I had the OtterBox Commuter Series Case for 5 months then this Caseology case. I dropped my phone in both cases several times. The phone seemed completely safe in both but eventually the internal hardware was damaged in the Caseology case. It gets three stars because I am not sure whether this was a defect with my phone or my case. Also the fingerprint reader isn't as nice as the one on the back of the OtterBox case. I've gotten used to it but I prefer the Otterbox.
Not as good as Otterbox