ColorSwap: A Color and Word Order Dataset for Multimodal Evaluation
Jirayu Burapacheep Ishan Gaur Agam Bhatia Tristan Thrush
This paper introduces the ColorSwap dataset, designed to assess and improve
the proficiency of multimodal models in matching objects with their colors. The
dataset is comprised of 2,000 unique image-caption pairs, grouped into 1,000
examples. Each example includes a caption-image pair, along with a
``color-swapped'' pair. We follow the Winoground schema: the two captions in an
example have the same words, but the color words have been rearranged to modify
different objects. The dataset was created through a novel blend of automated
caption and image generation with humans in the loop. We evaluate image-text
matching (ITM) and visual language models (VLMs) and find that even the latest
ones are still not robust at this task. GPT-4V and LLaVA score 72% and 42% on
our main VLM metric, although they may improve with more advanced prompting
techniques. On the main ITM metric, contrastive models such as CLIP and SigLIP
perform close to chance (at 12% and 30%, respectively), although the
non-contrastive BLIP ITM model is stronger (87%). We also find that finetuning
on fewer than 2,000 examples yields significant performance gains on this
out-of-distribution word-order understanding task. The dataset is here:
https://github.com/Top34051/colorswap.