united_states united_states case court held jurisdiction hear appeals criminal cases circuit courts error relying exceptions clause held congress grants jurisdiction court operated exercise congress power eliminate forms jurisdiction second criminal cases heard ensured court criminal limited error state later territorial courts original petitions error petitions circuit courts certificates division circuit courts congress grant court jurisdiction hear error circuit courts criminal cases capital crimes infamous crimes judicial code abolished circuit courts transferred trial crimes district courts extended court jurisdiction crimes statutory grants permit error filed prosecution arose political dispute judiciary gave rise madison stuart benjamin justice peace district_of_columbia argued repeal statutory provisions authorizing compensation office violated salary protection guarantees federal judges article united states constitution divided panel district_of_columbia sided interpreted repeal act sustained criminal indictment common law crime illegal fees color office background united_states presidential election democratic republican party comprised united_states democratic republican defeated presidential election jefferson party took control congress house senate elections elections lame duck administration passed judiciary act midnight judges act creating new circuit circuit courts opposed district judges supreme_court justices riding circuit district_of_columbia organic act organic act statutes created judicial adams filled nearly day office marshall dual role adams secretary state failed deliver commissions leaving office companion cases immediately inauguration jefferson instructed secretary state stop delivery outstanding commissions act march abolished circuit court created midnight judges act filled restoring system created acts viewed unconstitutional looked pending case madison concerning confirmed justice peace received commission test case repeal session supreme_court june month repeal effect judiciary act delayed court session february changes structure judicial system broadly jefferson removed incumbent second level appointed federal officials including attorneys jefferson displaced district judges citing technical flaws appointments district judge removed office party line vote following day house justice democratic republicans crossed party lines senate prevent conviction single vote supreme_court held madison failure deliver commission illegal grant writ ground judiciary act unconstitutional authorized court issue original jurisdiction stuart involving civil judgment rendered circuit court constituted midnight judges act enforced circuit court constituted judiciary act challenged circuit requiring supreme_court justices ride circuit brief opinion court rejected challenges district columbia organic act district_of_columbia justices peace created february district_of_columbia organic act unlike better known predecessor midnight judges act organic act survived repeal justices peace justices peace appointed president number discretion confirmed senate year terms justice peace jurisdiction matters civil criminal relates conservation peace county district_of_columbia divided counties east west justices peace authorized inflict imprisonment fine high pounds tobacco hear civil cases controversy year original case court granted writ corpus prisoner subjected detention justices peace compensation organic act provided justices peace shall entitled receive services fees allowed like services laws adopted continued eastern said district march amendment organic act provided appointed said district shall constituted board commissioners respective counties shall possess exercise powers perform duties receive fees levy courts commissioners county state maryland possess perform receive march president day office adams nominated senate confirmed justices peace march president issued commissions justices peace including nominated adams including nominated adams remainder choosing jefferson list submitted senate january erroneously contained confirmed adams appointed received commission jefferson instead madison confirmed adams nominees commissioned congress eliminated fees justice peace services travel expenses authorized organic act fees associated justices peace role board commissioners sources represented entirety compensation circuit court judge district_of_columbia populated judges mixture district judges circuit riding supreme_court justices like circuit courts circuit court jurisdiction crimes committed district regard appeals circuit court organic act provided final judgment order decree said circuit court matter dispute exclusive costs shall exceed value dollars examined reversed affirmed supreme court united_states writ error appeal shall prosecuted manner regulations proceedings shall shall provided case error appeals orders rendered circuit court united_states provision organic act referred error circuit courts supreme_court judiciary act provided like process writ error district court circuit court final civil actions suits equity circuit court brought original process removed courts states removed appeal district court matter dispute exceeds sum value thousand dollars exclusive costs examined reversed affirmed supreme_court citation case signed judge circuit court justice supreme_court adverse party having thirty days notice unlike provision judiciary act provision act february explicitly limited civil cases incorporated reference circuit court constituted framework judiciary act appeals supreme_court way certificates division issue heard appeals circuit court original criminal appeals availability criminal appeals supreme_court means error circuit courts open question prior england writ error available right cases cases required express consent prosecutor legislative history judiciary act reveals little consideration criminal appeals senator time drafting described act follows error circuit court causes criminal original matter dispute exceed senator future supreme_court justice noticed lack provision criminal appeals preliminary notes draft outline speech gave june according viewed inability government appeal court nation capitol protection ordinary citizens issue criminal appeals mentioned house debates shortly judiciary act took effect attorney general proposed report house_of_representatives criminal appeal similar england writ error right non capital cases error capital cases report referred committee took action prior marshall tenure supreme_court heard criminal cases writ united_states hamilton court granted bail capital defendant authorized judiciary act judiciary act greater portion decision dedicated court refusal order case tried special circuit court provided judiciary act court explained jurisdiction hamilton exercised original judiciary act second united_states lawrence court declined issue writ district judge order arrest french navy criminal trial united_states justice expressed dissent wrote right error judgment state proceedings record error shall man grant benefit new trial granting writ error supreme court united_states court heard writ error brought united_states merits criminal case circuit court case criminal writ error heard court attorney district_of_columbia argued benjamin justices peace jefferson choosing receiving interim appointment jefferson proceeded nominate year term senate confirmed april according appears man moderate sentiments nonetheless joined defense judicial independence unlikely character lead role attack principles case intended test case parties involved markings case manufactured present supreme_court issues principle raised repeal embarrassment direct conflict executive indicted grand july term taking unlawful fees services justice peace indictment charged having taken fees july december term issued members included justices peace member confirmed adams received commission jefferson indicted second time december term conduct december case continued july term indictment mentioned opposed attorney mason jefferson mason argued justices peace article judges established congress power district_of_columbia article united states constitution article provides congress shall power exercise exclusive legislation cases whatsoever district exceeding miles square particular states acceptance congress seat government united states mason advanced broad view congress power district_of_columbia limited constitutional provision support argument justices peace article iii judges mason argued jurisdiction broader permitted article iii according additional cited party justices peace article iii judges example organic act authorized president appoint justices peace shall time time think broad delegation president congress power constitute inferior supreme_court indicted criminal statue passed congress indictment common law having colour office taken illegal fee organic act provided laws maryland virginia continue force portions district ceded states justice peace common law virginia applied dismissal circuit court judges hearing chief judge assistant judges chief justice brother marshall adams jefferson reporter decisions supreme_court included circuit court opinions margin report supreme_court decision majority joined marshall sustained based article united states constitution clause provides judges supreme inferior courts shall stated times receive shall diminished office held congress power federal district limited remainder constitution response mason argument power replied doctrine said congress pass bill district columbia congress pass laws post facto district order soldiers time peace ports free ports entry lay duties exports away right trial jury criminal held article iii judge sitting tribunal inferior supreme_court response argument jurisdiction exceeded article replied causes causes arising laws united_states power trying judicial power response argument fees paid time stated replied compliance clause constitution requires shall stated times shall paid service rendered construction suppose command constitution question year term consistent good behavior clause unnecessary cause decide question holds office good behaviour stopped short declaring statute unconstitutional merely interpreted prospective holding affect justice peace office effect justices appointed office passing act contemporary media accounts reported circuit court held fee elimination provision act unconstitutional interpreting prospective according evidence published opinion reported differed oral opinion dissent chief judge dissent noted recent confirmation principle judicial review madison according course pursued supreme court appears unnecessary thing power court examine law instead proceeded taking power granted noted testing act legislature constitution positive provisions resorted briefly argued article iii judge fees question compensation received times stated bulk dissent devoted argument congress power federal district broad argued district columbia belonging united_states compass like state component provisions constitution applicable particularly relative situation united_states states applicable district congress exercising exclusive legislation territory enact laws away fees justices peace laws tested provision constitution evidently applicable judicial power united_states containing restrictions nature affect situation justices nature compensation fully accept mason argument congress power district unlimited argued word exclusive meant free power exercised states legislative power exercised congress subject general restraints contained constitution admitted federal district congress restrained writ corpus cases allowed passing district bill post facto law laying tax granting title nobility making law establishment religion freedom speech press soldiers contrary amendment oral argument mason argued appeal united_states supreme_court argued merits jones cited madison proposition justice peace serve merely pleasure president according president power remove office reference good behavior clause article clause provides judges supreme inferior courts shall hold offices good behavior mason countered held justices peace entitled hold offices years good behavior mason pressed argument congress power federal district unlimited constitution apply case constitution compact people united_states individual capacity states political capacity unfortunately citizens columbia capacities congress district columbia power respect unlimited argued article iii judge judicial power exercised district columbia extends cases article iii judicial power united_states power derived power given congress exclusively cases whatsoever district jurisdiction february chief justice marshall raised doubts court jurisdiction entertain criminal appeals argument question commenced february mason argued favor jurisdiction argument counsel issue reported typical reporter arguments sides mason acknowledged clarke supreme_court jurisdiction required grant congress mason argued grant found judiciary act known act authorized supreme_court issue corpus specially provided statute necessary exercise jurisdiction principles law mason argument based act necessarily limited circuit court reason writ error confined civil cases man life liberty good dear property inferior courts liable case nature cases difference novel doctrine writ error lie criminal case frequent country drawn forms judicial proceedings chief justice marshall replied congress provision appeals kind supreme_court argument irresistible marshall countered exceptions clause congress said cases writ error appeal shall lie exception cases implied exceptions clause provides cases supreme_court original jurisdiction supreme_court shall jurisdiction law fact exceptions regulations congress shall mason replied exceptions clause apply federal district second organic act differed judiciary act referring final judgment order decree explicitly limiting appeals civil cases mason suggested references controversy refer criminal fines civil finally mason pointed years earlier united_states court reached merits criminal appeal court mason argued marshall authored opinion response point marshall replied question case jurisdiction passed sub court consider bound case mason able counsel think proper objection opinion march writing unanimous court chief justice dismissed writ error want jurisdiction justice johnson absent opinion announcement marshall held partial statutory grant jurisdiction court operated exercise congress power exceptions clause limit jurisdiction court cases marshall noted supposed decision circuit court reviewed matter dispute exceed value dollars marshall interpreted controversy requirement judiciary act applying entire section marshall rejected argument organic act authorized criminal jurisdiction interpreted grant light controversy requirement confined civil cases words matter dispute appropriated civil cases subject contest value sum mentioned act criminal cases question guilt innocence accused fined upwards dollars eye law punishment offence committed particular object suit final refers united_states admitted criminal cases judgment inferior court final admiralty libel case oral argument attorney general argued alternative case criminal cause removed judgment final criminal causes court rejected lee argument unanimously opinion civil cause process nature libel degree touch persons aftermath error issued federal criminal trials circuit courts years congress created right appeal writ error capital cases judiciary act act extended right crimes judicial code abolished circuit courts placed original jurisdiction trial federal crimes district courts appeal courts appeals error provided final decisions civil criminal cases alike appeals supreme_court permitted directly district courts writ error courts appeals certified questions petition reported discussion issue court hear error criminal cases removed circuit courts recall judiciary act explicitly authorized appeals removal cases supreme_court limited sources jurisdiction criminal cases court hear criminal appeals state courts writ error authorized judiciary act court hear federal criminal appeals certificate division authorized judiciary act original petition authorized judiciary act authorized act court jurisdiction hear error petitions civil action circuit courts beginning court entertained appeals territorial courts attempts utilize sources jurisdiction unsuccessful analysis received far scholarly attention timing ground decision explain historians battle repeal ignored summary constitutional law stands proposition grant jurisdiction congress carries implicit negative jurisdiction constitutional description mentioned grant according strategy court intervene political struggle judiciary given justice acquitted senate case march day release decision imagine passing relief handed judgment dismissal marked end efforts obtain supreme_court ruling directly repeal judiciary act unconstitutional piece stuart avoidance opportunity open clash political critics courts shares characteristic declining exercise jurisdiction court found argues seize opportunity presented questioning marshall decision worth noting court previously entertained criminal appeals district raising problem reasonably wonder court wanted avoid decision merits march repeal question lost political strategy little gained reopening repeal battle marshall felt critical matters principle opinion
United States v. More