This means that no shock that the economy will face in the future is incorporated into both the forecast and the decision. In other words, there is no way of avoiding the last-mentioned uncertainty connected with future shocks and neither the central bank nor the markets have any superior information about them. The uncertainty surrounding the first two mentioned points – the current state of the economy and future monetary policy – will be the heart of my remarks tonight. Being forecasters we all face uncertainty surrounding the knowledge about the current state of the economy. This current state should be thought of as a shortcut to all the inflationary determinants brought from the past, but due to the transmission lags having an impact on future developments. Every forecaster, and of course also the central bank, has his own opinion about the economy’s current state. One question arises immediately: Should the central bank look at market forecasts and use them as a source of information about the economy’s current state and for its decision-making? My answer is: Market forecasts should not be neglected. On the other hand they cannot be the core for decision-making and the central bank must rely primarily on its own structural modelling. This implies that despite all the transparency and communication, the central bank will – from time to time – have to surprise other forecasters and the market. BIS Review 10/2005  1  Let me now briefly explain why this is the case.
On the other hand, since the inflation forecast is not only an important internal decision-making tool, but also a crucial communication device, market participants have a good knowledge of the central bank’s forecast and can compare their own view on the economy with the central bank’s one. This implies that both the central bank and the market are well informed about each other’s forecast. It is clear that a huge portion of uncertainty is inherent to any practical forecasting. Moreover, from the monetary policy perspective this uncertainty is complicated by the fact that the results of today’s monetary policy action will be effective with a significant lag. On top of that, from the economic theory we know not only that today’s monetary policy decision is important, but also that the expectation about future monetary policy has an important impact. With a certain degree of simplification we can state that in general any future value of inflation depends on three main factors. These are the current state of the economy and its underlying inflationary pressures, current and future monetary policy actions and, of course, future economic shocks. Consequently, the surrounding uncertainty can also be divided into similar parts. Let me first shortly address the last point, something we can call the “shocks” uncertainty. It is necessary to admit that both today’s central bank forecast and today’s central bankers’ decision are deterministic from this point of view.