pro-cyclical behaviour in a downswing. For example, UK regulators loosened regulatory constraints on insurance companies in the early 2000s following the bursting of the dotcom bubble. This was due to fears of selling pressure on equities being amplified as insurance companies de-risked their portfolios as they neared regulatory constraints. Pension fund regulators have taken similarly-motivated actions recently due to depressed real yields boosting the market value of liabilities. A third piece of evidence comes from analysing the impact of ICPF asset allocation decisions on asset prices. In particular, at the Bank we have analysed the impact of purchases of longterm UK indexed-linked debt by UK ICPFs since the early 1990s (Zinna (2014)). Over this period, the combination of accounting and regulatory rules led to large cumulative purchases of long-term government debt by ICPFs. At the same time, long-term real yields fell from around 4% to around –1%.
But you can’t have a meal without food — and you can’t have banking without service, trust, and capital. 6. Yes, technology is replacing some traditional banking channels and processes. But that actually enhances those core principles. So, I don’t think technology will replace banks. Rather, I’ll be making the case today that technology will make banks better — whether it is delivered by an established bank or a new market entrant. A new era established 7. In 2017, the HKMA launched seven initiatives to begin a new era of smart banking. Since then, the competitive landscape for banking in Hong Kong has changed quite a lot. We are proud to be one of the first markets in the region to have fully digital banks — or virtual banks. As we speak, our city has one of the highest numbers of virtual banks in Asia. 8. Today, customers can choose from a wider range of banking providers and platforms. They can choose digital or physical, niche or universal. 9. Not surprisingly, competition is bringing down costs and improving customer experience. For example, traditional banks have been phasing out fees for maintaining low account balances. Many are proactively improving their digital platforms to improve the user experience. 10. We owe this progress to the innovators, entrepreneurs, and bankers in today’s audience. It has been driven by your hard work and determination. 11. As a regulator, we help to facilitate this progress. We ensure a level playing field for all types of financial institutions.