Positional Description Matters for Transformers Arithmetic
Ruoqi Shen Sébastien Bubeck Ronen Eldan Yin Tat Lee Yuanzhi Li Yi Zhang
Transformers, central to the successes in modern Natural Language Processing,
often falter on arithmetic tasks despite their vast capabilities --which
paradoxically include remarkable coding abilities. We observe that a crucial
challenge is their naive reliance on positional information to solve arithmetic
problems with a small number of digits, leading to poor performance on larger
numbers. Herein, we delve deeper into the role of positional encoding, and
propose several ways to fix the issue, either by modifying the positional
encoding directly, or by modifying the representation of the arithmetic task to
leverage standard positional encoding differently. We investigate the value of
these modifications for three tasks: (i) classical multiplication, (ii) length
extrapolation in addition, and (iii) addition in natural language context. For
(i) we train a small model on a small dataset (100M parameters and 300k
samples) with remarkable aptitude in (direct, no scratchpad) 15 digits
multiplication and essentially perfect up to 12 digits, while usual training in
this context would give a model failing at 4 digits multiplication. In the
experiments on addition, we use a mere 120k samples to demonstrate: for (ii)
extrapolation from 10 digits to testing on 12 digits numbers while usual
training would have no extrapolation, and for (iii) almost perfect accuracy up
to 5 digits while usual training would be correct only up to 3 digits (which is
essentially memorization with a training set of 120k samples).