KITAB: Evaluating LLMs on Constraint Satisfaction for Information
  Retrieval
Marah I Abdin Suriya Gunasekar Varun Chandrasekaran Jerry Li Mert Yuksekgonul Rahee Ghosh Peshawaria Ranjita Naik Besmira Nushi
We study the ability of state-of-the art models to answer constraint
satisfaction queries for information retrieval (e.g., 'a list of ice cream
shops in San Diego'). In the past, such queries were considered to be tasks
that could only be solved via web-search or knowledge bases. More recently,
large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated initial emergent abilities in
this task. However, many current retrieval benchmarks are either saturated or
do not measure constraint satisfaction. Motivated by rising concerns around
factual incorrectness and hallucinations of LLMs, we present KITAB, a new
dataset for measuring constraint satisfaction abilities of language models.
KITAB consists of book-related data across more than 600 authors and 13,000
queries, and also offers an associated dynamic data collection and constraint
verification approach for acquiring similar test data for other authors. Our
extended experiments on GPT4 and GPT3.5 characterize and decouple common
failure modes across dimensions such as information popularity, constraint
types, and context availability. Results show that in the absence of context,
models exhibit severe limitations as measured by irrelevant information,
factual errors, and incompleteness, many of which exacerbate as information
popularity decreases. While context availability mitigates irrelevant
information, it is not helpful for satisfying constraints, identifying
fundamental barriers to constraint satisfaction. We open source our
contributions to foster further research on improving constraint satisfaction
abilities of future models.